
Category: Uncategorized
-
Response to 2019 Fiscal Strategy Report Chester Cooper, PLP Deputy Leader, Shadow Finance Minister November 21, 2019
Minister of Finance Peter Turnquest has failed miserably in trying to put a happy face on what was one of the bleakest statements on the government’s fiscal position that we have ever heard
Turnquest, himself one of the harshest critics of deficits due to hurricanes, has now apparently found religion.
All the lofty projections now mean nothing.
The painful VAT hike that punished Bahamians who voted for this adrift government, seems to have been all for naught.
More borrowing, likely more cutbacks, more unemployment and a BPL tax as the cherry on top.
There is no denying that Hurricane Dorian, the most devastating storm The Bahamas has ever seen, was bound to have an adverse impact on government revenues and expenditure.
But based on the prime minister’s own characterization, what we see is a lazy government lacking innovation that once again retreats to the pure madness of borrowing and taxation. We will have more to say on the BPL rate reduction bond in due course.
Having borrowed well over $2 billion to date, the government now plans on borrowing another $500 million; not to mention the $650 million Bahamas Power and Light bill this administration plans to stick on the Bahamian people.
This is a record level of borrowing.
It is all as a result of this administration being too focused on managing deficits rather than improving the cost of living and fostering economic growth.
Had the government focused on fostering a stronger economy the impact of this shock would not have been so sharply felt on the economy.
The Bahamian people cannot bear much more.
As I asked with the BPL rate reduction bond: What exactly is the use of funds of the $500 million being borrowed?
This administration tends to use the tactic of throwing huge numbers out to shock the public into stunned silence.
But these questions must be asked.
Is this money solely being used to mitigate the fallout from Dorian or are we seeing an opportunity being seized to cover for the government’s own poor planning and lofty, unmet revenue projections of the past?
What is the state of refunds and vendor arrears given this administration’s boast of achieving its prior year deficit targets?
Can vendors and creditors expect further delays that will further slow the economy by cutting off the tap?
This Fiscal Strategy Report is the first major test for the credibility of the Fiscal Responsibility Council.
We note that there appear to be two major omissions:
Firstly, there is no mention of the fiscal or economic impact of the pending electricity rate reduction bond.
The impact of a electricity increase would likely reduce local consumption, which would reduce revenue while increasing what the government itself spends on electricity.
This is a recipe for a recessionary impact on the economy, despite the minister’s protestations.
Secondly, where does the report speak to the costs of this new potential borrowing given that it intends to raise $500 million to bolster government coffers and another $650 million to bail out BPL; from the market at the same time?
From whom will this money be borrowed and at what rate?
We suspect the government does not yet know.
How is proper budgeting possible without this information?
This is symptomatic of a government bereft of ideas.
The international markets are likely to be concerned given the very public turmoil in BPL over the past two years.
Hopefully, the government will seriously take advantage of local liquidity, while not raiding our National Insurance fund.
We also don’t believe this report includes a credible estimate of revenue collection, even with the Dorian adjustment.
Last year, revenue was over $230 million below target without any hurricane impacting The Bahamas.
In the first quarter of this fiscal year, revenue performance was not significantly different from last year.
So, conservatively revenue might be $400 million below target this year.
So, this means that the borrowing estimate is perhaps $230 million below what it needs to be for the government to function.
We also note that the majority of the Inter-American Development Bank contingency loan is still not drawn down.
As a result, there is no potable water in Grand Bahama, hurricane debris remains uncollected in Grand Bahama and the Abacos, and contractors who worked in the immediate aftermath of the storm remain unpaid.
Government must stay focused on speeding the recovery and restoration efforts as doing otherwise will have a continued dampening impact on the economy.
The Progressive Liberal Party looks forward to the review and report of these matters by the Fiscal Responsibility Council as the government has completely lost credibility and does not inspire confidence.
Collectively, this government’s policies and mismanagement are more likely than not to inflict even more pain on the Bahamian people.
-
Sen. Clay Sweeting Contribution – 12 Nov 2019
Sen. Hon. Clay Sweeting
Shadow Minister of Agriculture, Marine Resources and Local Government
Disaster Reconstruction Authority Bill 2019
Madam President, Senate Colleagues, I’m thankful to be here once again to speak on behalf of the Bahamian people and to contribute to this Disaster Reconstruction Authority Bill 2019. However before I begin, I would like to take the opportunity to extend condolences on behalf of my family, my wife Delia and our son Davin, to the family of Frankie Symonette, he was a true friend, and a father, and he took pride in his job working for the privately owned St. Georges Cay Power Company on Spanish Wells. I extend my prayers to his family, especially his 3 year old daughter, his parents and the entire community of Spanish Wells who mourn his Loss.
I would also like to extend condolences to the family of Susan Sawyer of Harbour Island and contributed to the development of the Harbour Island community.
May their souls REST IN PEACE AND RISE IN GLORY.
Madam president, having read the Disaster Reconstruction Authority Bill 2019 I am left confused and uncertain about the benefits of establishing this Authority other than to provide cushy jobs for cronies and paid board appointments. Madam president there are so many overlapping roles and responsibilities of other Government agencies and this bill does not in my opinion reduce the “red tape” in the event of a disaster but seeks to add another layer of bureaucracy to an already overly bureaucratic system. Additionally, how does this Authority differ from, or how does this Authority and newly formed Ministry of Disaster work together to achieve the goals as set forth or how are their roles different? Who is the authority in the event of a disaster? It seems that multiple agencies are being tasked with the same goals. I strongly oppose the establishment of this Authority and I cannot support the implementation of the same.
Madam President, two months have passed since we have experienced the worst disaster to affect our country since 1992. Two whole months have passed and it is obvious that this government once again is devoid of ideas or seem to be scrolling through facebook waiting foir that ah ah moment on how to govern effectively. Two months have passed and families that are displaced are still in need of housing assistance, employment wherever they are, immediate food supplies and ongoing counseling. Families are still searching for their loved ones and seeking closure.
The people affected by this storm have real and immediate needs.
As I peruse this bill I see no evidence, no future planning that gives the Bahamian people the guarantee or even a glimmer of hope that the needs of those affected by this disaster are alleviated by the passing of this Disaster Reconstruction Authority Bill 2019. I find it incredibly difficult to rationalize the establishment of this Authority when we have an already established agency in the presence of the National Emergency Management Agency, whose mandate and responsibilities are almost the same and if not the responsibilities can be easily adjusted to encompass those missing aspects as presented in this bill.
Madam president, our current situation is dire. The people of the Bahamas are all feeling the aftermath of this disaster. Those that survived need help immediately. Should not the focus of this government be first to attending to the immediate needs of it’s people? The international community are reporting of the lack of organization the Government and relevant agencies and this new Authority undoubtedly will add to more frustration in the rebuilding process.
While it is imperative to establish a plan to be implemented should we experience such catastrophic events in the future, we ought to be focusing immediately on care and attention to the Bahamian people now and we have the agencies already established that can provide the same. We simply need to channel the Hurricane Funds that have been donated to these agencies and implement a system of guidelines for its usage and a policy initiated to ensure compliance.
Madam President as I stated earlier, I strongly recommend that this government retract this bill and delegate the necessary powers to the Ministry of Public Works and National Emergency Management Agency. We are already paying the people within these agencies to complete this mandate simply adjust some of the responsibilities and fund them appropriately.
In Part II section 13 we see the use of government workers already in the system being seconded to this new Authority. Is this not the same system that is currently being utilized by NEMA? As I said before, this Bill seems to be another avenue for the Government to provide cushy jobs for the board members because at the end of the day the people that will be engaged in completing the day to day work of the Authority are already in the civil service and are already being utilized by NEMA. We see in Part II section 12 subsection 1 that there is an unregulated concession made to this Authority to hire as it sees fit employees for full or part time employment at compensation levels to the determination of the board. This is a recipe for cronyism and impropriety at the highest level with no accountability of public and donated funds.
I draw your attention to part II section 3 subsection 1. Here we are establishing an Authority to manage the reconstruction of an area after it is affected. As I said earlier, should we not be focused on
1. Immediate recover for those affected using the agencies already established which has gotten the work done in the past without the implementation of new staff who are without experience?
2. Should we not be putting appropriate teams in place to assess our vulnerabilities and implement suggestions to mitigate the same in the event of future disasters?
Is it necessary to construct and entire Authority to accomplish the work already mandated to Government Ministries?
Madam President, I note with particular concerns Part III section 23 sub sections 1 and 2. How does the government compensate private land owners be it individuals or businesses once they have declared an area a Disaster Zone and implemented measures to prevent rebuilding?
Is this not an infringement on the rights of the land owner? Also, when determining that landowners ought to build to the specification of the Authority in the noted “disaster zone” is the Authority responsible compensation the land owner for architectural renderings and construction of such buildings as approved by the Authority?
Imagine paying over 100k for your property, building your dream home on your land to have it destroyed by a disaster. Imagine it being fully insured or you having the means to rebuild and be told by the Authority that 1. You cannot rebuild on your land
And
2. If you can rebuild on your land, the Authority dictates to you what you can build. This is explicitly spelled out in this section and it is an egregious infringement on the rights of the land owner.
I cannot support the enactment of this bill.
Madam President, the Government through the establishment of this Authority is setting itself up for internal conflict. Under Part V section 30 subsection 2 we see what should be an amicable separation of donated funds between the Authority and NEMA, where there seeks to be a distinction between funds donated for relief efforts vs funds donated for reconstruction who determines the use of such funds when both organizations have the right to solicit international and domestic donations? How does the donor know which organization is responsible for what and which organization needs the funds more. Madam President this bill does not clearly define the structure for donation of funds and the use of the same.
Madam President I concur with my Colleague Hon. I Chester Cooper in recommending that these delegated powers be turned over to NEMA as the agency is already established. If we find that the system is broken we should fix it. Not reinvent the wheel. This Bill and enactment of The Authority for the purpose of Reconstruction is a waste of public funds, tax payer dollars and donations received. We already have a vehicle in place for relief. We simply need to channel the funding being allocated the The Authority to NEMA; add additional staffing; extend the powers of NEMA and continue moving forward upward and onward.
Madam President,
Titus Livius once said “Men are only clever at shifting blame from their own shoulders to those of others.”
The side opposite should keep screaming about being non political when it comes to helping. Which I agree but being non political doesn’t mean that you support legislation that doesn’t make sense.
The people are screaming for help so we will do our job and echo their cries.
The fact of the matter is that the FNM is the Government.
The fact of the matter is that it has been about 8 weeks since Hurricane Dorain has wreaked havoc in Abaco and Grand Bahama and people are hurting.
Stay focused FNM.
Stay focused to elevate Abaco and Grand Bahama so they can rebuild their communities, rebuild their economies and become More industrious than ever.
It is time to roll up your sleeves, and just get the job done.
No politics. We want success but that doesn’t mean we agree with this legislation laid before us.
Red tape doesn’t help the people.
Our fellow Bahamians are counting on the government to make the right decisions that are in the best interests of the people.
I would like to echo again “We have an opportunity to rebuild from the ground up”
-
Sen. Jobeth Contribution 12 Nov 2019
Contribution
Senator, Hon., J.L. Coleby-Davis- Opposition Senator; and,
Shadow Attorney General, Shadow Minister of Legal Affairs, and Youth
November 12th, 2019
Madame President, I am grateful for the opportunity to contribute and speak in this
place as a voice for many Bahamians.
Madame President, before I begin my Contribution I wish to raise in this Honorable place a formal objection regarding the matter of the communication by the AG. Madame President it is clear that the conventions state there should be no controversial material in a communication and nothing that invites debate. However, on Monday pass, ignoring the conventions and rules, the PLP was ambushed and accused of things that it never did or said! I was further surprised and could not believe that the Vice President in accordance with practice allowed the communication and then allowed the Senate to be suspended without, in the interest of fairness, an opportunity to hear the other side. As a result, I wish now to controvert what the AG said, unfortunate he is not there but it’s the Government’s statement not personal to him, just as the PLPs statement was not personal to Senator Mitchell. The communication alluded to suggest that the PLP lied or mislead the house in a statement to the Senate and that is incorrect and not true. Further, in the communication, it was suggested that the PLP called the President a pawn of the Executive and that is just not so and a false interpretation of the matter raised. The AG spoke to some corrupted efforts in relation to Hurricane Mathew and I am certain he knows better throwing aspersions where it has not been proven! Lastly, no one on this side is trying in any way to assassinate the character of anyone in this Senate. The matter raised on this side is purely related to an apparent conflict, not whether Madame President is capable! As a result, Madame President, I ask, for these reasons that the communication is struck off the record of this Honorable Senate.
Disaster Reconstruction Authority
Madame President, I stand today to bring brief contributions to the Disaster Reconstruction Authority Bill 2019. Let me state from the onset that there is absolutely no way the Opposition will support this piece of legislation.What is happening here is not just a rookie mistake, but a careless and dangerous game being played by this administration- the same administration that claimed in 2017 “it’s the people’s time,” yet the people are suffering, lost and angry at this FNM administration. Two years post Irma and the Ragged Islands continue to be a wreck, even after all of the promises from the FNM to rebuild. I ask, is that the fate of Bahamians effected by Dorian as well?
Madame President, just over two months after the devastation named Dorian hit the islands of Grand Bahama and Abaco, we find this Government struggling to figure out whether to go left or to go right. Madame President, it is as if they are at a T-Junction, with a line of cars (that being the Bahamian people) behind them, blowing their horns loudly and profusely begging the Government to move of the junction as the light is green, so that they can proceed in the direction they are going. However, this Government, two months after Dorian is lost, confused and don’t know what to do. So what do they do Madame President, they throw together some legislation, that usurps authority across various Ministries and departments. They come to the House and the Senate continuously debating legislation after legislation, and don’t move with haste in correcting what is truly important, this is, bringing relief, REAL, TRUE RELIEF on the ground to the people that matter.
Madame President, we were just here a week ago debating another useless piece of legislation, that the opposition did not support because it was again unnecessary. And here we are again, engaging in yet another debate for the creation of an authority that adds more red-tape and more bureaucracy to an already bureaucratic system.
Madame President, I echo our colleagues in the House and state, IF THERE IS A PROBLEM WITH NEMA, FIX THE PROBLEM!!
Madame President, it is not sufficient for those on the governing side to tug on the emotions of those in society by playing recordings from some of the affected persons during their speech in this place. Because we all heard the cries, and we were all heartbroken by what many suffered. However, the storm has passed, don’t create another disaster with our government agencies- FIX NEMA!
Madame President, it is not sufficient for those on the governing side to stand with their fancy speeches about how the damages and ravages of Dorian are personal and emotional to them, because we all have family and friends that were affected, additionally, the damages experienced on those Islands are emotional and personal to us all. So again I say that the storm has passed, don’t create another disaster with our government agencies- FIX NEMA!
Madame President, it is not sufficient for those on the governing side to scream from the mountain top, that the PLP IS PLAYING POLITICS, because not everyone that were affected feel as if this Government has done or is doing everything in their power to bring normalcy back to their lives. So the opposition speaks for all Bahamians, inclusive of those who feel neglected by this Administration. Therefore, I state again, the storm has passed, don’t create another disaster with our government agencies-FIX NEMA!
Madame President, we must get things right, in get to things right, this Government must be willing and able to listen to and accept the criticism. So, some issues with this legislation, outside of the fact that it is not necessary, because you can just fix NEMA, is firstly, this Bill is laced with conflict, and confusion. And the impression I formed, Madame President, is that this Government has been making rookie mistakes and created so much confusion following the passing of Dorian, it’s as if they are Amateurs! Unable to identify their head from their tail, running around like headless chickens, just creating new Ministries and Authorities (Like Oprah said- YOU GET A MINISTRY, YOU GET A MINISTRY, WE ALL GET A MINISTRY!!!); but without any clear assurance as to whether the legislation is necessary, functional or practical.
However, Madame President, I advise this FNM Administration that a bigger or larger Government is not the answer; in fact, the answer to moving this country forward after a disaster of this magnitude, is having a more effective and productive Government, one that is ready on day one!
Madame President, I am further concerned with the duplication of the Government agencies and overlapping responsibilities. And I ask the question, can someone from the Governing side please explain to me the purpose or the relevance of NEMA? Because it doesn’t appear they are relevant from this legislation!
Madame President, for a moment let us go to the Bill, at Clause 6 the Bill grants the Reconstruction Authority the power (a) to accept, deposit and act as trustee and manager of any gifts, donations, endowments, or bequests for the purpose of reconstruction of a Disaster Zone.
However, under section 34 of the Disaster Preparedness and Response Act, NEMA has the power to operate bank accounts, and to receive and disburse monies held in those accounts. The funds for those accounts consist of monies supplied by Parliament and donated by persons.
Further, Madame President, the draftsman tried to clear this apparent conflict up at Clause 28(2) and provided that where a donation is given for both relief and reconstruction, the relief portion shall go to NEMA and the reconstruction portion should go to the Authority in the proportion as directed by the donor; and where there is no direction, it shall be equally divided.
However, Madame President, I find this to be an interesting and impractical solution.
How will the Government effectively manage this commingling of funds and ensure the Authority and NEMA are being properly funded? And all of this is only brought about by the creation of an unnecessary organizational structure and an attempt to construe the slightest of differences between the Authority and NEMA.
Madame President, I go even further, Section 3 subsection (6) of the Disaster Preparedness and Response Act, provides for the appointment of Consultative Committee in each settlement, town area or district to assist the Director of NEMA and Administrator in formulating disaster preparedness measures and in discharging the functions of NEMA in respect of the settlement, town area or district.
However, Madame President, at Clause 16 of the Bill, it provides that the Board may appoint a Disaster Zone Reconstruction Committee when there is contemplation of a potential disaster or immediately after the occurrence of a disaster that is large scale or complex in nature.
Madame President, here again there appears to be duplication of efforts, and frankly
this can only cause further confusion. On the one hand we have NEMA appointing a
consultative committee and on the other there is the Authority in the Bill appointing
another committee.
To further complicate things, Madame President, I also note that there are no qualifications or no maximum/ minimum number of persons given for such committee. As such, I query, exactly how many persons can be appointed to this committee? What skillset is required by those on the Committee? Is it necessary for the Committee to be a resident of the affected area? Why has this been left open ended? And why is there no defined role in this Bill for the Consultative Committee, or any committee?
Madame President, I am even more confused by (1) Clause 28 subsection (1) where it states it to be mandatory for NEMA to collaborate with the Authority and (2) Clause28 subsection (3) which grants the Director of NEMA to delegate any or all of its functions within the Disaster Zone to the Authority where he determines it to be appropriate. When this draft was being considered, I query, under which circumstance does the Government consider this transfer of powers by NEMA to the Authority desirable or necessary?
The Government should note, amidst all of this confusion that the functions of the Director of NEMA exceeds those of the Authority as it relates to disaster preparedness and relief. So why is there a provision for the Director of NEMA to transfer such powers? Further, Madame President, there remains to be no line of demarcation drawn between the recovery obligations of the Director of NEMA and the Authority!
Which leads me to my last point of contention. Madame President, I query, Can the Government honestly guarantee to the Bahamian people that there will be no political influence or interference with this Authority? In this place and the other, those on the governing side likes to cry, the PLP playing politics. However, I am certain the Bahamian people will agree with me that this Government is the only one playing politics, and wasting our time. Madame President, I ask why does the Minister have to give directions of a general nature to the Authority as stated in Clause 29? Why secure this overriding power for the Minister?
Further, Madame President, if you look at Schedule 3, you can almost round it off and
say the majority of the Board will be appointed by the Prime Minister or in Consultation with the Prime Minister, so where is the assurances that there would be limited Government influences across these Ministries.
It just seems the more things change the more they remain the same under this administration! However, instead of getting on with bringing relief, this Government, is wasting more time, more manpower, more resources in creating redundancy after redundancy.
While Dorian has been described as the greatest disaster in the world, Madame President, I am convinced that this Administration will go down in history carrying the same title and headline.
To describe by visuals what a confused group they are, I created this graphic to honestly show the mess that has been created. (BOARD)
Madame President, just look at what is happening. You have Grand Bahama, Abaco and all the connected Cays in the middle of all of this. And honestly, persons just truly want relief, recovery, and rebuilding. However, this Government is only bringing confusion, frustration and bureaucracy to an already difficult time. Who is managing who? Who is instructing whom? Which agency is the first point of contact? Who is the official authority in charge? When should you go to NEMA? Who directs Social Services and the Defence Force? What is the desired end result?
Madame President, while this Minnis Administration assume they are creating efficiency, it has unfortunately, added another layer of bureaucracy and I am afraid we will not be able to recover from this if they continue down this road of appointing this one, creating that authority, but not getting to the real issues. Some of which are:
• What is the official death toll to date?
• How many persons are confirmed missing to date?
• Do we have the same number of missing persons across all the agencies, that is, does Social Services records match that of the Police?
• How many death certificates have been issued to families of persons whose bodies have yet to be discovered? Madame President, I recall reading a statement where the AG said the Government would issue death certificates expeditiously, so how many if that is so?
• And are these numbers being added to the death toll? I see in today’s paper the Government plan to have a ceremony for people swept away by Dorian. So are these persons now included in the death toll or are they still listed as missing?
• When can we expect reconstruction of all Government buildings that were destroyed during the hurricane?
• What is the expected time for when those affected Bahamians can move into the temporary tent city? We don’t want to hear weeks, or soon, WHAT IS THE DATE? Will it be before Christmas?
Madame President, there are many more questions that are lingering in the minds of many Bahamians. And it is known in the Bahamas that we have a history of duplicating Government agencies and creating redundancies instead of correcting existing inefficiencies. Further, Madame President, there is an unstated point obviously being made by the Government, which is, that the existing agencies and departments are not responsive, suitable and/or capable of mounting a recovery effort. However, instead of conducting a proper analysis of the reasons for these apparent disabilities in the system, this Government has chosen to take the convenient path of creating another organization that will be funded from the Consolidated Fund replicating much of what NEMA was created to do.
Madame President, nothing in this legislation, can bring me to a point where I can support the bureaucracy this Government has created. Madame President, by the mere fact we are debating this legislation; it is evidence enough that this Government thinks NEMA is inefficient of ineffective. And while they are positioned with an opportunity to do what is necessary to fix the inefficiencies, they do the unthinkable and create another layer of confusion and for this reason, added to the many laid out throughout my contribution. I do not support this bill.
End.
-
Monthly Press Conference
STATEMENT BY THE OPPOSITION LEADER
HON. PHILIP BRAVE DAVIS QC, MP
MONTHLY PRESS CONFERENCE
PLP HEADQUARTERS
For immediate release
4th June 2019
PLEASE CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY
THE PLP SALUTES THE LABOUR MOVEMENT
This week is a week when we salute Labour and the working men and women of our country.
I do so this morning without qualification.
I say without fear of contradiction that the PLP and Labour are one. We are joined at the hip.
The history and the legacy are clear.
Labour and the PLP worked together to bring about the legal changes which we enjoy today which provide a greater measure of social justice in our country.
Further, the economic gains that we have made were made because of the work of the PLP and Labour together.
We remember today the workers who struck a blow for freedom on 1st June 1942 which the late Sir Randol Fawkes described as the seminal event in the history of Labour rights in the country.
It was because of that proverbial blow struck on 1st June 1942, called the Burma Road Riots, that we have Labour Day on this weekend.
I recall specifically our work together with Labour on the general strike of 1958 that provided the immediate impetus for constitutional change in our country.
I recall the historic Memorandum of Understanding between the Labour movement and the PLP in 1977 that led to the current changes in the Industrial Relations Act including
agency shop.
I call today for the PLP and Labour to sit and negotiate a new Memorandum of Understanding as we plot the way forward for the rights of working men and women in our country.
I am open to sitting with Labour and my colleagues to begin working on such a memorandum.
I shall be marching with Labour in Nassau on Friday as will PLP supporters. The Deputy Leader Chester Cooper will be marching with Labour in Freeport on Friday.
I urge all supporters to join us.
Solidarity forever – the union makes us strong.
THE BUDGET COMMUNICATION
The 2019 Budget has sealed the fate of this FNM Administration as the most dishonest in the history of an independent Bahamas and of this Minister of Finance as the worst Minister of Finance in our history.
Last year, I predicted that this arrogant and heartless Government would make ordinary and vulnerable Bahamians pay for their unrealistic campaign promises by increasing the VAT rate.
This prediction was correct, and the effects were as I had predicted.
At 1.6%, this is well short of the economic growth predicted at 2%.
The government has failed to achieve its revenue and deficit targets.
They spent $216 million more than they spent during the last fiscal year.
They borrowed more than $2 billion since coming to office.
They borrowed four times in this current fiscal year to pay salaries.
They begged RBC to extend the overdraft facility to pay salaries.
So, where did all the borrowed money go?
Where did the 60% VAT money go?
Bahamians are asking Mr. Turnquest.
They will miss their deficit target by a mile.
They will miss their revenue target by hundreds of millions.
No Mr. Turnquest, there will be no financial windfall in the last quarter.
But things could have been worse had it not been for three external forces:
- The opening of Baha Mar and the Pointe development,
- A robust and buoyant United States economy; and
- No natural disasters, such a devastating Hurricanes.
Despite the repeated deceitful assurances of the Minister of Finance in Parliament and everywhere else, there was no study or mathematical modelling around the VAT increase – an unbelievably poor decision.
Let’s briefly look inside the numbers. The Finance Minister said that revenue collection this fiscal year ending June 2019 would be $2.4 billion or 42% more than the Government reported as collected in March 2018.
This is not likely as the Government as of March 2019 collected $1,689 million or an average of $187.6 million per month.
Over 12 months, this translates to $2.25 billion and a revenue shortfall of $397 million in comparison to the original budget.
This 15% revenue shortfall without any external shock to the Bahamian economy, is catastrophic and speaks to the high degree of incompetence of the Minister of Finance.
The Minister’s request for roughly $72 million in new funding or an average of $6 million per month, is also unrealistic.
The true figure, we estimate, is closer to $20 million per month.
The Minister, with no plausible explanation, has increased the tax collection trajectory of the Government by $161 million in the last three months.
As I stated previously for this to go unchallenged would make The Bahamas the laughingstock of the fiscal world.
I call on Peter Turnquest to either withdraw that estimate or provide the evidence to support the estimate.
This is a serious matter, one in which every Bahamian is impacted.
I recently predicted that the government would either borrow more money or increase taxes as the revenue performance from the first quarter of this fiscal year has been consistently poor.
What is scary is that the Minister of Finance has chosen to double down on last year’s lie about the expected yield from the VAT rate increase.
Proper revenue and economic projections and estimates are important as they have consequences.
Parliament must make informed decisions about whether the Government has enough funds to operate otherwise our people will suffer.
Royal Bank, CIBC and Scotiabank, our primary creditors, must use that information to make decisions about whether they can further extend credit, something the Government desperately needs.
These bad decisions also affect ordinary Bahamians as they do business with these same banks.
The evidence available to me suggests that the Government currently does not have and in the next fiscal year, will not have enough funds to operate.
This means the following:
- Many businesses and contractors will have to endure long waits for payments. This imposes an invisible tax on them.
- Ordinary Bahamians and the vulnerable would suffer because of the lack of resources. We have seen further cuts to the Ministry of Social Services totaling some $1.5 million and in the Ministry of Youth totaling some $4 million.
- The net result of the fiscal policy of this Government is a recession and an increase in the economic pain of the Bahamian people.
My Parliamentary colleagues and I will have more to say on this budget during the debate.
We ask Bahamians to tune in on Wednesday at or around 3pm to hear our lead speaker, I. Chester Cooper, deliver his contribution, where he will dissect the budget and tell the Bahamian people what’s in it for them.
HOTEL UNION STRIKE VOTE
Simply put, if the Labour Minister was doing his job, labour relations in our premier industry should not have soured to the point where the Bahamas Hotel Catering and Allied Workers Union felt the need to take a strike vote.
They voted almost unanimously to strike.
This labour situation is now at a critical stage.
So, while the luckiest Tourism Minister ever is prancing around and boasting about the tourism arrival numbers, it appears that the financial windfall enjoyed by the hotels is not being shared equitably with the thousands of workers who drive the industry.
Our understanding is that the Government is not taking this matter seriously and is not moving aggressively enough to get the parties to the table and have this matter settled.
Our position is that the 15% gratuity must remain as part of the contractual negotiations.
Bahamians need to earn a livable wage and we stand with the hotel workers.
We call on the Minister of Labour to do more to settle this impasse.
We call for mutual respect at all levels between employers and workers.
Nothing should be done in these ongoing negotiations to harm The Bahamas.
THE PREMATURE ANNOUNCEMENT BY CORNELIUS SMITH
Many of you no doubt have seen the video that went viral on social media. C. A. Smith, former MP, Cabinet Minister and of late Ambassador to six Latin American countries, announced his resignation and advised that he would be the next Governor General.
We point again the rank disregard and disrespect for proper protocol that seems endemic in the FNM. The Prime Minister does not know what to say in church.
C. A. Smith also said that his appointment was approved by Buckingham Palace. This is untrue and is therefore of great concern to us.
I now note that he has, in fact, apologized.
APPOINTMENT OF RUTH BOWE-DARVILLE TO THE SUPREME COURT
In his latest mockery of our Constitution, the Prime Minister has appointed Ruth Bowe-Darville as a Supreme Court Justice – literally four days before her 65th birthday, the maximum age for appointment.
While I bear no ill-will toward Mrs. Bowe-Darville, it simply cannot be right to appoint someone to high constitutional office knowing full well that their appointment will run out in exactly four days time.
Moreover, it makes a complete travesty of the constitutional procedure that must now unfold to extend the appointment beyond the retirement age.
It shows that the Prime Minister never had any plan to seriously consult with me, as Leader of the Opposition.
On the contrary, he appointed Mrs. Bowe-Darville at the proverbial 11th Hour with the pre-conceived determination to immediately extend her appointment for two years without any real regard for any views that I, as Leader of the Opposition, might have on the matter of her extension.
This is not what our Constitution calls for.
Any consultation would therefore be bogus.
This is playing games with our Constitution and trampling it underfoot.
Unfortunately, the Prime Minister has a very bad habit of doing these things. It is getting worse. It is high-handed. It is unprincipled. It is arrogant. And it calls for unqualified condemnation.
The Prime Minnis really needs to check this increasingly dictatorial attitude.
He is behaving like an Emperor who is accountable to no one.
MINISTER ROLLE’S PROTOCOL BREACH
It is bad enough that the government has slashed the budget of the Ministry of Youth, Sports and Culture by $4 million, the Minister, Lanisha Rolle, has reportedly refused to meet with local sports federations led by the Bahamas Olympic Association (BOA) on the way forward.
I am reliably advised that of particular concern by the BOA, is the Minister’s breach of protocol in traveling to Tokyo to the IAAF World Relays, the same event that was stopped by the FNM government.
While the Minister is well within her rights to attend international sporting events, she must seek the approval of local federations, in this case the BAAAs, in order to secure accreditation if she is on official government business. We are advised that this was not done.
The federations are asking for a meeting or they’ll take a stronger stand, one of which will be the removal of the Minister or the athletes and federations will shut down.
The PLP has repeatedly said that the FNM, by their actions, do not support our youth, culture or sports.
It is bad enough that many major unions are unhappy with current labour relations, it is unnecessary and foolhardy for Minister Rolle to pick what would become a public fight with local sporting organizations and the BOA.
The government should be about supporting these organizations and strengthening our international brand as a sports powerhouse.
This is highly unfortunate, and the Minister’s behavior is unseemly and inappropriate, and the Prime Minister must intervene and correct this.
We have a government that believes the rules apply to other people, not to themselves.
How else to explain the appointment of a judge four days before the Constitution says her term expires?
We have a government that is completely disconnected from the people.
How else to explain a budget that ignores the serious cost-of-living burdens facing Bahamians today?
For too many working Bahamians, their wages are not enough to get by, let alone get ahead.
We have a government that believes Bahamians should shut up and deal with the economic pain in the name of reducing deficits, even as they fail to reduce those deficits, and even as they cut special deals for members of Cabinet, who – believe me — are not being asked to share these same burdens.
Thank you, and with that, I am happy to take questions.
-
Chester Cooper Budget Contribution
2019 2020 BUDGET CONTRIBUTION
CHESTER COOPER, EXUMAS AND RAGGED ISLAND MP, PLP DEPUTY LEADER
JUNE 5, 2019
Good afternoon,
It is always an honor to stand and address this House on behalf of the great people of the Exumas and the great and long-suffering people of Ragged Island.
I note that I have two hours to speak today.
Though I do hope and pray it does not take me two hours to say what needs to be said.
We sat in this House last week to hear a budget communication that lasted almost four hours .
Frankly, it was dull. Devoid of hope. Provided no uplift for the Bahamian people.
It was unimaginative and uninspiring.
It engendered no confidence in the future of this administration.
It had no overriding rallying theme. It lacked center. It lacked soul.
And I have to also be frank in saying that the vast majority of that was unnecessary political rhetoric.
But more on that in a bit.
When I came to this House two years ago, it was against the backdrop of an historic election that saw the Progressive Liberal Party suffer a great defeat, and swept in a Free National Movement that focused much on so-called corruption, and promises of transparency.
I thought there was a great deal of naiveté coming from the government side as it sought to demonize Bahamians as a corrupt people.
I heard a lot of piggybacking and attempts to fix or enhance PLP programs, not a lot of innovation or thorough discourse.
But I was hopeful.
I was hopeful that the FNM would move the nation forward, as they were elected to do.
I was rooting for their success, even being in opposition.
I am PLP but I am a Bahamian first, a nationalist, a businessman with a family.
If The Bahamas succeeds then we all do.
A rising tide they say, float all boats.
And so, with some level of hope, I sat through the member from East Grand Bahama’s first budget statement in 2017.
And my hope faded fast.
He used that communication to deride the PLP.
To claim they had done a disservice to the Bahamian people.
He said the PLP ran up hundreds of millions of dollars in bills, then he proceeded to borrow hundreds of millions of dollars on the backs of the Bahamian people.
I swiftly pointed out that it was the “wrong speech, at the wrong time”.
Then I sat here again in 2018, my hopes immensely tempered, wishing I would hear some semblance of sense after the hundreds of millions borrowed.
But my hopes were dashed again, as the minister and this administration did the unthinkable.
They raised VAT on the people, and tried to sell it at any cost.
This administration and their operatives made nonsensical arguments about dollar devaluation and the fate of other nations and the possibility of losing a country because they simply couldn’t manage to figure out to how to run this government without causing immense pain to the Bahamian people.
The things they railed against the PLP for – the establishment of value added-tax, the regulation and taxation of the gaming industry – they said that these same things were the mechanisms of their salvation.
And only going beyond where the PLP wisely decided not to go with these measures, could the Bahamian people be saved from certain doom.
What we understood at the time, and now it is quite plain to see, is that the ones the people needing saving from, were the members of the Free National Movement administration.
It was a dangerous move, a heavy gamble.
But they said they had the economic models.
They said they knew what they were doing.
They said they were confident they could collect the revenue and the Bahamian people could take the strain.
We told them it was too steep to soon; it would dampen the economy, increase unemployment, inflict great pain on the Bahamian people.
And now we know that they were wrong. And we were right.
We know that because we come to this latest budget communication delivered last week.
And we see a pattern of non-inspiring doubling down of wrongheadedness of epic proportions.
But before we get into the meat of this latest failed budget submitted to this House, let me explain something.
I did not come to this place to sugarcoat or to make friends.
I came here to help.
I came to contribute to a nation that has contributed so much to me.
For perspective, I was born and grew up at Forbes Hill, Little Exuma, in a level of poverty that many in this place claim to know, but surely don’t act like they’ve ever experienced.
I was the last of 12 children, raised by a widowed mother.
I had no silver spoon.
I had no prospects and no rich uncle.
What I had was a loving family, a supportive community, a nurturing “village”, and a government, a Progressive Liberal Party government, that believed in investing in the Bahamian people.
I stayed out of trouble. I studied hard.
I got a scholarship, a government scholarship, to attend university, and the village helped.
And through hard work and God’s grace, I achieved much.
And though I have given back much throughout my career and businesses, I found myself at a place where I saw politics as a chance to make a difference on a national scale.
I hear some on the other side as they constantly make references to my wealth.
They say I’m a rich man. You will hear it again before this debate ends.
I am not offended by it.
I have earned everything I have with sweat, struggle and a lot of tears.
I am proud of what I have achieved with the help of the Almighty and the loyalty and support of the Bahamian people.
But, I suppose, richness and wealth – it is all relative.
There are those who I could mention who benefited from a legacy of privilege who have amassed a bounty that would make a king blush.
Yet, they want more.
I call them the “Special Interest”.
The Special Interest in this country who are constantly protected by this government.
That’s right, this budget itself is a budget for the Special Interest.
This administration promised campaign finance reforms in the interest of their soap box “transparency and accountability”.
And I was once again naively hopeful that with those reforms we would be better equipped to limit and expose the influence of special interests.
And I came here to protect the poor and middle class from the “Wolves of Special Interests”.
Those special interests whom some on the other side would support by squeezing taxes from the poorest among us whilst turning a blind eye to numerous board appointments from special interests that apparently seeks to gobble the resources of this country, while displaying no consideration for the most vulnerable they represent.
I came to this place to protect and do all I can to uplift the Bahamian People; create opportunities and empowerment for our youth.
I came to this place to protect the struggling businessman, who wants to know the pride in building something he or she can hand down to the next generation, much like those who have so much who you so unfailingly protect.
I came here to empower the Bahamian people.
To help break the poverty cycle, to bring solutions if I can to structural unemployment; that’s what the PLP philosophy is about.
Many who sit in here will praise the movement of a post office to Town Center Mall as a national achievement, yet fiddle while Bahamas Power and Light says one thing and does another, while still failing to provide affordable electricity and keep the lights on.
I came here because I feared for this country should the wolves of special interests convince the gatekeepers they would be good protectors of the sheep.
And I see now my fear was right.
Yes, this is a budget for the rich, connected and the powerful. The special interest.
Some people are protected, their fortunes jealously guarded, while others are expected to give more than they have.
There are those of us in here who will dismiss the failure of this administration to keep the lights on with an admonition to take a “cowboy” shower.
There are those of us in here, who will sit idly by and thunderously applaud the application of even more pressure to the poor and working class, yet say nothing when asked why we do not tax the wealthy.
Because clearly, we give tax breaks to the rich in The Bahamas. We only tax the working and middle class.
We only tax those still in the struggle. But I will tell you, that the struggle is real.
If you’re one of the lucky few who made it, congratulations, it’s smooth sailing from here with this government.
I came to this place because I wanted to create a Bahamas my children, Chelsea, Izak and Chloe, could inherit.
I came here because I wanted to empower Exuma and her people and Ragged Island too.
From Duncan Town to Williams Town, From Forbes Hill to Farmers Hill, to Black Point, to Highbourne Cay and everywhere in between.
Because there are still far too many forgotten people in our Family islands.
There’s an incredible amount of work to be done, inside and outside this place.
And I do thank my wife, Cecillia, my children and my business associates for the significant sacrifices they make on my behalf and those I represent.
I came here because I saw so many who had no voice crying out, yet still being ignored.
Much like the people of Ragged Island, who many of you think can survive on grandiose promises by the prime minister.
It is my sincere hope, that during this budget debate, our prime minister will offer an apology to the people of Ragged Island for gross neglect on the part of this administration.
It is my hope that this prime minister and the minister of education will articulate what the government intends to do on Ragged Island about the upcoming school year.
It is my hope that there is a plan in place, right now, for the provision of a nurse and some sort of clinic facility on Ragged Island.
The need for this is urgent.
These are real people, with real needs that the government is not meeting.
I cry and make noise for them because their cries have clearly fallen on deaf ears.
A failed budget
This budget is a failure.
It is painfully clear that there was heavy lobbying for and on behalf of special interest and their negotiators won.
So, I ask, who negotiated for the people?
Because clearly the special interest got tax breaks and the poor and middle class got shafted once again.
We see the new car dealers at it again.
On top of the $25 million lost in excise tax lost last year because you allow them to bring in the cars duty free and only pay taxes when they sell the car, they get even more tax breaks this time.
In the real property tax amendments, the removal of the residency requirement for home owner’s exemption for real property tax. Instead of 6 months it is now just seasonal occupancy, which could be widely interpreted and abused by rich second home owners. This is going to cost the Government millions. So the rich get loopholes and the poor gets crayons.
Yay. It’s the poor people’s time to stock their cupboard with crayons.
There is a new tax on currency conversion of 1.5% when you exchange currency. Not only does this potentially undermine dollar parity but it unintentionally encourages hoarding and a black market.
The Exchange Control regulation was amended last year to allow businesses to operate US$ accounts. So this is going to hit the poor disproportionately. In the simplest terms, as I interpret it, if a straw vendor, jet ski operator or tour operator in Exuma deposits a US$100 into their B$ account they would receive credit for only $98.50.
The rich get loopholes and the poor get taxed! How caring. It must be the people’s time.
So, I will say it again, this is a failure of a budget.
But I expect failure from a failed crew, though it does sadden me.
As far as I’m concerned, this travesty of an FNM budget has not one new idea that the PLP did not leave in the pipeline.
What a curious set of people we have in governance now. Always blaming the PLP for something, then claiming credit for what the PLP put in place.
For instance, the Small Business Development Center we hear this administration talking so much about.
It was former Minister of State for Finance Michael Halkitis who signed the deal for the establishment of that program with the OAS.
It was the PLP that determined the SBDC would be at the University of The Bahamas, to shield it from political interference.
Yet, the PLP is never mentioned when we hear of these success stories.
I wonder what the PLP sowed that this visionless government will reap credit for next.
Yes, the FNM is a visionless party that is also wildly hypocritical.
There’s the obvious, “taxing is the lazy way out”, from their leader himself.
Guess we’re not supposed to bring that up anymore.
But there’s also just the embarrassing and the shameful.
Remember when the FNM was against the Spy Bill before it was for it and passed it? Didn’t Killarney march with We March against it? How hypocritical.
Remember when the FNM said it believed in free tuition yet is standing by while tuition costs significantly go up at UB?
Remember when the FNM said the BPL exemption would benefit 60,000 households, now we understand it’s only 23,000?
Remember when the FNM said they were friends of the poor, yet gave tax breaks on caviar, new cars, planes, helicopters? How compassionate? I guess it’s dem people’s time.
Remember when the member for Southern Shores promised more money for local government in his first budget speech, yet there has been no appreciable increase?
Is it just me?
No one else remember any of that?
Aside from the lack of vision, the hypocrisy, the claiming of credit for other people’s ideas, this budget itself falls short of the standard of a budget which should be delivered to Parliament.
This failure is alarming, given the traditional apolitical stance of the Ministry of Finance in presenting fiscal numbers.
The standard for budgets is included in the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) Manual of Fiscal Transparency.
And, honestly, for an administration that likes to refer to the IMF so much, I find their failure to adhere to the manual when presenting the budget quite puzzling.
Here is what the manual says this about budget data:
“Budget data should reflect recent revenue and expenditure trends, underlying macroeconomic developments, and well-defined policy commitments.”
On both accounts the government has failed.
The government has inexplicably increased revenue growth trends and decrease expenditure trends without explanation.
How can the government justify the withholding of payment to BPL as demonstrated in this budget for the period up to March 2019?
Or the non-payment of the insurance for the police, prison officers, defence force officers, customs officers, immigration officers and judicial officers as reflected in the numbers up to March 2019?
To ignore critical payments or inflate revenue numbers to meet some arbitrary deficit target is not right and reflects a minister and government desperate and disconnected from the reality of The Bahamas.
The government has simply ignored this basic principle and put forward a set of numbers with little or no reference to the commitments already stated and in the public domain.
I note, for example:
· The lack of funding for the free tuition commitment for Bahamian students at University of The Bahamas.
· The inclusion of cruise port revenue in the revenue figures of the budget given the government’s commitment to privatize the port.
· The absence of any forecasting for the proceeds from the sale of the Grand Lucayan, although a Letter of Intent is supposedly signed.
And that’s just to name a few of these examples on the expenditure side.
On the revenue side, it is even more alarming.
The minister of finance, apparently in seeking to avoid breaching the limits in the Fiscal Responsibility Act, appears motivated to make the numbers work.
Why should we believe any of these revenue projections when the projections for 2019/2020 were so far off target?
The revenue numbers, in my opinion, can’t be trusted.
It is unfortunate that the minister would seek to empanel a Fiscal Council with this failure to meet revenue targets so fresh in the mind of the public and this Parliament.
If the Fiscal Council is to have even a shred of credibility, it has no choice but to immediately dispute the revenue estimates in this budget.
The IMF’s Manual on Fiscal Transparency, your friends, mind you, says this about revenue estimates:
“Realistic revenue forecasts are especially important since relatively small errors in forecasting this large aggregate can have a large impact on the fiscal balance given that expenditure is often difficult to adjust in response to revenue shortfalls. Revenue forecasts should be fully explained in terms of recent revenue trends, likely macroeconomic developments, and the estimated impact on revenue of any emerging consequences of existing tax policies and of any new tax changes.”
Very little of that appears to have been taken into account here.
The IMF Manual, these are your good friends, also speaks to something called internal consistency:
“Crosschecks of internal consistency of fiscal data should be undertaken, and the effectiveness of these procedures reported.”
In this case, the minister of finance has clearly failed.
As of March 2019, the average monthly revenue was $188 million per month leading to a projected year-end figure of $2.252 billion.
The minister, without any explanation, has estimated the year end figure to be $2.413 billion.
This difference of $161 million has allowed the minister to project a year -end deficit of 1.8 percent rather than 3 percent.
If he is wrong as I contend, his budget deficit won’t be $229 million but more than $400 million on this point alone.
There is no credible financial analyst who would accept these figures at face value.
So, really, this is all for naught and the credibility of this minister and the Ministry of Finance which he heads has suffered further damage.
After the minister’s second budget I introduced a concept of a credibility deficit.
I’m afraid it’s gotten wider.
This minister is concerned about the GFS deficit, but should be more concerned about the “credibility deficit”.
Yeah, you have a Credibility Deficit.
Bank tax regime
The minister’s treatment of the new tax regime for banks is also curious.
I would hope this isn’t a case of his famous poor modeling and he doesn’t end up inflating the business license’s projected yield.
Bahamian commercial banks pay business license of 3 percent of gross revenue and bank license fees.
The bank license fees were returned to the Central Bank to pay for the regulatory cost of supervision.
The minister is proposing that this continues but is showing this figure in a separate line but not reducing the business license revenue by the corresponding amount.
He is doing the same thing for premium tax collected by the Insurance Commission and remitted to the central government.
This is now called a dividend from the Insurance Commission, which for presentation purposes has been subsumed in business license fees for several years.
So, the true business license number by my calculations needs to be reduced by at least $40 million.
Therefore, I submit, that business license revenue in the 2019/2020 budget may be overstated by as much as $40 million.
This, when you to add to the true shortfall of this year of what I explained is likely to be $400 million, means that next year’s starting deficit without any tax adjustment could be $440 million.
This is a huge amount and unless addressed would effectively cripple the government operations in the coming year.
That, or this fanciful spending planned for next year will be shelved, just like it was this year, in order to hit the legally mandated deficit target.
When one looks at such a startling shortfall of revenue, one would think the minister would seek to close the loopholes as he has been talking tough on tax collections.
However, going over the fiscal documents, it all appears to have indeed been all talk.
The minister covers for the failure to restart the Revenue Enhancement Unit during the current fiscal year as promised in last year’s Budget Communication by putting forward an amendment to allow the financial secretary to hire contract workers to collect taxes. We heard this talk and flip-flop on this REU unit before.
Business license issues
The creating of four different start and end of tax year periods for business license registrants is one of the worse ideas that can be found in this budget.
Why did the government not just make it easier to pay quarterly in arrears for large businesses?
That would have improved the ease of doing business.
Instead, the government will likely create a compliance nightmare for itself, and this is for a tax type where you already have a compliance problem.
Not satisfied with immersing just the Department of Inland Revenue in a nightmare scenario, it follows that those who compile national statistics will be dragged into this nightmare as well.
Perhaps the minister did not realize he has responsibility for the Department of Statistics and business license data is an important data source.
However, I get the impression from the current fiscal budget and the one that is being proposed. I must question whether the minister is not too concerned about the reliability of statistics.
Another example in folly, or perhaps design, is exempting the revenue of wholly owned subsidiaries from business license once 90 percent of their sales is to the parent company.
This, in essence, is legalizing a method of some entities, such as large construction companies, in The Bahamas to avoid paying business license taxes.
The tax for them would now be on the margin i.e. the difference between what they charge the final customer and their internal cost provided by their subsidiary for the good or service.
The decision to allow a taxpayer to choose a tax year for assessment would lead to a reduction in the business license base and ultimately in the amount of revenue collected.
It would be better to decrease the rates across the board rather than create loopholes for special interests.
As for the exemption of revenue derived from export services for business license fees, it is clear that the minister does not understand how much revenue the large communications companies derive from foreign based counterparts in things like roaming fees, which would now all be exempt.
Speaking about the communication sector, I did not see an explanation for the 75 percent reduction in communication levy revenue in the budget.
Nor did I see an honest explanation for making the VAT exemption for electricity permanent.
An audit of the two large power companies to determine how they account for the VAT exemption would be very interesting.
I say again, this is a budget driven by the “Wolves of Special Interest”.
Credit where credit is due
In the Budget Communication, the minister speaks of several initiatives without providing credit to the work of his predecessors.
This is an act of extreme bad taste.
Without the work done by the minister of finance and the minister of state for finance in the last Christie administration to modernize the Ministry of Finance, the country would be a lot worse off and the present minister of finance would have little to talk about in his communication except for his failure to achieve the revenue, expenditure and perhaps deficit goals in his budget.
Since the minister won’t do it, let me do it for him.
We would like to thank the Right Honorable Perry Gladstone Christie and the Honorable Michael Halkitis for the new chart of accounts – thank you.
We would like to thank them for the upgrade of the financial management system inclusive of the eventual replacement of the JD Edwards and SSA Global System. Thank you so much.
For the establishment of the Small Business Development Centre, we would like to thank the former ministers and the PLP. Since we like to talk so much about the PLP.
For the establishment of the inter departmental revenue taskforce, the Revenue Enhancement Unit, reporting to the minister of finance, we’d like to thank the PLP.
For the engagement of PWC to determine whether the Ministry of Finance was fit for purpose in a modern Bahamas, we would like to thank the PLP.
For the engagement of KPMG to examine public service pension reform, and the further engagement of an actuary, Mr. Derek Osbourne, to develop a framework for this reform, I’d like to thank the PLP.
I would note that this framework is currently in place for the University of The Bahamas and can be used as a model of pension reform going forward.
In short, you really don’t need to hire more consultants to figure it out.
The PLP already did that for you.
For the Electronic Single Window now dubbed Click2Share, that should have been launched two years ago, I would like to thank the PLP.
For the modernization of the property tax regime and outsourcing collection to experienced private agencies, I’d like to thank the PLP.
For the new Public Procurement Framework, let’s all take a moment, and thank the PLP.
IDB dependence
The 2019/2020 budget also reflects an alarming reality, that the Government’s dependency on the Inter-American Development Bank, and now the Caribbean Development Bank, to determine its development priorities for the government through the provision of funds.
But strangely, this administration seems not able to use the funds provided as none of the active projects had any disbursements up to March 2019, which is an indication of the inefficiency of this administration in managing these programs as the government is paying commitment fees on the undisbursed balances of these loans.
Also, for some inexplicable reason the government in its proceeds from borrowing is showing it would receive another $32.5 million from the IDB for an Air Transport Programme loan having budgeted for such, and I believe the minister of tourism and aviation confirmed receipt of these funds during this fiscal year.
If this is a mistake, I would recommend that the General Borrowing Resolution be immediately amended to account for the lack of availability of these funds.
The CDB streetlighting loan was approved by the CDB in December 2018 and it now coming to Parliament almost six months later for approval.
The Government should explain why it is borrowing money to invest in infrastructure owned by BPL.
On the face of it, this loan makes no sense as BPL, the entity providing the service is not obliged or committed to take any action.
Should not the loan be made to BPL?
Does the technical expertise exist within the government to run this program or would this be forced on BPL when it is focusing on fixing the major power generation issues in New Providence.
Is this also designed the way to cater to the “Wolves of special interests”.
Rate Reduction Bond
With respect to the Rate Reduction Bond, the minister in his communication did not mention the RRB when he provided what he called good news about making VAT exemption on electricity permanent, but this is material matter and warranted some commentary.
The RRB, I am told, could lead to increase in electricity bill by at least $0.06 a kwH on monthly bills this year, which could be a greater than 12 percent increase in the utility bills for BPL customers.
This would negate any savings afforded by the VAT exemption and for many large commercial businesses would be a potentially fatal blow.
I would have thought that the minister of finance would have use the opportunity of his communication to give some relevant information as the RRB levy is, for all intents and purposes, a tax.
But perhaps I ask for too much. Perhaps I will get their “wolves of special interests” to ask the question.
Tourism boom
As it regards our number one industry, the government appears to be wasting away the benefits from the opening of Baha Mar and the rise of Caribbean tourism.
By the way, no amount of self-praise is going to convince serious analysts that the minister of tourism’s hyperbolic comments about the bullish tourism numbers represents a renaissance in our product initiated by him.
He knows it has very little to do with him but its cool to ride a wave.
We know he is just the luckiest minister of tourism ever.
And we are happy for him and more so the Bahamian tourism industry and the Bahamian people.
However, what he has done is shamelessly, in my view, sought to appropriate credit to himself that is due to others who toiled in the face of his and his party’s unrelenting and mean-spirited criticism in trying to get Baha Mar operational. Now, Baha Mar is wonderful.
In addition, The Bahamas’ success is not unique.
Throughout the Caribbean, countries are experiencing a rebound in numbers.
Just look at Jamaica, St. Lucia, Cayman and Cuba.
All these countries have seen record breaking growth in tourism numbers.
The one difference from The Bahamas is that their investment pipeline is strong, whereas we have very little.
But we have Oban. An oil refinery deal mired in confusion, conspired by convicted criminals, where allegations of corruption persist.
Meanwhile in Aruba they are seeking ways to ensure that the closure of their refinery is permanent.
Outside of the Disney project for South Eleuthera, no significant investment in the tourism product has been announced by this government.
If the Grand Lucayan sale was close to reality the repayment of the so call equity investment would have been incorporated in the budget.
Yet, it is not.
I can personally tell you that this drop of public and private sector investment is worrying for our future economic prospects and this worry is compounded by this poorly prepared budget and an FNM administration that does not inspire confidence.
Squandered goodwill
What can be said about this administration is that it will waste no opportunity to squander good will and favorable macroeconomic conditions.
Never before have we seen a new government squander so much goodwill in such a short time.
There was a window, though my fear now is that it is closing before we can take advantage of it, that presented great opportunity.
With a global economy on the rise, no hurricanes in the last year and record tourism numbers, there was an opportunity to put the country on track for real economic expansion.
Instead, this administration borrowed billions, raised taxes and could not meet its own revenue projections.
And instead of concrete explanations that make sense, we get trite, superficial, platitudes laced throughout the communication, designed to camouflage this administration’s incompetence.
But know that the window may be closing.
There are storm clouds ahead in the global economy.
The U.S. economic slowdown is becoming more a probability.
The trade war the U.S. is involved in China will likely contribute to that slowdown and increase the cost of consumer goods for us in The Bahamas.
And in the face of these clear and present challenges, what do we get?
A budget and a minister who re-arranges the furniture whilst the house is flooding.
Here we go again
What’s really startling about this budget communication is that one can hardly tell where politics ends and real communication begins.
But I’m no longer surprised.
I would though, like to commend the professionals at the Ministry of Finance for work they do. There are many good people in public service who often get lumped in with bad apples.
I dismiss this notion that those in the public service are not at the top of their game, as I recognize their contribution to nation building.
When the minister delivered his first budget communication, I said it was the wrong speech at wrong time.
And here we are again.
For instance, the government has borrowed in excess of $2.5 billion, whether for refinancing or whatever.
Borrowing is borrowing, no matter how many times the minister tries to stand to his feet to object and claim people are misleading this House.
What is misleading is that in light of all this borrowing, the government only had one paragraph on debt at page 16 of the budget communication.
You have an obligation to explain to the Bahamian people why you borrowed $2.5 billion and what you did with the money.
Nothing on the amount or ratios as they increased.
So much for “transparency”, I guess.
In my opinion, we have a minister of finance who has a bad habit of speaking down to people who are expert in the finance field with more experience than himself.
When he talks about the budget he acts as if he is the only minister of finance in the history of this country who has any sense who knows what he is doing.
He belittles icons in finance and their contributions, like Sir William Allen and James Smith in newspaper articles and through the suggestion that before he came, as he did on page 5 of his budget communication things were wildly and negligently out of control.
However, I recall budgets with lower deficits, lower expenditure and much more expansive capital works programs where revenue projections were often met and sometimes exceeded.
This country has never defaulted on its debts, it has never lost its dollar parity, it has grown economically, though not fast enough, in my opinion, before this current minister of finance came along.
And I suspect we’ll be just fine when he is no longer minister of finance after the next election; time longer than rope.
We have a minister of finance who talks about no new tax categories.
Of course, he doesn’t mention the increase in taxes within categories.
Cute, but where is the transparency?
I note that this government went to great pain to say it wants to increase the Ease of Doing Business.
But the Ease of Doing Business Committee is in yesterday’s Nassau Guardian saying that they are disappointed and that the government is not doing nearly enough.
The government says it wants to build a 21st century infrastructure as a new foundation for growth. I honestly don’t see where this is being done.
You mean the road paving the prime minister announced in his national address?
I don’t think that’s going to cut it.
The government says it will invest in education to break the cycle of poverty. I’m not saying that’s not being done. But I don’t see it laid out where meaningful steps are being made in this regard.
I hear a lot of what we would like to see.
But I don’t hear or can’t find a roadmap to that place.
The government says it wants to invest in renewable energy to create a sustainable future.
Surely this is a joke.
The government doesn’t know whether it’s coming or going with BPL.
And there certainly is no green city in Ragged Island, two years later.
One day it announces a deal with Shell for X amount of generation.
The next day it has some side deal with Wartsila for some of that generation.
Yesterday, they said they had another deal to encroach more on territory that was supposed to be for Shell.
Meantime, the government doesn’t plan to get serious about renewables in the Family Islands, the most practical place to start.
SBDC
This minister says the government wants to take a focused approach to expanding support for Bahamian entrepreneurs and small businesses. A nice notion, but the SBDC is not well resourced enough to make a transformative impact in the overall economy in the short term, though I do applaud its successes.
Among them is Keniqua Burrows, a passionate educator, and former Teacher of the Year at L.N. Coakley High School, who stepped out on faith to open Exuma Christian Academy.
Keniqua was intent on blazing new trails in education in a difficult space.
I have no doubt she will do so. Best wishes to her and I offer my full support as I have demonstrated in the past.
What I believe though, is that there are many more Keniquas out there.
However, the SBDC has only been promised $25 million over 5 years by this administration.
A PLP government will dedicate at least $250 million over 5 years to the development of small and medium sized businesses in its next term in office.
That’s how seriously we take this sector. We mean business. Serious business.
We understand it is the driver of economic growth and employment.
We also believe the FNM should commit to listing in full the grants and funding made available through the SBDC.
That is, after all, what transparency is about.
Infrastructure
The government says it wants to build a 21st century infrastructure as a new foundation for growth. I honestly don’t see where this is being done.
You mean the road paving the prime minister announced in his national address?
I don’t think that’s going to cut it.
The government says it will invest in education to break the cycle of poverty. I’m not saying that’s not being done. But I don’t it laid out where meaningful steps are being made in this regard.
I hear a lot of what we would like to see.
But I don’t hear or can’t find a roadmap to that place.
The government says it wants to invest in renewable energy to create a sustainable future.
Surely this is a joke.
The government doesn’t know whether it’s coming or going with BPL.
One day it announces a deal with Shell for X amount of generation.
The next day it has some side deal with Wartsila for some of that generation.
Yesterday, they said they had another deal to encroach more on territory that was supposed to be for Shell.
Meantime, the government doesn’t plan to get serious about renewables in the Family Islands, the most practical place to start.
And your talk don’t line up with your action. You underspend your current years capital budget by $92 million and then you cut your next year’s capital budget by 25 percent.
The one thing you are consistent with is having talk that don’t line up with your actions.
This is why you have such wide credibility deficit.
Your words can no longer be trusted.
The cost of the FNM’s dithering
As opposed to being focused, what the FNM has done a great deal of is dithering.
For example, the FNM’s stop, cancel and review 2.0 lead to an at least 15-month delay in introducing new engines at BPL; the direct cost to BPL would average at least $10 million per month.
This is a conservative estimate just from the continued use of the most expensive fuel possible.
The actual cost to the public cannot be measured. You can’t really put a dollar value on suffering, can you?
The FNM’s dithering led to the disruption of the post office opening, ending in a windfall to a minister and an eyesore on a heavily trafficked highway.
The FNM’s dithering has led to the delay in completion of the baseball stadium, meaning millions of dollars in cost overruns.
The FNM’s dithering has led to increased interest due to a failure to pay legitimate debts on time.
The FNM’s dithering and witch hunts has led to millions of dollars in so-called forensic audits.
Of course, this supposed transparent government won’t reveal the costs of all these audits.
So much talk about old bills. Still finding bills, the minister says, under every nook and cranny.This, after borrowing billions and increasing taxes massively.
What I find interesting though, is that no one is disputing the bills.
By paying them they accept the concept of continuous government.
So where is the morality in still having not paid the bills two years in?
This administration is to be condemned.
They should be condemned for not paying the people.
Should they not pay them on a “first in, first out” basis?
Where is the morality in not doing so?
BTC
In relation to BTC.
Perhaps I’m reading it wrong, but this government’s approach to the BTC pension liability seems to be an admission that the BTC deal was a bad one.
But this was an FNM deal, yes?
The current prime minister sat in this place as a member of Cabinet and approved this bad deal? Correct?
Can we finally admit that the FNM effectively gave BTC away for $210 million?
Now they are sending some of that money back.
The minister of Finance is effectively condemning the prime minister who sat in the cabinet and was a party to that bad deal.
I do thank the minister of finance for validating the point the PLP has been making all along.
Further, the liability continues to grow every day the pension issue is not addressed, it grows exponentially.
Without a definitive and comprehensive strategy this will be an ongoing problem for the Government that might see the return of the entire $210 million to Cable & Wireless.
How entirely sad.
Real estate tax changes
Let’s, for a minute, speak about the impact on the real estate sector.
The VAT amendment bill 2019 is seeking to repeal stamp taxes on realty transactions and replace it with VAT at the same rates as those currently charged as stamp tax.
That is not in and of itself offensive. However, there are some exceptions to the general rule that may prove problematic.
For instance, Clause 16 of the bill says developers will not be able to claim input credits for real estate purchases.
The fact of the matter is that as it stands now developers are not able to claim credit on stamp tax.
However, I’ll try to explain why I view these changes as a huge issue.
The reality is that the tax increases to developers have an inflationary impact on the cost of real estate.
It also inconsistent with the ability of other industries to claim input credits on purchases necessary to create final products.
Under the current stamp tax regime, developers are entitled to transfer land between companies provided there is no change in beneficial ownership without the payment of tax.
Whist this provision is maintained, it now has the caveat that should the new company sell within a 7-year period, the tax becomes payable.
This provision puts developers in a less advantageous position than which they presently enjoy and creates a significant tax liability to accomplish land transfers which are often necessary to complete projects.
Once again, it doesn’t appear that the government is thinking through the changes.
There also appears to have been no broad consultation with the industry.
I have spoken to several prominent realtors who said they had no idea these changes were coming.
I see you learnt very little from how the last budget was botched, through lack on consultation and pretending to be all knowing.
While there may be some beneficial impacts with some aspects of the changes intended, there is also the need to make sure the government understands the full scope of what it is doing.
Grand Lucayan
I note that there was nothing substantive on the Grand Lucayan in the budget communication.
I know this administration was hoping we would all forget, but that’s not going to happen.
The government is still in a state of delusion and booking this as an investment.
As I said when I addressed the 9-month fiscal snapshot, there is an inherent disingenuousness in the full characterizing of the Grand Lucayan purchase as an equity acquisition.
We paid out cash and incurred debt through a mortgage with Hutchison to essentially nationalize a hotel that is losing money, that we acquired for significantly more than the reported appraised value.
If, for example, you buy something for $65 million and it’s only worth $50 million, the $15 million is an expense and it affects your deficit.
And if you’re losing money, and you keep pumping money in, it’s an expense that increases your deficit.
The minister understands full well how this should work.
The sale is nowhere near imminent and will not be complete by the end of this fiscal year. Much of it is an expense, plain and simple.
As are the funds associated with running it and separating employees.
Only in the make-believe world of FNM accounting does this not count as expenditure.
Perhaps when the prime minister makes his contribution he will tell us what is to become of the Grand Lucayan, exactly how much will be spent by the time we are finished floating it and fixing it up for Royal Caribbean, and exactly when the heads of agreement will be signed.
Tax breaks
I note that the minister of finance touted certain tax breaks in his budget communication.
I regard most of these as window dressing – gimmicks designed to distract from the pain of carrying on the massive VAT hike.
I hope the minister of health will inform the minister of finance that the people cannot eat pens, crayons, pencils and construction paper.
I call this the Crayola Budget.
That’s fine if you want to save parents 50 cents on a box of crayons, but how about taking the pressure off them with regard to their light bills?
In this Crayola Budget, the smaller refrigerators and stoves are now reduced.
Well, your rich FNM friends don’t buy them.
And the people who live in spaces where they fit can’t afford them.
As I said, gimmicks in the Crayola Budget.
Now, taking duty off musical equipment and commercial trailers is something I applaud.
Now you talking sense.
Banning plastics and Styrofoam. Good stuff.
With the increase in pollution and cancer in the Exumas and The Bahamas in general this is a necessary step.
But remember, you must educate the people so they understand the scope and timelines of what’s being proposed.
This is why I love the Exuma Pride Initiative, it is forward looking and links environmental stewardship to the needs of the people.
I hope the minister of health and the minister of the environment speak to this.
See there. Don’t say I never said anything nice about you and your Crayola Budget.
But, the spirits and beer amendment is a curious one.
For “microbreweries”. That’s cute.
I’d like to know who truly benefits from that.
Will the Minister now rise on a point of order or point of information and tell the Bahamian people which “wolf of special interest” is driving this initiative?
And then there’s the permanent exemption to water and light bills under a certain amount.
Well, your light have to be on to benefit from that. Those thousands whose lights are off. Nothing in this budget for you. And thousands more will miss out on it.
This must be the people’s budget.
We have duty reduction on new cars from 65-45 percent in this Crayola Budget.
Well, the poor can’t afford new cars.
And small and medium operators don’t sell new cars.
Sorry this budget is not for you, this is the People’s budget.
So, who is this Crayola Budget for?
The no tax on estate planning property is a clear giveaway to the rich.
So, if I buy property and put it in trust for my children, it’s duty free.
Nice loophole exploitation by the rich. Yay! It’s the people’s time!
Now how many Bahamians can afford that?
Why would you take that tax off of those who are most able to pay while increasing VAT on the poor and middle class who feel it most?
Exuma
Turning to Exuma, as has been well established, the people of Exuma are a proud people.
We don’t beg for government handouts, but we do want to receive basic fairness.
This budget proposes to cut our allocation for Exuma local government by 33 percent from $530,000 to $360,000.
This is disgraceful!
Local government in Exuma requested $1 million and for good reason.
The Exumas are growing rapidly in terms of the economy and population. Great Exuma alone is 44 miles.
The Central Bank noted in its February data that the number of room nights sold in Exuma grew by 46.0 percent compared to just under 22 percent for New Providence.
Also, the total number of room nights sold for the year increased in Exuma by 55.9 percent compared to the previous year.
Why, then, would you cut the local government budget?
This is simply foolish. We should be investing in the revenue generating sector of our economy.
I sincerely hope this is a mistake, but the mistake was apparently made in no other island.
If this is not a mistake, it is a wicked and spiteful act of this government and I assure them that there will be hell to pay.
I can’t imagine why this administration would want to undermine the credibility of local government in Exuma and the good Exumians who volunteer.
Except to score some cheap political point at the expense of the people who pay the taxes.
It’s not your money. It’s the tax payer’s money and the people of Exuma put a significant amount into the treasury. We expect our fair share.
I assure you Exumians won’t fall for your nonsense. And a PLP government will increase it the minute we are back in office.
We remain on the move in Exuma.
We are planning a youth center.
We are providing scholarships for kids to go off to school.
We are connecting in our communities and helping each other like never before.
We remain undeterred.
The best thing this administration can do for Exuma is to fix the schools, fix the roads, give us the allocation we ask for and finish our mini hospital and build that airport.
I note that the airport is supposed to be dealt with in short order.
Another brainchild of the PLP with the initial design and funding organized by the PLP; delayed by the FNM’s inability to focus.
Public has lost all hope in the FNM
What is telling about this budget is that in terms of the general public there has been very little discussion about it.
People have tuned this administration out.
We talk about it in this place and it is indeed important, but the people no longer care.
This is because the FNM and the minister of finance have failed to connect this budget to everyday people’s lives.
People no longer view the FNM a factor in bettering life for Bahamians.
They now view the government as covetous of their money and blindly devoted to having clean books, but dismissive of the need to foster an environment of prosperity.
Because of this government’s assault on the people, most who work for a living don’t expect anything but inconvenience and hardship.
This uncaring FNM administration has put the “numbers before the people”.
The people have come to believe that the politicians care more about the affairs of government, the ability to borrow at better terms and decrease deficits, than their very lives.
Are reduced debt and moving away from deficit spending and paying less in debt servicing important and impactful of people’s lives?
Absolutely.
But with these past three budgets, the government has failed to resonate with the people.
Because when it speaks, it only speaks about itself.
The minister talks about how well the government has done for itself.
Yeah, “how great though art”.
But it has done it at the expense of the people.
The minister has failed to connect the affairs of government to economic growth for Bahamians.
This is because the truth is, the FNM is doing the opposite with its practices. Its policies are harmful.
It is, in fact, hindering economic growth.
Government should never place its own welfare above that of the people who fund it, whom it exists to serve.
This is a cardinal sin.
An affront to democracy.
A budget communication, particularly one that takes more than three hours, should do much more than lay out numbers.
It should chart a path forward for the people.
Hidden in the figures is context that a minister should be able to communicate. He has failed to do so.
A government should not cause its people unnecessary pain.
But that is what this government has done.
It has pulled money out of the economy for its own selfish reasons.
The government is now, in essence, competing with the private sector for Bahamian disposable income.
There was no good and valid reason to chart such a drastic course.
You’ve hurt the Bahamian people with this approach.
Can’t you see it?
The missed targets, the lack of robust economic growth.
The inability to make any meaningful impact on unemployment, create jobs for the thousands leaving school this month.
This government has done the opposite of what it should.
It should have made people’s lives better through helping improve their economic situations.
A PLP government will ensure there is more money in more pockets.
But you have only made things worse.
And why?
To pay off bills incurred by the PLP?
What a petty, vindictive reason to put your Bahamians through so much pain.
You put your politics before the people.
I doubt very much they will forget it.
What would have been appreciated by Bahamians would have been some sort of vision for opening up our economy.
But it is expected that this administration would wash its hands of any responsibility to foster a sound economic environment.
I would have liked to have the government moving forward on legislation to decriminalize small quantities of marijuana and legalize medicinal cannabis, and harness the industry to create new jobs and opportunities.
I would have been interested to hear a real plan for BAMSI to reduce our dependence on foreign foods and get more Bahamians into local organic farming.
I would have liked to have heard a real push toward reducing energy costs.
Make no mistake, no one is fooled by what I believe is a clear gambit for the special interests to stake out claims for energy production and distribution in this country.
Perhaps we could have heard of broader investments in National Insurance for the construction on pre-schools and daycare centers so that more women who had recently given birth could re-enter the workforce.
I know you’re bankrupt of new ideas, I’m telling you now that this thing you call Terra Firma, or whatever you call, it is a non-starter.
The day you think you will transfer government building owned by the Bahamian people to some company to benefit special interest, there will be hell to pay on that as well.
Be ye warned! Be ye warned!
It would have been nice to hear about a broad investment in public transportation on New Providence.
But alas, we did not hear this.
What I see is a budget that has little to do with the people and more to do with international agencies.
The minister of finance claims that no international agency dictates to the government of The Bahamas.
Though I fail to understand the difference when the result is the same.
Does the IMF, or the minister of finance for that matter, understand that for many Bahamians, we saw ourselves surpass our parents in education, in home ownership, in business ownership, in investment and achievement?
However, this generation that we see before us, in the aftermath of the Great Recession, is faced with achieving less than the generation before for the first time since Majority Rule.
I see that the minister of education agreed with a University of The Bahamas study that said our men who are in prison for violent crime are disproportionately high school dropouts.
What are we doing about this, while we come here and laugh and bang on tables?
That’s a legitimate question.
Will we continue to allow our boys to fail out of a system at such an alarming rate?
I would rather change the system in its entirety before we let that happen.
Yet, you cut social services and urban renewal budget by $1.5 million.
Yet, you cut Youth, Sports and Culture by $4 million.
Yay. It’s the people’s time.
So, who will make an investment in the people? Who will fight for the people? Who?
Will we be the last generation of men and women who lead?
Do we stand by while the dreams of those who come after us slip further and further out of reach?
Or do we get serious about impacting the lives of our people?
Are we going to continue to make silly, arrogant remarks about the prime minister governing for 10 years while he plans his political future?
Or do we get desperate about the situation that exists today?
What Bahamas will he, in his mind, govern for another eight years?
One where children continue to have little to no hope?
One where parents decide between paying the mortgage, if they’re lucky enough to get one, and putting food on the table?
What Bahamas does this government want to leave in place?
One in which it can brag about some checklist it completed, or one in which people see more opportunity?
One in which it can brag about what they did for the powerful and connected?
Someone, at some point, should wake up and focus on economic growth, for the people, creating a more progressive and prosperous Bahamas.
A PLP government will build a nation that our children will be proud to inherit, connecting all Bahamians; grounded in the wisdom of the past and harnessing the creativity of the present to develop a future where our youth can have aspirations to not only survive but to thrive.
Not only to have jobs in existing and new industries.
Not just to have jobs but to own our Bahamas, to build and grow their own business and carve out their niche and their piece of the pie.
Exuma and Ragged Island thanks you, Mr. speaker.
May God Bless the Commonwealth of The Bahamas.
-
Leader’s Press Continued
PLP CONVENTION
In the face of gratuitous criticism, the uncompromising and necessary work to effect internal reform and the deepening of our democracy continue as we prepare for governance. Our recent special one-day Constitutional Convention demonstrates that our organization understands the critical need for self-examination as we strengthen our democratic processes. Its qualified success through the adoption of the committee’s report is a clear indication of the party’s appreciation that its structure, function, policies and organizational processes must reflect and represent the collective will and desires of those we seek to represent.
I am a democrat therefore I reiterate my support for reform and invite new blood and fresh ideas as the PLP built the modern Bahamas on this model. I encourage party members and all Bahamians of good will to join us and contribute to the further development of the democratic process.
Social Service
Governments have a solemn responsibility to protect the most vulnerable among us as this is part and parcel of the unwritten social contract between the government and the people. It builds up the common good and the common life.
The recent cuts by this government on social assistance for school uniforms is unconscionable. This FNM government has turned its back on the very people whose time they claimed it is.
The Prime Minister and his government have unceremoniously abandoned the general principle of providing a social safety net for the poor. Their pattern of behaviour include mass terminations of mostly minimum wage earners, cut backs at Urban Renewal and the cancellation of the R.I.S.E. program.
The Over-the Hill economic rejuvenation project is a mere shift in some tax policies to benefit the rich with little to no consideration for the plight of the poor. Where is the social component of the program to protect the poor and avoid gentrification or mass displacement of the poor in those affected communities within these economic enterprise zones?
There are more people living in extreme poverty in our communities and they need help desperately. Both a recent IDB Study and the Central Bank have indicated that nearly 50 per cent of Bahamians are struggling to “make ends meet”. We remind the Prime Minister that facts are stubborn.
Gutting the functioning Empowerment Program the PLP left in place and terminating hundreds of workers because of reported funding challenges only to borrow an additional $50 million from the IDB for jobs training and placement is a waste of public resources because it is a duplication of efforts. Dr. Minnis is not helping the poor or the youth with this program – he is simply changing the name.
This new social services policy reduces educational opportunities and retards the social and economic mobility of the poor and vulnerable. The Prime Minister is oblivious to and callous and uncaring toward the plight of the poor given their challenging social and economic circumstances.
I join the Member for Englerston in demanding that the Prime Minister, a self-proclaimed friend of the poor, to reverse this harmful policy and stop paying lip service to the poor when his policies and actions betray his crocodile tears and pompous and condescending rhetoric.
School Repairs
The Progressive Liberal Party is equally dismayed by the lack of progress on school repairs this year. Our concerns are further exacerbated by the comments of the Minister of Education that the Ministry of Education has a school repair budgetary shortfall of around $3 million.
Of equal concern is the accusation of negligence levelled by the Education Minister against his cabinet colleagues, the Ministers of Works and Finance for their failure to mobilize the requisite resources in a timely manner.
Casting blame around the cabinet table smacks of confusion, dissonance, disorganization, incompetence and poor leadership. Is Dr. Minnis in charge of his Cabinet? He said that he would not take on a ministerial portfolio to allow him to effectively coordinate all ministries.
Here we are, with teachers reporting to schools on the 27th of August, and few repairs have begun. This is poor governance and inexcusable. Where is the focus and priorities of this administration?
I am advised that Family Island Administrators were provided with a list of contractors by the Ministry of Works to hire for school repair work in the Family Islands. Many of them are non-compliant with the government’s pre-qualification protocols (no valid business licenses, no tax compliance certificates etc.) and therefore not qualified to secure contracts for the repair of schools in the Family Islands. This creates further delays and it is very unlikely that any school repairs have commenced in the Family Islands.
I submit that the Education Minister is wilfully misleading the public in suggesting that at this late hour, the government can realistically complete all school repairs in time for an early September school opening. This government has failed to plan and organize and in so doing has planned to fail.
Grand Bahama
Without being overly redundant, Grand Bahama gave the FNM an overwhelming electoral mandate: five Members of Parliament; three Senators; three Ministers and a Parliamentary Secretary. The FNM has rewarded them with increased unemployment; increased taxes; a proposal to repeal of the Investment Incentive Act; the cancellation of the apprenticeship program at the Grand Bahama Shipyard; the botched and fraudulent Oban deal and now this botched Grand Lucayan Resort sales purchase deal.
The evidence suggests that the FNM government has neglected Grand Bahama.
As an encore, the government amended the VAT Regulations to permit the refund of half of the tax revenue generated in Grand Bahama to certain business entities in the industrial sector. Meanwhile, ordinary Bahamians are saddled with additional taxes, but with no economic or jobs prospects for the foreseeable the future.
This sorry state of affairs underscores a popularly held view that the FNM government had no plan to govern; no plan for Grand Bahama and no plan for The Bahamas.
We in the PLP know from experience that a project takes roughly three and one-half years from approval to shovel in the ground. With Oban 2.0 being redrafted and no hotel deal fifteen months into their term in office, it is unlikely that the FNM government will succeed in materializing any project of substance or consequence in Grand Bahama.
As for the recent gratuitous rhetoric attributed to Paul Wynn in the media, we simply say that the PLP government held productive negotiations with Mr. Wynn and agreed on a framework on the way forward for the purchase, repair and opening of the hotel. The unvarnished facts surrounding our negotiations are contained in the written framework so there is no need to chase salacious commentary.
This administration owes the people of Grand Bahama a full and frank explanation as to why it was unable to close the sale of the Grand Lucayan hotel in Grand Bahama. The lack of transparency and uncertainty due to misleading announcements surrounding the hotel’s future have irreversibly eroded both hope and confidence of Grand Bahamians in this FNM government.
The Prime Minister’s strategy for the Grand Lucayan Hotel is secretive, deceptive, incoherent and mired in confusion. The Prime Minister must explain to the country how he intends to finance the purchase of the Grand Lucayan Hotel, inclusive of the source of the funding. Additionally, he must provide the total cost inclusive of renovation, marketing and airlift, and management fees. What will be the new marketing subsidy as the current budget is some $20 million?
We say again that the Minnis government must quit its dithering and move with focus, urgency and alacrity to fix Grand Bahama.
Lyford Cay
Our Party notes with much interest a communication from the Chairman of the Lyford Cay Property Owners Association to the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance over their concerns regarding amendments to the Real Property Tax rates. We have indicated before that the self-proclaimed smartest Minister of Finance the country has ever had, pursued ill-advised tax policies. Had the government engaged stakeholders through industry consultation it would have avoided the negative impact and the public embarrassment resulting from its decision?
We admonish this government to be as consistent in its response to the concerns expressed by trade unions, small and large contractors, vendors, public servants and the average Bahamian as it was in responding to the concerns of rich residents in Lyford Cay.
It is never good when the concerns of ordinary Bahamians are ignored by the government and are made to feel by the actions of the government that they must carry a disproportionate tax load so that the wealthy can maintain their lifestyle of opulence at the expense of the poor.
I will now take your questions!
-
Andrew Continued
At the check out, I saw the cashier/manager, a solid tattooed blonde serving two black women. I stood off to the side as she made eye contact with me. Paige was fascinated by the trinkets they put near the counter for that same reason so I made a deal that she could get one but only one. Again, the cashier and the ladies she was serving (Black) would glance over and smile at the negotiations taking place. At one point, another shopper came and stood off from where I was standing. I thought nothing of it.
As soon as the ladies were done (Black), I started to push the cart forward when the cashier/manager nods to the lady standing off to the side and says “Next customer”. The lady steps forward to the counter besides me and my child and begins to offload the items in her cart.
I look at the cashier. I looked back at the lady. I looked at the cashier again then over my shoulder at the other lady working in the store then back to the other customer. Then I say, very annoyed, “you realize I’m standing here and was here first right?”
The tatted blonde cashier/manager looks at me in disgust and says “the line starts here. There’s a sign there. You couldn’t read it?”
I looked at her and back at the sign then down to where I was standing and say “I was standing on the line lady and yes, I can read quite well even though this sign is not in the best place to begin with. You saw me here first. If I needed to move six inches on the left to be on your imaginary line then why not say so?”
She pauses taking the tags off the lady’s items and looks at me with rage. “You people need to…” I cut her off. My Incredible Hulk was now coming out. “You people? Which people lady? You men? You Bahamian men or you Black Bahamian men? Tell you what. This little basket you’re dealing with just cost you and Carters a whole cart full of money. What an incredibly racist thing to say. ‘You people.”
I look at the lady being served (White). Her face literally was white as a sheet. She was mortified. I saw the shame at being made an unwilling accomplice in this scene. I said nothing to her and I looked at my child off to the side oblivious to everything going on. Then I let the beast out.
“You can go **** yourself. If this is your idea of a power trip, fine. Have it. This is the best you’ll have it clearly. I got a whole country to go back to, you, well you have this shit so have a nice life. Asshole.” I took my daughter by the hand and we walk out. She’s upset because we didn’t get her stuff and she asks me as I’m walking past the other lady at the door “why are we leaving?” I say to my kid, while looking at the other lady, “because that lady over there is a racist pig”. The lady at the door looked stunned. Just as we get outside, my daughter says “my Disney stuff…”. Before going into Carters, we went into the Disney Store and she picked up a few things and I put the bag into the trolley that was still sitting at the corner. So I turn around and I march back into the store. The lady at the door is still standing looking stunned. The lady at the corner picks up the phone and says “Sir I’m calling the police. We don’t allow people who curse into the store.” I say nothing to her as I get the Disney bag out the trolley. She adds “really classy of you, right in front of your kid.”
I stopped dead in my tracks and turned around. Before I reentered the store, I promised I wouldn’t say anything further. Forget that. I say to her “For all you know, I could have been coming back to apologize to you. Be the bigger person. Lady, you don’t know me or my kid to say what’s classy or what isn’t. Maybe you’re not used to the idea of a black man shopping with his child and buying more than anyone else in the store. That’s your problem but let me tell you what I wouldn’t allow to happen in front of my daughter. She’s five. She understands fully what is happening now. I will never let anyone disrespect her father the way you tried to in front of her. You spit out fire, you got it back in your face. America can shit on it’s black men but I’m not one of them so you can carry your raggedy community college working two jobs snorting meth ass on with your bad self. This kid knows there are rotten people in the world and she’s looking at one right now. Good day.”
I high stepped out of that store like Deon Saunders in the end zone thinking “I got her good”. I knew that I would have to sit down and fully explain things to Paige that her little brain may not be ready to handle. Just as I was leaving the store, my niece, who’s just had a baby, is coming through the door. I stop her and say I just had a racist experience with that one over there. All of this is happening in front of the other lady who works in the store. Her face is crushed. My niece smiles and says “I’m just looking. I’m going to Osh Kosh”.
So two sales were lost. Sadly too, though, was the insulation that I’ve always felt from the sting of racism and the fact that my kid now knows there are people in the world who will hate her for nothing more than the color of her skin. I don’t know if I represented a threatening image that didn’t fit into a preconceived notion this lady may have had about black people, more specifically black Americans. Truthfully, I don’t care. I don’t believe in generalizing people so it’s not something I’d do right out the gate. Good and bad people come in all colors, sizes, shapes and backgrounds. But it did sting and sting badly but I’m wise enough (I think) to understand that this is more a reflection of that one person’s shortcomings as a human being than a label to put on a whole class of people.
I’ve got some good American friends. Black and white. This experience opened my eyes wide but it certainly does not make me look at them any different because they’re good people. Period.
-
TRIBUTE BY THE HON. PHILLIP “BRAVE” DAVIS, LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION AT THE FUNERAL SERVICE FOE SENATOR CLARA ROSE HALL-KING ON 11TH MAY AT ST. AGNES CHURCH, NASSAU
TRIBUTE BY THE HON. PHILLIP “BRAVE” DAVIS, LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION AT THE FUNERAL SERVICE FOE SENATOR CLARA ROSE HALL-KING ON 11TH MAY AT ST. AGNES CHURCH, NASSAU
Nothing could have pleased me more than that I would have this opportunity to say farewell to a woman who meant so much to me, personally, and to the Party that I represent in Parliament and in the country, than to be able to say farewell to Senator Rose Hall King.
She was a neighbour to my family in Marathon as together with my parents, they counted themselves among the earliest settlers of that new community. I was particularly close to her elder children, Sir Burton Hall who was a bit ahead of me at St. John’s College and Mrs. Bernadette Moultrie who was among the beauty in my class at St. John’s.
Senator Clara Rose Hall-King had deep political convictions and was a standard bearer for our Party in the 1992 General Elections in the constituency of Marathon. She was a great church woman, a community minded individual, a dutiful wife to her late husband Osborne, a loving and compassionate mother to her children, a nurturing grandmother, great grandmother and great- great grandmother. Above all she was a pillar of the community who could not sit idly by when she saw the need for something to be done. Most of all, through the simplicity and directness of her life she is the model of a great Bahamian woman.
She lived an exemplary life and sad as her passing has been, it was a life lived in full with ripples that extended to nearly every reach of our nation.
My sympathy and that of my wife, Ann and our great Party go out to her family and all those whom she would have impacted in some way or another in the long course of her journey in this vale of tears. But I offer the comfort that she has gone on to a better place, a place and a reward that is well deserved.
The history of every society, throughout time, has been made up of people and events. Today, we are here, in part, to reflect on a small part of our own Bahamian history as we remember a remarkable individual, in the person of the late Senator Rose Hall King. I will not dwell on her legacy in terms of what she did to build this community of Nassau, as this has been adequately summed up in eloquent words and is on display for all to see.
Senator Clara Rose Hall-King must have appreciated very early in life that she had to make something of herself in the world of Nassau society in the late forties and fifties when she was a young girl. Whether prodded by her parents, or on her own initiative, she set about to do something with her life. Her life’s journey was one of continuous self-improvement and education. Time for her represented opportunity and time was not to be wasted. Every second, every minute every day of her life was an opportunity for something to be accomplished.
Like so many of that generation Senator Clara Rose Hall-King was not born with the proverbial “silver spoon” and she realized that in order to succeed she had to continue with her self-improvement. This she did and as time moved on it all began to fall in place for her. In all this she was fully supported by a great Cat Island man, her late husband, Osborne King, who himself is the stuff of legends, especially in the cultural field.
It must be observed that as she herself began moving up the economic ladder, Senator Clara Rose Hall King was not selfish in her endeavours. She sought to assist others. This is notable when one realized that she had to balance the demands of family, job and other commitments with her community activities.
But she did. She was more than active in every aspect of the Anglican Church Women (ACW), the Cursillo movement and many other organizations here at St. Agnes and in the Anglican community in Nassau, as a whole. Having grown up in Masons Addition and around the Fort (Fincastle) Hill, she never forgot her roots and made it point to do whatever she could to assist in the physical as well as the human development of residents of that iconic community.
The list of her membership in community and charitable organizations is extensive and varied and tells me that she wanted to do all that she could to build up human lives and to lend a helping hand whenever and wherever she could. She was not selfish in lending her time and talent when she felt it could make a difference.
Our Party is grateful for the untiring and unstinting service that she gave to the Progressive Liberal Party. She was among some of the first women appointed as a Senator when she became a Senator in 1982-1987. In 1982, she did not flinch and accepted to contest the seat in Marathon against a much more youthful but not more qualified opponent. She was unsuccessful but unfazed. Over the years, she continued to be an anchor at the corner of Marathon and Samana Roads for the various PLP candidates who needed her encouragement and advice.
What is clear in all this is that through her activities in a broad range of organizations, including her church, Senator Clara Rose Hall King left her footprints on the history of our community. It is through efforts of women such as Senator Rose Hall-King that we now have a new generation of Bahamian women who are well prepared, confident, willing and ready to take their places in all areas of our society. It was not always like this.
The hallmark of her history in this place and time will be remembered as SERVICE. Service to her family! Service to her community! Service to her God! It was not for her to fall back when her service was needed. She always heeded the call to give of herself. In so doing, she was a model to many and had a positive and uplifting impact on our community. History is about people and events. Senator Clara Rose Hall-King is an important part of our history.
I join with others in saying farewell to a wonderful woman and it is my prayer that as she goes on to her final reward, she will remain forever etched in our memory as a model of service above self!
May She Rest In Peace!
-
Address By Hon. Philip “Brave” Davis, Q.C., M.P. | Special Called PLP New Providence Meeting
Address
By
Hon. Philip “Brave” Davis, Q.C., M.P.
Leader of the Official Opposition
Leader of the Progressive Liberal Party
On the Occasion of
Special Called PLP New Providence Meeting
Wednesday, 9th May 2018, 7:00 p.m.
Sir Lynden Pindling Centre
arnicFarrington Road
New Providence, The Bahamas
Theme:
“No LIE LASTS FOREVER”
PLEASE EMBARGO UNTIL DELIVERY AT 9PM
PLEASE CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY
Good Evening, thanks for coming and it’s a pleasure to be amongst energized PLPs as we make the SS PLP battle ready.
Proverbs 19:5 says that “the false witness will not go unpunished, and whoever utters lies will not escape.”
ARE YOU TIRED OF BEING LIED TO AND DISRESPECTED LIKE BEING CALLED CORRUPT?
ARE YOU TIRED OF DESCRIPTIONS OF PROBLEMS WITHOUT PRESCRIPTIONS?
ARE YOU TIRED OF NO BEDS, NO MEDS AND BODIES PILING UP AT THE MORGUE?
ARE YOU TIRED OF THE EXCESSIVE BORROWINGS WHEN SMALL CONTRACTORS AND POLICE RESERVES CANNOT GET PAID?
ARE YOU TIRED OF THE MASS FIRINGS AND INCREASED SUFFERING?
IF ENOUGH IS ENOUGH, THEN LET ME HEAR YOU!
On a platform of falsehoods, untruths, and a tissue of lies, it was one year ago when Hubert Minnis and his Free National Movement rolled into power proclaiming: “It’s the People’s Time!”
With no plan, no policy, no vision and totally bankrupt of ideas, one year later the chorus: “If I only knew” is setting in as Bahamians perish.
They have delivered No real investment and offer No new direction for the Bahamian people. They have admitted to recklessly adding to the level of joblessness.
They have flip flopped on almost every major PLP policy they opposed while in opposition.
They claimed it was the People’s Time, but before ballots could be counted, they began firing Bahamians.
From BAMSI to Bahamasair – they fired!
From Urban Renewal to NHI – they fired!
From Social Services to NIB – they fired!
From the hill to the valley – they fired!
The FNM was so eager to fire, they even began firing, victimizing and abusing people hired by the PLP but who voted for the FNM!
Flexing power like a mad man, Hubert Minnis – against sound advice – began abusing that power by directing agencies of the state to arrest and detain innocent Bahamians.
BAIC is a prime example. Now Bahamian tax payers may have to pay millions of dollars to those falsely arrested.
Drunk with power, he fired thousands of Bahamians throughout the country, including the sole breadwinners of families.
Jeffery Lloyd – the Minister for Education recently told the press he was “Happy to Report” how he fired 200 minimum wage workers in his ministry.
In that same week, Marvin Dames, the Minister for National Security, attempted to fire [without any notice] 29 Prison Officers. Only after public outcry did he pull back.
Now, Duane “Heartless” Sands is a real character in healthcare these days.
One day he tells us the hospitals and clinics have no meds!
The next day he says the hospitals have no beds.
No Ventilator machines for the babies. None for the Intensive care section.
No meds for HIV patients.
Last week he came out to complain that bodies are piling up in the morgue.
Also last week he faced a sickout by nurses. And, to date, the Minister has yet to have a sit down face-to-face with nurses, who have already filed a strike action with the Department of Labour.
And just this week “heartless” Sands on national TV threatened to fire some 100 junior doctors at the hospital, telling them to work as taxi drivers and hotel maids because they could not cut it as physicians.
Does all of this sound to you like It’s The People’s Time?
Does Sands appear willing to fix healthcare in the country?
The FNM Government is not serious!
We are witnessing a disaster unfolding in healthcare – with two doctors at the helm, and no solutions in sight.
PLPs!
In February when our Member of Parliament for Englerston, Hon. Glenys Hanna Martin made the charge of political victimization by the FNM, your entire PLP voice was victimized and silenced in the Parliament.
The Minnis Government sought to abuse the rules of the House and Chair to wipe from the record the fact that two hard working, single Bahamian mothers, who wereairport managers in Eleuthera, were fired for political reasons.
Around the same time, Party Chairman, Senator Mitchell, and I stood outside the offices of BAIC and watched as permanent and pensionable Bahamians were being sent home – for political reasons.
Tonight, I bring you evidence of their callous actions against Bahamians!
I charge Renward Wells tonight: guilty of Political Victimization.
Here is a letter from Minister Wells sent to the then-Chairman of BAIC, the MP for MICAL, Miriam Emmanuel.
In his letter dated 15th November, 2017 Minister Wells ordered that 16 employees of BAIC be fired forthwith at the next sitting of the board.
And here is a response dated December 13th, 2017 in which Emmanuel agrees with the Minister’s request, confirming that a resolution was passed by the Board to carry out the instructions to fire Bahamians.
No reasons were given for their terminations.
We know that these decisions are being directed from the Cable Beach and are therefore political!
But while this uncaring Government is laying off innocent, decent and hardworking Bahamians every week, look at what has happened at Bahamasair in Bimini.
An employee, dismissed from NIB back in 2010 for theft and ordered by a court to repay those stolen funds, has been hired in a senior position at Bahamasair in Bimini! But she is related to a FNM politician.
And the FNM claims they are fighting corruption? Fighting corruption, my foot!
THE FNM IS CULTIVATING CORRUPTION!
BAMSI, an academic institution designed to promote food security in the country, is now in trouble.
I am now advised that by directives, trained Bahamian professionals are being terminated and considerations are being made to hire a foreign national.
At a meeting on the 26th of April, 2018, The Human Resources Sub Committee reported how, [And I quote] “…The post of Executive Director [BAMSI in Andros] may have to be brought in from outside the Bahamas.”
The present Director is an accomplished Bahamian doctor, professor and research scientist, who returned home to Andros to make her contribution to develop BAMSI.
Why you think the FNM don’t believe in Bahamians? All I will say is, “keep your eyes on Bamsi!!!”
You recall that the FNM came to power claiming that they were about fighting crime and corruption.
But when their torchbearer was caught operating what appeared to be a Ponzi scheme in South Beach, cheating thousands of Bahamians, guess what happened? Nothing!
That torchbearer to this day remains untouched, never asked by authorities to account for her corrupt practices and crooked ways!
She walks around town freely, while justice is denied to her victims.
The FNM ain’t fighting corruption – The FNM is protecting the CORRUPT!
And then we have Michael Foulkes, the personality now in charge of BAIC.
Why did they move him from The Student Loan Programme ‘eh’?
We hear little now about a matter that happened in the United States of America.
Prime Minister Minnis is silent about Michael. And I think I know why.
Michael Foulkes has said very little about the revelations coming out of the Dade County Courthouse.
Does Minnis still believe in his ‘Seven Principles of Public Life’?
Remove your cloud of secrecy Prime Minister – and while at it – and in the spirit of accountability – tell us why the Member for Centreville. Reece Chipman was fired from the Antiquities Monuments and Museums Corporation?
Is it true that stealing went down at that Corporation? And so …by whom?
One year in and you cannot get a response from this crew.
It’s the People’s time they say, but – it more looks like Family and Lovers time, if ya ask me.
Information brought to my desk confirms that a number of government agencies, including the Department of Statistics, have been directed to purchase gas for their assigned vehicles from Minnis Service Station on Market Street.
I am advised the Prime Minister’s relatives own the station.
Is this the same Prime Minister Minnis who jets around the world calling Bahamians corrupt?
I also understand another relative of the Prime Minister on Grand Bahama has been loaded up with contract work from the Ministry of Education.
Numerous Contracts, while small contractors either cannot get work, or get paid for work already done for the government.
I also understand that the Prime Minister has hired another brother to work in the public sector…IF YOU ARE A MINNIS, IT IS YOUR TIME!!!!
Information has come to me that another minister hired his relative to decorate his office at tax payers’ expense.
Does that sound like the FNM is working for the people? Sounds like they working for their family, if you ask me.
Recently, a complaint was lodged by commuters in the South Westridge corridor of New Providence of an abrupt closure of Munnings Road.
Minister Bannister has told the press that residents have requested the closure. If you follow the reasoning given by Bannister he should close every road in New Providence.
The road closure is causing a traffic nightmare for morning and evening commuters along Gladstone and the airport road.
Perhaps the Prime Minister should explain the real reason for the road closure.
Why is Munnings Road closed to the annoyance of the public, Minnis? Who asked you to close the road?
PLPs!
We have come to remind the FNM that NO LIE LASTS FOREVER!
– Minnis claimed in London that $500 million is lost in the Bahamas through corruption. That was a LIE!
– He said, when elected, Bahamar would get a different owner – That was a LIE!
– Minnis said that the Vat Money was stolen – and – That was a LIE!
– The FNM made the claim that it was the people’s time – and – That was a LIE!
– Minnis told voters he would deliver Free Education at University of The Bahamas – and – That was a LIE!
– He promised to reduce taxes on Bread Basket Items – and – That was a LIE!
– The FNM Promised to deliver Tax Free Zones in the inner city – and – That was a LIE!
– Minnis said at Government House there will be no victimization by his government – and – That was a LIE!
– He said he would kill the Spy Bill – and we know – That was a LIE!
– Minnis said he would carry out hangings – and That was a LIE!
– He promised to repeal VAT – and – That was a LIE!
– They said the FNM would disclose to the public all travel expenses on these ‘gussiemae’ trips – now we all know – That too was a big LIE!
No Lie Lasts Forever!
I gave them a “U” for unsatisfactory after one year in office. But,…. I would be remiss if I were too kind to them.
There are some things this Minnis–led FNM deserves high marks for.
For lying – I give the FNM Government an A+ grade!
For victimizing Bahamians – they get an A+
For being unethical behavior in government, the FNM will get an A+
For the Government’s Failure to deliver one real investment to the country – they get an A+
For their cloud of secrecy and silence on national matters – I give them an A+
And for their failure to be honest, open and transparent to the Bahamian People – I don’t know about you – but I give them an A+.
In my assessment the Minnis-led government has been a danger to the Rule of Law.
They are unprincipled. And their exercises of cronyism and self-dealing have resulted in disaster for the Bahamian people.
The Bahamian people have quickly learned that, like in the OBAN Energies debacle, Hubert Minnis and the FNM are CORRUPT!
As for the Oban deal all I want to say is this: Who is the mystery man or woman of OBAN Energies?
There is a company called Clean Marine.
I want to know whether the mystery man or woman is associated with Clean Marine and what Clean Marine’s role might be in this Oban deal.
NO LIE LASTS FOREVER!
And so PLPs as I bid you good evening let us stand strong.
Let us stand firm and diligent.
Let us rise up to Do the Work that is before us.
For in the end, all of us will be measured not by what we say, or even what we believe, but by what we do.
In our great party, we know our values are the right ones;
….now we have a new opportunity to realize those values.
It is an honor to lead this great party, and to know that many of our finest days and greatest achievements are still to come.
PLP!
PLPs! PLP! PLP!
Thank You!
God Bless the Commonwealth of the Bahamas!
-
Address by Hon. Philip “Brave” Davis
Address by
Hon. Philip “Brave” Davis, Q.C., M.P.
Leader of the Official Opposition
Leader of the Progressive Liberal Party
On the Occasion of
A Public Meeting
Thursday, 22th March 2018, 7:00 p.m.
Sadie Curtis Primary School
Nassau, N.P., The Bahamas
Salutations:
To My Parliamentary Colleagues
Party Chairman
Party Officers and membersGood Evening, PLPs!
Tonight, we welcome people around the country watching and listening to this event via social media platforms.
I first want to thank you all for your presence here tonight.
We need your participation and thank you for tuning in.
For those watching and listening I need you to do a favour and share this event on your social pages now. Share the links via your social media links.
As an organisation, we in the PLP are continuing these exercises that engage Bahamians on the issues.
Log onto our social media pages on Facebook or Instagram at Progressive Liberal Party or myplp, find the link and share it. Share it across your platforms.
We are moving ahead with the process of crafting our Vision, Image and Message (VIM) for the PLP. VIM will become a watchword as we transpose our party into a battle ready machine.
That vision involves this process to address reforms to our constitution. Those discussions are now being had in meetings around the country.
Please join the discuss at PLP-Constitution-Discussions via our Facebook platform.
Announcement to dates of those meetings are regularly posted.
Share these discussion and weigh in on them because, this is your party to.
Our Vision will also entail our policy on matters from Health to Education to Finance and so on.
On every sector of our national life, we intend to produce a vision, we are going to image that vision and properly message that vision.
Our proposal for reforms, with the input of progressive thinkers will become the core elements to the management of our party well into the future.
As your servant, I expect to expand on these items of our Vision, Image and Message as we move around the country.
I thank Dr. Marcus Bethell – former senator and Minister of Health for crafting these items which I have embraced.
PLPs!
The country is now catching up with the list of lies from the Minnis-led FNM Government!
Everywhere we go the sad chorus of… “If I did only know…” is getting louder and louder.
Bahamians are discovering that the LIES by FNM Government are not just a dream, but is reality!
People are being hurt.
Your friends are being victimized.
And hardworking citizens all across the country are being sent home.
Unemployment is up! And there are no plans for the future development in the pipeline.
FNM lies about creating jobs have resulted in firing Bahamians on Friday and asking them to show up at Job Fairs on Saturday. They have no plan!
You just cannot trust this Minnis-led FNM Government.
FNM lies on the campaign about finding a Real Buyer for BahaMar have been silenced.
They in the FNM went against Bahamians getting a job at Baha Mar before May 10th, but today, if you listen to Minister Dionisio D’Aguilar, Baha Mar is the best thing happening for The Bahamas.
The FNM campaign of lies, fake news, catch phrases and deceptive political propaganda told the Bahamian people VAT Money was stolen – then after coming into power, even their Attorney General Carl Bethel said that too was a lie!
Remember the lie from Finance Minister Peter Turnquest, who made the claim that he could not find 40 million dollars for Hurricane repairs?
Imagine that…a professional accountant claiming he can’t find money.
And then the following week, he too came back to the House to confirm that his statement was untrue, and the money was right in the Consolidated Fund.
Turnquest should save himself from more embarrassment and resign. He has led the country to a EU Blacklist. And then blamed the OECD and the PLP for it. He has no shame!
Don’t forget the lies they told on me now.
Expensive audit reports for Bahamas Power and Light and Water and Sewerage they told nasty lies about me. Having their juvenile Executive Chairman grandstand in the Parliament.
Well, I don’t play with ‘churrin’.
They haven’t told us yet how much those Ernst and Young reports cost taxpayers.
They refuse to tell us how the bidding processes of these audits were done.
How one auditing firm got all the audit work by the Government?
There is nothing transparent about this FNM Government!
They refuse to answer questions. You just cannot trust them.
By the time they came back to Parliament – not once but twice – The Minister of Works confirmed the lies told and apologized to me.
He could have done that before the reports were allowed to be released. Reports which have failed to reach proper auditing standards. But at least he told the truth in the end.
The lies of the FNM Government are catching up with them.
And the People of the Bahamas are learning every day that is NOT THE PEOPLE’s TIME!
It is not the People’s time as the Minnis Government cancelled the RISE programme affecting scores of Bahamians.
It is not the People’s time when Minister Jeffery Lloyd could announce in Parliament that he will proceed to fire this week some 200 minimum wage workers – and tell the press he don’t care!
It is not the People’s time.
Remember when they told young people they will get free University Education when elected?
Minnis and the boy from Bain Town was up and down on the campus telling young people who supported them free University Education was coming.
But after elections scholarship were being cut, and fees gone up. What a LIE!
Bahamians are learning that it is not the People’s time, particularly after the Renward Wells announced during the budget debate last week that BAMSI will not be allowed to expand its food production operation for which it is designed.
He announced that the operation in North Andros would remain to lend technical support to local farmers.
You think they have a plan to dismantle BAMSI?
Remember now, this is the same Minister who recently traveled into CARICOM with the Prime Minister to tell Haitian farmers there they are ready to have their food on our plate by December 31st.
It is not the People’s time with this FNM Government.
I wonder where is Dr. Duane Sands these days? Where he is?
You think he still performing surgeries?
You think he still practicing medicine while neglecting the much-needed attention to the management of our health systems?
You think he is somewhere hiding in secret meeting plotting to take the Prime Minister job?
You think Dr. Sands was in that meeting in the East discussing the future of Minnis?
On Monday, 12th of March a report by the Tribune revealed in the headline “Cash shortage leaves hospital staff having to ventilate by hand”.
The story revealed the neglect at PMH.
The paper exposed how the Intensive Care and Neonatal Intensive Care [where the babies are] could not find $14,000 to care for the sick in our country.
And they say “It’s The People’s Time!”
Now let’s put this in perspective.
Here is a government that, since coming to power, has borrowed more than 1.7 billion dollars – yet – they are laying off staff, firing Bahamians, sending home scores of minimum wage workers and cannot find funds to purchase needed devices in the medical institutions of the nation?
It’s not the People’s time!
They have slowed/stopped/paused the construction of clinics in my constituency saying it is not necessary; and this week, the Prime Minister told the people in Exuma that space in the clinic there will now to be used to facilitate an office for him and his campaigners.
Health care gone to da dogs!
…. to da dogs …under the prime ministership of a doctor!
But it gets worse.
My teams have since paid a visit deep in the heartland of the Bahamian community of the Grove.
There, I am advised that the Coconut Grove Clinic suspended its operations since late last year.
No reason given.
I am advised that scores of children in need of medical attention, pregnant mothers, and seniors from the area are now to find their needed medical assistance more than a mile away.
Residents from the Grove must now make their way to the crowded Fleming Street or Blue Hill Roads clinics while the doors to assist the sick on Coconut Grove remain closed.
It’s not the People’s time!
Two doctors – one a Prime Minister and the other the Minister of Health, and yet, the doors of help and needed medical assistance in the most densely populated community of the Grove has been closed!
Doors closed by this heartless bunch.
It is NOT People’s time!
PLPs!
I must now weigh in on this Corrupt Oban Energies Deal.
It has grabbed headlines for more than one month now and it gets worse by the day.
Oh…What a web we weave when we seek to deceive.
The Nassau Guardian this morning reported how Mr Peter Krieger and Satpal Dhunna were removed from the company register.
The Prime Minister, this week, on 20 March, has entangled himself deeper in a bed of lies over this Oban fiasco.
And I am going to ask again, who is the mystery man? – Who are the real players behind this deal?
Mr. Prime Minister is the mystery man who brought you this project out of Grand Bahama?
He must be known to you!
Is he a relative?
Mr. Prime Minister I am now learning some things about OBAN, which neither you nor your advisors have yet told you.
But let me state some facts:
One – The Minnis Government has signed a Heads of Agreement without an Environmental Impact Assessment.
Two – the lead person on behalf of Oban Energies, Mr. Peter Krieger, never got any Agreement from the Ingraham Administration or the Christie Administration dating his idea as far back as 2009.
Three – The proclaimed open, honest and transparent Hubert Minnis, in a move to distract the country from the trial of the Speaker, announced on February 14th, 2018 in a communication to Parliament the proposed signing of a Heads of Agreement of a 5 Billion Dollar Deal for Grand Bahama.
The Prime Minister never told the House that the signing was to be a ceremonial signing.
Four – Mr. Krieger, a man who we later learned confessed to crimes, was paraded as decent in the eyes of the public.
Paraded live on TV with the Prime Minister himself knowing that Mr. Kreiger had misappropriated more than 3.7 million dollars worth of client funds.
And was subsequently fine by Capital Markets regulator and watchdog, the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States.
Mr. Krieger also found his name deep in matters involving CLICO, which operated a PONZI Scheme with money belonging to the Bahamian people.
Plenty Bahamians lost their money in Clico.
This is who he signed a Heads of Agreement with – and guess what?
On that signing with Hubert Minnis as witness – Peter Kreiger signed the name Satpal Dhunna.
And so the Guardian reported both men have since resigned.
But I doubt that to be the case because tonight. Right now at the St. Nicholas Anglican Church in High Rock Oban Energies President Satpal Dhunna is speaking about the project with residents from the area.
Follow me now…
Five – With the political fallout coming and the with revelations by the day from environmental groups and politicos around the country screaming, FNM Cabinet Ministers quickly fell insipidly into a code of silence.
Romauld Ferreira the said Environment Minister – who was strip of his portfolio assignments months ago – told the press to do not ask him anything about Oban Energies!
He directed them to the Prime Minister.
What happened to all that mouth by Mr. Ferreira about Freedom of Information?
What happened about Mr. Ferreira advocacy for keeping governments honest and accountable?
What happened to his passion and his party’s mantra for being Responsible and Transparent?
The Environment Minister silence is deafening.
The Attorney General is mute.
Peter Turnquest is lost for words even though it is his constituency to which the development is planned.
And the rest of the shameless bunch can’t find a microphone to discuss the crisis now engulfing the FNM Government.
And while this festers, with the missteps, corruption, wrapped in fraud no one can tell us where is the Public Land set to be given away to Oban Energies on East End Grand Bahama.
Tonight is the first time residents are being presented with the plan.
How many acres is to be given away?
Whose land is it?
Where is the funding for the Proposed Refinery?
Why was it necessary to proceed with Heads of Agreement without an EIA study in the area, which sits on one of the most pristine ecological environments in the community of Grand Bahama?
And my favourite question remains: Who is the mystery man and real owners of OBAN Energies?
The suggestions of missteps by the Prime Minister fell short of answering any of these questions. And his communication opened new revelations.
With an embezzler, a tax cheat, owing the United States government more than six hundred thousand dollars at his side the Prime Minister claims that Oban Energies Peter Kreiger had resigned from the company.
I now ask the Prime Minister: Where is the proof?
The Prime Minister also has claimed that Oban principal Satpal Dhunna signed the HOA on – [GET THIS NOW] Saturday February 10th.
But the PM tabled a document by the Parliament showed a signing by Mr. Dhunna on February 19th. Mr. Dhunna who we know from his own writings was not in the country at the time.
So, where is the signed February 10th Agreement confirmed by the Prime Minister in Parliament this week?
Mind you I told the Prime Minister that he had time long before these developments to extricate himself from this deal.
But you know, we are getting no answers from the man who flies around the world calling Bahamians corrupt!
We get no answers from a Prime Minister who cannot defend Bahamians when foreigners [as like in the case of Royal Bank] attack Bahamians and call us corrupt!
And this OBAN matter gets worse as new evidence has come to my attention.
Prime Minister Minnis, I submit, has deceived Parliament!
He has misled members.
He has fabricated untruths and he has misled the Bahamian people on this OBAN issue.
He announced that Mr. Peter Krieger of Oban Energies LLC had resigned from the company effective March 9th , 2018.
He failed to show any evidence to the same and I now have new information, which makes questionable the statement by the Prime Minister.
From the registered files of Oban Energies – Filings now in my possession reveal that Mr. Dhunna and Mr. Krieger were removed as managers, and that Oban Energies Management was added as manager to the registered company in Florida.
However, in the articles of Amendment to the Articles of the Organization of Oban Energies registered document #L1600011652 Filed on March 12th, 2018 [last week Monday] at 12:41PM by the Secretary of State Tallahassee, Florida – the same address: 3804 PGA Blvd. Palm Beach Gardens Florida 33410 is given for both Mr. Peter Krieger, Mr. Satpal Dhunna and Oban Engeries Management. And more importantly all future correspondence in relation to Oban Energies was to be sent to Peter Kreiger – why if he resigned or had no further dealing with Oban – he remains the contact person for Oban – we fool eh?
From this document supplied by the State of Florida, Mr. Peter Kreiger did sign Articles of Amendment to Articles of Organization of Oban on the 9th of March 2018.
The Prime Minister is Lost! He is out to lunch!
He has entangled his entire Government in a weave of deception and lies!
Prime Minister Minnis has failed to do his due diligence!
He witnessed fraud in the full glare of the press.
He has reduced the Office of Prime Minister into a web of lies, deceits and deceptions.
He has deceived the country!
He has betrayed my beloved people of Grand Bahama.
And I submit The Minnis Government has now engulfed itself in a web corruption and must do the honorable thing and RESIGN! RESIGN! RESIGN! REGSIGN!
PLPs! PLP! PLP!
Thank You!
And God Bless the Commonwealth of the Bahamas!
-
LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION ON MID-YEAR BUDGET
GENERAL SPEAKING NOTES
PHILIP BRAVE DAVIS MP, QC
LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION
2017/2018 MID-YEAR BUDGET DEBATE
HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY
13 MARCH 2018
Thank you for recognising me Mr. Speaker.
I rise on behalf of the resilient people of Cat Island, Rum Cay and San Salvador. I thank them for their support. It has endured now for twenty-seven consecutive years.
This is an onerous demonstration of their confidence, I am privileged to represent their interests in this Honourable House.
Mr. Speaker
Notwithstanding the apparent disdain the side opposite has for my constituency, I will continue to fight for their clinics, for more investments, more jobs, better roads and for better docking facilities. Their love and loyalty have strengthened my resolve as a public servant; and my commitment to them is deeper than ever before.
I endeavor to work daily to conduct myself in public life to prove myself worthy of their continued support and confidence.
Mr. Speaker
I have said on more than one occasion that no price tag is too great for the people of Cat Island, Rum Cay, and San Salvador.
It is clear that the Member for Elizabeth still does not understand that every Bahamian, no matter on which island they live, has the right to have access to basic health care and essential services. There is no priority of citizen by island.
Each Bahamian has the right to live where he or she wishes. Our responsibility to them is to ensure that they have at minimum access to essential services and where possible access to enhanced services.
Nothing is too good for any Bahamian. Nothing is too good for Cat Island, nothing too good for San Salvador, nothing too good for Rum Cay.
I also take note that the BAIC Office in San Salvador was closed. That office was a catalyst for the entrepreneurial spirit of the people there. What a shame that the people of San Salvador are no longer afforded the benefits derived from an agency that was doing good work, bringing out the creative best of San Salvador.
This cannot be the government that committed to spurring migration ‘Back-To-The-Island’.
This government has a basic challenge. What they say is very different from what they do; and what they do very often targets the privileged few.
Mr. Speaker
I want the Member for Elizabeth to know that I want my clinics built. The same technical officers who advised the former Minister of Health are the same who now offers the same advice.
I spoke to one in recent times and got confirmation that it was the ministry’s recommendation to build as planned. It is disingenuous to suggest otherwise now. I just want those clinics built for my constituents who are citizens of the Commonwealth of The Bahamas!
Mr. Speaker
When I consider this exercise, it is nothing less than a political campaign, a marketing and public relations exercise by the government. It is mere smoke and mirrors.
Rather than an exercise in dissecting the fiscal policies that traditionally underpin a government’s vision through its stated priorities and objectives, the budget statement is but a litany of words and figures, which I do not think that the Government itself understands. Many Bahamians, and I am no exception, are disappointed.
This FNM government appears more interested in revisiting the past, in character assassination, naming and shaming and in prettying up the accounting books, rather than using all of the instruments of government to improve the lives of Bahamians – the purpose for which they were elected to office – TO GOVERN.
In their collective imagination, the pasture is getting greener, when, in reality, there is no feed. People are suffering and expressing their level of discontent and despair ever so loudly each passing day. What irony!
Mr. Speaker
Contrast what we were presented with a few days back by the Government, with position of the PLP Government when it came to office in 2012, when it gave its first mid-term Budget Report.
We thoroughly analysed the failed policies of the FNM, but we did not dwell on them “ad infinitum”. Instead, we moved very quickly to lay out a plan and programme of governance, which, as events subsequently proved, did put the Government on the right track.
The truth is to be found in the answer to the question “where would our economy be today, in the absence of VAT and Bahamar?”
The essential role of government is governance. It is not the role of a government to conduct witch hunts. Governments are not auditors-in-chief. Their essential role is to provide for the peace and security, the social and economic upliftment of all of our people.
Not so with this Government. But, we are not surprised, as we all knew that they had absolutely no plans, no programmes and no vision to move The Bahamas forward.
Sadly, the results are now plain for all to see. I now refer to this administration as the “tabloid administration” It is merely content to grab headlines and put out Fake news. The recent disgraceful conduct over the OBAN affair is sufficient evidence of this.
Mr. Speaker
On the 21st February, when the mid-year budget statement was delivered, it did nothing to allay the concerns and views of the Opposition expressed during the budget debate 9 months ago. In fact, they have become heightened.
This government has no plans to govern this country. In numerous cases, their policy decisions have made conditions in the country worse for our people.
The Hon. Member for East Grand Bahama has demonstrated clearly that he does not understand the figures that were presented to him by his own Ministry.
The Minister of Finance indicates that during the period 2016-2017, there was a shortfall in revenue of some $200m. If the Minister would have done even a basic analysis behind this shortfall, he would have found that one of the main reasons for this was the devastating effect of Hurricane Matthew, which resulted in revenue inactivity and lost revenues due to exemptions provided to individuals and companies under various Exigency Orders.
At the same time, the Minister should have appreciated that there had to be a corresponding spike in expenditure as a result of the massive clean-up and the nature of emergency restoration and remediation.
The other side deliberately forgets that we had two devastating hurricanes in the short space of 12 months, Joaquin and Matthew.
Each had a direct bearing on our fiscal situation, resulting in a decline in revenues and an increase in expenditures. This is the analysis I would have expected from the Minister.
Instead, Mr. Speaker
This Government used a very noble and necessary intervention to raise foolish concerns about fiscal mismanagement by the previous government.
It is dishonest, therefore, to make sweeping accusations without fully understanding what one is talking about. Moreover, I would refer the Minister of Finance to various reports by the IMF, the IDB, the Central Bank of the Bahamas and Moody’s which shows the impact of these “Acts of God” on the fiscal indices.
The honest comparison would be, if they wish to boast about their fiscal prudence, is to look at the Revenue of the half year without the revenue inactivity and the increased expenditure caused by the hurricanes.
As I said earlier, though, the treatment of this budgetary exercise represents a “marketing exercise”, devoid of any true understanding of the underlying reality. It is all an attempt to represent certain facts which are not, in fact, there.
Before I leave this point, I read somewhere that the Minister of Finance made a statement in which he refers to the “immoral” use of the VAT revenues? What exactly does he mean? And why use the word immoral!
Any expenditure of funds must be approved by this House through Budgets, and to use the word “immoral” is taking this too far. As the Minister would know, VAT funds are not segregated from general revenues and when compiling a Budget the technocrats do not make assumptions on what is VAT and what is not.
Here again, emotions and gimmickry has overtaken the Hon. Member.
[To quote statement from budget presentation]
I know time is limited but I will seek to touch on as many salient issues of national import as my time allows.
The Economy
Mr. Speaker
By its own admission, the government has intentionally added to the rate of joblessness in the country (unemployment has returned to double digits); revenue performance has deteriorated; the state of national healthcare has worsened; our immigration laws and policies are under assault and conditions have worsened; the level of borrowing (some $1.4 billion in nine months) is unsustainable with no accountability.
To top it off, there is no immediate economic relief or plans for New Providence, Grand Bahama or the Family Islands.
Further, the Minister of Finance openly admitted to withholding much needed funds for capital expenditure, robbing scores of communities and thousands of Bahamians of basic government services and amenities to which they are entitled.
Consequently, thousands of Bahamian households continue to suffer hardship. The government for its part continues to describe the problems facing our country, fabricate and invent other problems, such as corruption and excessive hiring in the public service, abuse of the public purse and to engage in victor’s justice.
The Oban petroleum deal for East Grand Bahama presented unrealistic jobs creation numbers, but more fundamentally Mr. Speaker, the lack of transparency, accountability and the specter of fraud, deceit and sleight of hand have caused immeasurable reputational damage to our country.
Locally, our constituents have lambasted this Government for their action, eroding much public confidence in this government’s ability to govern us honestly, openly and in our best interests. Under the current cloudy and suspicious circumstances, the PLP could not support this agreement. There could be little doubt there could be no rational explanation for the conduct of the government on this issue. The cogent evidence is that the whole deal is fraught with fraud – and if you were had or taken, there are sufficient instances of misrepresentation for you to extract yourself from this debacle! Otherwise, who is the mystery man or woman to bring this project to your attention to act in such shoddily manner? – from Freeport or Nassau?
The Prime Minister represented on 19 February that the document being signed by the Secretary to the Cabinet with Peter Krieger was in fact the Heads of Agreement between The Bahamas and Oban.
He did not say this was a ceremonial, for the cameras event.
The press has indicated that the man signing the document Peter Krieger did not sign his own name but that of Sanpat Dhunna, the President. Mr. Krieger had previously been identified to the public as the President.
The Prime Minister and his Cabinet members were witnesses to the signing. None of them disclosed that this was not the real signing but only ceremonial.
The Prime Minister on Thursday 1 March tabled what he said was the Heads of Agreement between the parties.
The House and the country expected to find the signature of Mr. Krieger on the document.
They did not find that signature but instead that of Mr. Dhunna. This too is now questionable as we see a letter purportedly signed by Mr. Dhunna which appears to be different from that on the HOA laid.
The press has said that Mr. Krieger signed Mr. Dhunna’s signature or name.
The Prime Minister did not disclose to the House that there was a ceremonial signing and therefore possibly two different documents.
The impression was that there was one document and that was the one he produced to the House,
So questions have to be asked:
Will the Prime Minister say whether there are two documents or one?
Is the document signed by Mr. Krieger with Mr. Dhunna’s name the document that was tabled by the Prime Minister in the House?
Is the document tabled in the House then a true, valid agreement?
Whatever the answers to these searching questions, in my view this represents a fundamental dishonesty and government by sleight of hand. The country is entitled to implicitly rely on the word of a Prime Minister. The Prime Minister has an ethical responsibility to tell the truth. He has a legal responsibility not to mislead the House.
Mr. Speaker
According to official government records, more than 2,500 persons were separated from the public service in just six months – from May to November 2017 – thereafter, the firings continue unabated.
The Minister of Finance disputes mass firings and explained away the separations as “natural attrition”, including the unceremonious firings of permanent and pensionable officers with good years of service.
There is a principle called “the improbability of coincidence.” This level of attrition is unprecedented in the public service and never happened during previous administrations. But it is coincidentally happening during this particular administration.
Equally coincidental are reports of staff at the Ministry of the Public Service being inundated with contracts to be executed – that the backlog requires much overtime to process.
Could it be that certain people were identified and separated to make way for persons of the government’s own choosing? The government denies this, but, “the improbability of coincidence”.
Mr. Speaker
To date the real and tangible jobs are being created by Baha Mar and The Pointe. And now see, the Ministry of Labour recently announcing a jobs fair for the project at Ocean Cay – immediate job offerings.
Is it not ironic that the “peoples time” government is causing mass firings and adding to the country’s joblessness while projects executed by the PLP government continue to keep the economy afloat through the creation of thousands of real well-paying jobs, yielding positive economic benefits for our people? It’s the People’s Time, but thank God for the PLP!
Mass firings on Friday and job fairs on Saturday!
The irony continues Mr. Speaker.
Equally ironic is the initial claim by the Attorney General that the mass firings have saved the government some $75 million, yet the government returned to Parliament and borrowed another $90 million on the heels of passing a resolution to borrowing $722 million and later raised an additional $750 million.
First, the Finance Minister said the $90 million was earmarked for the airport upgrade in Exuma and a jobs training programme, among other projects that would not increase or impact the budget deficit or national debt.
The government apparently changed its mind and said that the funds would not be drawn down in the current fiscal year. Their latest salvo is that they are determining how this money will be spent.
This suggests fiscal irresponsibility; that there is no transparency, no accountability or no clear and focused policy strategy on governing the fiscal affairs of this country or our national affairs generally for that matter. No vision. No plan.
At the beginning of the debate, there was another resolution tabled for the borrowing of another $100 million.
Mr. Speaker
It is also ironic that as the government rails about PLP mismanagement of the fiscal affairs of this country, their record shows that overall expenses are $400 million more than last year – $1.3 billion vis-à-vis $900 million.
Further, after boasting of saving $75 million from mass separations from the public service, the member for East Grand Bahama reported to this Honourable House that public service salaries are $15 million more than last year.
Mr. Speaker
This can only be characterised as voodoo economics.
I encourage the FNM to simply take responsibility for being in government; take responsibility for their decisions and take full responsibility for the consequences of their actions. There is no need for caveats.
The single largest expense line item in the budget is debt redemption and it has been that way for quite some time now, so let us compare apples to apples in our analysis.
The fact of the matter is that the PLP, in 2012, met a fiscal deficit in excess of $500 million with deteriorating revenue performance. Not including overhangs – or the bills left behind – calculated on a cash basis – not on an accrued basis.
Our medium term fiscal consolidation plan successfully reduced this sustainably year over year by some 80 percent before two devastating hurricanes in 2015 and 2016 crushed the country’s infrastructure; shut down the country for almost one week; severely damaged the tourism plant; and crushed a number of economies on several Family Islands.
Additionally, liberal tax exemptions were extended to private citizens and numerous businesses to assist them in rebuilding their lives and businesses.
This is an inconvenient truth to some among us because it does not fit the narrative of corruption and mismanagement that others seek to spew; but those are the unvarnished facts.
The principal question now is, “where do we as a country go from here?” Are we looking behind and creating bogeymen or are we pressing forward and blazing new trails for a new generation of Bahamians to follow and be confident in doing so.
The Latest Blacklisting By The European Union
Mr. Speaker
According to several news agencies, both local and international, European Union tax experts took a policy decision to blacklist The Bahamas along with St Kitts and Nevis, and US Virgin Islands.
This decision, was endorsed by European Union Finance Ministers at a regular monthly meeting yesterday.
Even though the government said it would do all in its power to avoid another blacklisting, we find ourselves being blacklisted.
The larger question is what is the policy of the government to effectively push back against this onslaught to our second largest industry? The Prime Minister came to Parliament entreating that we stand unified on matters affecting this Industry.
We agreed. We did so notwithstanding the government’s decision to take an extended summer vacation break after the post-election ceremonies and celebrations when it had sufficient time to address the threats to avoid blacklisting.
No sooner than the agreement was made, the Prime Minister returned to the campaign trail telling the world that the PLP destroyed the financial services sector.
This is an example of what I mean when I say that this Government is intent on naming and shaming.
Mr. Speaker
This brings me to the multilateral convention for the Automatic Exchange Tax Information Convention.
The threat of blacklisting loomed large:
The Prime Minister’s communication of 13 December, 2017 spoke to the strenuous and decisive efforts of his government since May 2017 to avoid the threat of immediate blacklisting by the OECD and EU.
Blame was put at the foot of our administration, the accusations being that we failed to meet the required number of bilateral Tax Exchange Agreements.
The suggestion was that we waited two years after committing to the bilateral convention – noting that letters were sent out as late as in December 2016 to fulfil our commitment.
The accusation had been made before and I intervened to correct the view that the Prime Minister and his government had formed in relation to this matter.
Unfortunately, the view obviously persisted – and again, during the PM’s communication on 13 December, 2017 on the subject matter, I sought to intervene.
Mr. Speaker
You should recall that I was not permitted to do so by the chair as the communication in my view contained controversial statements. The Prime Minister did not yield.
My intervention was to warn the government, that despite their strenuous and decisive efforts – the goal posts continually move – and its moving does not depend on who is in charge of the administration – whether it be PLP or FNM.
The clearest illustration of this fact is the move from bilateral protocol to multilateral protocol and the ensuing threat to be blacklisted.
I also wanted to make the point that this was such a complex issue that we in Government needed to be guided by the industry. I know many of the key players in the industry would want to help.
The Convention relating to Automatic Exchange of Tax information, bilateral and multilateral, permitted participating parties to choose – bilateral or multilateral.
On the recommendation of industry stakeholders, we elected bilateral. The EU and OECD, in a meeting held in October 2016, thought best that we should move to the multilateral platform.
An outcome of the meetings also required an invitation for the Bahamas to join the Inclusive Framework of the EU’s “Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Initiative” (BEPS Initiative) and in March 2017, Government was invited. Our response to this invitation no doubt has led to the blacklisting yesterday by the EU.
Apart from correcting what were false innuendos – I was concerned by the admission of the PM that he was lost on the issues and no doubt they all seem out to sea on this issue hence the blacklisting by the EU.
Mr. Speaker
In December the PM confirmed that they were aware upon assuming office of the impending threats to be blacklisted and spoke of their strenuous and decisive efforts to avoid it.
Having had notice of an impending blacklisting, why are we some nine (9) months later being blacklisted?
In that communication, Our Prime Minister assured all of us that “we have thus moved away from the threat of being blacklisted.” Really?! Which he confirmed during his National Address and again I quote
“To protect our financial services industry, we took decisive action to avoid being blacklisted by the EU and OECD.”
Could I now say that the sluggish and lazy response of this Government have put our country on a dangerous and disastrous course? The suggestion for the blacklisting is “failure at a high political level”. [see letter if necessary].
It is sad that members of the government seems not to understand the need for constant vigilance when it comes to the Off-shore Financial sector.
I hope the FNM government’s excuse is not to blame the PLP and deflect from its responsibility. We stand ready to work with the government on a national strategy to protect this industry and Bahamian workers.
The Nation’s Health
Mr. Speaker
I have said this before and I say it again in this honourable place: The PLP’s policy prescription for decisively addressing the country’s national health needs is National Health Insurance.
We have always remained clear about that. Ten months into this government’s tenure of governance, Bahamians are still unsure and uncertain about this government’s plans to address this critical need.
Bahamians have been subjected to a PR campaign on national health care. This included reported free surgeries by the Health Minister, all with a steady dose of detailed descriptions of what they term a national health crisis. These are not policy solutions, Mr. Speaker.
In the meantime, there is a dire shortage of beds in the public health system resulting in critically and chronically ill patients being sent home prematurely.
Mr. Speaker
As part of the PLP’s revenue enhancement measures, heavy taxes, popularly characterized as sin taxes, were assessed on alcoholic drinks and tobacco products.
We on this side do not believe that additional taxation of these products will provide a sustainable funding mechanism to defray the costs of national critical and chronic – or secondary and tertiary health care delivery services.
The PLP
- completed and opened the critical care block,
- refurbished satellite health clinics across this archipelago,
- extended operating hours of selected clinics,
- expanded and deployed medical doctors in many family island communities,
- expanded the operational capacity of the Rand Memorial Hospital,
- opened mini hospitals in Exuma and Abaco,
- commenced construction and renovation of clinics throughout the archipelago, and
- executed contracts for the enhancement of the maternity ward and male and female wards
all in preparation for the access and delivery of universal health care to all Bahamians as a human right, not a privilege.
Bahamians expect successive governments to build on gains made by their predecessors or provide justifiable and workable alternative solutions. To date, the FNM government has provided neither.
This is disgraceful and further substantiates the fact that they were woefully unprepared to govern.
There is a distinct difference between political campaigning and actual governance.
For our part the former Minister put in place a solid workable plan and there is no need to reinvent the wheel but to simply build on a foundation of progress.
Quit with the moaning and groaning and fix the outstanding problems. Secure the required beds to accommodate sick people who are in serious need of medical care.
I implore the Health Minister to move posthaste and cease all the talk. Our people want action, a resolution to this crisis and not long talk filled with empty promises. Further, if you can’t fish, then with all due respect, please get the hell out of the boat.
PLP Immigration Policy Position
Mr. Speaker
A perennial, current and vexing issue remains immigration, and in light of the recent court rulings, the charges of legal ambiguities and outright misrepresentations of the law, I wish to restate our position on this matter to reinforce our position statement delivered by Senator Mitchell in the Senate last week. I adopt his words as my own as I quote him verbatim:
“It is therefore the view of the PLP that the cases before the Courts must be prosecuted to the highest courts in the land.
“Further and in addition to that the law should be amended forthwith to ensure that it is clear that it is the executive who has the right to grant citizenship of The Bahamas and no one else.
“Further, the law should be amended to remove the element of profit from people like Mr. Smith for whose firm the type of litigation in which he engages is a profit centre at the expense of the Bahamian taxpayer by adjusting if necessary the rule on costs of these applications in the Supreme Court. It should be juxtaposed against his invitation to migrants to sue the Government so that the government will be overwhelmed with cases and bankrupt the country.
“We have indicated in the public domain that given the zeal with which this is being pursued, and the number of illegal migrants who keep coming and continue to be defended one must wonder whether or not the two are not working in league with one another.
“There is a need for us to secure our borders. We support that. We are concerned that sufficient work is not being done to secure our borders. We are concerned when ships can make their way up to the main island of New Providence without let or hindrance.”
Soil Erosion And Road Collapse In Eleuthera
Mr. Speaker
It was reported in the media that extreme weather conditions have now made it difficult and some say impossible for residents in north and South Eleuthera to move about the island by land.
Many of us have viewed video footage on social media of water gushing across Queen’s Highway; the highway having been split in two in an area called the sandpit.
Information coming to our attention raise some serious questions about the circumstances surrounding this environmental disaster and with your leave Mr. Speaker, I wish to raise these issues as I seek clarification and answers for the general public:
- Can the Member of Parliament for North Eleuthera assist this Parliament in providing the name of the owner of the sandpit dredging operation?
- Will the Prime Minister confirm if a permit was granted to operate a sandpit? If yes, then when was the permit granted?
- Was there ever excavation of sand to a depth of 14 feet below the surface of the road in the vicinity of the sandpit and Queens Highway where the road was split in two?
- Will the Minister of Works who should have received a report from his Engineers confirm whether or not the excavation of sand and the operation of a sandpit in the area adjacent to Queens’s Highway contributed significantly if not directly to the road being split in two by the sea?
Bahamas Power and Light (BPL)/Energy Sector Reform
Mr. Speaker
It is no secret that the power generation and distribution systems owned and operated by the government owned Bahamas Power and Light are unreliable.
The amended Electricity Act, the Bond Reduction Act, the BPL business plan together with the national energy policy laid out the way forward for the reform for both BPL and the energy sector generally.
I note, however, that the recent $100 million bond issue by the Bahamas Government to upgrade or replace BPL’s power plants and aging distribution network failed to address the $500 million BPL legacy debt.
- What is the status on retiring such a debt?
- What is the status of self-generated power and net metering programme?
- What is the new timeline for BPL to reduce its electricity cost by thirty percent and for the introduction of alternative energy sources?
- Has the government abandoned our relationship and alternative energy commitment through the carbon war room?
- On what island and when can we expect the first Family Island pilot program to commence as part of the island challenge?
The Water And Sewerage Corporation Audit
Mr. Speaker
If any among us doubted that these recent forensic audits of public accounts at various public corporations commissioned by the FNM government were anything more than glorified and expensive witch hunts, the recent Water and Sewerage audit should eliminate all doubt.
Mr. Speaker
For the information of this House and for the consumption of the general public, I refer to specifics of the matter of the Ernst and Young (EY) forensic audit of the Water and Sewerage Corporation, which was tabled last week in this House and elaborately commented on by the Chairman of the Water and Sewerage Corporation, the Member for Long Island.
This is a most sordid and libellous Report, which has made its way into the ancient records of this place. For me it is distressing because it touches on matters that are extremely personal to me as morbid references were made to my dear departed mother.
They also attacked a lady, Mrs. Merlean Poitier, who has worked as a legal secretary for many years in the firm of Davis and Co. and before that Christie, Ingraham and Co. and then Christie, Davis & Co. She has an impeccable reputation in the ranks of legal secretaries, only to be sullied by persons with biased, prejudicial and puerile minds.
As members would know, this is the second report by EY both of which appear to be targeted at me and my role as Minister for Works in the last administration.
On the BPL issue, alleging and suggesting that a contract had been given to my brother by BPL at my instance which proved patently false and an a public apology had to be tendered to me by the Minister of Works.
It is vexing that I now tackle this latest saga from the government.
On Thursday, 1st March, 2018, the Minister of Works, the Hon. Member for Carmichael mentioned to me that my name had come up in the latest EY report but he refused to indicate the exact reference.
I immediately took it on me to write to the Global Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Ernst Young Global. I will read this letter so as to have it entered into the records of this Hon. House:
(LETTER to MARK WEINBERGER)
The key elements of my letter was to formally request a peer review of standard operational, accounting and auditing practices at EY because I perceived that the local Strategic Business Unit was unwittingly allowing itself to be used as pawns in a high-stakes, high profile political witch hunt by the FNM government.
I was not invited to comment on the accusations raised by the audit – not even a telephone call. And yet, the report has brazenly been put forward as being an established fact.
This report by EY indicates a true lack of professionalism and is an attempt at assassination of character by hired hands and mercenaries.
This report could not be the work of true professionals. At best, it is that of a “side corner” organisation holding itself out as a professional organisation.
The entire report is riddled with unsubstantiated statements and innuendos
Mr. Speaker
The EY report (forensic audit) is a slap-dash piece of work designed to aid the government in their on-going witch hunt of individuals and game of naming and shaming.
It has unfairly maligned senior members of the management of the W&SC and has damaged their professional standing. How can the present Chairman and Board expect to work with these same individuals in a professional and above board approach when they have been so spitefully savaged.
The report is badly flawed and cannot stand. I would think that the report should be withdrawn forthwith and apologies issued all around.
I must go on record as condemning the performance and presentation of the Member for Long Island, the Chairman of the W&SC. His behaviour was deplorable and puerile.
It was something that we would expect from a high school debate. He appears to take delight in bringing out sordid details and appears to have no sense of public propriety.
As a new member and a young member, I should only wish to caution him that time is longer than rope and what today he is so gleeful about can in a very short while prove to be his nightmare.
I am sure that the good people of Long Island did not elect him to be the avenging angel of wrath. In his daily conduct of the affairs of the W&SC Corporation and by his performance in this place, his stature has steadily diminished.
Before I leave this matter, EY reportedly observed from email discussions that someone within government was “directing” a payment of IM to NID despite clear objections from WSC and MPW personnel. Several emails were exhibited and one lifted to be put in the substantive report.
A read and understanding of the email lifted clearly demonstrates the mischief that the audit exercise was engaged to create. It was story telling without regard to the truth as it was clearly disingenuous to suggest that someone within the government was directing this payment. The email lifted was sent by the PS of the MOW, where he wrote about an officer in the MOF being directed to request the MOW to facilitate payment. I was MOW and whereas I wished I could have given directions to officers in the MOF, that just could not happen. Chairman spoke of a “guardian angel” in the MOW pointing to no doubt to me.
It was very easy for EY to speak to the PS. I am advised this never happened. Couldn’t EY speak to Simon Wilson? Again, I am advised, this did not happened. Couldn’t they speak to me?
These inquiries would or could have deterred them from the salacious innuendo and spectre of wrong doing by the views expressed by EY. This brings me to the issue of the unnecessary reference to one share of 5,000 shares held by Mrs. Poitier and the disinterring of my mother’s bones to connect her to me.
EY confirmed that they reviewed the corporate registry files of NID to ascertain who the owners are – they discovered that this company was incorporated since 8th July, 2004.
These are the facts that they did not mention:
– The company was incorporated by Joan Ferguson & Co.
– The owners by shareholding at that time were ALF – 4,700, Ann Krallis – 150 and Joan Ferguson – 150
– That 8th August 2006 – shareholdings changed to Avery Ferguson – 2,400 ALF -2,400 , Joan Ferguson 150
– That on 28 May, 2008, ALF – 4,998 and Joan Ferguson – 2
– That on 5 January, 2009, ALF – 4997, Shawn Smith – 2, and Joan Ferguson – 1
– That Agency moved from Joan Ferguson to Commonwealth Law Advocate on the 19 June, 2012 – Ruth Bowe Darville/Desmond Bannister –
Could they not have spoken to Ruth Bowe Darville?
I recall Long Island informing me that they told him that EY spoke to Ms, Ruth Bowe-Darville. She says it NEVER HAPPENED! The corporate regime requires that there be at least 2 named shareholders.
Has the time come to eliminate the concept of the nominee shareholder? It evolved from 5 persons to 2 – EY, no doubt is familiar with the concept, had they made a full and true inquiry to determine the ownership of NID as they purported to be doing, this much ado about nothing, sullying the names of others all of this could have been avoided.
Mr. Speaker
More damaging is characterisation of a purported text message exchange between myself and DGM Deal under the Rubric – suspicious/unusual communications. On review of the exchange, I know that it was not me. I don’t conduct myself in this fashion. I will inquire about matters and may make recommendations on matters. Directions from me would ordinarily fall in matters of policy.
This exchange therefore troubled me. I contacted DGM Deal to have the context in which these exchanges were made – his response embolden my view that this exchange did not take place between us.
So, I asked that he provide me the phone number involved in this exchange. He did so and it is a number that I do not know nor am I familiar with the number. It was 376-0001. 1 do not know it!
Did EY discover this number? Did they seek to determine to whom this number was assigned or who is the owner of this account? Clearly someone impersonating me was engaged in the text exchange.
Would this not have been uncovered had they truly engage in a proper forensic audit?
Mr. Speaker
Members opposite continue to paint a picture of corruption on the part of the PLP and their associates. We go on record as condemning corruption. It has no place in our world.
As for the FNM, their style of governance is to name and shame as if that is what they were elected to do. This is a continuing narrative of the members of the FNM.
The two PLP governments of 2002-2007 and 2012 to 2017 came into office knowing full well that there were instances of corruption on the part of the FNM.
In fact, there are members sitting opposite who have conflicted themselves and raised alarming issues of corruption while holding posts in the government.
I should just like the newer members of this House to know that Article 49 of the Constitution provides for a member to come before the House and ask for an exemption when either, personally or through any of his companies, he is conflicted in his business interests and seek and exemption.
There is no evidence in all my time here that any member, some of whom are in this place have sought any such exemption. But we know who you are.
At the same time, there are others of the FNM who are not in this place against whom serious allegations have surfaced but against whom we have never sought to shame or name.
All I wish to say is that we know who you are. But the PLP is bigger than you think. We are a national party that has tirelessly sought to advance the welfare of the people and we will continue to be that kind of party.
Pettiness will not deliver food on the table; it will not provide that culture of oneness and dignity that we seek to strive for as a people.
So get off of it and go about the task of governance.
Conclusion
Mr. Speaker
Our solemn pledge to the Bahamian people remains unchanged. We will continue to be a voice for the poor, weak, the underprivileged and ordinary Bahamians seeking a better way of life to replace the tyranny and culture of mean spiritedness under this uncaring, spiteful and vindictive FNM government.
What we have in The Bahamas today is an apparent threat to representative government. Underpinning all democratic societies is the principle of representative government with the basic compact that assumes that public officials (MPs) will hear from constituents/general public and to act appropriately on their concerns.
The EY report with the complicit endorsement of the government casts a pall of potential challenges over the relationship between MPs, constituents, and the general public.
Mr. Speaker
Our democracy is at stake. It is for all of us to remove the scales from our eyes and see things as they really are.
Nothing this FNM Government does will deter us from our mission of advocacy, constructive engagement and wiping every tear from every eye.
Nothing!
-
Contribution by Glenys Hanna Martin
Contribution by Glenys Hanna Martin –Member of Parliament for Englerston: Mid-Term budget Debate- House of Assembly; Monday March 12th., 2018
Mr Speaker, I am privileged to rise once again on behalf of the good people of Englerston who despite all odds as manifested in the last General Election results, sent a Member of the Progressive Liberal Party to be their voice in this House.
I have vowed to be faithful to the principles of this great Party, the Progressive Liberal Party.
To advocate for and fight for the interests and the advancement of the Bahamian people; such that we realize the true and immense potential of our people and in particular our children whether they live in Lovely Bay, Acklins or True Blue, Crooked Island or Rose’s, Long Island or Pleasant Bay, Andros or the Forest, Exuma or Spanish Wells, Eleuthera or on Podoleo Street in Englerston.
To insist upon a society built upon sustained fairness and equity for all of our people and achieved in particular through the vehicle of Education by stimulating creative and independent thought ;by providing liberal access to a premiere healthcare system which not only treats illness but which aggressively promotes healthiness, by securing a timely and responsive social safety net infrastructure to alleviate suffering and extreme want, and by providing an overall vital atmosphere which awakens collectively the physical, spiritual , cultural and intellectual talents of our people.
This is my commitment. This is my desire. It is why I stepped up for a political life.
I am not interested in sitting in this House all day and calling someone “teef” , or in pointing cheap political fingers at the next side, while at the same time fundamental needs are being neglected throughout our country, and unfortunately our country stagnates.
You see, Mr Speaker, this is the dilemma we currently face in The Bahamas.
This great country of so much promise is stuck in a quagmire of rancid political rhetoric, stuck in a singular preoccupation when we face a myriad of challenges which are unchecked, and all of which are lowering the morale of the Bahamian people and endangering our progress.
Mr Speaker, the people of Englerston, and indeed the Bahamian people are really not too much interested in the politicking.
A lot of people are out of work and are catching almighty hell trying to survive from one day to the next.
It has not helped that this government itself put hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of people on the unemployment line since they took office.
They have provided some alleged rationale for these terminations but in light in what is now becoming a sordid track record we must take everything this government says with a grain of salt.
We do know, however, that the process of choosing who will be terminated across the public service does not appear to be based upon any transparent or declared criteria.
Questions must be raised about the firing of the employee of 15 years at BAIC (with apparent known affiliation to the Progressive Liberal Party which is his constitutional right) and who worked harmoniously and professionally under administration after administration, PLP and FNM, but under this particular administration has been deprived of his right to earn an income and care for his family; again the reason is becoming clear as to why the two young Bahamian women who served with distinction and with a high degree of professionalism with the Airport Authority as managers at airports in Eleuthera , ( with ties to the Progressive Liberal Party (which is their fundamental right and freedom), namely Danielle Gibson and Holly Pearce Barrett, were unceremoniously sent home (newspaper article).
This pattern is very disturbing.
And We are left to be gravely concerned about what criteria is being applied in the brute application of state power to deprive citizens of a livelihood.
Mr Speaker this government claims it is firing Bahamians in the “public good” but at the same time they are hiring, is that in the public good too?
Is there anything of interest in the political antecedents of these persons becoming gainfully employed?
Members opposite who criticized the former administration for engaging the consultancy services of Sir Baltron Bethel in the Office of the Prime Minister because of his advanced years, bust now explain how this principled position coexists with the hiring since May of 2017 of not one or two but several “consultants” of advanced years?
What happened to that solemn pledge to the Bahamian people that no person would be engaged under contractual terms in excess of $100.000 ? How do members opposite explain that since May 10th of last year you did precisely what you said you would not do?
Was the Member for Killarney as Leader of the Opposition said he could not on principle support a pay increase for MP’s was he serious because as soon as he took the helm of government, he declared his intention to increase salaries for MP’s. Even the former Chairman of the FNM could not be restrained when he accused this government of sending the message of “me first, you last”
Clearly consistency is lacking with this , unless it is consistency in displaying disingenuousness, consistently failing to reveal a progressive agenda, consistently contradictory, consistent in untrustworthy the rhetoric, consistently flip flopping
This consistency is fostering a growing lack of confidence in and a loss of credibility for this government even after only a few months in office.
None of this would have mattered that much if the people could feel that this administration had any sort of concrete agenda that would advance the interests of the Bahaman people.
But to date there is no evidence of this.
We are seeing that this is a government of straw, un-substantive.
Grossly hypocritical, so consistently hypocritical that it is almost unbelievable.
In Opposition led by the member for Killarney, they attacked and criticized virtually everything, they virulently opposed the implementation of Value Added Tax (VAT) calling the tax one of the worst forms of taxation, “regressive”, yet just a few months ago the same objector using those words, the Member for East End lavishly commended VAT as being wonderful.
In Opposition, they said that VAT revenue had been misappropriated or was not accounted for, The now MP for Freetown said at one of their rallies that we “teef” the VAT money but now they are saying they never said we actually teef the VAT money.
But here they are today pointing to VAT as a continuing primary source of revenue to the State all of which is duly accounted for as would be expected in a modern state and not the banana republic they were suggesting.
We can never forget the vigorous undermining of the very sensitive negotiations surrounding Bahamar a multibillion dollar project so important to the economy of The Bahamas and where so much was at stake which was then embroiled in legal wrangling internationally with pending bankruptcy proceedings.
Never mind that a few of the vocalists had apparent conflicts of interest in the matter.
But those opposite are telling the world that now everything is ok: what a photo moment to see the Member for Killarney smiling from ear to ear, ringing that bell at the SLS opening at Bahamar; the member for freetown could not be more pleased with bahamar these days.
One can only listen in stunned silence at the Prime Minister in one of his famous national addresses declare that the “ success (of Bahamar) is the Bahamas’ success. We will do all we can to aid them in attaining this success”.
It is of note that the member for Killarney previously severely criticized and chastised the former Prime Minister for not Firing the MP for Bamboo Town over the Letter of Intent saga while the PM since May 10 saw fit to Promote him to Leader of Government business in this House.
We are quickly learning that much of what we are being fed in these National Addresses cannot be taken to the bank.
Last year in one such National Address the Prime Minister claimed that the government was involved in negotiations with the owners of the Grand Lucayan in Grand Bahama for a joint ownership in partnership with a number of investors. He said they identified a number of travel and hospitality companies that can bring quality brands to Grand Bahama but also much needed air transportation. He claimed that the government would “resuscitate” and “grow business” and thereafter sell the government’s equity to investors. He claimed renovations at the resort would begin within a month and the facility ready for business for the “winter season”.
The winter season has come and gone and the hotel building remains idle.
But they had so much things to say about Grand Bahama now all we hear is silence.
But then again there were so many grandiose promises, some of which feel certain will go the way of all flesh. There was the promise of free tuition and board to every student throughout the country, the promise of removing VAT from breadbasket items.
But we must remember that while these promises have been deferred , the first budget of this new government gave tax breaks to the wealthiest groups in country and Mr Speaker you will recall questions raised about self-serving tax breaks – tax relief for businesses which senior members of the FNM owned or have interests in.
One of the vexing issues plaguing our country is the state of healthcare in this country and it is now a matter of grave concern for most Bahamians:
As an aside and Interestingly the Member for Elizabeth before being elected to this House in one of his many TV interviews described this member’s ministerial performance as incompetent.
I thought him most unkind as I was trying very hard and was of the view that much fundamental reform had been undertaken; we had launched the modernization of the aviation sector, completed the automation of the Road Traffic Department, initiated the redevelopment of Potters Cay Dock, finalized a first time comprehensive Review of the 1958 Road Traffic Act, drafted legislation for a modern maritime sector, oversaw the completion of 2 of the 3 phases of LPIA, marshalled the redevelopment of the San Salvador Airport, procured a new runway for Staniel cay and Mayaguana airport and the recommencement of Bahamasair flights, , completion the installation of emergency runway lighting stystems on every government runway, Advanced to end stage the preliminary plans for the redevelopment of the North Eleuthera and Exuma airports, partnered for the Redevelopment of the Bimini airport inclusive of facilitation of night flights . We were esteemed to drive the modernization and strengthening of capacity of the Department of Meteorology including the acquisition of a network of Doppler radars along the archipelago for comprehensive coverage, now installed in Nassau and Abaco and continuing throughout the country, acquiring a state of the art Air Traffic Management system and related technology and infrastructure, and we were able to far advance the reform the public transport sector including a pilot project which upon demitting office was ready for rollout., and of course, the historic signing of the Declaration of Intent between The Bahamas and the United States of America for the management and control of our sovereign airspace which resulted in the immediate cessation of Bahamian aircraft paying fees to the FAA to fly within our own airspace (see)
But here we have now the shoe on the other foot and the member Englerston wants to know what that member for Elizabeth is doing as Minister of Health to address the dire circumstances in the country’s healthcare sector.
We not only have a shortage of beds but are experiencing a systemic crisis that goes beyond beds of which I believe the Minister is well aware. But on the issue of shortage of beds in the public health system, will the Minister advise whether space is being utilized to create a private surgical ward under the management of Physician’s Alliance and will he advise what effect this will have on the already critical shortage of beds for public patients, poor people? And will he advise further who are the beneficial owners of the shareholding in Physician’s Alliance?
We know that we have serious health challenges, we know we rank high on so many lists for so many diseases. We would need more than chronic descriptions of the problems we face, We demand a real plan of action leading to tangible solutions on an urgent basis.
The Member for Elizabeth must be careful that the very word that he used to describe my ministerial tenure does not come back and bite him in the posterior.
He like the others in this government will quickly learn that political opportunism requires little skill or minimal aptitude but the mandate to deliver in a tangible way , to advance the cause of a people requires substance.
This government has proven to be grossly deficient and incompetent in the execution of these necessary objectives,
On the economy, the chief spokesman, the member for East End the Minister of Finance has in my view failed to bring an objective analysis, indeed he has engaged in much political rhetoric superimposing on the economic data and the Member for Exuma and Ragged Island would have highlighted some fo this already
I was interested to read the Central Bank quarterly report (see) which stated :-
Over the past three years, The Bahamas has performed fairly well compared to the other countries in its credit rating peer group, albeit amidst low growth. (see)
And it is disappointing to see a Minister of Finance not give the full weight to the effect catastrophic hurricanes must have on an economy even one as large as the State of Florida, for example.
Instead we see what is in my view the downplaying of the economic effects of Joaquin, one of the most powerful tropical cyclones ever on record which dealt a full assault on The Bahamas and Matthew which impacted our population centre in New Providence, Grand Bahama and North Andros among other areas.
Ironically this government has yet to adequately respond to the devastation in Ragged Island caused by Irma as pointed out by the MP last week.
But our Prime Minister is expanding his reach all over the region – in Dominica and even most recently in Haiti where he touted agricultural trade with Haiti, the famous banana speech, compared to when it was alleged that he was faster than Usain Bolt in ducking local farmers.
When you consider the stances taken in Opposition, it is interesting that all of the revenue gains proudly touted by the Minister of Finance emanate from implementations by the former administration none of which he nor his colleagues in Opposition supported whilst in Opposition namely Gaming, VAT and the newly reformed Road Traffic Department.
It seems, however, that there is some contradiction on the performance of VAT revenue as the Minister of Finance in a recent newspaper article suggests VAT receipts are underperforming . In this article you see what has become the characteristic hedging as to the reason for this (see)
I am advised that the real reason for the underperformance is that the Unit established to focus on VAT collection under the prior administration was dismantled and trained personnel sent home.
Unfortunately, it inconsistencies such as I have highlighted and the consistent flip flopping , the constant backtracking and the inelegant moonwalking, the varied and multiple hypocritical stances that the word “fraudulent” is now creeping into our national dialogue.
Nowhere has this word resonated more or become so rooted as in the last several days when the country witnessed an alarming display for which there is yet to be an explanation in what is becoming known as the Oban debacle
We have learned that the foreign investors touted to invest in our Bahamaland are of dubious character. The face of the investment, someone whose role has been shifting before our eyes and more lately self-described as an Ambassador has been convicted of fraud and barred by the SEC from engaging in a multiplicity of activities.
This Ambassador was seen on our national TV , seated next to our Prime Minister, purporting to execute a $5 billion Heads of Agreement while signing someone else’s name ,said to be the President of the Company ( who himself is reported to be of dubious past behavior}.
A document was laid in this House said to be the Heads of Agreement , however, this is not the same document the country witnessed being executed in the formal ceremony touted as the execution of the Heads of Agreement.
The document laid in this House , however, was apparently signed by another person allegedly on the same day which in itself raises questions.
Has this House been misled?
Was the country purposely misled?
Why have there been no answers to date for the questions and concerns. Where is the mandated accountability to this Parliament?
And while the government is silent , this foreign company released what was clearly a sponsored public relations piece in the daily newspapers which I found offensive. I abandoned it after reading only the first paragraph.
We do not want the principals of this Company to believe the Bahamian people are stupid even if they may feel they hoodwinked this government.
In light of the bizarre happenings surrounding this Oban deal, we need to know if Bahamians are associated with this Company and if so, who are they?
Because it is not just the suspicious circumstances surrounding the deal, not just the cornucopia of criminals associated with the deal, but of even greater concern is the substance of the deal.
First we note that the BEST Commission was surreptitiously removed from the portfolio of the Minister of Environment and placed in the Office of the Prime Minister , it is at his feet therefore that we lay squarely the grotesque and unprecedented departure of standard provisions in such arrangements for the protection of our environment .
It is stunning to see that under this deal, the Developer may simply abandon the project if it does not wish to take steps which are” commercially reasonable” to ameliorate environmental concerns. The government , however, cannot walk away even if the environmental impact assessment is unfavourable.
Under this agreement penalties for damage to the environment caused by failure to remediate infractions are capped at $3.5 million.
Remarkably, the agreement ( in Clause 17: 12) gives the developer immunity and/ or exemption from any future laws or regulations , approval or other legal requirement which is applied including any changes in the conditions applicable to the issuance of any approval: this will include environmental laws. This is unheard of.
The Prime Minister who now has responsibility for the BEST Commission must explain to the Bahamian people why such peculiar provisions have been agreed to and why our interest has not been jealously guarded in this agreement. He must explain why the fate of the Bahamian people has been tied to this Company with associates of such dubious repute.
Why have our national resources been locked into this 90 year agreement with such unusual provisions?
Why are these constraints placed upon the State in clause 13 which prohibits the government taking any action over the seabed lease or the Crown land but no corresponding obligation placed on this foreign entity.
Why does the agreement mandate that the government give a right of first refusal of neighbouring crown land measuring 500 acres to this Foreign Developer? (clause 13 g).
And what is the true economic impact to The Bahamas of this project which is described as being “in the substantial economic interest of Bahamian people and will provide employment benefits”? described in the agreement as having “significant economic benefit:”
The agreement stipulates there will be 600 direct jobs and 1,000 indirect and induced jobs during construction and 250 direct full time jobs at a ratio of 80 per cent Bahamian to 20 per cent foreign although there are wiggly provisions which could shift this ratio (clause 8);
The agreement states the Developer will apply $100,000 annually on the job technical skills training and periodic assistance towards curriculum development at University of The Bahamas. It provides for a one off payment of $150,000 for marine research and the sum of $100.00 per annum for community projects and the development of East Grand Bahama.
When you consider objectively the alleged multi billion dollar nature of this enterprise and its potential leverage in the global market and when you weigh in the balance the enormous concessions being given including crown land (with no disclosure on the scope and size or location nor any reference to a purchase price , additionally a lease of the sea bed, again the size, scope and location not disclosed); the commitment to expeditiously change our law for the sole benefit of this Investor in amending the Industries Encouragement Act : the country is left speechless.
This is a first .
and the agreement is not just for oil, it allows for the construction, lease and sale of houses on what is described as “private lands” for the housing of workers during construction and for the involvement of foreign real estate agents even though it states (clause 10) the developer shall insure the inclusion of Bahamians.
This substantial divestment has been made by this Government to this now controversial company which now indicates that they can take our agreement and go out and raise funding…. why would this government do this to the Bahamian people and for 90 years at that ?
I raise two final concerns: has this project received an exemption to the exclusivity clause on the construction of Ports vested in the Freeport Harbour Company as was necessitated for the development of the Carnival Cruise Port in East End which raises the second question of the status of that deal the Carnival Cruise Port negotiated with the previous administration, which as I recollect had restrictive clauses prohibiting the approval of this type of development , a large industrial oil refinery plant within a designated range of the Carnival location. What is the status of this? Are we confronting a potential collision of vested interests?
If this is the nature and quality of what the Bahamian people can expect from this government, all things considered thus far, then we have much to be concerned about over this five year term or as one distinguished jurist lately expressed “if they last that long”, Mr Speaker,.
I end by expressing my grave concern that this duplicitous government has placed our country in a quagmire of a web.
-
BUDGET REMARKS BY CHESTER COOPER
2017-2018 MID-YEAR BUDGET REMARKS
CHESTER COOPER, EXUMAS AND RAGGED ISLAND MP, PLP DEPUTY LEADER
MARCH 7, 2018Good afternoon Mr. Speaker,
I rise on behalf of the great people of Exuma, the Exuma Cays and Ragged Island today to contribute to the government’s mid-year budget for 2017-2018. Mr. Speaker, it’s been about ten months now since the first budget debate. I truly wanted to give this administration a chance, but not much has changed since my first doubts.
I have no confidence in this government’s ability to manage public finances.
I have no confidence in this government’s ability to grow this economy.
I have no confidence in this government’s ability to execute a feasible economic plan on behalf of the Bahamian people.
And I have no confidence in the numbers the government has presented to this Parliament.
There has been pretty much no improvement in how I felt 10 months ago, and nothing has changed since two weeks ago when I
said that this mid-year budget communication is simply voodoo economics.
A patchwork of sleight of hand accounting tricks, politically motivated to distract from an underlying, underwhelming ocean of nothingness that this administration has so far offered the Bahamian people.
If you couldn’t tell by now, Mr. Speaker, I’m not particularly impressed with the mid-year budget communications and I’m going to tell you why.
But before I do that, please allow me to expound on an issue of grave national importance that has gripped national attention just through the absurdity and sloppy amateur hour sideshow antics that have surrounded it.
And that is the Oban Energies saga.
Mr. Speaker, the prime minister, the member for Killarney, has essentially embarrassed the Bahamian people on an international scale by parading a convicted criminal in front of the world as a partner with The Bahamas government in some purported multi-billion dollar oil storage and refinery project, all for the sake of a few hundred jobs that may or may not materialize over the next few years.
Mr. Speaker, Bahamians from all walks of life, and I’m not exaggerating here, are now seriously asking if The Bahamas government itself is engaged in a fraud on the Bahamian people.
They are wondering if we are selling our reputation for a bowl of porridge, Mr Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, on Thursday, March 1, 2018, the member for Killarney tabled a document that he said was the heads of agreement for the $5.5 billion deal the government signed with Oban Energies just over two weeks ago.
Surely, you must remember this grand announcement, Mr. Speaker. The prime minister announced the signing of the heads of agreement for the deal on the very day we debated a no confidence motion in the Speaker.
And sure enough, a few days later, on February 19th, the government signed a heads of agreement with one Peter Krieger, an American man convicted of fraud, involved in a multi-million-dollar scheme and shrouded in controversy even with the defunct CL Financial of Trinidad and a sister company of CLICO a company that saw the fortunes of so many hard working Bahamians dashed.
A criminal, Mr. Speaker, a convicted criminal, is who the government paraded before the country, photographed and videoed and livestreamed to the world as our partner in a multi-billion dollar venture.
This from the prime minister who said last week in this place, that corruption is the number one problem in our country. Yet, there he sat right next to a corrupt individual whose name would later become synonymous with our shame.
Of course, the government said not a word about Mr. Krieger when he sat next to the prime minister, the people’s prime minister, and among the National Economic Council, made up of several honorable members of this House.
It was the media, Mr. Speaker, who unearthed these revelations about Peter Krieger, and got him on record admitting to his corrupt past.
Some of it, anyway, much more came not too long after.
According to media reports, Mr. Krieger said he was not an official part of Oban; that he had no shares, no management role and made no decisions.
What, then, Mr. Speaker was he doing next to the prime minister signing a multi-billion dollar heads of agreement if he was only an ambassador for the project, as he told the media?
In the days to come, Mr. Speaker, not only did investigative journalists expose Mr. Krieger’s past, but they got the prime minister, the member for Killarney, on video admitting that he knew of Mr. Krieger’s criminal past, admitting that the government knew, yet told the Bahamian people nothing about Mr. Krieger’s dark past or his non-involvement with the company.
Then, Mr. Speaker, comes the member for Killarney to table the heads of agreement, though he indicated he would table the one we all were led to believe was signed by Krieger.
Instead, he tabled something purportedly signed by Satpal Dhunna, the would be president of Oban Energies.
Of course, we have never seen Satpal Dhunna, we do not know when he might have signed these heads of agreement, though if the HOA tabled in this place is accurate, it was signed on February 19th, the same day Krieger signed the other agreement.
So, there are, I’m just trying to put it all together myself here, two Oban Energies heads of agreement?
One, that Peter Krieger signed and one that Satpal Dhunna signed?
That is, of course, Mr. Speaker, an assumption on my part, as The Nassau Guardian revealed this week that Krieger did not sign his own name on the heads of agreement he signed while sitting next to the member for Killarney, but rather signed the name of Satpal Dhunna.
Mr. Speaker, are we to believe that though Krieger signed that document in the name of someone else, again, something the side opposite never disclosed, the document that the member for Killarney tabled was truly signed by someone we have never seen?
Given all the confusion surrounding this project in the past few weeks, I simply find this all hard to believe.
Mr. Speaker, though we have not seen Satpal Dhunna, we have a raft of reading materials about him that have been presented in the media, which have yet to be disputed.
In the Prime Minister’s communication to parliament he said “Oban Energies Management Team has been involved in large energy infrastructure projects around the world and brings over 30 years of large complex construction experience”
The Tribune newspaper said Mr. Dhunna was fired from a company called CreditSight for “gross misconduct”. CreditSight is a research firm not an oil company. The newspaper also reported that Dhunna was fired as a used car salesman.
Clearly if he wasn’t any good at selling used cars, Mr. Speaker, Oban thought, ‘we should now promote him as the big man who will operate our $5 billion oil refinery’.
Mr. Speaker, I have a few more questions about the Oban deal:
Where is the agreement signed by Mr. Krieger on February 19th, and why was that document not tabled in this House?
Did Mr. Satpal Dhunna ever visit The Bahamas, Mr. Speaker?
If so, when?
How did he get here?
On which island did he clear immigration?
Curiously, Mr. Speaker, in an ad that ran in the papers yesterday, Dhunna said he is now “on the ground” here in The Bahamas.
But where, Mr. Speaker? We want to see the man responsible for this purported $5 billion affair?
He can write flowery language about what we perceive to be fact or fiction and the entire fishiness surrounding this deal, yet he can’t be bothered to show up for a press conference or a photo op with the prime minister of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas, Mr. Speaker? What are we to make of this? What does that say about him?
How and when did Satpal Dhunna sign the document the prime minister tabled in this House?
If it was on February 19th, why was he not at the press conference to sign his own name when Peter Krieger reportedly signed Satpal Dhunna’s name?
Will the government say when the Oban heads of agreement tabled on March 1st was signed?
And has Oban Energies as yet produced proof that it is indeed able to fund this project? I do believe at the press conference they said proof of funding will come in a few days. Well its 16 days and counting.
Again, please Mr. Speaker, show me the money.
Oban wrote in yesterday’s papers that the deal will grow the country’s gross domestic product by over 10 percent per year, Mr. Speaker!
This, of course, makes little to no financial sense.
Our economy has never grown by that much in a single year. Not even with Atlantis or Baha Mar. This claim raises more concerns about the wherewithal of Oban Energies.
This company that is exempt from import duties, value added tax and export duties, stamp tax, real property tax for 90 years; plus, they get hundreds of acres of crown land. It is expected to produce 600 jobs over the next six years, with the addition of 250 jobs over the next 12 years and they say they will grow our economy more than Atlantis, Mr. Speaker?
This member wants to see that calculation Mr Speaker.
I am pro-business, I am pro-investments, heaven knows the people of Grand Bahama need a break, but I wonder, Mr. Speaker. I don’t know that this is the one. I ask, have we given too much for a bowl of porridge?
According to the agreement, “the government shall not have the right to terminate these heads of agreement based upon any EIA report, but instead shall work with the developer to mitigate any concerns”. How incredible!
And Oban has the right to abandon the project, whenever it wishes. It also has the right to sell the project to another party and transfer the concessions,
Is this really a gamble we should be taking with our environment, Mr. Speaker?
It is a most serious question to which I have yet to see any suitable answer from anyone on the other side.
In any event, Mr. Speaker, I don’t expect much clarity on this to come from the side opposite. They’ve clammed up as of late. Maybe they’re still trying to convince us that we’re seeing holograms.
But let me see if I’ve got it right. People of checkered characters, gets concessions to build an oil refinery and don’t have to have a satisfactory environment impact assessment. In the Bahamas. Our pristine Bahamas. In East Grand Bahama where I understand there are many wild life sanctuaries. If it happens that the EIA says this is dangerous for the environment the government cannot stop them. Will the environmental laws permit the government to do this?
Then, in clause 5.4 of the HOA if something goes wrong, let’s say a massive oil spill, the maximum penalty is $3.5 million. So if it takes $5 million or $10 million or $50 million to clean up, Oban will only be responsible for $3.5 million, and I didn’t see any mandatory requirement for environmental insurance either.
Something smells with the deal, Mr. Speaker, and it ain’t oil.Maybe they think that brining up contracts signed under the previous administration with three-year exit clauses will lead the public to forget the government’s solemn duty to operate above board and protect the interests of the country, as quickly as those elected seem to have forgotten theirs.
But we don’t all have the luxury of discarding our responsibilities, Mr. Speaker. Some of us must hold firm to the standards we espouse before coming to this place.
Unlike some of those on the side opposite. Particularly the member for Killarney, who in opposition blasted sweetheart deals, now signs one faster than a proper environmental assessment can be completed.
The same member, who in this very place, before the last general election, raged against a government having anything to do with those accused of fraud, yet now sits next to an admitted fraudster, who signs somebody else’s name to document while the entire affair is broadcast to the world.
Some of us, Mr. Speaker, actually have a care what we say, and consider the ramifications of promises we make before abandoning them for no other apparent reason than the day is different.
Mr. Speaker, you may or may not know that my leader, the member for Cat Island, Rum Cay and San Salvador has pledged to call for a select committee to look into this Oban matter if the government does not at least table the quote – ceremonial heads of agreement that Krieger signed.
And I fully support that move.
Though, I’m a little more than skeptical, given how this issue has been handled so far, that we’ll see any genuine interest in exposing this matter further.
That being said, if that route is not successful in getting full transparency for the Bahamian people, we will have to probe this sordid affair through the Public Accounts Committee, of which I am a member.
Again, something smells about this deal Mr. Speaker and it ain’t oil.
On the budgetMr. Speaker, let me get back to this mid-year budget.
Again, there is no real vision here, no real plan and no real strategy. Unless that vision, plan and strategy is to present some manufactured picture of a robust financial situation.
But even if that is what has been achieved, the government’s own details and an inescapable narrative that surrounds the government’s performance indicates how flat the economic situation is and how this administration had no real grasp of what to do when out of power and even less of a clue what to do while in power, except complain that the PLP left bills for it to pay.
Well, news flash, this is what happens at the end of a government cycle. One administration undertakes commitments for the next to pay. This is the role of continuous government; this is what happens when you have cash accounting systems. You pay the bills as they come in.
Mr. Speaker, I would venture to say that the current administration is still paying for commitments undertaken during the last Ingraham administration, let alone the last Christie administration. Just as the next PLP administration will have to pay for all the debt restructuring and additional borrowing this government is undertaking and the commitments they make.
The difference is the PLP left you a means to pay your bills.
The PLP left a department of inland revenue, we left an incredibly well run value-added tax regime, we left a restructured Road Traffic Department, a new regulated gaming industry with tax revenues. We left you Baha Mar and The Pointe and we left you other projects in the pipeline, which will benefit the Bahamian people if only this government will do its due diligence.
A little less whining about paying the commitments of the country and a little creativity in actually growing the economy and facilitating job creation may put this bellyaching to rest.Mr. Speaker, the minister of finance boasts of economic growth of 1.8 percent over the first six months of the fiscal year. This is wonderful! However, what he won’t tell you is that is attributable to the PLP.
Let’s think about this for a moment. What has the FNM done since coming to office to grow this economy?
Well, Mr. Speaker it certainly wasn’t the Commercial Enterprises Act. It wasn’t repealing the Grand Bahama Incentives Act and it surely was borrowing more than $800 million or eliminating thousands of jobs from the civil sector.
I can tell you what it was that led to this growth; it was mainly Baha Mar.
The same Baha Mar that the prime minister and his deputy said was a fake opening. The same Baha Mar he promised to sell. The same Baha Mar, whose Chinese owners the member for Free Town said were not to be trusted when the Christie Administration struck the deal.
Mind you, the member for Free Town is Baha Mar’s best friend nowadays. He can’t talk about it enough. It’s his pride and joy now.
He was just in the paper yesterday raving and gushing about it, Mr. Speaker.
He now says he’s “thrilled” about it, and it’s “wonderful” and how its “creating thousands of jobs”.
So, yes, the economy grew, but let’s all be honest about why. Especially when the DPM said that the cupboard was bare.
On the health of the numbers, Mr. Speaker, overall expenses are up, way up. About $1.79 billion so far, this fiscal year compared to $1.35 billion in the same period last fiscal year.
This, according to the minister of finance, is mainly due to debt redemption in the amount of $787 million. Up from $247 million in the previous year’s period. In fact, Mr. Speaker, the debt reduction amount in the period July to December of $787 million is nearly double the entire debt reduction amount of $432 million the previous year.
Being so eager to paint a pretty picture, he neglected to say how much of the expenses and the shortfall in revenues in prior year related to two most devastating, catastrophic hurricanes. He failed to tell the whole story.
As far as revenue, Mr. Speaker, while that is up $19 million, it should really be more, shouldn’t it?
Given the scale down on capital infrastructure spending, the sending home of thousands of government employees, the reneging on promises to eliminate categories of value-added tax, and only one hurricane with minimal impact on the archipelago, these numbers really, really should be more robust.
And then there’s the other side, Mr. Speaker. If, as the minister of finance said in this place, last May, that the cupboards were bare, then surely the situation should have been much worse. It’s hard work following the many inconsistencies, Mr. Speaker.
Also, regarding tax revenue, Mr. Speaker, just a few months ago, the minister was saying VAT revenue was down.
Now he’s saying that VAT revenues are up. Now he’s acting like he anticipated it to be that way.
See what I mean when I say, “no plan”?
With regard to overall revenue, Mr. Speaker, I cannot be the only person who’s noticed on page 11, the proceeds from borrowing for the period July to December for fiscal year 2018-2018 has exceeded the same period for 2016-2017 by one billion dollars.
I promise you I’m not making this up. Where $399 million was borrowed in the first six months of the previous fiscal year by the last administration, this government has, according this mid-year budget tabled in this House, borrowed more than $1.4 billion in the first six months of this fiscal year.
And it’s right here on page 11 of this book with all the pretty pictures, if anyone wishes to challenge it or better explain why the minster and the ministry insists it has not exceeded borrowing of just over $700 million.
This is nearly double, double, Mr. Speaker, the approved forecast of $755 million of proceeds from borrowing approved by this Parliament.
Double. He says it financial restructuring. I think this is something the Public Accounts Committee will have to examine more closely.
Why the glossing over of these important numbers when the Bahamian people have a right to full disclosure directly from the minister?
Does this include the new borrowing of $190 million for Bank of The Bahamas bailout money and the IDB loan of $90m they claim doesn’t impact borrowing levels this fiscal year?
It really is sad how they treat the Bahamian people, Mr. Speaker. Less than one year, and more than $1.4 billion dollars borrowed.
And what do the Bahamian people have to show for it?
Bad roads, failing infrastructure, and a busted healthcare system.
Surely sometime before the next general election will be the peoples time, Mr. Speaker.
Just no time soon. It doesn’t add up.
More borrowing, Mr. Speaker, yet thousands sent home.
And even that plan, their only plan, was an abject failure.
While overall spending is down around $67 million. Payroll is up. The attorney general, a member of the other place, says the government saved $75 million dollars with the people sent home from the public sector. Yet, now salaries are up by $15 million.
The minister calls this the results of union payments and other things coming due.
Again, I call it having no plan. It just don’t add up.
And then failing at the plan they tried to cobble together when they tried to make financial sense of bad political policy decisions.
I guess they’ll say this is part of the paying off bills the PLP left too.
Last year it was “hundreds of millions” in bills the PLP left, this year it’s “tens of millions”, I wonder what it will be next budget communication? It simply don’t add up.
I wonder when this administration will start taking ownership of its actions?Speaking of bills, what about the bills they don’t pay, Mr. Speaker? Those that have nothing to do with what the PLP left?
What about basic maintenance that’s been neglected?
Why starve the economy to make the numbers look pretty, Mr. Speaker?
That is just terribly bad business. Why not grow the economy? Inspire confidence to improve revenues.
What does it matter if the books look good but the people are hurting?
It’s like owning a farm, Mr. Speaker and having a beautiful meadow, but your cattle go hungry. The grass looks greener but the cattle are starving.
What’s the point?
Is government not here to make sure the people get the best benefit from their tax dollars?
According to this budget, the grass is greener in Exuma, but the lunch vendors can’t get paid.
According to this budget, the grass is greener in Exuma, but the roads can’t get paved.
The grass is greener in Abaco, but the power company is on the brink.
According to this budget, the grass is greener in Acklins, yet the poor people on the government empowerment program can’t get paid.
I want the people of The Bahamas to take note, Mr. Speaker, that the minister of finance has bragged, bragged, that the government deliberately withheld the capital budget. And for no logical reason.
When public restrooms are broken, remember his boast. When public parks are in disrepair, remember his boasts.
When your car axle is snapped hitting a pothole deep enough to have struck the water table, be sure to remember his boast. When your clinics don’t have what they need. When the morgue in Cat Island is storing bodies in bathtubs. When we don’t have sufficient beds at Princess Margaret Hospital, remember his boasts.
A reasonable question would be: What are they waiting for, Mr. Speaker? Where’s the imaginary marker that tells them now is a good time to get to work and start taking care of business?
Was an arbitrary mid-year budget statement worth the suffering of the people?
I suppose they congratulate themselves, Mr. Speaker, that they spent $15 million less in public works, but Lord knows it shows.
The people can see where the savings are. I doubt the people are pleased.
$32 million less was spent on healthcare in the first half of the fiscal year, Mr. Speaker, while there’s a crisis at the hospital no less. It surely shows there.
Environment spent $4.3 million less than last year, and, of course, the dump burned again, inflicting untold health risks on residents of New Providence and even more untold damage on our tourism product.
Ministry of Grand Bahama spent $650,000 less than last year while those who didn’t get assistance after hurricane still get wet when it rains.
Ministry of Transport and Local Government spent $2.5 million less than last year whilst a potentially environmentally damaging derelict barge sits on the rocks at Long Island and Family Island local governments get scraps for garbage collection.Moody’s
And what is all this posturing for, Mr. Speaker? Surely not to impress the ratings agencies.
They don’t believe a word the government says. They don’t believe, at least Moody’s doesn’t believe, and is not impressed with all the cash vs accrual and old PLP bills talks. After demonizing the PLP to make yourselves look good, Moody’s doesn’t believe the government will hit its deficit targets.
Moody’s doesn’t believe the Department of Statistics’ GDP revision numbers.
Moody’s doesn’t really believe your plan to reduce the public sector will pay off.
And as you fall over yourself to impress them, Moody’s didn’t blink an eye when it just said a few days ago, that it will still downgrade the country to “junk” if every, single, onerous mark isn’t met.
Dry eye, they call it, Mr. Speaker.
That’s what Moody’s was.
Frankly, I found the assessment insulting. I felt bad for my colleagues on the other side and my friend from East Grand Bahama – I believe his heart is in the right place. But I felt even more so, for the professionals in our government, who have to live with the bad decisions of our Cabinet, as the foreign ratings agency has the sword of Damocles hanging over their every action.
Perhaps the government should take a page from the PLP and how we stood up to RBC after one their executives insulted Bahamian professionals.
The minister should demand Moody’s clear up what reason it has to so doubt what the government is telling them.
I’m sure the Bahamian people would be keenly interested in knowing.
But, Mr. Speaker, after our own government has talked down our economy so consistently and our prime minister has branded us the most corrupt country and told the Haitian prime minister that we must endure more pain, maybe Moody’s just figures that’s how this administration views The Bahamas, and it’s all OK. If you talk down your economy, talk down your country, if you call yourselves as Bahamians corrupt every chance you get, how you expect the international community to believe you.Economic Growth
Wrapping up here, Mr., Speaker, let me point out that the public is not at all impressed by the bantering between the PLP and the FNM. They want progress. They want things they could touch, see and feel. They want progress for The Bahamas and they expect us to deliver.The way out of this quagmire is simple – two words: “Economic growth”.
You can only fire so many people before service starts to suffer irreversibly.
You can only tax people so much until the burden becomes too much for them to bear and jobs and livelihoods are impacted. You can only cut so much without strangling the economy.
So, growth is the key.
I would say to the government, that an economic czar, as suggested in my first budget speech, is still needed to marshal the best ideas and the best talent from the private sector to move the country forward.
There’s still FDI in the pipeline to get out, Mr. Speaker.
Don’t do it like you trying to do with Oban, for goodness sake, but you could move with a little more speed. A good start would be to meet with those investors and encourage them to get on with it.
We must also unlock and mobilize domestic investments.
Also, Mr. Speaker, I honestly think it’s time we seriously consider a medical marijuana industry in The Bahamas.
I don’t personally buy into all this fearmongering over medical marijuana and the anxiety about what the Americans will say. They are doing it themselves and so is Jamaica whilst we miss a potential opportunity.
If we look at the adverse sociological, financial and health impacts that alcohol has on our country, while we twiddle our thumbs as other countries monetize this industry, I don’t understand why we’re not exploring a model that could work for us and provide lucrative taxes. I agree with the Minister of Health when he talks about more research of the potential social impact of decriminalizing, but medical cannabis is well studied. We should draw on the existing international body of work, but put in place the regulatory framework and make Phase I, the harvesting for medicinal export.Next, we must get the this small business initiatives off the ground.
Again, stop waiting for arbitrary timelines to make yourselves look good. Just do what need to be done now.
Growing small businesses drives Bahamian empowerment and employment.
You’re killing two birds with one stone when you do this.
And also put more focus on tackling structural unemployment in The Bahamas. Launch programs swiftly to mobilize discouraged workers, additional training, self-starter initiatives, cottage industries that plug into tourism, and home-based businesses – low hanging fruit.The Citizen Security Initiative is actually a pretty good example of this. Do more to get that going and then replicate it.
Agri-business is another way to get the economy going.
Aggressively pursue to food security right here at home. BAMSI is a good start. Ramp it up with more focus. Expand to other islands, perhaps. BAMSI for livestock farming might be located in Ragged Island for example.
Maybe the farmers will stop running after you if you do.We must focus on government business development, spending in revenue generating sectors, like using Bahamasair to bring more tourists into The Bahamas.
And help smaller, commuter airlines to get reliable craft to service the Family Islands. It doesn’t take much to create an airline hub in Exuma, creating jobs, opportunity and industry.
Invest in local government. You’d be surprised what adequately funding these local councils and allowing them to properly function would do.
Take this stranglehold of central government off their necks and let them soar.
Explore the opportunities that present themselves with the Sovereign Wealth Fund, being creative with the development of new industries and harnessing our resources for the benefit of all Bahamians. When we give away our crown land or lease it for 90 years why don’t we have an equity stake in the business. Equity Mr. Speaker, Equity!Ya’ll talked allot about it on the campaign trail. Y’all forgot about that one, eh?
Let’s examine and extract maximum value in industries like commercial fisheries, aragonite mining. Put in place quickly the enabling policies and permitting and get on with drilling an oil well to determine once and for all whether we have a commercially viable oil industry.
How about some BOLD initiatives and incentives under the industries encouragement Act and funding for entrepreneurs in solar and other renewable energy.
We have options. Use them.
And for the love of all that is holy, develop some sort of plan.
Right now, there’s nothing. It’s embarrassing, to be honest.
And stop blaming the PLP. The FNM has been in power for 15 of the last 25 years.
When do you stop blaming everybody else for what’s transpired in The Bahamas?
As if you’ve had no part in it?
Exhibit some agency.
Bahamian people want to hear your plans, they want jobs, they want opportunities – stop the mud-slinging and just get on with it already.
Are you going to spend five years blaming the PLP, then the next five saying you can do better than the PLP, only to blame them all over if you get the chance to govern again?
Just stop it. Just govern now. Take ownership now. Move the country forward now. That’s what the Bahamian people expect from us.
Revisit the National Development Plan. I see you’ve hijacked it to try to give this inner-city redevelopment thing some oxygen.
But it was supposed to be a non-partisan effort for long term sustainability of our country.
Surely the PLP and FNM can agree on broad principles – otherwise we risk being told what to do by the likes of IMF without local context. We must have our own plan here in The Bahamas.
This plan should include a debt reduction strategy, a liquidity strategy, an asset management strategy for government assets like buildings and a creative funding strategy to encourage private sector participation in economy.Exuma & Ragged Island
Before I go, Mr. Speaker, let me say a few words about Exuma and Ragged Island.
On paper, Exuma is having her best year ever.
Again, the grass looks greener, but things aren’t as they should be.
Exuma continues to hold its own as a leader in the Foreign Direct Investment and the tourism space generally. We continue to employ Bahamians from Nassau, Grand Bahama, Long Island and Andros.
Sandals, our flagship property, has had a very good start to the year with robust occupancy and is very bullish about the remainder of the year.
There is also the recent re-opening and refreshing of the world-famous Peace & Plenty with an initial spend of $1m in renovations, which brings that product in line with many upscale offerings.
Children’s Bay Cay, although delayed, is still on the horizon. I am advised, that after full revision of the plans for the project that construction will begin in earnest by the end of the 3rd quarter 2018. At Grand Isle: The $4 to $5 million investment in the Emerald Beach Club is expected to be open for the American independence this year and with a 90% occupancy level they are experiencing their best year ever. This is good news for Exuma.
The Exuma Cays are also faring well.
However, we have major issues that the government should take note in order to not squander the opportunity that Exuma presents.
As far as infrastructure goes, the hospital continues to be plagued by the lack of both financial and human resources.
I have recommended to the Government to consider a full outsource of the Hospital to a management company that will not only fully resource the A & E but also facilitate a medical school and create an infrastructure where we can benefit from medical tourism as well as a training hospital.
I have also recommended to the Government and introduced people to the table who are keenly interested in a Private Public Partnership (PPP) to help in advancing the clinic network in mainland Exuma and the Cays, which will be beneficial to locals, tourist and the yachting community.In short, Exuma’s economy is a bright spark for the Bahamas. We can do much more. We need more investment in infrastructure and I look forward to the commitment that the Minister of Local Government made to provide a percentage of revenues collected to Exuma’s local government for the management of the island. This is critical to continue our momentum.
As for Ragged Island, Mr. Speaker, nothing has changed. No school, no nurse, no police, no administration and no green plan. We ask that you keep the people of Ragged Island in your prayers.
On behalf of the wonderful people of Exumas and Ragged Island who I am grateful to represent. I thank you. Mr. Speaker. -
OPENING REMARKS BY THE HON. PHILLIP “BRAVE “ DAVIS AT THE MONTHLY PRESS CONFERENCE
OPENING REMARKS BY THE HON. PHILLIP “BRAVE “ DAVIS AT THE MONTHLY PRESS CONFERENCE WITH MEMBERS OF THE LOCAL MEDIA ON 6TH MARCH, 2018 AT THE LYNDEN PINDLING CENTRE, FARRINGTON RD, NASSAU, BAHAMAS
(Check Against Delivery)Good morning, Ladies and Gentlemen of the Press.
Good morning to my Parliamentary team and Party OfficialsI thank you for coming and as I am accustomed to doing, I will make a brief opening statement then I will take your questions.
We in Her Majesty’s Official Opposition continue to remain deeply concerned about the capricious actions and behavior of the Prime Minister and his Government. The behavior is not one that I would expect from a stable government and, increasingly, this type of behavior makes the point that the Government is directionless and unfocused and, indeed, is playing games with the well-being of the people of The Bahamas.
This is not the time for game playing or headline grabbing. I believe that governance is a serious business and that we should bring all seriousness and focus to the process in the interest of the Bahamian people who we serve.
Permit me, if you would, to take you back to several key events of the last two weeks. Two weeks ago, on the 14th February, I presented a Notion to the Honourable House of Assembly in which I asked the Hon House to condemn his behavior as Speaker of the House and because of the egregious nature of his conduct and the moral texture of his attacks on members of the Opposition and of a private citizen, I sought the resignation of the Speaker, the Hon Halston Moultrie.
The Speaker subsequently apologized for his behavior but this, in itself, does not remove the obligation for him to resign and to step down so as to restore the dignity of this honourable and ancient chair, the symbol of parliamentary authority.
Ladies and Gentlemen:
The hurtful and derogatory words and scandalous innuendoes will remain a part of the records of the House. We have an ancient Assembly going back to 1729 and it is a shame that in 2018, in this modern and enlightened era we of this generation would allow these words to be a part of the historical record of the House.
Yes! The Speaker has apologised but the Government has been silent. We all are familiar with the phrase – silence gives consent. In short, although the words would have been spoken by the Speaker, ever single member of the Government bench stands condemn and are in fact complicit.
All of which brings me to the matter of OBAN! It must be concluded that the Government has lost credibility over this particular issue.But, here is the connection between my Motion in the House and the OBAN matter.
On the same day as my Motion was being raised in the House, as if to divert attention from this most serious issue, the Prime Minister stood in the House and communicated that the Government would be signing a HOA with OBAN for the construction of a $5bn (USD) oil refinery in Grand Bahama. This was a diversionary tactic to take the heat of the ongoing issue in the House. It was all “smoke and mirrors”. It was intended to change the narrative.
This is among the most confusing and negligent HOA ever entered into by any Government. This Agreement is reckless, shrouded with incompetence, in fraud and dishonesty with a cast of characters straight out of book of fiction. The Prime Minister has not helped his cause by tabling the HOA in the House of Assembly, last Thursday, an Agreement that had a different signature from the one that had been signed in his office with the media present.
The Prime Minister represented on 19 February that the document being signed by the Secretary to the Cabinet with Peter Krieger was in fact the Heads of Agreement between The Bahamas and Oban.He did not say this was a ceremonial, for the cameras event.
The press has indicated that the man signing the document Peter Krieger did not sign his own name but that of Sanpat Dhunna, the President. Mr. Krieger had previously been identified to the public as the President.
The Prime Minister and his Cabinet members were witnesses to the signing. None of them disclosed that this was not the real signing but only ceremonial.
The Prime Minister on Thursday 1 March tabled what he said was the Heads of Agreement between the parties.
The House and the country expected to find the signature of Mr. Krieger on the document.
They did not find that signature but instead that of Mr. Dhunna.
The press has said that Mr. Krieger signed Mr. Dhunna’s signature or name.
The Prime Minister did not disclose to the House that there was a ceremonial signing and therefore possibly two different documents.
The impression was that there was one document and that was the one he produced to the House,
So questions have to be asked:
Will the Prime Minister say whether there are two documents or one?
Is the document signed by Mr. Krieger with Mr. Dhunna’s name the document that was tabled by the Prime Minister in the House?
Is the document tabled in the House then a true, valid agreement?
Whatever the answers to these searching questions, in my view this represents a fundamental dishonesty and government by sleight of hand. The country is entitled to implicitly rely on the word of a Prime Minister. The Prime Minister has an ethical responsibility to tell the truth. He has a legal responsibility not to mislead the House.
In any other developed system of Parliamentary democracy this would be grounds to move a vote of no confidence and censure in the Prime Minister and the Government fro materially misleading the country and the House.
The Prime Minister sought to absolve himself of the responsibility of the decision in this matter by saying its’s the PLP’s fault. This is not about the PLP. The PLP did ot sign the Heads of Agreement . The Prime Minister did. So he must say why he did it. He cannot be seen to say that he knew that the man was involved in nefarious activities and he went ahead any way. He then has adopted the wrong doing.
We now have the spectre of a HOA signed by two different individuals as representative of the investment group. Which one are we to put our faith in? More to the point, why have a Mr. Peter Krieger signed in the presence of everyone and the next week lay on the Table of the House an Agreement with a different signature.
We are advised that the B.E.S.T. Commission, the government’s official policy advisor on the environment and its protection, preservation and sustainability was kept out of the loop on this project. Why is that? B.E.S.T. is reportedly unaware of the location of the proposed project, therefore, was unable to offer any policy advice to the government on this matter. I am sure the Prime Minister has an explanation for his decision to exclude the B.E.S.T. Commission in this environmentally sensitive project.
The critical EIA, the results of which should determine whether a project should be preceded with is not a game changer according to the HOA, Senator Darville has recently expressed grave concerns about the sustainability of the project in that it could destroy very important fresh water lens that supply potable water to much of Grand Bahama. The area in question is the property adjacent to Stat Oil. Even if the EIA confirms this, the project still goes ahead as the government and the developer will “work around” any adverse finding. This is inexplicable.
The government must not only be seen to be protectors of the public interests, but must seem and appear to be advancing the public interest. In the interest of accountability, transparency, honesty and open government as the Prime Minister consistently promised in both local and international forums, he must come clean and clear the air on all of these questionable matters.
These observations and queries beg the questions of what was the consultative process with the Attorney General and his Office? Were they aware of these maneuvers? Are they satisfied as to its legality? The government has much to answer for on this debacle.
Let me go on record as saying that we in the Progressive Liberal Party would like to see any legitimate and sustainable project proceed for the good and benefit of Bahamians everywhere. What is at issue is the Government’s conduct!
What is at issue is the Government’s competence! The Government’s credibility has been lost!
Finally, ladies and gentlemen, we take grave exception to the fact that the Prime Minister would venture abroad to make statements about The Bahamas and the former government being a corrupt. He has on more than one occasion inferred or stated publicly that investors had routinely been asked for monies for projects to be approved.
The Prime Minister has yet to provide proof to support his statement. This is a distraction from the many issues facing the Minnis Government which they are unable to tackle.
The question Minnis has to answer is whose administration these investors were talking about? The record clearly shows that unprecedented foreign direct investments took place under the watch of the PLP and not the FNM. Every major investment and economically impactful investment throughout the Bahamas over the last fifteen years has been under the watch of the Progressive Liberal Party.
Definitely, these investments were not turned off by a PLP administration, so what about the FNM administration.
For example in seeking agreement for the establishment the Arawak Port Development, Brent Symonette was the chair of the group of waterfront property owners negotiating with the Government. Were his and the group’s actions ever castigated as corrupt?
Then there was the BTC Agreement which saw the sale of BTC to a private group – were there any accusation of corruption?
Was the Letter of Intent (LOI) signed by someone who sits in the current Cabinet corrupt?
Was the Lease Agreement between Dr. Hubert Minnis, then Minister of Health for the lease of a building to the Ministry of Health corrupt?
When the Prime Minister talks about “hand held out” by Governments when investors come to do business in The Bahamas which Governments is he talking about? The record shows otherwise.
At the same time, it cannot be lost on the public that in almost one year in Government, the Minnis Government cannot conclude the negotiations for Our Lucaya in Freeport, a matter which the PLP Government left virtually concluded.
At the same time, it cannot be lost on the public that in almost one year in Government, the Minnis Government cannot conclude the negotiations for Our Lucaya in Freeport, a matter which the PLP Government left virtually concluded.
-
CHESTER COOPER REMARKS ON DEBATE OF THE PROCEEDS OF CRIME BILL
CHESTER COOPER MP, Exumas and Ragged Island, PLP Deputy Leader
REMARKS ON DEBATE OF THE PROCEEDS OF CRIME BILL AND THE FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS REPORTING BILL
MARCH 1, 2018
Thank you Mr. Speaker,
I am most grateful to the wonderful people of The Exumas, Exuma Cays and Ragged Island for allowing me to stand on their behalf to contribute to debate on these bills.
Let me first take this opportunity, however, to thank the Hon Minister of Works, the member for Carmichael has been very forthcoming in answering questions and issues put to him by the public and myself in relation to Ragged Island., I must once again remind the government that the people of Ragged Island are still in need and still wait for the complete restoration of government services on the island. I trust the honorable minister of works is giving the situation his full attention and we will get a communication from him on this in short order. I also thank the Minister of Health for the work he is doing behind the scenes to restore medical services to Ragged Island and addressing issues with the mini hospital in Exuma. I sincerely thank him.
Mr. Speaker, I stand to contribute to the debate on two pieces of legislation that can have fundamental impact on the Bahamian people, not just in Financial Services but also across the business community, throughout the spectrum of politics and the Bahamian people at large.
However, let me first say a word on the recently passed Credit Reporting Bill 2017, which was debated and sent to the Upper Chamber without a single word from the opposition, whilst the palace intrigue played out in this place the other day.
G
Had we been allowed to properly debate the legislation, I would have supported it with a few recommendations to strengthen it and protect vulnerable Bahamians.
It is my view that, over time, the bill will bring certain benefits including enhancing the integrity of the financial system, ultimately reducing loan arrears, and these are ideals I support. However, in the short to medium term it is the small man who would feel significant pain as a result of its implementation.
In theory, the Bill will allow banks and other lenders to access data on every individual and corporate borrower in the country, enabling them to assess credit worthiness of applicants, looking at existing obligations and track records with other institutions. There is currently no effective mechanism to track an individual bouncing from one institution to another leaving a trail of unpaid debts behind.
The bill will also access to information from utility companies, and not only impact an individual’s ability to get a loan but might impact their ability to rent an apartment or in some cases used in pre-employment checks and impact their ability to find meaningful employment. Bahamians, particularly those “maxed out” or having experienced default or non-payment, are likely to experience major adjustments.
I trust therefore that as a matter of urgency, the Government, with the support of lenders, will undertake appropriate education of the public beginning immediately so that Bahamians can have time to improve their situations by stopping unnecessary use of credit cards, paying their debts on time and not missing payments.
There is much to be said about personal responsibility, Mr. Speaker.
However, we must also ensure we have appropriate mechanisms in place to protect those, particularly government workers, utilizing salary deductions from many institutions that have and continue to make their fortunes on their backs. What we see in some cases is unconscionable and the Government has a role to protect the vulnerable.
In my career, I have seen Government workers taking home as little as $36 a month.
Mr. Speaker, this is a troubling trend and no doubt leads to more troubling social ills. The question is how do you live as a single mother on $36 a month?
There is also much to be said about improving our national savings rate, which is at a severe level with Bahamians having only a few hundred dollars in their bank accounts on average.
I call on the Government, to lead a national Savings Campaign with support of Banks and Financial Services institutions.
Improving savings is not only good for families but also good for capital markets and national development.
Also, we must ensure, Mr. Speaker that the regulators of this Bill ensure an obligation to confidentiality of people’s information in this system as well as guarding against accessing information retroactive to the implementation of this Bill. No doubt the competent authorities will be on top of this.
I guess it’s a little late now, Mr. Speaker, but I wanted my concerns noted for the record.
On the Financial Transaction Reporting Bill and the Proceeds of Crime Act, Mr. Speaker, let me say at the outset that nobody need guess, I’m going to vote in favor of both pieces of legislation, though they are far from perfect; if indeed there is any such thing as perfect legislation.
I don’t plan to spend my time in this place during this term opposing just for opposing’s sake.
This administration believes that these bills will help curb, corruption, money laundering and terrorism; I am on record as supporting those ideals.
And, if the laws prove ineffective, over-reaching or infringe too deeply on the rights of Bahamians, then when the PLP retakes the government in 2022, we can and will amend them if necessary, with the benefit of practical experience.
But until that time Mr. Speaker, let me urge the government to consider the sound and practical advice of practicing professionals in the industries impacted so as to not risk over-regulation.
We must not simply accept lock, stock and barrel the suggestions of international bodies without localizing them in our best interest as a jurisdiction.
Yes, we must address international concerns as we operate in a global environment, but we can’t do that at the expense of killing businesses and industries that are the lifeblood of thousands of Bahamians.
So, in principle, I support the intent of the legislation.
I believe that the Bill would result in the strengthening of anti-money laundering protocols but I have some concerns.
Let me say in full disclosure that I have personal financial interests in the financial services and insurance industry, as well as the money transfer business that the existing Financial Reporting Transactions legislation already regulates – though I believe that is public knowledge.
At the very least, Mr. Speaker, that should tell you that I know something about what I speak.
I’m not going to go through the entirety of both bills, but I’d like to point out some areas that I think warrant clearer definition and description, or could be problematic.
Mr. Speaker, in the previous version of this legislation, Section 3 states the definition of Financial Institutions and implicitly includes the Property & Casualty / General insurance industry in this definition.
I applaud the government for having the good sense to take this provision out and for realizing, it appears, that it is absolutely essential for meaningful industry consultation when dealing with these wide-ranging pieces of legislation. Financial services providers are generally deeply committed to protecting the credibility and integrity of their industry. We must not over regulate this sector as we arguably did in 2000. Industry knowledge is not easily duplicated. Politicians are not anointed to be “all-knowing” upon their election or appointment to the Senate and Cabinet. I am happy that the attorney general, who was previously adamant that he was leaving general insurance in this definition, has now earnestly consulted and agreed to remove it – although I have not seen the amendment yet.
It is globally accepted that the insurance industry, in particular General Insurance i.e. the property/casualty insurance sector in particular, pose minimal risk of money laundering and terrorism financing to countries’ economies.
It was also of great concern, Mr. Speaker, that a simultaneous increase in administrative costs and premium rates would make general insurance less affordable for Bahamians and legal residents.
It is a relief to the sector not to have another burdensome hoop to jump through and another weight to put on the backs of Bahamian consumers.
So let’s talk about some other areas of the bill.
With regard to the money transfer business, Mr. Speaker. This industry is already tightly regulated by the Central Bank of the Bahamas. Major money transfer companies like Cash N Go already adopt these standards.
As a general point, we must take care not to over-regulate and put up unnecessary barrier for businesses to do business in The Bahamas.
It’s already hard enough.
We put up barriers to commerce that prohibit the smooth functioning of business.
For example, why do I need an NIB card to license a motor vehicle?
Why do I need to pay real property tax for individual directors serving on Boards to get a tax compliance certificate?
Just two examples of government overreach that should be discontinued, Mr. Speaker.
These are the kinds of things that I call vexing business issues. My friend from Free Town often railed on these issues before his anointing to high office. I trust that he will not allow himself to be silenced.
With regard to Clause 6 of the bill, Mr. Speaker, regarding customer due diligence by financial institutions.
We must not, and let me say it again, WE MUST NOT overregulate the financial services sector, especially when it comes to low-risk accounts. We must balance the need for regulation and the need for more ease of doing business to remain a vibrant competitive jurisdiction. Domestic banks are already applying a sledgehammer in some cases where a fly swat will do.
And I know what the side opposite will say. It will say this legislation is desperately needed to come in line with international commitments. But again, Mr. Speaker, we must strike a balance.
We must not fold our tent. We must not just have legislation thrust upon us.
We must respect that we live in a global village with interconnected systems.
However, we must assert our understanding of local context and the realities with respect to the bigger global picture.
If we react to harshly, we run the risk of starving to death, an already diminished financial services sector.
This Parliament must defend our sovereign turf and not accept what is sent to us hook line and sinker.
If G20 countries like the U.S. and Great Britain have standards that are acceptable to them that are simpler than ours, surely they can’t object if we are doing what they are doing.
If it’s good enough for them, how is it not good enough for us?
So, Mr. Speaker, We have to be forward looking.
I support the legislation, but continued attacks on our sovereignty are to be expected. And the government must be prepared to speak up on behalf of small open economies perhaps in unison with our Caricom countries.
Next, they will come after foreign direct investment regime and the tax concessions we offer.
We must defend our territory from the microscopic analysis and demonization of everything they deem to be a threat to their own practices that do not benefit us.
I note in many of the discussions in relation to the IMF that the Government appears to be adopting their suggestions as their Government’s policy. This is not appropriate in my view. I heard the Hon Minister of Foreign Affairs, the member for North Abaco talk about corruption. Transparency International ranked the Bahamas 28th in 2017 down from 71st in 2015 and 61st in 2016. So there was significant improvement on that measure. We are ranked the least corrupt in the Caribbean. No we are not perfect, but we must stop talking down our country – stop talking down our Economy – especially on the international stage.
Let me just pause here since we’re on foreign direct investment.
Mr. Speaker, I asked at a recent public gathering outside this place that was nationally televised, about this deal that the government has announced with Oban Energies. Now, Mr. Speaker, the other side seems to be saying that since the last administration, which they try to brand as irredeemably corrupt, approved a deal in principle with Oban Energies with the caveat that it gets regulatory approval from numerous government agencies, that this makes it okay for the current administration to sign a heads of agreement with this company.
I said at that meeting that the government needs to show me the money of this deal. And yet, nobody has yet shown me the money. They’ve shown me empty talk. They’ve shown me an investor admitting that they don’t have the money yet and only the heads of agreement will release this money, which is just incredible. But I have yet to see this $5.5 billion that’s supposed to go in the ground on Grand Bahama.
On top of that, Mr. Speaker, in the context of the bills we’re talking about today – the Financial Transactions and Reporting Act and the Proceeds of Crime Act, where does this Oban Energies deal fit in with the government’s soapbox stance on due diligence, anti-corruption, accountability and transparency? I trust that the company, its Principals and Associates will past the fit and proper thresholds and due diligence guidelines laid out in these Bills.
The timing of this debate is ironic.
But God is a Just God.
I am pro-business and pro investment.
We need FDI to develop our country in an orderly way and create opportunities, but not at the cost of our reputation.
I have many more questions but I will leave it there for now.
Penalties
Getting back to the bill. The penalties for certain infractions under this bill also seem to be quite high, Mr. Speaker.
For example, if a financial institution opens up one single account without KYC, it is subject to a fine of up to $1 million dollars.
An individual can be fined up to $500,000 for a similar offence and have the unintended consequence of potentially shuttering a financial institution.
I’m not so sure potential insolvency should be the remedy for a possible violation of this legislation.
The fines under the existing legislation are high but not unreasonable. Perhaps these should be maintained.
Governance Issues
Mr. Speaker, the definition of politically exposed person (PEPs) also seems extremely broad. The bill should clarify whether directors of state-owned corporations qualify as PEPs. The definitions on page 9 of “senior management” of state-owned corporations, as PEPs seem to suggest this is so.
It is my view that every individual serving on a Government Board will be a PEP under this legislation. I am certain that they didn’t sign on for that and you will see some resignations effective immediately on implementation of this Bill!
These directors would populate an already small pool of people serving in this capacity. The government must take care not to reduce the pool of persons willing to serve in these positions.
The government should also address the very tribal nature of such appointments, keeping in mind that all Bahamians, PLPs, FNMs and everything in between must be utilized to move the nation forward. I would in fact recommend that when a new Government comes in that they consider leaving a few of the competent Directors of the previous Boards in place for continuity especially in highly technical businesses like BPL and Bank of the Bahamas for example. The pool of suitable Directors is decidedly small and we must use the best and brightest in our country to advance our institutions. The political cleansing that we see after a change in Government is not fitting of a modern progressive society and I call for more political maturity in this regard.
The broad definition and interpretation of PEPs is troubling. Whilst I have signed on to offer for public office I did not ask permission of my 12 siblings and Associates who would also be captured in the net. Again we must not diminish the already small pool of persons committed and qualified to offer to serve.
So, Mr. Speaker, we must take care not to become further uncompetitive with such sweeping changes and the government must fully lean on its practicing professional to guard against measures increasing the cost of doing business and reducing the desirability of the jurisdiction.
.
Mr. Speaker, wrapping up my remarks on this legislation, we have to guard against making it more difficult to do business and making The Bahamas less competitive.
It is already more onerous to open a bank account in The Bahamas than the U.S. Will these measures truly benefit the ease of doing business?
I would find it hard to swallow that the FATF, CATF and OECD believes that the standard the USA uses is not sufficient for The Bahamas.
I am told that a Bahamian can walk into a bank off the street in Florida and leave in 15 minutes with a bank account, with cheques and a debit card. Whilst this process can already take weeks in the Bahamas for the same individual.
U.S. banks in states like Delaware, Wyoming, Nevada and Oregon are already “capturing” much of our traditional financial services business with proverbial onshore financial centers raiding the business of offshore financial centers.
We must not shoot ourselves in the foot by going further than the international standard and undermine efforts aimed at making The Bahamas more competitive as an International Financial Center. We only need consider how we lost the captive insurance market, and how Bermuda continues to benefit from that move. There must be balance.
Proceeds of Crime Bill
With regard to Proceeds of Crime Bill, Mr. Speaker, I do have one major concern.
Looking at Section V of the bill, Mr. Speaker, it speaks to the seizure of assets without a conviction.
Mr. Speaker, it says: The Court, on an application by the enforcement authority, shall grant a civil forfeiture order in respect of property within the jurisdiction of The Bahamas where it finds, on a balance of probabilities, that such property is proceeds of criminal conduct, an instrumentality or terrorist property.
There is a provision where a confiscation order may be had if a person is charged. Mr. Speaker, I implore the government to seriously look into whether this section can stand up to constitutional scrutiny. The threshold for charging someone is not very high, Mr. Speaker. We should not, in our haste, be so quick to leave behind the basic tenet of law that a person is presumed innocent until guilt is proven.
The provisions in this section could potentially backfire cause significant hardship if we get it wrong and lead to costly lawsuits against the government, for which the Bahamian people will have to ultimately foot the bill. We must take care that this and other provisions of the Bill do not infringe on the constitutional rights of Bahamians.
In closing, Mr. Speaker, I support these two pieces of legislation but I do hope the governing side will consider the concerns I have raised, which I believe echo those of stakeholders who will ultimately be affected. I trust that in the spirit of political maturity they would consider my interventions and review my suggestions for amendments.
On behalf of the people of the Exumas and Ragged Island, I thank you.
-
Remarks by Chester Cooper
REMARKS AT PLP RALLY, CHESTER COOPER, EXUMAS AND RAGGED ISLAND MP, PLP DEPUTY LEADER
February 15, 2018
It’s incredible to be here tonight to see so many PLPs who will stand up for what is right!
I hope that today, in the aftermath of what went down in the House of Assembly yesterday, Bahamians of political persuasions can see that democracy and due process are under assault in this country.
The four members of the opposition went to Parliament in attempt to do something extremely straightforward – have the speaker of the House of Assembly removed for his complete lack of impartiality and flagrant abuse of the rules of the House.
We followed the proper procedure; we sat out the suspension handed down by the speaker, even though we obviously disagreed with his ruling.
We put the motion on the agenda and waited patiently while the prime minister tried to steal the attention away by talking about a heads of agreement signing that they plan to do next week. I shall return to this point later.
And even still, so undemocratic is this lot, so petty, that they couldn’t even see fit to contribute to the motion that the leader had moved.
Abusing their power yet again, they amended the motion in order to make it look better for the speaker, who had disgraced himself.
They were so desperate to control the narrative, to assert their control, that they even tried to shut down one of their own – the member for Pineridge, Fredrick McAlpine.
Even McAlpine, who took the PLP to war on the campaign trail, suggested that they were perhaps being unchristian.
He told them, after he had to create a little bit of a fuss, that they should be careful not to be seen to be bullying the opposition, or even their members on the back bench.
He told them that what they did looks bad and it’s a reversal of their promise to have a different kind of governance, a different kind of politics.
Well, maybe McAlpine is just realizing it, but I could have told him that the promises of the Minnis-led FNM are often not worth the paper they’re printed on.
You can ask the people of Ragged Island about that. And I’ll talk more about that in a little bit.
But what kind of insecure leadership seeks to change a motion in the middle of the debate just to make themselves look good?
Like I said, it’s petty.
So, our motion was changed and they succeeded in keeping the speaker in the chair.
But what was so shameful about the entire day is that the speaker apologized when he went back in the chair.
He was contrite and remorseful, even though the damage was already done.
At least he had the decency to apologize for attacking the leader and his wife, and Maurice Tynes and spewing personal, hateful nonsense from the chair and bringing the office to all-time low.
My question is, where were the other apologies?
Where were the apologies from these respected men and women who sat there listening to the speaker last Wednesday then praised him for his great moral character?
Where were the apologies from the men who sat there while the member for MICAL talked about when it was OK to beat or manhandle a woman?
Where were the apologies or the condemnation from those members of Parliament who are divorced or have foreign-born wives?
Where were the apologies to their constituents for wasting their time last Wednesday and not dealing with the people’s business?
It has to be questioned if the FNM has any respect for democracy at all
And why was all that we heard about what the PLP did before?
Why was it that not one of them, outside of McAlpine, would actually speak to what the speaker did?
They were probably too embarrassed or frightened of the repercussions from stepping out of line.
Clearly, toeing the party line is more important to them than honesty.
Sometimes a little courage is just what the doctor ordered.
After I became the MP for the Exumas and Ragged Island, I was invited to speak to an arm of the party and I pulled no punches in explaining what I thought were the reasons behind our election loss. And the party still embraced me. Nobody came for my head. There were some who some who agreed and some who disagreed. We all agreed to examine the election results and move forward in strength.
That is what democracy looks like. Look to the PLP if you want an idea of how a party should function in and out of office.
In any event, the speaker remains in the chair and we are constrained to operate under his oversight.
However, I want him to know, and I want the government to know, that we’ll be watching like a hawk and we’ll be jealously protecting our rights and the rights of our constituents.
We won’t go quietly into the darkness of undemocratic rule. We’ve fought too hard and too long to bow before a party that appears to have little regard for the rights of the minority.
But we’ll use every available means of recourse we have to hold this speaker in check and to make sure the minority is heard until we become the majority again.
You know it’s important for PLPs to come together in times like these.
Times like these when we see that our government is perfectly willing to trample on democracy.
Times like these when we see that the prime minister is satisfied to send his minions to his dirty work and undermine institutions that have stood for hundreds of years.
This is the time that we must stand and galvanize our base and speak truth to power.
We threw a blow for democracy yesterday and we must continue to do so.
I urge you PLPs, stay battle ready!
National Events
I’m going to make way for the leader here in a little bit, but I just wanted to touch on one or two things happening on the national scene at the moment.
First, let’s talk about this $4 billion deal with Oban Energies for the oil refinery terminal in Freeport that the prime minister was so quick to tout yesterday.
Let’s acknowledge something – that was a deal, I understand, that was being looked at for quite some time. The former administration looked at that not too long before the last election.
Now, I hear the prime minister saying this deal was approved in December 2016.
But I don’t know about that. He’ll have to table whatever he claims on that in the House for the nation to see before I believe that.
I don’t really know who this company is or what they’ve been promised by this administration. So, you’ll forgive me if I don’t celebrate with them right now.
What I find curious about this FNM government, especially when it comes to Grand Bahama, is how much they lean on the PLP.
As much as they castigate the PLP, as much as they say how bad the PLP was, it appears that the PLP continues to save the bacon of this administration time and time again.
I had a great time in East GB the other day, and they can certainly use the activity. I hope it’s a real deal. Right now we have too little details about this Oban Energies deal to tell what’s what. And I have a question – is there funding in place for the deal? I am not prepared to accept their word for it. I am a man of business. I want them to SHOW ME THE MONEY.
And I got one more question for them with regard to this $4 billion deal. What is the track record of this business in this environmentally sensitive industry? I googled it and it looks like a relatively new company to me?
Just two questions for now, eh? But I have this in my sights. Shouldn’t be too hard to give the Bahamian people some answers.
Now, maybe it’s real. Time will tell. But the timing right now seems a little desperate to me.
Speaking of leaning on the PLP to pull their fat out of the fire, this is certainly the case with the buyer of the Grand Lucayan, who made a sensible deal for the benefit of Grand Bahama before the last election, only to have the new Cabinet reject the buyer just because the deal was a PLP deal.
Now, they’re back at the table with the same buyer, and all they have to show for their procrastination is the suffering of the people of Grand Bahama. No wonder McAlpine gone rogue on them.
It was reckless and irresponsible, and hopefully now that they know better, they’ll do better.
I’ve been to West Grand Bahama too and the people there are in desperate need of jobs and economic activity.
I ask this Gov’t again to don’t just throw out empty talk to string our people along, show us the detail. I am a man of business they must SHOW ME THE MONEY!
I also want to take this opportunity to ask this government where in the current budget is this $90 million they say they won’t affect government borrowing this year.
I checked the budget book again, you know. And I still don’t see it.
The IDB said this money was approved by the organization under the last administration. But the last administration never went to Parliament to approve that borrowing because VAT was on the right track.
Now they’re borrowing again, after promising that, that astronomical deficit they blamed on the PLP was the last of it for this fiscal year.
I want the minister of finance to know that we’re watching you.
And when you bring that resolution to Parliament, be prepared to answer some questions.
First they say it won’t increase the amount borrowed. Now they say, well, it’s gonna increase the amount we borrowing but we won’t draw it down until next budget year.
Well, that minister has the tendency to change his story. So we will see what they say next.
Forgive me for being sceptical about everything they say. But once bitten, twice shy.
For instance, the government keeps telling me that they’re working on a master plan for Ragged Island and this “green city”.
They keep telling me be patient, don’t talk about it, I should be shamed for questioning them.
They keep telling me Tesla and Google and Amazon, and the Carbon War Room, or whoever, is working on a plan for the island. They have sexy talks, you know. That’s how they won the election.
And I keep asking them what that has to do with fully restoring government services and rebuilding buildings on the island.
I have to wait for Tesla to figure out how to construct a school for fewer than 50 students? Or send a nurse, or a police officer?
I have to wait for an international design firm to put an administration building on an island a few square miles in area?
Let’s be serious.
I’m going to keep advocating for Ragged Island. And I’m going to keep advocating until we see results.
A green city sounds great, but let’s deal with the immediate need right in front of us right now.
In closing, I want you all to be encouraged. Know that you have a band of fighters in the House of Assembly and those of you who believe in the PLP, can rest assured we’ll continue to hold their feet to the fire and we won’t let up. Your four by one relay team will continue to bring home the Gold.
PLP!!!….
-
Address by Hon. Philip “Brave” Davis
Address by
Hon. Philip “Brave” Davis, Q.C., M.P.
Leader of the Official Opposition
Leader of the Progressive Liberal Party
On the Occasion of
A Public MeetingThursday, 15th February 2018, 7:00 p.m.
Sir Lynden Pindling House
Mount Moriah Constituency
Nassau, N.P., The BahamasSalutations:
• To My Parliamentary Colleagues
• Party Chairman
• Party Officers and members
PLPs! Good Evening!If you were looking for a house and someone took you to a house with a weak foundation, rotten beams, and a sagging roof, would you be inclined to buy it and make it your home? Probably not.
Even a fresh coat of paint would not change the fact that the house is not structurally sound.
Sooner or later, it will likely collapse.
PLPs!
The Speaker has put on a new coat! He has apologised and, if I am to go to God to ask forgiveness for anything, I must forgive him.
So, I forgive him, but I have to walk circumspect in that Place because under that fresh coat remains the weak foundation, rotten beams, and sagging roof.
While there is forgiveness, the Speaker must now sit down to his banquet of consequences because notwithstanding the fact that the Government has had its way, we brought our case to the High Court of Parliament, and on every single count, he was found GUILTY, GUILTY, GUILTY!
On Count One
A statement made to the House on 7 February in response to we do not know what;What is your Verdict?
On Count Two
The unlawful, wrongful, capricious, arbitrary and disproportionate suspension of the Member of Parliament for Englerston on 31 January….What is your Verdict?
On Count Three
The wilful, malicious and personal attacks on private citizens in his statement of 7 February in the HouseWhat is your Verdict?
On Count Four
Attacking the staff of the House of AssemblyWhat is your Verdict?
On Count Five
Disgracing the role and reputation of the Office of The Speaker of the House
What is your Verdict?
On every count Speaker Halson Moultrie has been found guilty on all counts in the court of Public Opinion.
So, we forgive him because he has asked for it, but we and the majority of right thinking Bahamians are perplexed and appalled by the fact that the governing members, save and except for McAlpine (who was not brave enough to go all the way) said that the Speaker was right in his actions.
Even the Speaker came along and said that he was wrong. Do those men have a moral compass!?
They made the debate about Hanna Martin when the issue was the Speaker’s behavior. Hanna Martin had already been sanctioned, even if unjustly. Her matter was not before the House. It was the Speaker, who has been found GUILTY! GUILTY! GUILTY!
PLPs
The difference between an apology and seeking forgiveness is profound and not to be taken for granted.
The Minnis regime is embarrassed by these developments. They were left confused. They silenced their members and across the front bench the face of defeat was clear!
They proved to the country that they are ill prepared, are unequipped, and lack focus on how to run the country.
The Minnis Government proved to the country that they are not prepared to uphold what is right, what is decent, what is just and fair for our people!
Just look at what happened. Speaker after Speaker on the side opposite were unable to refute any of the charges placed at the feet of the Speaker.
And what was worse was the fact that all of the Ministers like Brent Symonette, Dinosio D’Aguilar, and his friend of many years – Jeffery Lloyd all sat in silence after the charges were read.
….Unable and powerless to defend the claims brought against the Speaker.
What is worse that as you would have heard some seven FNM MPs, including the Member for Pineridge Fredrick McAlpine all left the Parliament and failed to support the government in a vote against the Speaker.
You know, victimization is real under the Minnis Government. And political victimization is indeed the feature deep inside the governing Party.
Look how they treated their own Mr. McAlpine yesterday. He came to speak for his constituents in Pineridge but the Government decided they wanted to stop him from speaking!
Why would they not want Pineridge voice heard?
Why is the Minnis Government seeking to silence the people sent to Parliament to speak for them?
I told you the other night that democracy in the Bahamas in under threat!
Let me get back to the Speaker, who has embarrassed the country.
You know, everywhere I go in this country, I am being told to continue to stand up against this FNM Government.
Yesterday, we placed on the record that the Speaker has disgraced the Parliament! He has crushed democracy, and, he has insulted the hardworking staff of the House.
His action represents much of disorder we saw yesterday even during the debate where the Government side did not even know how to amend the motion!
In the end it must be said that Prime Minister Dr. Hubert Minnis must learn how to lead!
And I hear they keep saying these things like; we need to get on with the People’s Business.Parliament has been adjourned for next week Wednesday. And let’s watch and see what their business will be next week.
Oh, and I hear the Prime Minister talk about how he will be signing agreements. Ask him for me if he intends to lay these agreements on the table of the House of Assembly.
Remember how they love to describe themselves as the open and transparent government! Bring the Agreements to Parliament so all the people could see what deal you cut for the country!
That’s the first thing I wanted to deal with tonight.
Talking about the Prime Minister, this week Minnis has shown how poorly he governs our country.
This week a group of farmers from around the country showed up at the office of the Prime Minister for a meeting. The meeting I am told was to begin at 3:30 PM and confirmed by his office.
They wanted just to speak with their Prime Minister. But guess what? They were denied an opportunity to meet they leader.
I am advised after those farmers were ordered out of the building the PM fled through the backdoor ducking Bahamians!
What does all this mean?
Here is a man who serves in one of the most powerful offices in the nation. An office to which the holder is to defend Bahamians. A job, which requires one to support Bahamians. A job that requires one to protect the interest of workers, and empower all citizens.
But look at the disgrace now coming from the office of the Prime Minister?
We have a man occupying that office, who I am now convinced is failing to protect Bahamians!
A man who goes on the world stage and call Bahamians “corrupt”! Say he having an “Anti-corruption investment trips”
A Prime Minister who says nothing when a guest to the Bahamas calls Bahamians “dumb” and “corrupt” in the case of a Royal Bank employee!
We have a Prime Minister who cannot protect democracy in Parliament!
And these days rather than running to the assistance of Bahamians, is running from Bahamians!
Does that look like a leader to you?
Is this the kind of leadership Bahamians deserve?
Do you believe Hubert Minnis is anyway prepared or ready for the job?
Last week, while Hubert Minnis and the FNM were busy shutting down the voices of the opposition in Parliament, the Minister for Finance Peter Turnquest rose to his feet to seek approval of the Parliament to borrow 90 million dollars.
He – just like his boss – is running from people these days. He the one Minnis appointed to take on that IMF advice to downsize the public service and fire Bahamians.
Now I want you to examine what this is we have operating in Ministry of Finance.
Last year June, Turnquest came to the Parliament to borrow 722 million dollars in what he claimed to defy expenses for the ensuing year. The Central Bank issued said that the debt of the Bahamas was substantially less than that.
But a few months later after carrying out another round of firings at Urban Renewal, NIB, NHI, The Gaming Board, and at The Inland Revenue, this same Peter Turnquest came back to the Parliament to seek another loan for 800 million dollars.
What are they doing with all that money?!
Now, I am no accountant nor do I profess to be, but someone needs to explain to me why we in the Bahamas in these tough times do we need to borrow all that money while we firing Bahamians?
You see any major developments being carried out by the Minnis Government?
You see them opening any new agency to hire Bahamians?
You see them attracting any new investment like Bahamar or Atlantis?
Meanwhile, in their haste to fire Bahamians the results are taking a toll on this economy.
According to the Minister his department has delivered reduced revenue, more unemployment and a sense of “JOBLESSNESS” all across the country! Those are Turnquest’s results these past nine months.
People are going home and small businesses – the lifeblood of this economy – are closing their doors by the day under this Minns-led Government.
The FNM has no plan!
And I submit, they never had a plan!
They plagiarized material out of a Caribbean Island election manifesto, and now that it is time to govern they are visionless!
Bankrupt of ideas to deal with the People’s business!
They have no plan to uphold democracy.
No plan to create employment.
No plan to attract investment …and no plan to defend and protect Bahamians!
They have no real plan for the recovery of Grand Bahama!
No Real Buyer as promised on the campaign trail for Bahamar!
No delivery on the promised tax-free zone for inner city communities. And no strategy to create jobs in this economy.
Speaking about protecting Bahamians, you would recall it was your PLP Government, which began the work to step in to assist homeowners through a Mortgage Relief Plan.
Our goal in this was to keep Bahamians in their homes while arrangements were being met to have the loans restructured with the banks.
Just this past December, I am advised that the Financial Secretary met with staff upon the instruction of his bosses, to have the Mortgage Relief Department shutdown and all of the workers sent home.
My team on the ground have advised me that today the mortgage crisis is once again setting in and banks are moving in to take homes.
I call on the Minnis Government to step in and save these mortgages with the same energy he has to fire workers.
PLPs!
As I bid you good evening I want to be reminded of something.
We have pledged to be a party that has “dedicated itself to the service of all Bahamians, not a privileged few.”
We are the Party that has signed up to fight for the rights of workers.
Bahamians who have worked hard, who have pushed hard to get ahead to build a better country. We all have signed up to build a better nation one that will shine brighter in a world ripe with opportunity for our place in it.
Freedom, Justice, and Equality are no strangers to our chorus. But they are the threads that has woven the knit of our great organization.
And so I ask you are you ready to move this work forward?
Are you ready PLP? Let me hear you!
If you are prepared and ready then know that there is plenty work that lies ahead, and yes, our party needs you.
Our Branches need your energy!
Sign up and be counted as that voice for all our people.
Join us as our finest days and greatest achievements are still yet to come. The time is NOW!
PLP! PLP! PLP!
THANK YOU!
And May God Bless the Commonwealth of The Bahamas! -
Statement from Fred Smith
‘Minnis Is The New Mitchell And He Is A Menace To The Rule Of Law!’
By Fred Smith QC
THE Bahamas is now being thrown from the frying pan into the fire.
What makes this worse than under the PLP administration is that Prime Minister Minnis keeps talking about respecting law and order and the rule of law.
What he and his cabinet intentionally fail to understand is that the immigration policy enforcement is so illegal.
All due process has been thrown out of the window!
How does “The Government” or “the Immigration Department”, or the “Immigration Officer” know someone is an “illegal”?
On what legal basis can the government justify falsely imprisoning and calling it “detention” as if that’s supposed to make it okay?
It is only the court that is the judge and jury under our constitution, not an immigration officer nor the director of immigration, nor the government!
I thought this FNM administration as promised by the Prime Minister would respect the rule of law as he pledged when he took his oath of office at Government House.
I was there; I watched; I listened; I had hope!
Respecting the rule of law means taking people who are suspected of being “illegal” before a court, charging them and letting the judicial system deal with their guilt or innocence.
Once proven guilty, then the government can execute the judgment.
Whether it is to deport, or to imprison in accordance with the sentence imposed by a judicial authority.
For the last five years and now continuing under the FNM government, they have failed to abide by the provisions of the Education Act, Criminal Procedure Code, the Constitution, or the Immigration Act.
It is the government that is acting completely outside of law and order.
No wonder crime is rampant in this country when there is so much lawlessness at the highest level of governance.
And, if the government is really interested in stopping corruption at the Immigration Department and at the Carmichael Concentration Camp, then deal with people in accordance with the law, not in accordance with some illegal policies of the Immigration Department.
If the Prime Minister, cabinet ministers, Director of Immigration ,etc. cannot see and understand everything they have been doing is completely lawless, illegal and an abuse of the rule of law then they are being intentionally blind.
They are pandering to a xenophobic public.
They don’t see that huge human resources are being wasted and squandered; the taxpayers’ money being squandered in these raids, detentions and deportations instead of making thousands of people positive, contributing members of our society.
That is why I say the Bahamas has now been thrown from the frying pan into the fire.
Minnis is the New Mitchell and he is a Menace to The Rule of Law!
I say this because those in power now know better!
They have been educated.
I have advised them.
I have spoken with them.
I have explained it to them.
Judges have done the same thing… again and again and again!
The international community has.
They were part of the Opposition opposing this kind of conduct and they pledged themselves to the rule of law.
They are being intentionally criminally illegal in their application of the immigration laws and the Education Act.
This is a disgrace and Rights Bahamas intends to fight this as hard as possible.
I wish I could be expending my energies in constructive, positive, uplifting ways instead of having to fight the evil policies of this FNM government yet again for another five years.
Similarly with the spy Bill.
It is worse than the PLP spy Bill.
What could possibly possess this FNM administration to come to the Bahamian public and then take away their right to privacy so abusively.
Pure hypocrisy on the part of the FNM.
And why do we need a spy agency?
This Government doesn’t even have any money to pay the national debt; education; hospital; teacher salaries; and Freeport continues to deteriorate!
There are so many socially uplifting, culturally developmental, economically expanding and environmentally profound policies that can be adopted by the government.
What the government needs to do instead of threatening the alleged “illegals” – and let us remember that everyone is presumed innocent until proven guilty – is to spend time and energy and resources in regularizing people who have been here for decades; who have been born here; who have citizenship rights; who have residency rights!
Then the government should start to legally arrest, take before the courts and prosecute both alleged illegals and employers!
This can be done in a humane, systematic, orderly, cost effective and legal way.
What is the public policy sense in going on an illegal rage and rampage of illegal behaviour and to continue breaking law and order and to continue to disrespect the rule?
It is shocking how an administration that has been given a unique mandate to dramatically change the Bahamas for the better is so lackluster, visionless and barren of ideas they should continue to follow in the steps of the PLP.
Does the FNM really have nothing positive to contribute to the development of good governance in the Bahamas?
What happened to the Freedom of Information Act?
What happened to resurrecting the Grand Bahama economy?
With this announcement, by the Prime Minister nonetheless, the FNM administration has shown itself to be nothing more than a PLP Fred Mitchell copycat!
I urge the government to rethink this declaration of war against the rule of law!
Stop, consult with public and civil society on the immigration issues, and develop a constructive and positive plan.
I am sickened by this approach.
It is a human rights disgrace.
And yes it was a wonderful humanitarian gesture for the Prime Minister to open the arms of the Bahamas to assist our neighbours in Dominica, but not at the expense of abusing children born in the Bahamas to their own right to education!
Especially, how can the government in good conscience, invite, with open arms, children from Dominica into our public schools, at the Bahamian taxpayers expense, when children born in the Bahamas can’t even go to public school because of the illegal immigration and Ministry of Education policies?
I am so so disappointed, discouraged and exhausted by this lackluster, visionless and unthinking FNM administration which is just following in the footsteps of illegal PLP policies! -
Contribution by Senator Dr. Michael Darville
Senator, The Honorable Dr. Michael R. Darville
Contribution to the Speech from the Throne
Honourable Senate of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas
Thursday, October 12th, 2017
Madame President, it is indeed an honor and a privilege to once again rise in this Honorable chamber to not only carry the banner of the progressive liberal party, but on behalf of the people of our nation the residents of Grand Bahama and to make my contribution to this resolution to thank her Excellency the governor general for her most gracious speech from the Throne. We all know the important role her excellency played in shaping the history of the modern Bahamas, but as the former minister for Grand Bahama I had the opportunity to work closely with her excellency in the after math of hurricane Mathew. She demonstrated love and compassion for the people of Grand Bahama and played an intricate role in sensitizing the business community it the much fund raising efforts that followed.
Therefore on behalf of all the residence on she touched during their darkest moments I wish to thank express our gratitude and thanks.
Madam President before getting into my substantive contribution with your leave, I would like to take this opportunity to once again thank the residents of Pineridge for their support, as well as the many dedicated civil servants, and professionals from the private sector, who worked closely with the government in my capacity as the former Minister for Grand Bahama.
You know what madam president as bad as people talk about civil servants I was pleasantly surprised coming from the private sector to find many hard working public officers who were eager to work closely with the people’s agenda to bring about positive charge in the system.
I would also like to take this opportunity to send get well wishes to my good friend Stalwart councilor Mable Gibson, who unfortunately was in a serious traffic accident a few days ago in Freeport; and had to be airlifted to the Princess Margaret Hospital for further medical care. We are all praying for the family and for her speedy recovery and finally I extend our deepest condolences to the family of the late Ken “Motorboat” Ferguson; a cultural icon in our community and former officer in Charge of the Grand Bahama Road Traffic Department ; as well as the family of the late Jack Parker, Grand Bahama’s very own native Cowboy. May their souls rest in peace!
Madame President, after being grossly neglected by the Ingraham administration, from 2007-2012, the people of Grand Bahama cried out for focused and immediate attention. Our administration immediately implemented a comprehensive strategy that would improve health and educational infrastructure, enhance and simultaneously grow our tourism and industrial sector, train Grand Bahamians, and as a result, create employment and entrepreneurial opportunities for all.
Madame President, although Hurricane Mathew hindered our momentum , it did not stop our plans for diversifying the economy of Grand Bahama, through the injecting of hard to find capital into the island’s economy, and investing in the training, employment of our young people. Evidence based research lead the way for the drafting of our 2030 charter of governance that was presented to the people of this country, outlining what we would implement from day one if given a second term in office. Our plan going forward was to continue with well funded capital works projects, the launch of our aggressive medical tourism strategy, focus our attention on attracting second home owners back to Grand Bahama, further expansion of our industrial sector and our world class ship care facility, capitalize on the new opportunities in the maritime industry and work with our private sector partners to establish a new air, sea break bulk logistic center. All these initiatives would have proved to be instrumental in the progressive liberal party’s strategic plan for economic reform over the next 15 years. Among the many capital works projects and infrastructural upgrades initiated by the Progressive Liberal Party were the reconstruction of a new state of the art clinic in West Grand Bahama as part of our plan to improve medical outcomes for the residents in West End and help in the sale of the Ginn property ( this state of the art facility was commissioned last week and clearly demonstrating that the foundation was already being laid ), then there was the renovation and expansion of the High Rock Clinic, the construction of the new fire station on Settler’s Way (which to my understanding was completed months ago but still not operational ), the construction of the Fishing Hole Road Bridge, the construction of the new junior high school in Holmes Rock, the construction of a new government complex in Eight Mile Rock, and the construction of the Smith’s Point Sea Wall. All these and other capital works projects were designed to improve the quality of live for the residents and prime our local economy.
Madam President, contracts were also awarded for renovations to the Rand Memorial Hospital, which included the relocation of the kitchen cafeteria facilities from the middle of the medical and surgical wards to the new site, which proved to be necessary for creating new critical bed space to compensate the current shortages that exist at the Rand Memorial Hospital and the construction of a new sixty two thousand (62,000) square foot Freeport Community Clinic, on a new green field site off East Sunrise Highway.
Madame President, under our watch, the Grand Bahama Shipyard Employment Program was created, which was designed to train and employ six hundred (600), young Bahamians; fifty (50) every three (3) months at that facility. Up to May, 2017, approximately two hundred (200) young Grand Bahamians were certified and employed at the facility just prior to us leaving office. It is my understanding, however, that since then, no additional persons were hired and some 70 plus persons were terminated. I have spoken to at least twenty of these workers who lost their jobs in the last few months. The minister of state on his feet yesterday made mention to the labour issues with an independent contractor at the ship yard which was correct, but today I am speaking about the program between the government and the Grand Bahama ship Yard.
I was also informed from reliable sources that no new apprentices were hired as customary in July 2017. My question to the government is what is happening with this state of the art program put in place by our administration and what will happen to the 40 young men and women that were hired last year.
Madam President while in office we also established the innovative Earn While You Learn Program in conjunction with public hospital authority, which was designed to train and employ young Bahamians in the areas of pre allied health, in order to fill the gaps at the mini hospital in Abaco and the nine primary healthcare facilities on Grand Bahama prior to the implementation of National Health Insurance. We also established the National Training Agency, reestablished the Trained Clinical Nursing Program and revamped the Fresh Start Program in conjuction with the private sector; all designed to provide training and employment opportunities for our young people! As a result of our collaborate effort our administration was able to reduce the employment rate from about 19.4% in 2012 when we came to office to just over 10% prior to leaving office even in tough economic times.
Madame President, under our watch, the tourism product on Grand Bahama was on the rebound. Prior to October, 2016, we had an active cruise ship market that was growing, and an increased number of flights that were bringing large numbers of stop over visitors to our shores. We attracted many international events and conferences, held two successful Bahamas Junkanoo Carnival Kickoff celebrations that proved to have an economic multiplier effect on our local economy, and had advanced plans to fill our island’s calendar with more offerings to showcase our unique Bahamian culture to the world.
Additionally, Madame President, prior to the 2017 general elections, we were in the advance stages of negotiating the sale of the hotels and casino on the Lucayan Strip, we signed the heads of agreement with Carnival Cruise line, after spending over one year negotiating with the Hutcheson Group of companies to lift their exclusivity of ports on the island of Grand that was put in place by the Free National Movement. These successful complex negotiations make way for the signing of the heads of agreements between the Hutcherson, carnival cruise lines and the government to construct a new cruise port in East Grand Bahama. We are asking the government to please be transparent and notify the Bahamian people what is happening with the new port.
Madame President, the history books would reflect that despite the sluggish global economy, and the difficulties we faced to grow the local economy in tough times, there is no question that the Progressive Liberal Party left the island of Grand Bahama and our country better than we meet it in 2012. Grand Bahama was in a recovery mode; poised for growth, and ready to make a positive economic comeback; even in the aftermath of Hurricane Matthew but the free national movement went on a five month vacation.
Madam President, as an administration we invested in the people and we laid a solid foundation to build upon. Unfortunately, Madame President, our agenda came to a grinding halt on May 10th, 2017, when the Bahamian people spoke loud and clear, and rejected us at the polls.
Madame President, the Free National Movement, in its political campaign, indicated to the Bahamian people that they had a master plan to turn Grand Bahama around and were ready to govern on day one. In the Speech from the Throne, Her Excellency articulated, very eloquently and I quote, that this administration would “launch the rebound of the island of Grand Bahama, in accordance with the template of a master strategic plan designed for Grand Bahama. Accordingly, the government will establish a tourism signature identity in the marketplace for the island of Grand Bahama.” I wish to ask the minister of State for Grand Bahama what is this so called template that your administration is using and for the sake of transparency please outline some of the short term strategies of this plan. Is it the same template that has been used over the past two decades, which took Grand Bahama on a roller coaster ride from boom to bust?
Madame President, “launching the rebound of Grand Bahama” and “having a master plan for Grand Bahama” as noted in the speech from the throne looks good on paper! And sounds good but all of us who have been around understand the political game of hide and seek and know the devil is in the details. However, the people of Grand Bahama are tired of the games and calling on this so called peoples government to be transparent and give us the details to your master plan, not the shake tank plan for selecting 10 micro enterprises a year for the next three years. Please explain why the short term strategies of your plan have not been implemented after five months in office in order to stop the down would spiral!
Madame President, I would venture to say that the majority of Grand Bahamians are indeed trying to determine where are the five Members of Parliament, one of which is the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance, two other cabinet ministers are doing other that dressing up and riding around in aircondoo while the people of Grand Bahama continue to suffer. What is this master strategic plan that the FNM said that they had for Grand Bahama? Asking for the people!
Madame President, the Cambridge dictionary defines a template as something that is used as a pattern for producing similar results. Madame President, the truth of the matter is, we don’t need an old template that continue to benefit the chosen few, what we need is a paradigm shift from the old into the new. The truth of the matter is madam president there is no workable template anywhere in the world that can be replicated for Grand Bahama; so a new strategic plan had to be created, and that is what we were established with technical support in the mist of great pushback form the powers that be during our term in office. I ask again, what is this administration plans for the economic recovery for Grand Bahama island? How do you plan to establish a tourism signature identity in the marketplace for the island of Grand Bahama? When will we start to see the benefits of this “master strategic plan?” Asking for the people!
Madam President, this FNM administration has been in office for over five months; and NOTHING tangible is happening on the ground in Grand Bahama, the people are tired of talk from this administration and a campaign has been launched by the people on the island by disillusioned and frustrated residents called Fix Grand Bahama!
But instead of trying to fix Grand Bahama, the FNM is once again in this honorable place playing politics with the Speech from the Throne; and using smoke and mirrors, as well as the blame game to distract the people from the fact that they were not, and still not ready to govern.
Madam President, they are almost half way into their first year in office, and there has not been a single piece of legislation brought to this honorable place as part of their so called change agenda. It’s not only sad, but pathetic, and clearly demonstrates that this inept FNM government is lost and must find their way home. The Prime Minister, is obviously sleeping at the wheel, and we are watching as aggressive members of his cabinet are stepping forward trying to fill the gaps, while other are still having victory celebrations or still on vacation; while the country is riddled with violent crime, Bahamians are being victimized daily, businesses are closing down, and the borrowing of millions of dollars continue.
Madam President, I came to this honorable place today to bring a message; the people of the country are growing weary of the accusations and the political rhetoric. They want action, not talk! So, ministers it’s time to put the pedal to the metal; and start governing!
Madam President, while on the campaign trail, the FNM said that they would be ready to govern, and they would bring immediate change to Grand Bahama, jump start our economy, and get people in the tourism sector back to work. On the contrary, Madam President, instead of bringing immediate relief to Grand Bahama like they promised, they have created new layers of bureaucracy to collect taxes to frustrate the people, trying to buy time.
Madam President, new policies and penalties are currently being implemented at the harbor, at customs and other government agencies without proper notification of the public; which are frustrating business owners and negatively affecting the ease of doing business in an already difficult business environment.
Madam President, I recently watched a video with small business owners from Grand Bahama, some of whom admitted to campaigning for the FNM, but are now experiencing, I quote, “the most difficult and trying times.” I admonish this administration to address the people of Grand Bahama, and fix their concerns.
Madam President, the people of Grand Bahama have just cause for concern. The tourism numbers have plummeted, and those in the industry are describing its present state as the worst it’s ever been in the history of the island!
I was reliably informed by a concerned employee recently, that at one point the largest hotel on the island, only had fourteen (14) guests checked into the resort. Further, the largest section of the Lucayan resort, remains closed and the hotel remained unsold; after the Wynn Group pulled out of a few weeks ago.
Madam President, The Grand Bahama International Airport remains barren and empty; with flights barely coming in and bringing hardly any visitors to our shores. As a matter of fact, I’ve also been advised that less than five hundred (500) tourists total if that are presently on the island. To add insult to injury, I received a correspondence last night which confirmed that American Airlines has discontinued its direct flight from Philadelphia to Grand Bahama for this winter season! This is another blow to Grand Bahama’s already stagnant tourism sector!
Madam President, The Port Lucaya Marketplace, once a vibrant sprawling center of economic and tourism activity on the island of Grand Bahama, now looks like a wasteland, a ghost town, and a mere shell of its former glory. I noted with interest the attempt of this administration to host a bimonthly event in Port Lucaya. I also note that while this event has been going on, businesses in the marketplace continue to hemorrhaging, and many were forced to shut their doors.
Madam President, the economy of Grand Bahama is now stagnant under this administration and now thousands continue to struggle to make ends meet, and are barely able to afford groceries at the end of the week. Long standing businesses that have been symbols of hope in the community are closing their doors, and sadly countless others have followed and/or are threatening to do so in short order. We are in a crisis I want to say that again we now in a crisis on the island of Grand Bahama, and the government must act now!
Madam President, during the 2017 Bahamas General Election campaign, the FNM painted a picture of doom and gloom under the PLP.” And for months and months, weeks and weeks, the FNM came to Grand Bahama and shouted, “It’s the People’s Time!” Today, however, the cries are loud and clear from residents that indeed nothing is happening under “Thompson, Turnquest, Pintard and the FNM;” and as a result, many more people on Grand Bahama are jobless and others homeless.
Madam President, the prominent attorney Terry Gape, in an article about the state of Grand Bahama, indicated that if we are not able to turn things around within the next few months on Grand Bahama, the damage would be so severe that it would be virtually impossible for the island of Grand Bahama to rebound within the next ten years.
Madam President, this administration must stop making excuses! All Ministers must revisit those budget lines to find spending room for the people of Grand Bahama. We have three ministers from Grand Bahama around the table. I admonish them to fight for a piece of the pie for Grand Bahama!
Madam President, as a former minister in the government, I too sat around the table when the cupboard was bare, and the pressures from the rating agencies were knocking at our door. Yet, Former Minister Wilchcombe and I fought for Grand Bahama’s share of the pie; and everyone can see the number of capital works projects and reform that is presently ongoing across Grand Bahama.
Madam President, the people of Grand Bahama are in need of immediate relief. Although we understand that the economic challenges on the island are the result of years of problems, some completely out of the hands of Government, we expect that this FNM Administration would deliver for the people of Grand Bahama. The people of Grand Bahama do not expect immediate solutions to every problem, but we do expect immediate action by the people’s government!
Madam President, I have read the FNMs promises for Grand Bahama, as outlined in their manifesto and wish to make a few suggestions to address the immediate crisis on Grand Bahama before I take my seat.
Firstly, Madam President, there should be a waiver placed on all government business license fees for all businesses in East and West Grand Bahama, to supplement the duty-free concessions put in place by our administration and sit with the Port authority to and ask them to follow suite
Secondly, Madam President, the hurricane home repair program and the social services relief efforts should beefed up as the safety net for the unemployed’ people need food now.
Thirdly, Madam President, there should be an immediate capitalization of the Bahamas Entrepreneurial Venture Fund, with specific emphasis place on Grand Bahama. All grants should be processed locally through the Office of the Prime Minister, along with a small team of business leaders from the private sector.
Additionally, Madame President, grant funding and low interest loans should be given to those businesses affected by hurricane Mathew. This can be administered through the Ministry of Finance and the Bahamas Development Bank, to prevent serious political contamination, and the wastage that took place with the FNM’s last jump start program.
Furthermore, Madam President, the Ministry of Tourism must work closely with all hotel property owners, the local promotion board to solidify a workable marketable strategy to per mote tourism activity on Grand Bahama.
Finally, Madam President, the new investment promotion board for Grand Bahama needs to be established before the end of this month and dispatched to attract Foreign Direct Investments to the island.
Madam President, there is so many things that could have been done, to bring immediate relief for the people of Grand Bahama but the government went on a five month vacation. The reality, however, is this administration is lost out to sea and so overwhelmed with the realities of governance, that they feel to comprehend the urgency of the challenges Grand Bahama faces; and they are still asking for time in the midst of a real crisis!
Yet in the middle of this, there is indeed hope, Madam President. I find hope in the thousands of Grand Bahamians who are uniting under the call “Fix Grand Bahama” and holding this government to account for the promises they made to the people of our island.
I am inspired by the business owners who are coming together in unity to call on the Government to get to work and grow our economy again; and I am encouraged by the fact that our Administration left in place a working plan to stabilized our local economy in the aftermath of hurricane Mathew.
Overall, Madame President, this Speech from the Throne was eloquently presented by her Excellency but offers nothing more than fancy words on shiny paper that must be implemented.
Madame President, I certainly want to see our Government and country succeed and as a Bahamian I am prepared to put my politics aside, and work with the government and other stakeholders, to assist with the recovery of Grand Bahama. Finally, on behalf of the people of Grand Bahama I am asking all senators for your support for the people of Grand Bahama.
Finally madam president I would like to once again thank her Excellency.
Thank you and God bless the commonwealth of the Bahamas
-
Senator Clay Sweeting Contribution to the Senate
Madame President, it is indeed and privilege an honour that I stand on behalf of the people of North, Central and South Eleuthera as a Senator and more importantly, the people of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas to thank Her Excellency the Governor General for her most gracious speech from the Throne. She was looked most eloquent and beautiful as she delivered a speech like no other. Lady Pindling, along with Sir Lynden Pindling and my grandmother and grandfather spent time together in North Eleuthera when Hon. Peter Bethel won the seat for the St. Johns Constituency in 1982. They always spoke of her humbling personality and incredible demeanour.
It is only by God’s grace and his blessings that I am able to be here and contribute to the further development of this great country of ours. Madame president, we were sent here to do the people’s business and to act on their behalf and in the best interest of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas. I do not take it for granted.
I would like to offer condolences to the family and friends of Ms Angela Elden from Current Eleuthera especially her brother Mr. Derek Elden. She was a great women and someone that was loved by all in the Current and Eleuthera. She had strong ties to all the communities and showed her love throughout.
I would also like to offer condolences to the family and friends of Keisha Roberts especially her mother Ms. Midred as well as the Roberts and Percentie families.
Lastly, I must offer condolences to the family and friends of Mr James Rolle of James Cistern. He was a nation builder and community activist. A proud member of the Progressive Liberal party and part of our country’s social, cultural and economic reformation. Mr. Rolle was a pillar of his community and of the country.
May their souls and the souls of the faithfully departed rest in peace.
Madame President,
I am a former fishermen and a young businessman. My grandparents and parents raised me to toil and to work hard. The Bible says by their fruits you shall know them. I don’t pretend to be the most eloquent speaker or flamboyant, but one thing I am, is a dedicated hardworking Bahamian. One who wants to see the best for my country, for Eleuthera, for my home. I want my family to be able to live in an economically robust community with proper education, proper health care, a crime free and safe environment. While I enjoy my time here in the Senate, I am here to work.
However, Madame President, I’m not sure the Government is! I share in the sentiments of my leader when he said that it seems to becoming very clear and painfully obvious that this FNM Government has no plan and no vision for this country’s future. This is both unfortunate and unacceptable. Our primary purpose in this Place is the passage of laws for the good governance of the Bahamas.
Many times during the campaign we reminded the Bahamian people about the FNMs stop, cancel and review policy and well here we are. There are numerous persons in Eleuthera that were hired on the Job Empowerment Program that have not been paid in weeks and months. These individuals wake up every day, get dressed, drive miles or hitch hike to work religiously, day in and day out and still are not getting paid. There are individuals that are working at the administrator’s office, social services, the airport, and other government offices in Eleuthera that have not been paid in months. They call me almost everyday, wondering what has happened to the so called People’s Time Government. Are they not the same people the FNM campaigned about, or is it something we’re missing? All I ask is pay the people. They worked for it, they have earned it.
Madame President, I read the speech from the throne thoroughly, but for some unknown reason the fishermen and the fishing industry was not even mentioned. Maybe there is an appendix that I didn’t receive.
Does this show the Government’s dedication to the fishermen of the country?
Have they been forgotten by this People’s Time Government?
The last time we met in this Honourable House, I spoke about my unequivocal care for the fishing industry and my unwavering support for the fishermen. As the shadow Minister for Agriculture and Marine Resources, I made a commitment to be the voice for them and do to whatever I can on their behalf. I spoke about their plight and how the fishermen of this country are hardworking and resilient people. I spoke about the hopes that the Government of this country continues with the PLPs initiatives to patrol the Grand Bahama Banks.
Unfortunately, the fishermen are now faced with another harsh reality. Hurricane Irma swept across the Caribbean causing devastation to a number of countries and wreaked havoc on our country especially Ragged Island. My prayers and thoughts are with the people of these communities and their families.
The fishermen of this country are now faced with the single most devastating natural disaster that has ever faced the fishing industry. I have spoken with many fishermen in this country and according to them they fear that the industry as they know it has a rocky road ahead. The fear that they may not be able to provide for their families is overwhelming. Some fishermen will have to build their companies from the ground up. Most of these has been established for 30+ years. Lobster Processing for this year up to date is down 40% with a steady decline. If something is not done to assist the fishermen of this country, we may see communities that were once lavish and successful become another economy horror story.
I issued a press release a few weeks ago in response to the Minister of Marine Resources’ statement that they were reviewing the possibility of extending the grouper season to allow the fishermen to make the monies lost in the crawfish season as a result of the hurricanes during the summer.
However, extending the grouper season would not be able to even come close to recoup the money lost because of the category 5 storm. It is not possible to substitute the collection of grouper to counteract the effects of Hurricane Irma on the fishermen of this country. The fishermen have immediate financial needs, so they need immediate assistance. We must think logically when disasters occur and the most efficient way to deal with disasters is not always the quickest.
Fishermen across this country have lost a significant amount of hardware including condos and traps which damages their ability to harvest crawfish. A few vessels have explored the bank since the press release and the report is much worse than anticipated. Fishermen across this country have lost millions of dollars in revenue as well as in condos and traps. In order for the fishing industry to continue to thrive, fishermen will have to replace their hardware as soon as possible.
The Government of the Bahamas has made the commitment to restructure the Bahamas Development Bank. In September, at a Eleuthera Business Outlook meeting, the Deputy Prime Minister stated that the Government was exploring the possibility of providing entrepreneurs with grants for their startup businesses. With that being said my recommendation is for the Government to make funds readily available for the fishermen of this country to replace the equipment lost during the storm instead of exploring the opening of the Grouper season.
This can be in the form of short term loans or government grants to assist the fishermen to replace their condos and traps as soon as possible. Senator Thompson spoke yesterday about the possible restructuring of the Bahamas Development Bank and it is my hope that they will extend a helping hand to the fishermen of this country as well.
I also heard the Member for Killarney in the lower chamber speak to an exigency order for the fishermen and farmers of this country. I haven’t seen the order, however for the record, I will say this. There is no use insulting the intelligence of the fishermen and farmers of this country with an exigency order, if it provides duty free exemption for fishing equipment or farming equipment because they are ready able to bring in such equipment duty free.
Don’t try and make political brownie points spewing rhetoric that has no significant impact on the lives of the people affected.
The Fishermen need cash to get restarted.
I would also like to address an issue that has been brought to my attention in regards to foreign fishing. The Government must review regulations and provide better oversight of pleasure crafts entering and leaving this country to protect fishing stock. The regulations provide for 6 fish of each species to be caught per person per day. Imagine if a crew of 10 is in the Bahamas for 10 days. In any event, I am reasonably advised that yachts with walk in commercial freezers frequent the Exuma Cays, North Eleuthera and the Berry Islands in particular. They then go back home with freezers full of fish paying no mind for legislation or policies. This has been a continuing issue under both governments but we must provide better oversight and enforcement; even of the existing regulations.
There is also a policy that was implemented by the former government that makes it mandatory for foreigners who wish to bone fish to acquire a Bahamian guide as well as a license. I do support the inclusion of Bahamian guides in the industry but the process of acquiring a permit is cumbersome. It is my suggestion and personal opinion that the government implement an online licensing program whereby guides wishing to fish on the weekends can acquire a license through an online portal, pay with a credit card and print the license at home. This will increase local bone fishing charter activity as persons will not have to wait until the weekend is over to acquire a license.
Inquiring Minds Want To Know
- Before the Progressive Liberal Party left office, the then government executed a contract with funding from the IDB to construct and install a reverse osmosis plant in North Eleuthera. This would in turn provide potable water to all the residents and citizens of the island. They need it and I hope that the project continues. I have not heard much about it in recent months, so inquiring minds just want to know, is the project still progressing?
- Inquiring minds want to know…what is the government going to do to promote local land ownership and development in the family islands? Will they make available, Crown Land to qualified Bahamians at concessionary rates in communities such as Bogue and the Bluff? I do support these type of initiatives as these communities do not have access to purchase personal property and it is of my opinion that we must find ways to encourage Bahamian ownership. There is an old adage that states that land is wealth. Even in the past, you couldn’t vote without owning property and you were able to cast your votes according to how much property you owned.
- Inquiring minds want to know…what is the government going to do for local farmers? Will there be measures and programs put in place to encourage local farming with youth initiatives with the possibility of canning factories and processing plants. You will provide tax incentives to industries associated with farming in order to further promote the industry and so we can get one step close to feeding ourselves.
- What is the government doing with NHI? In the speech from the throne the government promised to extend the focus of NHI to secondary and tertiary health care as well as oversee the incremental implementation of a progressive and functional National Catastrophic Health Insurance Programme. In July the Minister of Health stated that the government has made it very clear to the Bahamian people that NHI will be improved. He said that he made a commitment to the Bahamian people to make it work. I find this so odd that in July the Government made a commitment to continue to enrol people with NHI and here were are only three months later and persons contracted with NHI are being let go.
How can the Peoples Time Government properly roll out NHI without proper staffing. I am told that employees contracted under NHI has been released in North Eleuthera and all staff in Grand Bahama were released yesterday. I am sure the government may make the assertion that there is a difference between expiration of contracts and termination. That is all well and good but at the end of the day the people are without jobs. We just spoke in depth yesterday about Freeport and saving Grand Bahama. You cannot allow people to go without a job and expect to save the economy.
If the government was serious about providing proper healthcare for citizens of this country, let me ask…how can they do it without adequate staffing and resources? Inquiring minds want to know.
- Will the government abide by its promise to construct, upgrade and expand state-of-the-art facilities and services throughout New Providence and the Family Islands, inclusive of a mini hospital on the island of Eleuthera? The Progressive Liberal Party laid the framework, architectural renderings and the initial phase of the mini hospital in Eleuthera. I am told that the project is put on hold…. inquiring minds want to know. Will they enhance the conditions of service for all health care staff.
- In Harbour Island, the former administration approved a public private partnership to demolish the old Government administration office and construct a new one in Harbour Island. This new administrative complex would house a new police station, magistrate court, administrator office, and other government entities. Trailers were sent to Harbour Island to serve as temporary office locations for these entities while the old complex was demolished and a new one constructed. Unfortunately, this project too seems to have fallen to the government’s stop, review and cancel policy. If the Government supports the people of this country and the people of Harbour Island, than why is the project sitting on the shelf or is it cancelled. Inquiring minds want to know. The people of Harbour Island want to know. I am sure that the Member of Parliament for North Eleuthera will not sit by and let that project be cancelled. Just because it was a so called PLP project doesn’t mean that the government shouldn’t complete it. Let’s not play politics with the lives of the people of this country. Let’s not be political when it comes to the betterment of our family island communities.
- In the speech from the throne the government dedicated themselves to provide a one-stop shop for the ease of doing business in this country. In the later part of September, I was invited along with the Deputy Prime Minister to speak at the Eleuthera Business Outlook. I listened attentively as he spoke about the Governments initiative to provide the one-stop shop for doing business. I do support this and I feel that businesses especially on the family islands are disadvantaged and the red tape seems never-ending. As long as it is initiated correctly and efficiently, I support it. Businesses should not have to wait three to four months just to get a business license because of the paperwork involved. All inspections and procedures should be procured from one location in order to speed up the process and in turn encourage Bahamians to become business owners. I’m a family island boy so I understand their frustrations. It is time that the Family Islands are no longer treated like Out Islands but as piers with Nassau.
Madame President, I have seen on social media that some supporters of the side opposite calling members of the Progressive Liberal Party salty which I assume means bad sportsmanship. This side, the opposition, has said on numerous occasions that election is over, we lost, get on with governing. We are looking for a bigger, brighter future in the PLP as we renew, rebrand and revamp the party.
If you want to say we’re salty……You right we’re Salty.
We’re salty on behalf of the young lady who’s working everyday as a janitress, traveling miles, hitch hiking to work just to ensure that her father can buy medication.
You right we’re salty. Salty on behalf the young mother who is working two and three jobs just to get by. Hoping to provide for her children to give them a quality education.
Salty…you right we’re salty. Salty on behalf of the people of this country that were promised VAT exception in bread basket items but are still waiting.
Salty…you right we’re salty. Salty on behalf of the young men and women of this country that were promised a free college education but has yet to be offered it.
I’m Salty on behalf of the fishermen and farmers of this country that have not seen any hurricane relief assistance from the government.
I’m Salty on behalf the thousands of people that need proper health care but cannot afford to receive it.
Madame President, I will close with this. In the book of Ecclesiastes in states that:
3 To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven:
2 A time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;
3 A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up;
4 A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance;
5 A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;
6 A time to get, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away;
7 A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;
8 A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace.
This is the FNM’s time. They say this is the People’s Time. We all have our time, so People’s Time Government, don’t waste the Peoples Time.
God Bless you and God Bless the Commonwealth of the Bahamas. I support the resolution.
-
Senator Jobeth Davis contribution to the Senate
October 2017 Contribution-
Resolution to Thank Her Excellency Governor General for presenting the Speech from the Throne.
Senator, Hon., J.L. Coleby-Davis- Opposition Senator and Shadow Attorney General, Shadow Minister of Legal Affairs, and Youth
Madame President, Senate Colleagues, my fellow Bahamians, I am grateful to God and thank him for another opportunity to present in this place once again. With pleasure and gratitude, I rise to thank Her Excellency the Governor General, Dame Marguerite Pindling, for the gracious and eloquent delivery of the Speech from the Throne. The actual speech, as we all are aware, was prepared by the FNM Administration to outline their legislative agenda, priorities and focus for the upcoming session of Parliament. Being given by the Governor General, the intention is, to present a level of commitment, seriousness and dignity to the words and policies set out in the Speech.
Madam President and my fellow Bahamians, while I rise to thank the Her Excellency the Governor General for delivery of the speech with distinction; though 5 months later, one cannot rise to thank this FNM Administration for any achievement of goals set out in the said speech. The FNM, in the speech, stressed the urgency to implement a number of important polices. However, the FNM has stimulated a disengaged snail’s pace to move a legislative agenda forward that is reflective of the promises made to our people.
Stop Complaining, K.I.S and GET TO WORK!
Madame President, My advice to this FNM Administration, STOP COMPLAINING, KEEP IT SIMPLE AND GET TO WORK!
Now in this statement, Keep It Simple is abbreviated to K.I.S!
The Bahamian people voted for this FNM government on the promises and expectations that they posses effective plans to bring about economic growth. The mass numbers at the polls indicated the urgency to be placed on the challenges continually faced by the Bahamian people.
Therefore, now is not the time to backpedal or point the finger to the previous administration. You did that during the debate, we indulged you on your extended summer holiday, with the expectation that you would be laying some bills on the table. As a result, is it our request that the FNM place focus and attention to the urgency or depth of economic decline faced in this Bahamas.
Madame President,
There is no need to complicate the job; the Government was hired by the people to Govern, the fact that we are here today thanking the Governor General means that they have presented a clear mandate. I suggest to the Government, STOP COMPLAINING, K.I.S AND GET TO WORK!
As to some of the laundry list of promises, so eloquently laid out by our lovely Governor General, Dame Marguerite Pindling:
This FNM Government promised that they will establish a One-Stop-Shop to improve the ease of doing business! Though this is a necessary and modern approach to doing business; how do we achieve removing barriers to encourage Foreign Direct Investment and increase the growth of Entrepreneurs across the Bahamas? Much must be provided to the Bahamian public as to the plans on implementing such promises. There should be step by step guidance following review and consultation of similar programs. Furthermore, the Government should by now, be advancing the Conversation on what they plan to change or implement to make doing business in the Bahamas easier. So I ask:
- How will they reduce regulatory inefficiencies and reduce red tape for all investors?
- Do they intend to bring legislation to update Company laws?
- Will they introduce regulations to streamline businesses and ensure adequate and effective processes are implemented?
- At present, we have automated systems that allow local limited liability companies to register online. In addition, we have the new electronic license and registration systems at Road Traffic, all thanks to the PLP. Where do we go from here? How do we expand on this system to effectively reduce regulatory complexities surrounding doing business in the Bahamas? The business community needs answers, not promises!
So I say, Stop Complaining, K.I.S and GET TO WORK!
This FNM Government promised to launch the rebound of the island of Grand Bahama in accordance with the template for a master strategic plan designed for Grand Bahama. Yes, I read that exactly how it is written. Whilst, they are good at making promises, I am not entirely convinced that they can deliver. I go further to suggest that this Government, over- abuse of words, almost seems as if they think, if the sentence appears to be long, then it would look as if they are doing A LOT. However, let me KEEP IT SIMPLE, here is what the Government must do, in a nutshell, FIX GRAND BAHAMA NOW!
All of that long drawn out discussion, about master strategic plan, is worth nothing if you continually ignore the critical, but yet unique challenges that presently exist in Grand Bahama.
Once again I say, Stop Complaining, K.I.S and GET TO WORK!
This FNM Government promised to renew the Family Island Incentives Act to promote growth in agriculture and manufacturing and support diversification in growth of agricultural produce among Family Islands and encourage and enhance inter-island trade.
As I stated before, providing these promises in such long drawn out sentences does not get the work done. Here are my questions related to this promise:
- Do you intend to include legislation that will speak to industrial policies to develop manufacturing in the Bahamas?
- Are you providing tax incentives, subsidies and land concessions to manufacturers to ensure the introduction of this industry has minor burdens and to avoid unnecessary setbacks?
It is evident on a daily basis, that the Bahamas needs innovation, expansion in industry, and a modernized structure for ease of doing business. Therefore, this Government has no time to waste.
Stop Complaining, K.I.S and GET TO WORK!
Another promise by this FNM Government is that they will take action to effect a reduction of the VAT on breadbasket items. See, Madam President, I would be remiss if I do not properly speak on behalf of my Bahamian people. There is no time for the games, on the Campaign trail, the FNM promised REMOVAL of VAT on bread basket items not reduction, and THAT is the promise we will hold you to.
As a result, of the promise to REMOVE VAT, I ask, when can the Bahamian people expect further information on those plans of VAT removal? I go further to state, on behalf of the Bahamian people, please ensure, while you are removing VAT off of breadbasket items and essentially reducing the tax burden, DO NOT, try and sneak in another burden by the name of INCOME TAX!
Again, I say, Stop Complaining, K.I.S and GET TO WORK!
Madam President, I want to speak to one more of the promises by this Government before I move on to other matters. This FNM government will implement a pilot programme for single gender classes at the Junior High School Level to assist with closing the achievement gap between boys and girls.
Here again I ask relevant and necessary questions:
- Did the Government embark on a review of whether the Bahamian public or parents wanted such pilot programme?
- Has any consultation been completed within the schools with teachers, administrators and students prior to making this promise on the campaign trail?
- On what basis are we certain that we would get positive results from such programme?
- Why not look at other educational programmes and societal changes to increase our literacy level?
Madam President, I took some time to read and review various articles that debated the pros and cons of single gender schools.
From my review, I have made some assessments on my own:
- First, from the majority of the reviews, there has yet to be a definitive research study that shows single gender classes produce a larger majority of intellects or a better learning environment as opposed to coed classes.
- Second, as persons from African decent, we are continually fighting this subject of racial segregation; however, does one not think gender works in much the same way?
- Unless we forget, social psychology states that one of the impacts of segregation is that it promotes stereotyping and sexism. I further state that this single gender class plan does not appear to be forward thinking!
Further, we live in a society that is not Gender-Blind! More importantly, women are continuously overlooked for positions which society deems would be better suited for a Man. Additionally, we live in a society where equal pay across genders is still thought of as a foreign language.
Madam President, therefore, because of the ever-present gender ills in this society and those around us, I feel it is important for our girls to be taught early on the realities of life and some of the challenges they may face. Integration should remain throughout the public school system so that both genders learn confidence to speak-up, to voice their opinions, to accept their differences, to discuss matters and to learn about issues faced by both genders. This is empowering and helps with social development skills which they need to embrace, because college, university or on jobs, there will be no segregation.
Madam President, as we are discussing the school system, the focus must be placed on combating social ills within the Bahamas and the inefficiencies that exist in the public schools.
- Let us focus on the underlying issues of having younger parents, the lack of after school or youth mentoring programs in various communities.
- Let us focus on completing the school repairs on time to ensuring the learning environment is conducive to produce the result we desire;
- Let us focus on ensuring the classrooms are equipped with adequate tables and chairs not to frustrate the learning process.
- Let us focus on preparing a curriculum that is relatable to the challenges and changing times in our Bahamaland. For instance, how about we place less focus on Christopher Columbus and we begin to give in-depth teachings on the Bahamas Constitution, which many persons still to this day does not know or understand!
- Once more, it is apparent that all of our students are not academically inclined, they just cannot get it! Madam President; therefore, let us focus on building some Charter Schools that allow for a broader approach to learning. It is time we take the focus on just teaching, and place it on educating! Education goes beyond whether you get an A or B, but it helps with nation building and empowerment; one may not understand the theory, but may possess many useful practical skills. And there is still an appreciation for those skilled and gifted young people!
CRY FOR BAHAMIANS.
Madame President,
A few months ago the Prime Minister spoke on an issue that pulled on our hearts, he spoke on the bad state of Dominica’s economy. In fact, while he was listing off the challenges and unique situations faced following the passing of Hurricane Irma, he became overwhelmed with sadness and began to weep. This inspired him to make some policy changes to allow for DominEeKan children to be afforded the opportunities to come and continue the education until their country has been rebuilt. Madame President, I was torn, on how I felt when I saw the emotions that consumed the Prime Minister, on the one hand, I have been taught Christian values and principles by my parents, I will not quote the bible, but I know and understand what being our brothers keepers mean. However, I felt shortchanged as a Bahamian, because while the entire international community along with the Bahamas focused their resources and relief efforts on Domineeka. I felt we as Bahamians with our own unique problems were forgotten.
Therefore, Madam President, I invite the Prime Minister to redirect his tears and cry for this place:
- There is a place where presently the largest hotel on the island has an overall occupancy of 14 persons, a place where Pisces restaurant a staple in the community has now closed its doors after being around for 30+ years, a place where Shipping agents are complaining about the new taxes that has recently been enforced despite the decline in the economy, a place where a shipyard employment program which employed about 200 persons recently terminated 70+ with no employment opportunities on the horizon, an economy that is so bad that persons cannot afford to license their vehicles, a place where evictions are being exercised daily with no affordable housing options available, a place where Small Business owners are closing on a daily basis due to lack of revenue or profits, a place where some have resorted to sleeping in their cars, a place where a mother can admit how happy she was to have made $5 dollars in five weeks at the Straw Market, a place with no ships at the harbor for days and weeks on end. A place leaving many of the residents homeless, jobless and HOPELESS. Cry for this place, this place is my home, where I was born, Grand Bahama. Why not cry for them? They are on their last leg, shouldn’t they be positioned to gain much, with all five seats to the Government and the Minister of Finance holding one of the five? So why not cry for them? If that is too much to ask:
- Then cry for the Southern Bahamas, that received catastrophic damages following Hurricane Irma, our Bahamians in Ragged Island, with total devastation, and the insult and demand by persons in the Government that suggested everyone must relocate and leave their island they know and love, without second thought. Why not cry for them?
- For the families that lost their loved ones due to crime, for the family that suffered recent lost of their 8 year old son, Eugene Woodside by a stray bullet, Cry for them.
- For the families still awaiting home repairs following hurricane Mathew, Cry for them;
- For the young man or woman that was sent home, fired, and removed from their honest paying job, and are now unable to provide for their families. Cry for them?
- For the young lady that worked and had perfect attendance on the 52 week program, but 3 months later have yet to receive her pay. Cry for them?
- For the thousands of Bahamian students who completed high schools but are unable to attend UB because of financial hardship yet their counterparts from Dominica are eligible to attend. Cry for them?
Madam President, as the Prime Minister did not think it important to cry for those Bahamians, I submit that the People of the People’s time Bahamas CRY SHAME ON YOU!
IMF this IMF That!
Madame President, I want to speak a little on these drastic recommendations by the IMF. They are foreign, they do not understand the Bahamian Dream, I question their recommendation, and how they will impact the lives of Bahamians and the cost on the Bahamian society. Most importantly the IMF were NOT VOTED IN BY THE BAHAMIAN PEOPLE, in fact it is the FNM that the people gave their confidence to govern. And govern they must!
Therefore, the IMF strict measures should not be used as a governing plan by the FNM Government. Madam President, by placing so much focus on the IMF advice of austerity measures one can only assume that the people’s time Government is NOT about working for the people.
Hundreds of civil servants depend on their wages, if you cut their wages; you cut their way of life. Whilst some may live somewhat above their means, this strict approach can only wipe out the already weakened middle class. Think about that mother who was unable to attend private but works hard for her wages to provide her daughter/ son with private school education. How do you explain cutting this mother wages? After cutting her wages, what if she goes to take on another job to keep her children educated at the same private school? Can you imagine the further social damages that may result? Social ills entirely related to troubled youths, and a possible increase in crime, because parents have to work 2 or 3 jobs. Furthermore, where will some of these jobs come from as the unemployment line has increased tremendously?
Madame President, this strict approach by the IMF has the potential to lead us into a poverty stricken Bahamas, one that is very UNFAMILIAR to Bahamians, and not the Bahamas our forefathers and those that marched with the Woman Suffrage Movement fought long and hard for.
Is it truly the People’s Time? Because austerity measures will NOT WORK! Bahamians should not have to live dishonestly to survive in their own country. Bahamians should not be forced to working 2 and 3 jobs just to stay broke. And ANY government that seeks to take from the people should no longer have the people’s confidence to govern them!
It is the Government’s time to GROW THIS ECONOMY:
Madame President, All campaign talk aside, the Government must take serious that they are 5 months out with 55 more months to go. Focus and attention must be placed on the important need to transform and grow this economy. Some of the things this Government must seek to do sooner rather than later are the following:
- Reduce crime in our society;
- FIX GRAND BAHAMA
- Reform of the Immigration Policy;
- Implement ease of doing business to encourage Entrepreneurship and Foreign Direct Investment;
- Produce an efficient and effective plan to eliminate the sub-standard conditions under which too many families still live in our inner cities;
- Meet the demand for decent Affordable Housing;
- Provide free UB education to Bahamians as promised;
- Introduce new strategies for the economic improvement of our Family Island Communities;
- Stimulate an expansion of our Tourism industry;
- Reinvigorate our financial services sector;
- Promote economic growth and prosperity in all other sectors; and
- Protect our coastal and marine environment and our fisheries resources.
SPY BILL
Madame President, before I take my seat, I wish to briefly address the blatant hypocrisy by the FNM Government, in particular, the Member for Yamacraw in the other place. It was as recent as February 2017 when the Former Bahamas Bar President joined activist on public protest to resist the Interception of Communications Bill, which the member called the “dangerous” spying legislation.
Months later, Madame President, following elections, and with the transfer of power, the Member for Yamacraw, now unashamedly provided communication in the other place to the Government’s intention to table the Interception of Communication Bill. Surprisingly, instead of producing the bill as drafted by the previous administration; and in accordance with the Maycock decision by the Privy Council, to grant the authority to the Judiciary; the Supreme Court; independent and free from any political influence. The new Interception Bill, which is out for consultation, gives the Executive (including the Minister of National Security) the right and power to intercept.
Madame President, while I understand we have yet to table this bill and it is in early stages out for public consultation, subject to amendments and changes prior to the debate. I wish to simply remind the Members in the other place and those in this place of the same concerns of trust by the public and the need for assurances that interception warrants would only be obtained in the public interest or the interest of justice!
So, Madame President, I patiently await the day by which my colleagues in this place and members in the other place prepare for the GREAT DEBATE!
I end with one of my favorite scriptures to bring back hope and encouragement to those across the length and breadth of this great Commonwealth of The Bahamas. I wish encourage you, that though times might seem tough, be reminded of the word of God in Jeremiah 29:11, For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, saith the LORD, thoughts of peace, and not of evil, to give you an expected end.
Therefore, my fellow Bahamians, I implore you to continue to be encouraged, do not lose hope in New Providence, stay strong in Grand Bahama and press on in Salina Point, Acklins, Ragged Island, Inagua and all the other Family Islands.
Madame President, though it took long enough, I wish to once again thank Her Excellency the Governor General for delivering this speech from the throne, so eloquently and with distinction. May God continue to bless and keep her.
May God continue to bless the Commonwealth of The Bahamas.
-
BRAVE DAVIS CONTRIBUTION TO DEBATE
HON. PHILIP BRAVE DAVIS MP
MEMBER FOR CAT ISLAND, RUM CAY AND SAN SALVADOR
LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION
CONTRIBUTION TO DEBATE TO THANK THE GOVERNOR GENERAL FOR HER SPEECH FROM THE THRONE
5thOCTOBER 2017INTRODUCTION
Mr. Speaker,
I rise on behalf of the faithful and hardworking people of Cat Island, Rum Cay and San Salvador; islands to which I have strong familial ties and longstanding professional and social associations. I remain ever grateful to Almighty God for this privilege to stand here. I am, in fact, having served in this place since January of 1992, that makes me the Elder in this honourable House. To God be the glory!
Mr. Speaker
Before I proceed to the substance of my contribution, permit me to lament the atrocity that took place on Cat Island over the past weekend. As I prepared for Sunday worship, I got the news that police had discovered the lifeless body of one or our American residents Janice Mildred Kessinger in bushes in North Cat Island. Unfortunately, she has now become just a number to some – Murder Victim 107. How tragic…
Today, I give condolences to her family and all who loved her. This incident has shaken Cat Island to its core. Ms. Kessinger was well-known and well-loved, particularly among the children to whom she extended so many acts of benevolence. I am grateful to police on Cat Island, who took her disappearance very seriously and acted accordingly. I am also grateful to their counterparts, who have acted likewise at the gruesome discovery.
Cat Island will memorialise Ms. Kessinger in the coming days. To die violently at any age is a grim consequence, but at 74, one expects that natural causes will be your likely demise. Yet, this is where we are today. May her soul rest in peace and may those who loved her find comfort.
Mr. Speaker
This death is a symptom of a deeply rooted scourge on The Bahamas. In this place and otherwise, I have said that crime is not just an important issue. Crime is the most important issue facing The Bahamas. A government’s first responsibility is to protect its citizens; and we are traversing most violent years in our nation’s history.
Keeping people safe is not a small thing. On the contrary, it is everything. If our homes and streets are not safe, we cannot do great things as a nation – we cannot look to a prosperous future. We must win the war against violence. The alternative is unimaginable. I will speak to this issue further in my presentation, but for now, I needed to register this as priority.
Mr. Speaker
Albert Schweitzer[1], a French-German theologian, gave us these words. He said, “At times, our own light goes out and is rekindled by a spark from another person. Each of us has cause to think with deep gratitude of those who have lighted the flame within us.” As I think on these words, I too recall the light that Her Excellency carries. Even though it was four months ago, I can see her now on the dais, delivering Her Majesty’s Speech within variable grace, impeccably clear articulation, and metered authority.
I am very grateful to Her Excellency as she executes her duties with such impartiality. She has kind words for everyone – not empty words. I will take the liberty and say that her actions have garnered the respect of this Honourable House and its members. I thank her not only for the Speech, but for her years of dedicated public service.
Mr. Speaker
While the Governor General made a remarkable delivery of the Government’s legislative agenda, I believe that we are only now thanking Her Excellency because the governing side thinks that we have short memories. They would wish us not to remember to say that the Speech was a clear acknowledgement of the transformative foundation already constructed by the Progressive Liberal Party Government.
I was encouraged to hear that the Government has embraced the essential job-related skills training and specialised programmes for youth unemployment that we set in motion. I was equally encouraged to note that we had laid the foundation for wider access to justice. We created the Public Defender’s Office and the statutory ability to appoint more judges. We also reduced the time it takes for cases to come to trial.
Mr. Speaker
We set the path to Customs and Treasury reform modernising the administration of public finances. We implemented the primary phase of National Health Insurance (NHI) as important components of this Government’s policy foundation. I can go on and on about it, but it would be too much. For clarity, though, I will say this side will support any policy which protects the poor and the vulnerable and those in which the national interests are protected and promoted.
We will not oppose for opposing sake as this Government did in opposition.
Mr. Speaker
My brows raised and I smiled when I saw yesterday’s headliner for the “National Review”. It read “Spy Bill hypocrisy: FNM introduces in House what it railed against in opposition”.
Mr. Speaker
Mark my words. The people of The Bahamas have only just begun to witness the extent of this Government’s hypocrisy. We sounded the alarm long ago, but sometimes, as my dear grandmother used to say, “Sometimes, ya gatta let people buck dey own toe.”
Mr. Speaker
East Grand Bahama knows how buck toe feels. The entire Bahamas felt the backlash wielded by Moody’s in response to his Budget Communication. Even the international rating agency responded to the doom and gloom.
Mr. Speaker
Members will recall that when I made my contribution to the Budget Debate, I warned the side opposite that the Communication should have avoided the language that was inordinately laden political mischief, grand-standing and disingenuous posturing. It sought to demonise everything that transpired during our term in office and frankly painted a sad picture for The Bahamas.
Moody’s responded on the 6th of July in very concise terms.
“Moody’s Investors Service has today placed the Baa3 bond and issuer ratings of the government of the Bahamas on review for downgrade.
“The decision to place the ratings on review was prompted by official statements that The Bahamas’ fiscal position was weaker than previously estimated and that the government’s debt ratios will continue to worsen over the coming years. This diverged from Moody’s expectation that the government’s debt ratios would stabilize in fiscal 2017, thus supporting the Bahamas’ Baa3 rating and stable outlook. Moody’s review will focus on evaluating the credit risks posed by ongoing economic and fiscal challenges, taking into consideration the recent revelations of fiscal deterioration as well as the new government’s proposals to arrest this deterioration. During the review, Moody’s will also assess how the Bahamas’ overall credit profile will evolve compared with those of sovereigns rated in the Baa and Ba categories.
“The Bahamas’ long-term local-currency bond and bank deposit country ceiling remain unchanged at A2. The long-term foreign-currency bond and bank deposits ceilings remain unchanged at Baa1 and Baa3, respectively. The short-term foreign-currency bond and bank deposits ceilings remain unchanged at P-2 and P-3, respectively.”
Of course, that sent East Grand Bahama into a scramble. Ouch!!! Bucking your toe really hurts! Grammy used to say, “What you give to the world, you can’t take back.”
I would not mind a fly-on-the-wall report of what happened to cause Moody to allow Bahamians to breathe a literal sigh of relief. We know the story.
New York, August 25, 2017 — Moody’s Investors Service has today confirmed the Baa3 bond and issuer ratings of the government of the Bahamas and changed the outlook to negative. The rating actions conclude a review for downgrade that commenced on July 6, 2017.
Moody’s confirmation of the Baa3 rating is driven by the following drivers:
1) Prospects for debt stabilization supported by the government’s fiscal consolidation program
2) The Bahamas’ credit metrics remain in line with Baa3 peers, with GDP revisions supporting an improvement in quantitative metrics
3) Despite higher government borrowing needs, government liquidity risk remains contained.
The negative outlook reflects potential downside risks to the fiscal consolidation process posed by weaker than- expected growth, exposure to climate-related shocks in the form of hurricanes, and implementation risks associated with measures to rein in expenditure growth and enhance revenues.
Absent successful fiscal consolidation, the Bahamas’ fiscal and credit profile would likely weaken. In addition, the sovereign is exposed to contingent liabilities stemming from state-owned enterprises and the Bank of the Bahamas, which would lead to a further deterioration of the government’s fiscal strength should these materialize on its balance sheet.
The Bahamas’ long-term foreign-currency bond ceiling remains unchanged at Baa1 and long-term foreign currency deposit ceiling at Baa3. The short-term foreign-currency bond ceiling remains Prime-2, whereas the short-term foreign-currency deposit ceiling is at Prime-3. The Bahamas’ long-term local currency country risk ceilings remain at A2.
Mr. Speaker
It is becoming very clear and painfully obvious that this FNM Government has no plan and no vision for this country’s future. This is both unfortunate and unacceptable. Surely, by now, 217 days later, we have lost opportunities to bring more Bills to this Place. Our primary purpose in this Place is the passage of laws for good governance. Apart from Money Bills, we are with only a Bill that expands the powers of the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions and another the side opposite labelled the “Spy Bill” when we tabled it in February of this year. Ironically the very person who called on all right thinking and concerned Bahamians to march in opposition to the Bill is the very Member to table that which was so despised.
I take the liberty here to manipulate some words that my former Parliamentary colleague Melanie Griffin likes. They are based in scripture and says that “A double minded man is unstable in all his ways.” This very aptly describes the new leadership of the FNM. They have not changed. Hypocrisy is the order of the day. Hypocrisy and victimisation. God, help us all!
Mr. Speaker
Let me show you the extent of hypocrisy. We proposed for the Interception of Communication Bill to entrust power to approve selective monitoring to the judiciary, a separate and equal branch of government. It is confounding that the Bill now proposes this power should reside with politicians. This cannot be right and it is certainly not progressive or forward looking.
In its current form, it must be rejected by right thinking freedom loving Bahamians as a rank and arrogant invasion of privacy. In its current form, the Bill violates the civil liberties and privacy by opening the door to political abuse and persecution. I daresay, it takes away rights from Bahamians when we in this place should be about deepening and expanding democracy through the expansion of civil liberties and rights of privacy.
Mr. Speaker
The FNM government has distinguished itself over the last four months as a government of broken promises. The undercurrent of discontent cannot be ignored. The people are wondering if it is really their time. Notwithstanding all the noise to infer otherwise, the people have heard Government’s admission that The Bahamas is in good economic health.
The people are not likely to get an apology for Government’s abandonment of key promises either. Most people tell me that they can’t find their MP. They can’t hear from them. They can’t see them. I usually say, “Well, there are plenty of them to find.” But, it ain’t long now. Somewhere in the range of 240 weeks, we will go back to the same people for votes. Let them keep ducking and dodging and skirting around promises. The Bahamian people are taking notes.
When will Bahamians receive selective catastrophic care under NHI?
When can Bahamian students expect free tuition at the University of the Bahamas?
When will ordinary Bahamians receive tax relief on breadbasket items?
When can Bahamians expect the program that will lead to a unified busing system?
Mr. Speaker
Hypocrisy and victimisation…These are the hallmarks of this Administration. We added 39,505 jobs to the national economy between 2012 and 2017.
Since this Government came to power, we hear and see news about firings almost on a daily basis. We have Bahamians living right here in The Bahamas, who thought it was their time, reading ads from Baha Mar on social media targeting US citizens and residents wanting to work at Baha Mar and live in The Bahamas. Many of the positions advertised are well within the skillset of Bahamians trained in the hospitality industry.
Mr. Speaker
I can tell you that this recruitment exercise does not sit well with Bahamians as we battle an unemployment rate of just under ten percent. It took us five years to reduce unemployment to single digits. Bahamians want answers and rightly so. Let us hope that there is some plausible rationale.
But, Mr. Speaker
Even in the Public Service, there is a groundswell of discontent. Many, duped by this Government while in opposition, now see the error of their ways. So many effective and efficient officers have been stifled or sidelined, primarily because of their perceived politics.
How can we be silent when policies or practices that threaten to let go 600 to 800 contract workers in the Ministry of Education some of whom were hired up to ten years ago?
The process toward their regularisation was well underway. This is necessary to bring certainty to their lives and filter them into defined career paths. We succeeded in placing about half of the nearly 3,000 contract employees on the permanent and pensionable payroll.
Mr. Speaker
I am advised that last week Friday, the Department of Inland Revenue began dismissing young people.
But, Mr. Speaker
The former Member for Fox Hill tried to steer Public Officers toward a sensible vote. He said, “Vote PLP if you want to keep your jobs.” It hurts me to say, “We told you so.” But we did.
Mr. Speaker
I have not heard any good news coming out of Grand Bahama. Grand Bahama – an island that gave solid support to the FNM – an island with Cabinet level representation. They recently lost a cruise ship calling on its port. The Tourism Minister’s casual and insensitive response offered was that he was not concerned. What a message for suffering people! We all must be concerned when we lose business! This loss means job losses and a decline in the quality of life for our people.
The government’s mishandling of the Grand Bahama economy and specifically its failure to get the major hotels – the Grand Lucayan Properties – has intensified the uncertainty and the sense of hopelessness among Grand Bahamians.
Mr. Speaker
I am concerned. The PLP is concerned. The lack of transparency, clarity and consistency in the government’s overall strategy of revitalising Grand Bahama’s tourism product and beleaguered economy is pathetic.
Misstatements and mixed message statements characterise this Administration. They send mixed signals that provoke scepticism around their policies.
A typical example is how the Minister of State for Grand Bahama indicated that a deal with the Wynn Investment Group was imminent. Eventually and abruptly, Wynn pulled out of the purchase for the Grand Lucayan Complex.
How did they get from the point of imminent sale to a pull out? Well, we wait to see and hear more conch salad stories in this Place. Yes, conch salad! Mixed right up!
Mr. Speaker
I look forward to hearing the details of the government’s plan to take an equity position in the hotel complex as articulated by the Member for East Grand Bahama. Progress and updates on that front went totally flat and Bahamians are in the dark about the government’s strategic plan for Grand Bahama.
On this side, while in Government, we made tripartite efforts to aggressively reach a meaningful resolution in the best interest of Grand Bahamians.
Victimisation and petty spite saw the demise of a viable deal we left on the table. This is incompetence and has left many Grand Bahamians feeling that Government has either abandoned them or is not up to the task of leading the economic resurgence of Grand Bahama.
Mr. Speaker
I condemn this Government’s ad-hoc approach to negotiations. At the same time, I urge all Bahamians to note that this Government is not interested in all the people. It is interested in some people. Take notes because sometimes our memories are short. This Government is clearly not committed to rapidly improving the dire economic situation on Grand Bahama.
Mr. Speaker
This Government’s gross disregard for the economic strategy for Grand Bahama will negatively impact that island’s economy. This is no time for status quo. The status quo is the root of Grand Bahama’s economic malaise. Government must act and NOW!
We injected over $100 million in Grand Bahama during our Administration. Hurricane Matthew, however, had a severe deleterious effect on our intervention.
We wait now to hear about the proposal in respect of Carnival Cruise Port, which was earmarked for East Grand Bahama. I urge Government to make the right choice. Let go of the spite. Take on a new attitude.
Mr. Speaker
I recently spoke at an event to celebrate Bishop Neil Ellis. There, I mused that God sometimes asks us to do strange things. When we listen, we are recipients of the full and abundant blessings of obedience.
Listening is the most useful tool I know.
I bring this up because an FNM government gave Hutchison Whampoa exclusive rights for any port development on the island of Grand Bahama.
This policy decision was a barrier to economic growth on that island. As Government, we secured a waiver of those rights through protracted negotiations with the principals. There is now no real barrier to the East Grand Bahama Port Project.
Mr. Speaker
This side, through you, asks that side to look beyond this strange request. Listen to sage advice. Do some good for Grand Bahama. Not later…NOW!
I also caution Government in respect of repealing the Investment Incentive Act. This would be a travesty – a return to that which triggered economic stagnation – a return to the status quo.
Mr. Speaker
I urge Government to get to work. The country is adrift as time is wasted trying to demonise political opponents and rewriting history. It’s the people’s time and all over The Bahamas the people are saying, “Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.” The campaign is over. Get to work. The people are not interested in the pre-election campaign propaganda narrative. Action! Walk the talk!
Mr. Speaker
When I began my contribution, I alluded to my consternation with crime. The carnage is a matter of grave concern to all Bahamians. There are too many reports of horrific nights of violence and boldface daytime gun slinging. Innocents at both ends of the age spectrum are affected. I spoke about Ms. Kessinger earlier. I now reflect on eight (8) year old Eugene Woodside, who perished in his mother’s arms, the victim of a stray bullet.
Mr. Speaker
“Beyond Tears” was the headline in August that heralded the heartless murder of a sleeping eight-month old Shelton Tinker, Jr.
Within the last four (4) months alone, we have had more than forty (40) murders. Bahamians no longer feel safe. This horrifying rate of killing and bloodshed combined with an alarming rise in armed robberies must be stemmed.
This will surely erode confidence in public institutions mandated to protect public safety and security while threatening our social and economic stability. We cannot allow this phenomenon to continue.
Mr. Speaker
It’s the people’s time and the people remember the Mount Moriah stridently saying that we would be safe with him at the helm because he had the answers to crime. Well, the people look to him now because he said that he understood the criminal mind and could out manoeuvre criminals.
He said all of our policies were all wrong and ineffective. Four months into the job, Bahamians still do not feel safe in their homes, on the streets, or in the workplace.
Crime is both destructive and complex at the same time and is driven by multiple factors including easy access to firearms, high unemployment and substandard living conditions due to a cycle of poverty, a condition too many of our children are forced to live in.
Mr. Speaker
I am not interested in the foolish argument advanced by some apologists about bad boys killing bad boys. That does not give cover to a Government with no plan to fight crime and fails to address the murder of innocent law-abiding citizens and residents.
As the Member for Englerston said, this epidemic of violence requires the Government to go to another level. On an emergency basis they must collaborate with all relevant stakeholders in our country to develop a comprehensive plan that will yield results, both in the immediate short term and in the long term.
This must be done as a matter of urgency and the Official Opposition stands ready to collaborate in this national effort. Let’s get to work!
Mr. Speaker
It would be insensitive of me to close without speaking to issues concerning Hurricane Irma. I commend the Government’s efforts to evacuate our Southern islands. This evacuation, I am certain saved lives. When I visited Ragged Island, I witnessed sheer devastation. “Unliveable” was the headline.
Mr. Speaker
Ragged Islanders are about demonstrate their resilience. They are about to show us how they can rise from ashes. Salina Point too! They will rebuild. I urge Government to assist their efforts.
Mr. Speaker
We cannot fault Ragged Islanders or any other’s reluctance to leave their birthplace. I have said it more than once in this Place. Bahamians have a right to live and work where they choose by virtue of their citizenship. I directed this particularly at Elizabeth before and I do so now with good reason.
Very early, they must learn that the 80 people in Rum Cay – the 72 in Ragged Island – the 700 in the Berry Islands – all have the same rights accruing to them as those who live in New Providence.
They are all citizens. None has priority over another. Each has the right to live where he or she wishes and Government’s obligation to them is to ensure that they have, at minimum, access to essential services; and, where possible, access to enhanced services.
Nothing is too good for any Bahamian. Nothing is too good for Cat Island. Nothing is too good for San Salvador. Nothing is too good for Rum Cay.
Nothing is too good for Ragged Island.
In the same way that our medical personnel will be identified for other countries on a volunteer basis, that proposal should be made for Ragged Island. They are our first priority. They are our constituents. They are why we are here in this Place of Privilege.
Whatever happened to the “Back to the Island Campaign, which [was] anticipated to become the largest migration of Bahamians back to the Family Island”? What an awesome opportunity to start from scratch!
Mr. Speaker
This dovetails into an “I told you so” moment. At the start of this Administration, this side was severely criticised for our decision to demit from making payments to the Caribbean Catastrophe Risk Insurance Facility (CCRIF). We told the Government that experts in the Ministry of Finance, Met Department and the Port Department advised that self-insurance would be more cost beneficial to Government. This came after we were unable to make any successful claims in respect of Hurricane Joaquin.
Up to that time, The Bahamas had been paying premiums in the tens of millions and was unable to collect anything.
Following Matthew, I am advised, CCRIF wrote the Government suggesting that we may have qualified for loss compensation, this suggestion was referred to the team that had advised earlier and it was that team’s considered view that we would not have qualified. The persons who advised us are still in the Public Service.
The Honourable member for Killarney promised this House on several occasions to table the letter received from CCRIF confirming forfeiture of some $33 million but to date has flatly refused to do so.
Mr. Speaker
Ahead of Hurricane Irma, the Prime Minister was pleased to advise that we had expended around $2.8 million. The Bahamas received a reported settlement of $234,000 in post hurricane claims.
Mr. Speaker
I told him so! This is a waste of public resources was the result of rank political posturing rather than adhering to the advice of senior policy experts and technical advisors in the Public Service.
What a painfully humiliating and expensive lesson. Maybe the Member for Killarney will finally reconcile himself to the policy of self-insurance against damages from natural disasters such as hurricanes and tornadoes.
Mr. Speaker
I take the time spent in this Place very seriously. As I mentioned earlier, we are here for very clear reasons – to make laws, to represent and act on behalf of voters and citizens, to scrutinize the work of the Government.
On this side, we are committed to holding Government to account for its promises to the Bahamian people. We have all heard the legislative agenda, which Her Excellency delivered so well.
It’s the people’s time now. So, I admonish Government to put the needs of the Bahamian people first.
Mr. Speaker
I stand for the people of Cat Island, Rum Cay, and San Salvador. With them, I salute Her Excellency for the Speech from The Throne. I look forward to lively, robust and passionate debates on behalf of the Bahamian people. May Almighty God continue to bless the Commonwealth of The Bahamas.
-
Foreign Minister’s UN Address
23 September, 2017
NATIONAL STATEMENT OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF THE BAHAMAS DELIVERED BY THE HON. DARREN HENFIELD, MP, MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF THE BAHAMAS DURING THE 72ND SESSION OF THE UNITED NATIONS GENERAL ASSEMBLY
Mr. President,
On behalf of the people and Government of the Commonwealth of The Bahamas, I congratulate you on your election as President of the 72nd Session of the General Assembly, and I assure you of my country’s full support and co-operation during your tenure.
I also extend sincere congratulations to your predecessor, His Excellency Ambassador Peter Thomson, for his leadership of the Assembly during the 71st Session.
The Bahamas congratulates His Excellency Antonio Guterres on his election as the newest Secretary-General of the United Nations.
He has the daunting task of continuing the implementation of the bold and ambitious Agenda 2030.
I commend him on the work he has done to date in steering the work of the organisation, and wish to assure him of the full support of The Bahamas.
Mr. President,
In the time since the 29th of September 1729, when the first meeting of the Parliament of The Bahamas took place, democratic values have taken deep root throughout the archipelago.
On the 10th of May 2017, The Bahamas conducted its eleventh consecutive round of General Elections since attaining universal suffrage in 1962.
The people of The Bahamas, in a free, peaceful and democratic process, elected a new Government, led by Dr. the Honourable Hubert Minnis.
The new administration is one made up almost exclusively of new members – one as young as 21 years of age. We promised our people bold change, and we are committed to the fulfilment of what we have promised.
We stand on the threshold of advancing a new agenda, as demanded by our people; one that has, at its core, the protection and promotion of the rights, interests and welfare of all Bahamians – women, men, young people and children. I am, therefore, proud today to make my first address to this august body as the most recently-appointed Foreign Minister of the Commonwealth of The Bahamas under this new Administration.
Mr. President,
Economies large and small are facing very difficult times, where myriad factors challenge our capacity to create an environment where people can be assured of sustainable livelihoods, security and safety, and a promising future for succeeding generations.
Very troubling are the insidious increase in international terrorism; unfair practices in the international financial sector, such as de-risking and correspondent banking; illicit crime; trafficking in persons; drug trafficking; trafficking in weapons; gross violations of human rights; and reprehensible corruption by those who have been entrusted to govern.
Especially of concern for small island developing states are the dangers of environmental degradation and climate change, which threaten our very survivability. With what we have witnessed just recently with the passage of Hurricanes Harvey, Irma and now Maria, I cannot underscore sufficiently the importance The Bahamas attaches to combating climate change, and the preservation and protection of the environment.
Even while these Hurricanes were occurring, there have been earthquakes in Mexico, resulting in further tragic loss of life and destruction.
Climate change is global.
We have expressed before, and today we reiterate, our thoughts and prayers to all adversely impacted by these devastating events.
Mr. President,
I need to emphasise that this is the third time in three years The Bahamas has been hit by a major hurricane and Maria is still churning in our territory.
There are two more months before the end of the hurricane season, and we can only pray that we will be spared from further destruction and loss.
Hurricane Irma changed course and did not directly hit the entire Bahamian archipelago, thus minimizing the impact on our tourism industry. However, we were not entirely spared.
Our southern islands experienced serious damage, Ragged Island was totally devastated and is now uninhabitable. Additionally, tornadoes inflicted considerable damage on the northern islands of Bimini and Grand Bahama.
We are grateful to our international partners who provided immediate support after the passage of Hurricane Irma, and now continue to stand by our side as we begin the painful and burdensome process of restoration and rebuilding. I commend you, Mr. President, and the Secretary-General for convening the recent High-Level Meeting to allow those of us impacted to bring focus on these events to other potential partners.
One of the countries immediately affected by Hurricane Irma was the Republic of Cuba, which, as on previous occasions, caused this massive hurricane to lose some of its energy and probably led to a lesser impact on our neighbour, the United States of America. All developing countries affected have been placed on a short-list for assistance to shore up their internal conditions towards recovery.
Cuba does not enjoy this capacity to the fullest. The Bahamas joins other nations in calling for the Congress of the United States to reconsider the legislative barriers to the biggest of the Caribbean islands in order for it to develop to its fullest potential as a member of the international community.
Mr. President,
Hence, it is the intention of the Government, working with the private sector, to create out of the destruction of Ragged Island the first fully green island in the region, utilising renewable energy and smart technologies from solar energy to sustainable water purification systems to create a more sustainable, resilient, island community.
The implications for the existence of SIDS like The Bahamas, as we are confronted with global warming, rising sea-levels, and more severe and frequent hurricanes and other extreme weather events, are all too clear. For the first time in its history, The Bahamas evacuated whole communities to safe quadrants ahead of Hurricane Irma. What’s next: wholesale evacuation of the entire Caribbean?
I call on the international community to recognise the imperative of accelerating the efforts to deal urgently with the adverse impact of climate change and to do so in a co-ordinated way.
Only then will we mitigate against these ferocious and frequent destructive weather events, which now potentially threatens to add to the world’s migration issues.
Mr. President,
Well over two decades ago, my Government, recognising the very real threat posed to our very existence, upgraded its human capital capacity to address the unintended consequences of climate change, as well as its commitment to environmental conservation.
Through its many marine protected areas, The Bahamas is committed to the conservation of sustainable oceans, as well as through our active involvement in initiatives such as 10X20, and our participation in the consultative process of Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction.
In this context, The Bahamas has presented its candidature once again for a seat on the Council of the International Maritime Organisation in Category “C”.
Mr. President,
The continuing imperative for us in The Bahamas and the Caribbean, is the re-evaluation of the measurements used to determine economic well-being.
The IMF in its Policy Brief on “Vulnerability and Debt in Small States” recognised that “Many [SIDS] face an uncertain future.”
The Bahamas continues to dispute the use of Per Capita GDP/GNP as an instrument to measure wealth and economic development.
The use of this one-dimensional instrument prohibits countries that are most in need to receive development assistance or loans at concessional rates. It is time for us to replace that metric with a realistic measurement that takes into account the vulnerability and fragility of SIDS to exogenous shocks.
Mr. President,
Notwithstanding our best efforts at self-sufficiency, exogenous shocks, in the form of reduced correspondent banking relationships, continue to create challenges for the region.
International banking institutions, fearing that they may be subject to fines and sanctions related to illicit activities of money laundering and terrorist financing, have pulled out en masse.
Citizens in our region depend of the services provided by these entities, and have now become severely disadvantaged as a result of the actions taken.
This threatens our ability to remain competitive as one of the leading international centres and hinders our efforts to expand our trading relationships.
The Head of the IMF, Ms. Christine Lagarde, spoke convincingly in 2016 on the subject of correspondent banking, highlighting that all stakeholders had to uphold their end of the bargain.
For its part, The Bahamas has invested in a strong compliance regime, at great financial costs. We invite the international community to work together to find another way to deal with the issue and allow input from those to be impacted by their decisions before moving the goalposts again.
Despite the challenges faced, the Government of The Bahamas remains committed to a comprehensive development agenda for the country. With the launch of the National Development Plan Vision 2040 in the coming months, we will set a course towards the achievement of the SDGs.
In this connection, The Bahamas has committed to participating in the Voluntary National Review process at the High-Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development under the auspices of the Economic and Social Council in 2018.
We appreciate the support of the UNDP and the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean in this regard. Indeed, it is through this anticipated integrated framework that we address the range of challenges that face our nation.
Mr. President,
The scourges of terrorism and trafficking in arms of all types continue to impact our way of life. The Bahamas reaffirms its commitment to stand with the international community in fighting terrorism in all its forms.
We also stand in solidarity with the peoples of France, Spain, Belgium and the United Kingdom who have recently experienced horrific terrorist attacks.
Violence in the furtherance of “political” aims is never the answer. Only through dialogue and negotiations will aspirations be realised.
Mr. President,
I spoke earlier about the importance of accountability, truth and transparency in government and the rule of law to good governance. It has been said that,
“Corruption is a global phenomenon found in all countries – but evidence shows it harms poor people more than others, stifles economic growth and diverts desperately needed funds from education, healthcare and other public services. An estimated one trillion US dollars get siphoned off through bribes every year according to the World Bank.”
The Government of The Bahamas has firmly committed itself to eradicating corruption. We are resolved to have in place an efficient, results-based public sector, with an Office of the Ombudsman, in order to create the best environment possible to promote economic development, foreign direct investment, small business development and equal opportunity for all to share in prosperity.
Mr. President,
The role of the United Nations in advancing human rights has been essential.
The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a series of international instruments, human rights operations on the ground, and the various human rights bodies, such as the Human Rights Council, permit the United Nations to continue as a beacon to promote and protect human rights through both immediate and long-term action.
In The Bahamas, we are committed to protecting and promoting the rights of all Bahamians, and, indeed, all human kind. The achievements of The Bahamas relative to human rights have derived from collaboration with all stakeholders, and a willingness to explore fresh approaches to longstanding challenges.
Within this context, I am pleased to announce that The Bahamas is seeking election to the Human Rights Council for the term 2019-2021. As a member of the Council, as a SIDs, The Bahamas will bring to that body a fresh, distinct and constructive perspective, with the potential to add depth and richness to human rights advancement and discourse.
Mr. President,
The Government of the Bahamas believes that education must be at the heart of driving sustainable development, where we build resilience and an educated, inclusive and diverse workforce and community. This has positive implications for creativity, innovation and productivity that allow learners and youth to fulfil the potential to act as agents of social change.
For this reason, our Government has designed an Education Agenda, which encourages lifelong learning and recognises the potential of technology and digital platforms to serve as tools in the teaching and learning process.
I take this opportunity to bring to the attention of the Assembly that The Bahamas, in recognition of the invaluable role of technology and communications in education and all aspects of development, has presented its candidature for a seat on the Council of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU).
Mr. President,
The New York Declaration for Refugees and Migrants, adopted in September 2016 by the General Assembly, called for the development of a global compact for safe, orderly and regular migration.
We commend the ongoing work in preparation for the global compact. While recognising the potential yields of global migration relative to the reduction of poverty and global inequality, we believe that proper co-operation, through the appropriate mechanisms, can help to ensure that migration occurs through safe and regulated channels, to the benefit of all involved countries.
Mr. President,
The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development recognises non-communicable diseases (NCDs) as a major challenge for sustainable development. The UN General Assembly’s third High-Level Review Meeting on NCDs in 2018 will provide the opportunity for a renewed political commitment to take concrete actions to address the challenge of NCDs as a matter of priority, including sustained engagement at a high-level to co-ordinate on strategies to achieve targets and to mobilise necessary financing.
We also recognise the successes experienced in global AIDS response, and caution the international community, at this important juncture, to resist complacency and continue to offer support to achieve targets and to sustain the Joint Programme relative to HIV/AIDS.
Mr. President,
The Bahamas supports the work of Peacekeeping Operations and the Department under which it falls, as a fundamental instrument to build, protect and maintain peace and security within the United Nations.
We note the approach of the termination of the mandate of the United Nations Stabilisation Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) and the establishment of the United Nations Mission for Justice Support in Haiti. As was the case with MINUSTAH, The Bahamas looks forward to doing its part to support Haiti’s continued national development.
We also enjoin the continued support and engagement of the international community in Haiti.
Mr. President,
During the main session, the General Assembly will consider and approve the Programme-Budget for the biennium 2018-2019.
It is our expectation that the General Assembly will, in a transparent and constructive manner, approve a budget that aligns with the mandates and activities of the United Nations.
We welcome the Secretary-General’s initial efforts to promote management reform aimed at strengthening service delivery.
We encourage the Secretary-General, in the execution of the budget, to continue to find innovative means to advance an efficient implementation of mandates, but without arbitrary cuts.
Mr. President,
The Bahamas values the role of the United Nations as the custodian of the interests of the world’s people, in particular the poor and the vulnerable.
We believe that the United Nations Charter remains a viable and firm foundation onto which global peace and security, social progress and economic development can be built.
I thank you.
-
Address by Chester Cooper MP
I. Chester Cooper MP, Exumas & Ragged Island,
Speech to thank Her Excellency the Governor General for the Speech from the throneMr. Speaker,
I rise to thank God for the opportunity to once again address this great House of Assembly, on behalf of the wonderful people of Exumas and Ragged Island who I represent in this place. It gives me great honour to thank Her Excellency the Governor General for delivering the speech from the throne.Let me say though that the timing of this resolution to thank Her Excellency is incredibly bad form.
Her Excellency, radiant, eloquent and gracious, read this speech in the precincts of Parliament four months ago.
She braved the hot May sun to deliver this voluminous tome and this House has failed to conduct itself with the decency that should be afforded her office by waiting until the end of summer, for some unknown reason, just to say thank you, let alone debate its contents.
We call that “no manners”, “no manners” Mr Speaker, that’s what we call it in Little Exuma where I come from.
We must do better next time.In any event, it has been more than four months and most Bahamians, like myself, are probably still waiting to hear what the plan is from this administration to grow the economy, create jobs and solve our national challenges like crime.
Having said that, it has only been four months, and while I would have hoped for more, I acknowledge it takes time to accomplish much in government.
So, I’ll try not to judge my colleagues too harshly despite my gut feeling and disillusionment that there really isn’t a plan to move the country forward. You see Mr. Speaker, as a Newbie Member of Parliament I came eager to work. I listened to Minister after Minister talked about how the country is in free-fall; so what do they do – they took a 10-week vacation. To add insult to injury we return to very little legislative agenda, no real Bills presented to create jobs, grow the economy or address the national challenges facing the Bahamian people.
Regarding the speech from the throne, Mr. Speaker, I don’t have the time required to go through all of it promise by promise, as there are scores of them, so I’ll stick more closely to the things that concern my portfolio as shadow minister for finance, financial services & industry and what affects more specifically the Family Islands; The Exuma and Ragged Island in particular.I counted nearly 80 promises in the speech from the throne. Some good, some quite vague, some are bad ideas, and some I don’t get, because I’m pretty sure they already exist, and others that given all that has been said in this place and outside this place since May 24th , I fail to see how they can be accomplished.
The Good
For instance, Mr. Speaker, the government says it will endeavour to establish mechanisms to include and engage the Bahamian Diaspora in the fulfilment of our national interests and development. This is a good thing.
They’ve repeated it often; haven’t really said how they’ll do it, but if they can accomplish it even a little, it will be a positive step forward in starting to stem the brain drain the country is experiencing.Let’s look at another good thing in the speech. Don’t look so surprised, my critiques are coming, but you have a few good ideas in here. I like you all, you know? I want you to do well for the Bahamian people. I’m trying to help.
Another good thing in the speech is the promise that this administration will provide for a portion of the revenue collected by the Islands to be used to address local needs. Now that, Mr. Speaker, is a good idea. Exuma collects tens of millions of dollars in tax revenue for the public treasury yet only gets a local government allocation of $400,000 per year.
Again, no one has said how they will do this, or when, but if they do it, it will truly assist Family Islands like Exuma in their development. And I’m also ready and willing to give my input when the time for planning comes. Hopefully, sooner rather than later.So those were a couple of good things.
Now let’s talk about some of the stuff that doesn’t add up and seem like empty promises.
This administration says in the speech it will strengthen the sales and marketing team in our network of Bahamas Tourist Offices across the United States, Canada and Europe. Now, to me, and I do stand to be corrected, that has not happened. I seem to recall the government reducing staffing in these areas and closing some offices.
Now if, by strengthening, you mean hiring a foreign firm to do what Bahamians were doing, then OK. I don’t agree with it, but OK.But I have a better idea than this. How about someone, anyone, display some focus on attracting Foreign Direct Investment to our shores? Where is the attention to this? What has been done in the past four months? Perhaps we can get a communication of some sort on FDI?
I also have an issue with the lack of initiatives for Family Islands.
I see where the government says it will launch the rebound of the island of Grand Bahama in accordance with the template of a master strategic plan designed for Grand Bahama.Is this the plan where a major hotel on Grand Bahama was supposed to be renovated and the government was going to take a stake in it and it was going to be open and providing jobs by now?
That plan? Because we still don’t have any update on that and I know the hotel isn’t open or being renovated, despite what the prime minister said in his national address.So, not only is this fantastical plan, that I can’t locate, for Grand Bahama not happening, our Family Islands have no tangible plans laid out by this government either.
Exuma
Now, just a reminder, I have an eVision 2030 plan for Exuma already all laid out. You don’t have to do anything but help me implement it. I’ll provide each member of this place with a copy to peruse. I don’t mind it becoming the blue print for family island development because I truly believe that the future of the Bahamas lies in the Family Islands.The Exuma Int’l Airport Mr. Speaker is not only a national disgrace but it’s an impediment to further development on the island. Major international developers committed to spending hundreds of millions of dollars are delaying investment in Exuma as a result of lack of action. I am advised that the previous Gov’t left funding in place for Airports at Exuma, North Eleuthera and Bimini. We ask the Gov’t to get on with it, as this is also an opportunity to create jobs.
While we’re at it, I note where the government says it will also review and give consideration to the ownership of taxi license plates by persons who have been leasing those plates for many years. This is weak tea. Sure it will help some, but on Exuma, for example, we need new taxi plates, new SD plates. There’s an entire economy waiting to blossom. Entrepreneurs not looking for any hand-out from the government waiting to get into business or expand their business to better the lives of their families and improve the tourist product. Remember, eVision 2030. It’s a solid plan. I’ll send copies.
The government also says it will repeal and replace the Grand Bahama (Port Area) Investment Incentives Act 2016;
It says it will focus on the development of Freeport as an off shore technology hub;
It says it will promote Grand Bahama as a primary location for the local and international film and television industries;
It says it will create incentives to establish a financial services centre in Grand Bahama.
Grand Bahama, Grand Bahama, Grand Bahama.Now, I like Grand Bahama, a lot, and it is in desperate need of recovery, [I listened to the cries of Pineridge yesterday] but I have to tell you, the number of mentions about Grand Bahama and the lack of mentions of Family Islands has some of us feeling a little left out.
Although this government does say it will renew the Family Island Incentives Act to promote inter-island trade. Pretty vague, and nothing new, but I’m listening whenever someone wants to start talking about it.Mr. Speaker, the government says it will establish a One-stop-shop to improve the ease of doing business in The Bahamas for entrepreneurs. Like they say in the commercial, “there’s an app for that”. The previous administration already had a plan for a small and medium size enterprises development agency. Just go implement that. It already had built in provisions for ease of doing business on Family Islands as well. SMEDA, go check it out. You’ll see that all this waiting around just isn’t necessary. We need action, people are hurting across our Bahamaland.
The government also says it will grant tax inducements or incentives to Bahamians comparable to or in line with those given to foreign investors. Is there some discriminatory practice in law in this regard that I’m not aware of? Bahamians aren’t getting these now? This is one I need help with.
The Minnis administration says it will enact legislation to ensure that there are standards applied to import products that Bahamians consume as well as to products manufactured here.
Again, I don’t get it. A Standards Bureau already exists. Are we going to create another one? Just for fun? Why would you do that?My time is limited, so let’s talk about some of things that I was actually looking forward to that were promised but have, by now, apparently been abandoned. Or, let’s use a gentler term – indefinitely delayed.
• Pre-school learning for all two and a half year olds – abandoned, I mean, indefinitely delayed
• Ensure the availability of adequately staffed and equipped pre-school facilities in all Family Islands where practicable – abandoned, I mean, indefinitely delayed
• Enhance the provision of Specialty Education to ensure equity in education and employability of students with special needs – abandoned, sorry about that, indefinitely delayed
• Implement a pilot program for single gender classes at the Junior High School Level – abandoned, I mean, indefinitely delayed. Basically, are we doing the last five points by laying off educators, getting people out of the education system that we still need?
• Provide easy and affordable health care throughout The Bahamas – abandoned, I mean, indefinitely delayed
• Extend the focus of NHI to secondary and tertiary health care – abandoned, I mean, indefinitely delayed
• Oversee the incremental implementation of a progressive and functional National Catastrophic Health Insurance Program – abandoned, I mean, indefinitely delayed
The promise to institute Urban Development by revitalizing inner city communities – this one I don’t get. I don’t want to say it’s abandoned because Urban Renewal already exists. But if you were talking about an all-new program – then we’re going to have to put that in the indefinitely delayed column.
• Create tax-free economic zones – we all know that hasn’t happened and of course, no mention of elimination of VAT on bread basket items. I wonder if this is an oversight since it was such a popular talking point during the campaign. But abandoned and indefinitely delayed.
• This Gov’t said that the PLP stole the VAT money. Then their Chairman said we know that was untrue. Then the Minister promised a report to this Parliament. BUT this administration promised Bahamian people a full report on where the VAT money gone. That seems to be indefinitely delayed as well.Mr. Speaker,
I’d like to now turn to the economy, and I refer to communications in the house by my friend the Honourable Minister of Finance and Member from East Grand Bahama.Recently in this place, we heard a lengthy presentation by the minister of finance, where basically the FNM administration patting itself on the back while giving a report on the IMF Article IV consultations and the Moody’s downgrade review.
Mr. Speaker, the communication was essentially a summary of the IMF and Moody’s recent assessments of the Bahamian economy and contains little or no indication of any concrete plans that are under consideration to stimulate economic growth and reduce unemployment.
There was no mention of the type of policy stimulus that is needed to jump-start our major economic sectors of Tourism, Financial Services and Construction.
For example, is there a need to re-focus tourism marketing in light of the hurricane impact on the south eastern U.S. states and the Caribbean?
Is there a need to adjust the financial services model in light of the recent decision of The Bahamas to adopt the multi-lateral approach to the Common Reporting Standards of the OECD? Perhaps some focused attention on streamlining and modernizing even more the services of the Registrar General, the Immigration Department and give focused attention to making the Bahamas a mid-shore destination rather than keeping the connotations of an offshore “tax haven” reputation. No such thing from the Minister. The OECD’s next big initiative is BEPS (base erosion and profit shifting). We must get ahead of this, be proactive and modernize our business license tax perhaps, leveraging the change to create incentives for real international business to domicile in the Bahamas. We have some work to do in Financial Services, Gov’t must provide the appropriate support.By the way Mr. Speaker, the PLP does not support the implementation of income tax, and we do not equivocate or waffle on the subject. We do support a consolidation and maximizing and enhancement of efficiency of existing taxes and swift reforms to the archaic business license tax.
On page 20 of the Minister’s communication he seem to accept a link between his budget communication and the Moody’s review.
Mr. Speaker, I am a humble boy from Forbes Hill, Little Exuma but I am not so humble that I cannot throw in an “I told you so” when one is fitting.
I told the member for East Grand Bahama that his budget presentation was the wrong speech at the wrong time and in the wrong place.
And we barely escaped the downgrade, and only by promising to fire people and slash budgets.
So, I told you so.
Mr. Speaker, I want this administration to do well, and so let me say it again and again.
In order to get the Bahamas back on track, we must get the economy growing again. The government must outline and implement an aggressive economic growth plan.
And in an economy such as this, economic growth can be induced either by government intervention in the short term by expenditure on meaningful projects or, by allowing the private sector to spend on projects by providing the appropriate incentives and ensuring the availability of credit.
Unfortunately, to date, the government has not seen fit to pursue either path.
Ragged Island
Finally, Mr. Speaker, let me close by saying a few words about my beloved Ragged Island.
The community was hard hit, but it is already on its way to recovery. Ragged Islanders are resilient people. You may agree that Ragged Island has produced more professional per capita than most islands of the Bahamas; when you consider names like Maycock, Munroe, Lockhart, Wallace, Wilson, Moxey, Curling, Pintard and Others. They are emboldened to rebuild – and quickly. Contrary to some information received by this house, I wish to emphasize that the clean-up including the removal of debris from public places and animal carcasses to date has be led and executed by Ragged Islanders, their families and descendants are emboldened to rebuild their homesteads. I commend the people of Ragged Island for taking initiative and their resolve. Residents and the Association are in fact interested and are actively charting a proposed master plan for the island in hopes of making it the model for recovery in the region. We look forward to collaborating with the Government, the Association of Descendants and residents to BUILD BACK BETTER. I assure the good people of Ragged Island that I will stand with them long after the cameras have left the scene.In closing, I send a special shout out to the 59,000 thousand Bahamians who voted for the PLP and the thousands more who now wish they did. We only have 55 more months left so I say in the words of Isaiah: “They that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength, they shall mount up with wings as eagles, they shall run and not be weary, and they shall walk and not faint”. 55 months or less Mr. Speaker. 55 months or less.
I thank you for this opportunity, and though it took long enough, I support the resolution to thank Her Excellency the Governor General for delivering the speech from the throne. May God bless and keep her.
May God Bless Exuma, Exuma Cays & Ragged Island and May God Bless the Commonwealth of The Bahamas. -
2017 Budget Presentation by Senator, Hon., J.L. Coleby-Davis
2017 Budget Presentation
Senator, Hon., J.L. Coleby-Davis- Opposition Senator and Shadow Attorney General, Shadow Minister of Legal Affairs, and Youth
Madam President,
I feel extremely blessed to formally address this place for the very first time. Additionally, I count this a privilege and one of my most proud moments as a young professional; to have been afforded this opportunity to take part in the continued effort to build, empower and unite this great country, the Commonwealth of The Bahamas. I pray that God grants me continued favor and my contributions in this place will be beneficial to the betterment of the Bahamian society, and by extension the Bahamian people.
I wish to extend praise and adoration to the Heavenly Father, who has instilled in me the faith and confidence to be fearless, work hard and reach for the sky, because it is indeed the limit!
To Her Excellency Dame Marguerite Pindling, THANK YOU for presenting to me the instrument of appointment to the Senate.
I am so pleased to send THANK YOU to the Leader of the Opposition, The Hon. Philip “Brave” Davis for inviting me and entrusting in me, the opportunity to be an opposition Senator. I am honored and extremely grateful to the officers and members of the Progressive Liberal Party, National General Council, Progressive Young Liberals, my good friend Ryan Oneal and all those that have personally reached out to lend their assistance; your words of encouragement, support and guidance have assisted me in my preparations.
Madame President,
I wish to extend further congratulations to all of my colleagues represented here today, inclusive of the side opposite. To the Attorney General, Hon. Carl Bethel, I extend congratulations for your appointment. To the leader of opposition Senate, I am so honored to serve in this place with you. I wish to also thank those that have already contributed, even if at times we disagree, I wish to remind you that we are all here to work for the people and that is a job I take seriously.
To my Bishop Helen McPhee and the Agape Church, thank you for your continued prayers.
To my family, friends, and the people across the waters in the Turks and Caicos Islands, thank you for your love and support.
To the people of this great country, to the Bahamian people, THANK YOU, for your love and support, from near and far.
To my beautiful, loving and caring family, my parents Pastor Wayde and Irma Coleby, my sisters, Tameka Hadley, Owenta Coleby, Angel Taylor and Crystal Coleby and my in-laws Donavon Davis Sr. and Suzanne Davis, words cannot describe the LOVE and GRATITUDE I hold in my heart for you. THANK YOU for everything that you have done, and what you will continue to do in the future.
Lastly, THANK YOU to the man that stole my heart many years ago and keeps my soul smiling, to my husband, Donavon A. Davis Jr. For always pushing me to higher heights, for your continued words of encouragement, for your friendship and always lending your support to many of the ideas and plans that enter my mind, THANK YOU.
I also would like to send Happy Belated Father’s Day to ALL Father’s, especially my Father Wayde Tyrone Coleby and my father-in-law Donavon A. Davis Sr.
Lastly, congratulations to all the recent graduates in the Commonwealth of The Bahamas. I wish to encourage them to take pride in their talents and gifts, work hard and strive to be better than you were yesterday.
Madam President,
As a representative of the millennial, I find my position in this place very important. At every obstacle in my life, I have always faced rejection; so much so, that rejection was my expectation, in fact, I perceived it to be the norm. Everything else was gained through hard work that someone finally noticed or my blessing from the man upstairs. Therefore, this appointment as an opposition Senator is not seen to me as a struggle, as I have come to the conclusion that my blessings will continually come in the most unique and unexpected packages. As a result, I am here to embrace and work for the Bahamian people.
Madam President,
I have thought long and hard about what my platform in this place. As I am presently wearing a number hats and in my life, and this appointment just added another hat. Madam President, I am by profession an attorney, we are trained in this honorable and ethical profession, to be truthful, respectful, confidential, but most importantly to give responsible representation of our clients. On my job my client is Bahamas Petroleum Company, in my personal life as a wife, my client is my husband, and now with this appointment to this place my clients are the Bahamian people. Therefore, Madam President, it took quite some time for me to find my bearings, as I wish to represent all of my clients in the most honorable, honest and REAL way.
Madam President,
I listened attentively during this budget debate, because I was taught at a very young age to ‘listen to understand and not to respond’ and so I do my best to uphold that practice throughout my life. Therefore, if at any time I may have misunderstood the contributions of any Member in the other place or anyone in this place, I will gladly accept correction. In any event, listening to understand is a very important trait one can have, so I listened!
Madame President
I then read and reviewed the budget upon receipt of the package. I looked over the reductions and concessions, I even reached out to persons that may be more adversely affected by many of the changes and I inquired on their particular feelings.
I spoke to millennials on both sides of the political divide and challenged them on some of the issues raised. See, because I do not wish to express only my concerns, I aspired to allow persons to vent and raise issues, which I may have not raised or thought about.
Here is what I concluded:
Madame President,
I respectfully commit that this budget is flawed and lacks MANY of the promises that gave the middle and lower class hope, faith and trust in the new Government. After, days and days of deliberation, I summarize to say that this is a BLATANT slap in the face to middle and lower class, VERY stingy for the rich man and one can only assume the campaign promises was THE ART OF DECEPTION.
This Budget is filled with big words, huge insults, unsupported allegations, and percentages, projections and more percentages.
What it lacks, Madam President is the growth which was promised to the Bahamian people, it lacks the plans and road maps to ease the way of doing business and bring the anticipated tax relief to the Bahamas. It does not discuss in any detail the way forward…oh wait that was the PLP slogan –Forward Together. Let me rephrase that, what it lacks is the answer to one very important question, WHEN DOES THE PEOPLE TIME START?
To that end, it is very clear that this Government has No PLANS, Just ideas!!! And ideas are not worth the paper they are written on, if there is not an effective plan to follow!!
Furthermore, to detract from the inadequacy of this administration having no plans, the BEST strategy this FNM Government can come up with, (which is from the usual FNM playbook) is when all else fail, let’s just ATTACK THE PLP! Keep talking about bad this and bad that, don’t worry about providing any substantial evidence to back these claims up, ATTACK is the order of the day.
In fact, this Government seems to think they are still on the rally stage, I heard the Prime Minister say, there is a particular calm over the Bahamas since the general elections, so I am left to wonder, are the recent crimes and murders are being committed calmly? Madam President, we must get SERIOUS about the work of the people! I wish to advise the Government that Play time is over, as kids we would say, ALL FUN AND JOKES ASIDE, let’s get SERIOUS. FNM, let’s get serious, time up for play, IT IS TIME TO GOVERN. In case you are confused, YOU WON, GAME OVER FOR THE PLP, until 2022 or before. BUT YOU WON, YOU ARE THE GOVERNMENT! Don’t bother pinching yourself, 35-4; you are in the winning seat. I beg you, please take this country off of auto-pilot, and drive us into a future filled with greater accountability, good governance, and transparency, as promised.
Madame President, additionally, if this government was serious to get the work started from day one, they would have rolled out plans, NOT IDEAS, plans that can effect change. Let me guess, your argument is the PLP left the country in a bad state, right?
If that is the case, then I have a few questions. There is a saying amongst millennial and it goes; asking for a friend; WELL I AM ASKING FOR A COUNTRY, and by extension the Bahamian People. Madam President, we wish to determine the answers to these questions:
During the year 2012-2017, was the then opposition in hibernation? Did the Minister of Finance just relocate to the Bahamas from space?
Where was the Minister of Finance, when his government borrowed to remediate the Landfill and DID NOTHING substantial?
Again, where was the Minister when the now Prime Minister admitted that the FNM left the country in a wheelchair?
Oh and this is very important one, Where was the Minister when the mid-year budget was presented that spoke to the projections increasing to over $350 million due to Hurricane Mathew?
Madam President
While this budget so eloquently took us down memory lane, lambasting the PLP administration, and what they did so wrong, it also ignores and excludes the largest of our Bahamian populace. One would think that if it truly important for this FNM government to bring tax relief and lower the burden on the middle and lower class, the focus and priority of this budget would have been to ensure they implement if not all, some of the plans to start the process of tax reform. I submit, Madam President, that once the FNM Government received the first draft of the previous administration budget, they adopted SOME of the previous administration policy, and input the parts of their policy which were important to them. I go further to say, they made “THEIR PEOPLE” the priority, and I will speak further on who their people are later in my contribution.
There is a familiar quote that I will use at this instance, by Abraham Lincoln, you can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time. Madam President, this budget did not fool me.
REFORM OF PUBLIC SPENDING
Madam President,
I now turn to discuss reform of the public spending. Madam President, I am of the view that this budget does not represent the policies or promises of this FNM Government. Borrowing a billion dollars does not appear to be reforming of the public spending. Actually, a song comes to mind whenever I look at this budget; a song by Shirley Bassey titled “Big Spender”. Yes, that’s what this appears to be, we are now dealing with some BIG SPENDERS.
For this reason, I can only predict that this FNM budget may inflict further taxation, fees and penalties on the Bahamian public. If not a new tax, they are heading down a road that will lead to a potential increase the VAT percentage, in order to avoid a possible recession.
In fact, during the campaign, the FNM said that it was irresponsible for the Christie Administration to borrow $2 billion over a period of 5 years! Can you believe that the same FNM that called the PLP irresponsible for borrowing $2 billion in FIVE YEARS; has just asked the Bahamian people to approve the borrowing of 1 billion dollars in just 3 weeks.
Madam President,
If the FNM feels the PLP acted irresponsibly with borrowing $2 billion over 5 years, I wish to ask, does this government intend to borrow less than $1 billion for the remainder of their term in office?? I hope so, or otherwise, by its own admission, it would be acting irresponsibly and by its campaign rhetoric, should either resign from office or invite the Bahamian people to FIRE THEM come 2022 or before.
BROKEN PROMISES, REALITY SETTING IN
Madam President, I turn now to discuss broken promises and reality. Madam President, this FNM Government, under the wise council of I don’t know who, went on the rally stage and promised a number of items to the middle and lower class of our society. Promises that if they are successful in pulling them off, would be impressive; granted they have also made a commitment to reduce spending and retain revenue in the economy. However, it appears that many of those promises were JUST IDEAS, and this recent Budget communication shows that they have yet to determine a PLAN and a way forward to implement such tax relief. What is astonishing, Madam President, is that the FNM INSIST that all of those promises will be fulfilled, when in fact at the very opportunity to bring some relief to those that truly need it, they blatantly excluded that part of society in this first budget.
Madam President
What is more disheartening was witnessing the tax relief that has been granted to those that does not need it, and reading articles of them celebrating. The shocking amendments to Business Licence Act, grants a reduction of .25% to companies with a turnover of $50 million and above, so these companies now only pay a 1.25% tax per annum on their turnover.
Madam President,
Let me break that down further, if you own a company which earns a turnover above $50 million or more, then you receive a tax break. Therefore, I ask, WHAT ABOUT MY OVER-DA-HILL PEOPLE? They are going to need “dat lil ting!”
What happen to those persons that were promised immediate relief on taxes upon bringing this FNM Government to power?
Madam President,
On behalf of the Bahamian people, I ask:
Where is the elimination of VAT on breadbasket items? I submit that the people of “The People’s Time” Bahamas, need “Dat lil ting”.
Where is the VAT off of electricity? I submit that the people of “The People’s Time” Bahamas, need “Dat lil ting”.
Where is the tax-free zones promised to the Over-da-hill community? Again, I submit that the people of “The People’s Time” Bahamas, need “Dat lil ting”.
Where is the application form for Free UB Education for all? I submit that the people of “The People’s Time” Bahamas, need “Dat lil ting”.
Madam President,
I ask further, was it necessary to use this first budget to give tax relief to the businessman that can afford to operate without such relief?
This FNM government action is so blatant, and the beneficiaries follow the same protocol. In fact, one businessman celebrated publicly, stating, that as a result of the proposed tax relief his business gets to enjoy a savings of some $444,000. He didn’t stop there, Madam President, the article went further to state that he, the Businessman, have a choice of whether the profits will go back to the Consumer? What? Man, come on, that should have been an automatic! It should have went something like this, oh wow, I have a tax break, since we are saving so much money, let me help you THE CONSUMER save! But no, this Businessman needs to think a little more about how he will enjoy this tax relief and will decide later if, at all, there will be some relief passed on to the consumer! Madam President, I must then ask, where is the Consumer Protection? This Government must look into bringing a Consumer Protection Act, implementing this Act and ENFORCING THIS ACT!
Because, as I stare longer at the obvious, I can only assume that the FNM campaign strategy was to HOODWINK AND BAMBOOZLE THE BAHAMIANS.
OR, Madam President, it might be that we were all mistaken, in that, “The People” who they spoke of were a special interest group of not “A FEW GOOD MEN”, but “A FEW WEALTHY FNM MEN”! Madam President, this Budget reminds me of that scripture in Proverbs 22:16 and it says He that oppresseth the poor to increase his riches, and he that giveth to the rich, shall surely come to want. FNM oh FNM, be very careful the perceptions you are creating in this first budget!
LACK OF VISION OR PLANNING FOR THE FUTURE
Madam President, I turn now to discuss the lack of vision or planning. I viewed this budget and listened to the contributions, and upon adjournment, I was left wondering, WHAT ARE THE PLANS FOR ECONOMIC GROWTH? This Government better get serious with governing this country and get serious VERY FAST, otherwise they will be met with lots of challenges and very little time to fulfill them! I remind the governing party in this place that millennials are very impatient by nature, and we are the microwave society, which is a double-edged sword. However, I remind this FNM government that they have approximately 45-50 months to govern! It is no excuse, to blame the PLP that is not good enough! The Bahamian Economy, not only New Providence, but the entire Bahamian Economy wants to know the plan for ECONOMIC GROWTH. However, this FNM government seems to be figuring their way through the maze of Reality, on the corner of No Plans and down the Highway of How TO GOVERN. Therefore, as an impatient millennial, here are some things they should think on in terms of growing the economy:
- ACCESS TO FUNDING! There needs to be a link between foreign direct investors and Bahamians, the local banks are not cutting; this government need to remove that barrier and allow Bahamians access to REAL FUNDING, MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR FUNDING, found in the International Stock Markets!
- Expand the government contribution to other industries, including by not limited to Agriculture, Maritime, marine and Cultural Sectors. There need to be more information and education of the sectors to encourage growth and promotion. Don’t talk about it, BE ABOUT IT!
- There must be investment in the Non-Hotel Tourism industry through public private partnership. The sort of investors that will build museums, parks (water park, heroes park, etc). It is urgency for the FNM to ensure the necessary public private partnerships are created with Bahamians to build on the many ideas that exist in the Bahamas, to empower and create Entrepreneurs. At this time, I wish to state I saw the Prime Minister state on the news the intention to create a museum that display junkanoo and cultural artifacts, I look forward to this project and hope that many Bahamians from various backgrounds and expertise are allowed to be apart and gain from this project.
- Madam President, the Government must work hard to REMOVE THE RED TAP & THE BARRIERS of doing business. This FNM government had the perfect opportunity to do something for the Small and Medium Business owners; instead they gave businesses with a turnover above 50 million a tax break. GET REAL AND GOVERN FOR ALL BAHAMIANS!
- There needs to be an impactful Reduction of the CRIME rate, they must increase the size of the force and implement strict rules and policies to eliminate corruption!
- Immigration Reform, the size of our immigration officers must be tripled; it is impossible to speak about building the economy and our borders are continually threatened by illegal immigrants. TRIPLE IMMIGRATION, PROTECT THE BORDERS.
- Unemployment is a serious issue, in order to combat this, we must create jobs. However, there needs to be training for persons who lack the necessary skills to qualify for specific jobs. Therefore, I commend Minister of Labor, for his outspoken support of the National Training Agency, and I look forward to further building up and implementation of that program, created of course by the PLP, the party with the PLANS!
Madame President, I can go on and on, but I digress, and state those points to show the importance of having rather, than ideas. Focus and attention must be placed on the major concerns across the Bahamas as it pertains to growing the economy. This Government has been elected to GOVERN, stop with this party bashing and mudslinging, and get on with presenting PLANS, not ideas!
REDUCTION OF CRIME
Madam President, I must admit, the Minister for National Security had a well edited video during his campaign about how he can turn things around and bring crime at a very low level. Whilst I admit crime is a social ill and all must work together to reduce the rate; it is clear that the Minister has NO PLANS! I saw an article that stated, the Minister of National Security intends to continue NIA, and then I saw another article that stated the Minister of National Security discontinues NIA. I must inquire; does the Minister have a plan?? If so, when will the Minister present those plans to the very anxious people of the People’s Time Bahamas?
However if he does not have a plan, Madam President, I wish to advise that there is no need to scramble, as the PLP has left a very good foundation to build on. In fact, the PLP 2012 administration carried out a number of programs and initiatives to assist with the fight against crime. To name a few, Madam President, the following programmes have been left in place:
- Implemented Swift Justice;
- Urban Renewal Programme;
- Tourism based policing;
- School based policing;
- There are over 70 new cars for the RBPF and 15 new buses;
- More than 200 Police officers has been added to the force;
- More than 150 Prison officers has been added to the prison;
- More than 220 Defense Force Officers have been added to the Defence Force;
- The PLP acquired new sea crafts; and.
- To date hundreds of guns have been seized along with substantial ammunition, substantial cash and significant quantities of cocaine and Marijuana have been seized.
Madame President, this is a very good platform, one that had the FNM been attentive over the last 5 years, they would have an appreciation and a better understanding of the work, cost and time it takes to build a safe and secure environment.
Additionally, Madam President, I ask that the FNM Government focuses on Rehabilitation of Offenders, but most importantly, first time offenders. This Government must give offenders a hope, a future and an expected end. CRIME, PUNISHMENT THEN REHABILITATION is the smart and best approach! I remind those on the governing side in the other place and also in this place, you have approximately 50 months to bring the crime rate to a manageable level. GET TO WORK. STOP WITH THE IDEAS, TELL US THE PLANS!!
Madam President, the PLP 2012 administration introduced a new Correctional Facility Act 2013, which provides the legal framework towards rehabilitation of Offenders. This Act provides the tools to move the Department of Corrections from a Penal Institution to one of Rehabilitation. It is time the Bahamas stop harboring criminals and transition men and women back into the society to give them the second chance they deserve. Nonetheless Madam President, I say to our Minister of National Security in the other place, STOP WITH THE IDEAS AND BUILD ON THE PLP PLANS. They are there for you to use, so take advantage of the hard work that has been implemented by Dr BJ Nottage and Mr. Keith Bell. Just get to work, govern, and build on the foundation laid by the PLP!!
CLIMATE CHANGE AND SUSTAINABILITY
Madam President, I wish to turn to the matter of CLIMATE CHANGE. I wish to stress to the government in the other place and those represented in this place, that CLIMATE CHANGE IS REAL! Let me break it down a little, Climate Change or Global warming, means the earth is getting warmer. However, that does not mean oh great, good weather! That means, oh my, we must get prepared for the domino effect! Climate change will make our weather more unpredictable and extreme. Madam President, as temperatures rise, the following can result:
- More rainfall;
- Melting sea ice;
- Sea level will rise; and
- Changing climates.
Madam President, two of the largest contributors to climate change occurring hear in the Bahamas are, BURNING FOSSIL FUELS, AND DEFORESTATION.
Madame President, as it relates to the burning of fossil fuels, if every Bahamian take a drive on Frank Watson Boulevard, heading west towards Clifton, you will see something that looks like cloudy gray fog going into the atmosphere, coming out of the boilers which burn fossil fuel. Those gases that are being released into the atmosphere act like an invisible shield or blanket trapping heat from the sun and warming up the Earth with its own heat. This is called the Greenhouse Effect, the warmth we would feel is not natural heat from the sun, and it is mostly the heat from the gases released in the atmosphere!
Madam President, I bring this issue forward, because, whilst some are focused on publicly dilly dallying about what they didn’t like about the PLP government, there is a major concern about climate change, even more so, as we are presently once again in Hurricane Season! This season is being projected by meteorologist and experts alike, to be a very active Hurricane Season.
I pray that God grants us mercies this year as we are still trying to recover from the damages of Hurricane Mathew.
Nonetheless, Madam President, this government has to stop with this media frenzy of having pictures taken and headliners that bash the prior administration, it is imperative that the FNM Government GET TO WORK. There is a need for greater focus and attention to be given to the matter of Climate Change. I quote from the Honorable Perry G. Christie stated at the United Nations Small Island Developing States and Sustainable Development Goals symposium, “we do not need any further evidence in the Bahamas that sea will claim the land” because it will and it does during storms.
Madam President, the National Development Plan Secretariat also recognized the importance of mainstreaming the Sustainable Development Goals into the country’s development planning to achieve the 2030 Agenda for Bahamas Sustainable Development. Madam President, this is where the focus should be! This government had the perfect opportunity to show they are different, they are mature and not amateurs, that they understand how to GOVERN and possess THE PLANS to do it! However, they are still wrapped in their efforts continually blame the PLP for everything, instead of getting on with more pressing issues presently in the Bahamian economy. I once again remind the FNM government, you have about 45 to 50 months to prove yourselves, STOP WITH THE IDEAS, AND SHOW ME THE PLANS!
Madam President, I ask that this Government bring some Climate Change legislation to address how we as a developing country will work with the International Organizations to implement preventative measures and contingency plans. I appreciate that the Prime Minister stated in his contribution, his government intention to continue with the National Development Plan, as that will be very helpful and beneficial in preparing the Bahamas for proactive Climate Change preventative measures and sustainable development.
Energy Conservation and Sustainable Development
Madame President, there is a tremendous need for this government to turn their attention to educating the public on Energy Conservation and Sustainable Development. Madame President, I wish to commend the Minister of Environment as I heard him speak in the other place, and it appears he realized that this government had NO PLANS and the manifesto possessed only IDEAS. I say this because much of the Minister’s contribution was a detailed overview all of the plans and programmes implemented by his predecessor. Madam President, it appears to me that the Ministry for the most part will be business as usual, and, in actuality, many of the Ministers will reap from the efficient and effective hard work of the PLP. Additionally, I am most pleased with this outcome because Renewable Energy is the way forward and that was indeed the focus of the PLP administration.
FNM UNTRUTH AND PLP VINDICATION
Madam President, I now turn my focus on the recent vindication of the PLP party following many untruths that were spoken on the FNM rally stage. It is important that I address some of these matters, as I am new to frontline and many millennial’s and aspiring politicians does not appreciate the way in which the FNM campaign lambasted the PLP with PURE AND EGREGIOUS UNTRUTHS! As a result, Madam President, I wish to present the following:
First, FNM UNTRUTH
I quote the Minister of Tourism from the rally stage April 7th, 2017:
“They are thiefing, theifing our VAT money…”
PLP VINDICATION
A quote from the FNM Chairman Collie May 15th, 2017:
“Now, we knew that they didn’t steal the VAT money but they did not live up to their promises.”
FNM UNTRUTH
- Prime Minister Minnis in August 2016 said the PLP had the courts seal the Baha Mar Deal.
PLP VINDICATION
- Prime Minister in the other place said: the deal was sealed by the courts upon the request of the buyer!
- Further, Madam President, the AG on Friday admitted that and I want to quote him, “There are, and we are cognizant of this, other commercially sensitive documents which were sealed at the request of the private parties in the Baha Mar matter, and which remain SEALED.”
- This proves that former AG and former Prime Minister was honest with the Bahamian people in saying that due to “MARKET SENSITIVITY,” the commercial transaction between the two private parties involved in the sale of Baha Mar, CTE and EXIM Bank, had to “remain sealed for the time being” as per the Bahamas Supreme Court – not Mr. Christie.
FNM UNTRUTH
- Minister of Finance said in the budget, the cupboard is bare;
- Further, Minister of Environment says “Our country is Broke; every Bahamian needs to understand that our country is broke with a capital B.”
PLP VINDICATION
- AG Bethel on Friday in this place stated, “The Country is NOT BROKE OR INSOLVENT!”
FNM UNTRUTH
From the campaign trail, scolds of FNM supporters chanted “Dey gern ta jail, Lock Dem UP!”
PLP VINDICATION
AG Bethel state during an interview, and I quote, “… I do not believe that anything that’s been said by anyone in Parliament has gone to the extent of raising any criminal concerns.”
OVER DA HILL REVITALIZATION
Madam President, I now turn my focus to the people of the People’s Time that live Ova Da Hill. Madam President, there were many promises made during the rally, and there is grave concern that some will not be fulfilled. When you consider some discussions that have ensued regarding the revitalization of Ova Da Hill, I begin to think first what about also revitalizing, Gambier? What about Adelaide? Oh, and also what about Fox Hill? All of those communities and more are very important to the History of the Bahamian society. Therefore, I submit, first and foremost, any discussion on revitalization should not exclude, but include the above named communities, along with Ova Da Hill.
First and foremost, Madam President, as it pertains to Ova Da Hill community, the FNM government must initiate a study to determine the owners of the property Ova Da Hill. If the study determines that it is indeed owned by the less fortunate, tax incentives for urbanization can prove beneficial to incentivize development. However, Madam President, if we find that the landlords are wealthy Bahamians, the FNM may consider passing regulations that provides use of land standards, which would require that landlords maintain their property at the appropriate levels.
Madam President, I request that this FNM government ensure that any form of planned urbanization occurs without gentrification! Let me explain, gentrification, is the restoration of run-down urban areas by the middle class, resulting in the displacement of lower-income people. To put it even simpler, gentrification is the arrival of the wealthier people in an existing urban area, i.e., Ova Da Hill, and following their arrivals and them acquiring the land in that community, it becomes unaffordable for the Ova Da Hill people to remain. The FNM government must ensure that any form of revitalization blocks the development of condos, or townhomes or any form of development that will misplace the people of the Ova Da Hill community.
Madam President, additionally, I submit that creating a tax-free zone in the Ova Da Hill community presents a moral dilemma! This is because the less fortunate in New Providence are not concentrated in one specific location. It is stretched across various parts. Additionally, Madam President, small to medium businesses like “Mom and Pop” stores are likewise, not concentrated in one location. Therefore, I query, how can the FNM pass a law giving tax incentives to the small business owner within the tax free zone boundary, and neglect his neighbor, also a small business owner, who would potentially be across the street outside of the determined tax-free boundary?
Madam President, this can also potentially lead to fraud! Again, I query, what enforcement provision and legislation will the FNM implement to accompany this initiative and ensure the wealthy business owners are not defrauding the government and the community?
Lastly, Madam President, there must be assurance to the Ova Da Hill community that savings earned by the business owners in the community, will be properly passed down to the consumer, otherwise, your plan to bring relief will be ineffective!
A BETTER BAHAMAS
Madam President, before I close, I wish to briefly mention something that troubled me. I was raised in a Christian home, in fact, both of my parents are Pastors and Ministers of the Gospel; and they uphold a certain standard when it comes to their relationship with God, the church and the people of God. Madam President, I have been disturbed by the silence of many of the Ministers of the Gospel represented in the other place and in this place. I say that because, Madam President, the Bahamas atmosphere at present is filled with hate, anger, revenge, spite and no love! All across social media, people enjoy tearing apart ex-politicians, their families, friends and any other person associated with them. There seem to be a lack of morale or respect for one another! In addition, Madam President, presently in the Bahamian atmosphere, there is a lack of concern of one’s feeling and it seems anything is accepted. This is across both parties. However, this hatred is not a depiction of what it means to be truly Bahamian. This beautiful country needs healing! The nasty campaign almost made me forget what a beautiful country we live in! Our pledge of allegiance says to the end, “one people united in love and service.” We must serve this nation, but ensure we are encouraging everyone to live in love.
However, Madam President, I am particularly disturbed due to the fact that many of the FNM statements have proven to be dishonest or alternative facts. Additionally, the Ministers of the Gospel have yet to speak out and demand the new Government, act honest, responsible and uphold the truth. In fact, Madam President, some of the Ministers of the Gospel, also spoke alternative facts. To go further, some made very vile and insulting comments about a particular spirit that needs to be removed from the government. I must admit, at first viewing of a viral FNM rally video during the campaign, I was disappointed and disgusted by the statements, because the bible says in Mathew 7 1-2, “Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.
Therefore, Madam President, I say to the Ministers of the Gospel, represented in the other place and in this place, if you serve the same God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob; I call upon you this day to stand for whatever is true, honest, godly, Christian and Good! Speak out against this vicious, vengeful and dishonest behavior, no matter what side of the political divide it came from. I encourage them to take this opportunity to use this platform to help and heal the nation! Bring back the spirit of love, respect and honesty to this great Commonwealth of The Bahamas. Further, if my statement today convicted anyone of them, I urge them to please use the first opportunity to offer a prayer of repentance, because God hears the prayers of the righteous.
CLOSING
In closing, Madam President, there have been much threats and statements of Corruption, Malfeasance, and public chants of “Lock dem up,” all resulting in no charges or convictions. As Shadow AG, I say to this FNM Government, stop with all of the threats. There is a Justice system in place in the Bahamas, one that is clearly understood. If this Government is confused in any way on the protocol and procedures for criminal charges or convictions, then the PLP will gladly explain. Where the government has evidence of malfeasance, corruption or any other criminal matter, it is unnecessary to continually make vile threats in the House of Assembly. Madam President, they can simply request the Minister of National Security to carry out the necessary investigations, and turn the facts and the matter over to the AG for criminal prosecution. Additionally, if there have been proven; upon efficient review of the facts, any form of criminal wrongdoing, I say, “let the chips fall where they may.” Madam President, I do not condone and will not condone any wrongdoing by anyone, let me state for the record, that is not my position or platform. However, I am requesting the government to act maturely and execute the powers afforded to them by the justice system of the Bahamas. Present the facts and the evidence and if proven to be criminal, bring the prosecution and convictions.
There is a quote I think of when quantifying the time this FNM government have to implement their policies and govern this Bahamaland. The quote is by Damon Brown and it states, “Remember that money can come as quickly as it goes, but time, once it is gone, never comes back.
Madame President, I wish to remind the governing side in this place that time is of the essence, use it wisely and GOVERN this great nation, the Commonwealth of The Bahamas.
-
Senator Clay Sweeting Maiden Speech
Madam President,
It is indeed an honour and a pleasure that I formally address this Honourable chamber for the first time. As in all things I first give thanks to Almighty God for all of His many blessings that he has showered on me. He is my rock and my shield and I pray that the Lord will guide my words, thoughts, and actions inside and outside of this Honourable place.Madam President, I would like to congratulate all that has been selected to represent the people of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas. I congratulate the Government members for success at the polls and I also congratulate my colleagues who were selected to represent the Opposition in this Senate. We must be reminded colleagues that as the book of Proverbs 3:4-6 encourages us by stating that even if “You will find favor and good success in the sight of God and man. Trust in the LORD with all your heart, and do not lean on your own understanding. In all your ways acknowledge him, and he will make straight your paths”
Madam Present, I do not take this opportunity for granted as it is one of the greatest accomplishments of my life and I pray that I will indeed be an inspiration to the young people of this country and a steward for all Bahamians, fighting for their rights and best interests.
I must thank the people that supported me in my political endeavours during the past 8 years especially the people of North Eleuthera. I have had many persons who have stood with me and encouraged me to push forward. These people who I speak about are too numerous to name but it would be remise of me if I did not recognize them at all. These people were steadfast and unmoveable through the thick and thin, win or lose, in the good times and the bad. Their passion to continue to fight for their beliefs year after year, election after election just shows their dedication to the betterment of North Eleuthera. I must thank the Leader, Hon. Philip Brave Davis for awarding me this opportunity and having the faith in me to appoint myself to the Senate. It just shows the Progressive Liberal Party’s commitment to the young people of this country, being the current youngest Senator in this Honourable House and the second youngest in this country’s history.Madam President,
I am the oldest of four children, the child of a traditional fisherman and a housewife. My father Stanford and mother Melonie Sweeting pushed me to excel from a young age and I am sure they are so proud today. I am from the small community of Spanish Wells, the fishing capital of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas.
At the young age of 21 I got involved in politics, becoming a member of the Local Government Board in Spanish Wells and later vying to represent North Eleuthera. I knew it was a hard seat to win, Madam President, but that didn’t deter me, I dreamed of making a difference that positively impacted the people of Eleuthera and the generations that followed.
Madam President, when you find something worth fighting for, you don’t give up, you fight that much harder! That’s what I believe!I must say a big Thank You to my wife, Delia, who remains steadfast and supportive through all my endeavours. To my young son, Davin and to my family, who has sacrificed so much, I say Thank you and I remain forever grateful.
We must ensure that whatever is done in this place, is done so for behalf and for the betterment for all the people of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas.
Marine Resources
Madam President, The people of this country know that I have a special passion for the fishing industry. It was indeed a privilege to be named the Shadow Minister for Fisheries, Agriculture and Local Government. I along with many other fishermen of this country have been extremely vocal about the neglect of our fishing industry by the former FNM administration as well as the successful implementation of the initial phase of the Sandy Bottom Project by the PLP.
There hasn’t been a government in the history of the Bahamas who has committed more to the protection and advancement of the fisheries industry than this current Government.
I can remember as a young fishing vessel owner attending meetings when different Ministers visited our communities to speak with the locals and how they would improve the fishing industry. Many meetings, many times and it seemed as if no one heard the cries of the fishermen.
That is why it was I was so excited to see the implementation of the Sandy Bottom Project. The previous government spent 252 Million in order to accomplish the hard task of providing the proper equipment and vessels to protect the fishermen of this country. Some people may say that I feel the PLP put the lobster on the banks, this past fishing season. That is not so! We may never know why crawfish behave the way they do or why certain areas of the banks perform better at certain times than other areas, other than God controls their movements. However, Madam President if it wasn’t for the now Commodore, Captain Tillis Bethel, the defence force officers and the use of the new fleet, the crawfish would not have been there to harvest.
Who would have retrieved the crawfish if they banks had not been patrolled…maybe the Foreign Poachers?
I must commend the Progressive Liberal Party and the defence force for an outstanding border protection this past season and I hope that the defence force continues to do so.
The Communities such as Spanish Wells, Long Island and Abaco make up the largest fishermen population of this country. It is my hopes that the Government does not turn a blind eye on them but builds upon the foundation towards the proper poaching preventative measures that the PLP initiated. I listened tentatively at the Speech from the Throne and there was nothing mentioned about the fishermen of this country or the industry. I trust and hope that it was just an oversight and that the Government of the day remains committed as did the previous administration.
Step one was to eradicate the country of illegal poaching. We have established a good defence force patrol system in the Southern Bahamas and we must continue to build upon that. Now we must now look at the non-Bahamians that have work permits in our fishing in this country. The law specifically states that commercial fishing is for Bahamians alone.
There are many foreign nationals that are fishing on Bahamian owned vessels. These individuals are issued permits under the presumption of being employed as a boat engineer, but last time I checked a fishing vessel didn’t need 10 engineers. This is an issue that the people of Spanish Wells, Long Island and Abaco would be extremely happy if the Government would look into this matter and take the appropriate action. It is important to the continuous sustainability to the fishing industry of this country.
Madam President, the fishermen are looking towards a bountiful season when the season opens on August 1st, 2017. During this off season, I plead to the Government to continue with the patrolling of the fishing banks as the off season is when poachers seem to attack the banks viciously. The southern border is necessary as well as the areas around Bimini and northern Andros. The fishermen has experienced off season poaching in both the north and south Bahama banks.
I have noticed in the budget that the Government has indicated that they have allocated 4 million dollars to continue with the Sandy Bottom project and construct the Inagua Defence Force Base. This base is vital to continue to eradicate the poaching problem and I support the continued provision of proper sustainable measures to protect the fishermen. 731610During the PLP term in office between 2012 and 2017 the stats attributed to the Royal Bahamas Defence Force and in part to Sandy Bottom speak for themselves.
-13 illegal poaching vessels seized.
-Over 100 poachers arrested and prosecuted.
-Over 190,000 pounds of seafood seized.
-6,000 illegal migrants interdicted at sea and arrested.
-17 illegal weapons brought in on pleasure seacrafts intercepted.
-Over 100 distressed persons rescued at sea.
My hope and prayer is that the FNM will continue with this program and continue to provide refuge for the fishermen and a safety net against foreign poaching. I remain committed to the fishermen of this country and will be vocal on their behalf.AGRICULTURE
Madam President, Agricultural Imports currently equate to almost $1 billion a year to The Bahamas. We have always believed that a strong and thriving small business community can be the catalyst for a strong and vibrant economy, not only employing thousands of Bahamians but, economically empowering the people of The Bahamas.
The agricultural industry has experienced a continual and dramatic decline in the Bahamas, becoming almost insignificant as to the total economy. As my grandfather would say, the agricultural industry today is less of an industry now than of years past. We need revolutionary policies to reverse this trend and establish the Bahamian agricultural industry as a significant element of our economy, providing entrepreneurial opportunities for Bahamians to participate.
The policy initiative must encompass both an industry development plan, and then a plan to incorporate Bahamians into ownership opportunities with adequate training and preparation. Agriculture, to be a viable industry, also has to encompass a full circle – from growing to processing to export and distribution.
Technology – The advancement of technology in agriculture is a necessity to promote the industry. To be viable for hotels and the hospitality industry, agricultural production must be consistent and uniform, technology allows for this ability. In order to produce a wide range of produce and fruits, modern farming techniques are required.
Today successful commercial farming operations are utilizing technologies such as hydroponics, aquaponics, and organic farming. There must be a provision for training opportunities for Bahamians to learn modern day farming techniques. By providing an opportunity for existing farmers, and for new farmers to learn modern farming techniques, the agricultural industry will have the tools to develop and grow.
Distribution – The distribution channels is a key to the success of an agricultural industry. Today the Bahamas utilizes the packinghouse system as well as produce sales on the docks of Nassau to distribute the product. This has proven inefficient and results in a high degree of waste. Implementation of a modern day logistical distribution system which will have the ability to know what products are being farmed, what products are in demand of restaurants, hotel and distributors, and match up the supply and demand to maximize distribution by the farmers, while ensuring Bahamian grown produce makes it to the local consumers.
Entrepreneurial Opportunities – Once trained, Bahamian farmers will need the ability to go into business for themselves and utilize the knowledge that has been provided. Constituent with the theme that the former PLP Government will give a hand up to Bahamians, the Government needs to implement a plan to facilitate entrepreneurial endeavors in modern farming techniques.
Once trained, the farmer will be provided access to commonage or crown land in an identified family island. This will be limited to certain acreage, 5 – 10 acres. Modern farming techniques require much less land.Madam President, The Government must find ways to stimulate, facilitate and
encourage the development of agriculture in the Bahamas And to Engage in any
other activities designed to promote the Agricultural, Commercial and Industrial
Development of the Bahamas.
The Government must be mindful of the need of bridging the gap of the estimated Agricultural import bill and engaging Bahamians in the ongoing proposed billions of dollars of investment mainly via anchor projects throughout the Bahamas. Previously BAIC had commenced work on the following initiatives:
• Expansion/Creation of large scale commercial enterprises
• Expansion/Creation of smaller cottage industry
• Assistance to School programsThe targeted product items include, Vegetables (Cabbage, Tomatoes, Sweet Peppers, ETC.) Livestock, tree farming (limes, mangoes, avocado, coconuts etc.) and plants for landscaping (sea grapes, coco plums, etc.). Where the present or potential market and or project exist, the entities will be encouraged to produce for that market on that particular island in the first instance and subsequently for the larger Bahamas.
The initiatives undertaken by the corporation via activities inclusive of the following:
• Review the possibility of further developing and expanding green house technology
• Provide and publish a listing of incentives for the agriculture sector
• Review and comment on training for the agriculture initiatives (e.g. Budding of Trees, Animal husbandry)
• Review and comment on funding for the agriculture sector (public, private, and guarantee funds)
• Develop business profiles for the various components of the initiative
The corporation is dedicated to pursuing its mandate to stimulate, facilitate and encourage the development of agriculture in the Bahamas.Some of the actual services included:
• Project Proposal Assistance
• Farm Visits
• Farm Review and monitoring
• Farm Appraisals
• Input Supply and Procurement
• Seeds
• Chemicals
• Equipment
• Livestock
• Assistance to strengthen and form farmers groups or associationsIn the FNM manifesto it states that an FNM government will Provide tax incentives and concessions to encourage Bahamian farmers and farming cooperatives throughout the country to promote sustained production and packaging to ensure a continuous supply of quality products to customers.
How can the Government do this if they are reducing duties on fruits to thus encouraging foreign imports? We should be looking at avenues to encourage domestic crop growth with farmers and farmer entrepreneurial success.
One of the questions that can be asked is why has the FNM eliminated duty on certain fruits that are grown locally?
Why eliminate the duty on pineapples?
Why eliminate duty on Limes?
Why eliminate duty on grapefruits and why on oranges?Eleuthera is known for its Sugar Loaf pineapple across the country, possibly world renowned and now, we want to say to the farmers that we do not believe in you anymore? How is it that the manifesto says one thing and the Government does another? If the Government cared so much about the farmers and if it is the people’s time wouldn’t they find ways to assist the farmers of the Bahamas?
Let’s face it, it will be impossible for the farmers of this country to compete with Local Food Stores that can now import the fruits duty free.BAMSI
When we took office in 2012, we were faced with a Bahamian economy in shambles and an agricultural sector was collapsing due to a lack of investment in the training, tools, and resources. Our country’s food import bill was far too high, which meant we were depending too much on foreign imports and paying too much for produce.BAMSI grew out of the former Prime Minister Christie’s vision and his leadership – he was determined to diversify our economy, to revive the nation’s declining agricultural sector, and to create new opportunities for Bahamians. Where there was nothing just few years ago, there are now fields and fields of papayas, bananas, tomatoes, onions, citrus and much more. Where there was once nothing, there is now a school graduating Bahamian experts in agriculture and science who have their choice of jobs. Where in the past some Bahamian agriculture and marine scientists might have been tempted by jobs abroad, they can now contribute their expertise here at home.
Even though BAMSI is so new, it has already created hundreds of jobs for Bahamians, Bahamian farmers are working with BAMSI to produce and sell crops, and the first class of students graduated from the institute in 2016. BAMSI also means more agri-business scientists and professionals, wealth creation and wealth expansion, economic growth, and greater foreign exchange retention potential and economic diversification. As of now, $100 million worth of food in the Bahamas has already been supplied by BAMSI.
As part of creating a successful BAMSI, the former government supports farmers and fishermen throughout The Bahamas by “granting them duty free concessions, for farming equipment such as tractors and trucks.”271 They also offered assistance in land clearing, irrigation systems, animal feed, vegetable seeds, and fertilizers.”271
BAMSI was the first big step towards sustainable agricultural growth, but the work is not done. I am encouraged by the governments dedication to BAMSI and to allocate 12 millions dollars in the budget to its continued success. BAMSI’s success is now poised to create new opportunities throughout our islands, for both farmers and entrepreneurs.
It is important that we as Bahamians, Buy Bahamian!
Family Island Economies
Madam President, We must start to focus on the economy’s of the Family Islands and find ways to add economic and structural growth. Economies should be developed in the family islands as full circle economies, where
production, processing, packaging and distribution are done at the respective family island locations. This would permit residents of various family islands to participate in all aspects of an economy and industry, not just one, for example, as farmers. To illustrate this position I use the Spanish Wells fishermen as an example.
Spanish Wells Fishing Industry – The residents of Spanish Wells are very talented fishermen, having some of the highest per capital income in the country. But, the success of the fishing industry in Spanish Wells is because the fishing industry on Spanish Wells is a full circle economy. The development of the industry was as a result of the following occurring on Spanish Wells:
• Once built the boats (skiffs)
• Selling the engines for the skiffs
• Repairing the engines and other mechanical matters
• Fishing for the crawfish and fish
• Wholesaler purchase the fish from the fishermen
• Fish is processed at the wholesale facility
• Fish is packaged at the wholesale facility
• Fish is exported by the wholesale facility
By developing full circle economies, the proceeds from the industry remain within the island, providing a significant multiplier effect. Developing a full circle economy on family islands also provides employment opportunities in all sectors of the industry on the island.
This model should be translated to all family islands in a variety of different
industries. Examples of industries that this theory should be applied to include:
• Agriculture – from growing to canning and juicing to exporting and
distribution.
• Green Energy – from research to assembly and manufacture to export of
alternative energy technologies.
A Government must operate under the fundamental and obvious premise that The Bahamas does not consist only of New Providence. That means, therefore, that the other Islands of The Commonwealth deserve our attention. We must be active in islands throughout our country. The former Government traversed this country, taking our “Gospel of Entrepreneurship” and BAICs mandate, we conducted successful programs through working partnerships with the Administrators stationed there. Wherever there is a resident population with ambition for economic development/improvement through entrepreneurship, BAIC’s Business Services Division came to their aid.Activities/Programs
Farmers Associations & Agri-Business Development
The Division travelled throughout the Commonwealth promoting the development of Farmers Associations as a business model proven to increase business success for farmers. Associations have been formally organized and legally registered in North Andros, North and South Eleuthera, Exuma, North and South Abaco.
Our activities included:
Farmers Empowerment Workshops
1. Corporate Governance (officer training)
2. Establishing New Associations
3. Business Training/Capacity Building of Existing AssociationsManufacturers Empowerment
We worked hard to empower manufacturers, bringing focused attention to their business problems with a view to fostering solutions. To this end we will be undertook a number of initiatives.
1. Manufacturers Empowerment Workshops/Seminars (3 per year)
2. Manufacturers Business Forum (2 per year)
3. Solar & Alternative Energy Solutions Review Briefings
4. Manufacturers Business Expo
5. Information BrochuresI would like to express to you some goals that we have accomplishes just with BAIC in Eleuthera.
1. We approved a facilitated property and dockage for Bahama Biters. A Eleuthera based company that currently has around 14 young individuals employed. They export Stone Crab biters to the U.S.A. direct.
2. Eleuthera Island Organics- Is an organic farm that was established in 2012 with approved property from Agriculture facilitated through BAIC. They have invested in excess of 300,000 dollars and are doing very well. They are in the process of selling there items where people can purchase organic fruit and vegetables direct. They currently have numerous Bahamians employed.
3. We at BAIC has just approved another property for another large organic farm in the Hatchet Bay area. They too will employ people of EleutheraMadam President,
In the 2015/2016, the PLP extended the Family Island Encouragement Act to other family islands which included Eleuthera, Abaco, Bimini and Grand Bahama (excluding the Port). The purpose of this act was to increase and stimulate economic growth as well as to offer relief to people who wanted to construct homes locally. The Act allowed duty free concessions on items that are used for construction as well as home and business repair. This included removing the duty off many items that were previously 45% such as cabinets, plumbing supplies and other items used for the construction. In return, the economic impact in many communities was extremely positive. Contractors enjoyed and still do continuous requests for work and this program has positively impacted the lives of many.
Madam President, this added much needed relief to the locals of the islands and ignited a surge of housing improvement and construction projects. The positive impacts are numerous and if you don’t believe me try calling a contractor in Harbour Island or Spanish Wells and ask for an estimated start date that they can construct your home. I am glad the FNM has taken the PLPs lead and extended the Family Island Encouragement Act.EDUCATION
In the budget, Capital Detail 732280, the Government has allocated 4.3 million dollars to build new schools across the country and 4.7 million for expansion and refurbishment of existing schools. As I welcome the Government’s investment in education, I sure hope Eleuthera was on their minds when the funds were allocated.
Madam President, in just Eleuthera alone there is a need for new school in Gregory Town and a new school block in Harbour Island. To build just these schools would possibly exhaust the total budget for new schools in this country.
In the earlier part of this year there was a meeting held in Harbour Island outlining the proposed architectural plans for a new K4 through grade 6 Primary School Block. I hope that this project is not subject to a stop, cancel and review policy. Harbour Island is in dire need of the school block to provide proper educational facilities for the children there.
I also hope that out of the capital funding for this year, the school for Gregory Town is contracted and built. The children have been meeting in a lodge hall for far too long and I hope that we can provide proper schooling facilities for them as well.Business License
Madam President, as a young businessman I understand that we must find ways to promote the ease of doing business in this country. It is important that Governments realize the need to promote small and medium size business development and entrepreneurship. It is also important that if Governments feel the need to extend tax concessions to business owners, then wouldn’t we hope that the young up and coming businessmen/women enjoy these concessions. Don’t you think that…
– The business owner who owner gets up 6 o clock in the morning and is at his store before some people think about waking up deserves it.
– The business owners that stay late after closing time just to make a couple extra dollars, would you think he deserves it
-The business owner who has worked relentlessly to ensure his business survives when others thought it would fail; don’t you think he deserves it as well!
It is most unfortunate that the business license act was only altered to give relief to businesses that gross 50 million or more.
What happen to the relief for the small and medium sized businesses?
How about the young business owners and entrepreneurs?
We are a hard working people Madam President and there are many small to medium sized businesses across this country that would have welcomed the same .25% reduction in their business license fees.AIRPORTS
Madam President, in the budget, capital detail 736299, family island airports, it is unfortunate that no airports in Eleuthera was included for reconstruction or renovation. While it is important that other airports need repair and constructive improvements, the North Eleuthera Airport is in dire need of not just repair but new. North Eleuthera, including Spanish Wells and Harbour Island has become premier tourist destinations in this country. In return we have outgrown the current airport. Numerous times through the week you can see people sitting outside of the airport because there are not enough seats to accommodate the travels. Some people may look at this as a good problem, which maybe so but it is a problem that needs immediate attention. They say a first impression is a lasting impression, so we should want our guests, to arrive to a WOW factor in North Eleuthera and give them a reason to come back.
To date this year, Aircraft Arrivals in North Eleuthera total an estimated 5,400 with a passenger total of an estimated 30,300 passengers. Just this week Silver airline made 6 round trips to North Eleuthera in one day.
I plead to the Government to take action ASAP to correct this issue.SPORTS
Madam President, whether recreational or professional, sports are a positive outlet for people. Sports promote discipline, precision of skills, teamwork, coordination, enjoyment and help people to stay fit.
During the PLPs term in office we –
-Launched the Bahamas ‘Sport in Paradise’ program
-Launched a National Sports Academy
-Created three new stadiums designed by young Bahamian architects, engineers and contractors
-Constructed a one of the kind FIFA Beach Soccer Arena at the foot of the Sydney Poitier Bridge
– Commenced construction of the National Sports Academy on Moore’s Island
In the budget, there is an allocation of 5 million (731260) capital expenditures for 2017/2018 budget, for the construction of gymnasiums in Abaco, Cat Island and especially Eleuthera. I am hoping that these indeed comes to fruition and the money assigned actually is used to construct these much-needed sporting facilities. Eleuthera is one rich with sports history.
-Chris Brown, from Green Castle is an Olympic Gold medallists and has won numerous medals in various competitions around the world
– The Senior Girls Basketball Team in Harbour Island won the National Championship in 2016,
– Sean Rolle from Bannerman Town won the silver in Javelin in the 2017 Carifta Games and
– just recently the Samuel Guy Pinder All-Age school won their fourth national softball championship at the annual Austin Knowles Softball tournament.
As an island, Eleuthera is rich in athletic ability and is well deserving of the sport facility. A sport facility will be able to help in fitness testing/assessments and will provide a location for specific conditioning programmes. I do believe that we have only touched the surface with the sports abilities in this country with the likes of Buddy Hield. Providing proper facilities will expand the abilities of our local athletes. I hope the FNM expands on the foundation the PLP has started. I will do my part to keep reminding the Government of the allocation for the complex in Eleuthera, Abaco and Cat Island to ensure they get it!Local Government
Local Government plays an important role in executing the duties of the central government in local communities throughout the family islands and Grand Bahama. The local government election took place in the family island last week, June 22, 2017. It was a peaceful election and I must say I was very impressed of the slate of candidates offered across the island of Eleuthera. There were many young individuals who offered themselves for the first time and they ran passionate, clean campaigns, and some of them were ultimately successful. Some of these young individuals include Terrence T.J Davis, Wanda Percentie, Damon Bethel, Holly Bartlet, and Sumer Pinder. These names who I have called are young people in these communities who are passionate about promoting domestic economical growth, empowering young people and making their communities better.Conclusion
Madam President, the campaign and rallies are officially over. The Government must get do what they were hired to do, Govern. We are not here to play the blame game! We will support the Government in policies and legislation that align with our beliefs and convictions. We wish the government well and wish them success, however we will hold their feet to fire, so to speak. We will keep the Government accountable to ensure that they govern in the best interest of the Bahamian people.
The PLP was voted OUT. We have a new administration, they promised to give us free education, no tax to over the hill communities and impoverished areas and to give us transparency and accountability.
Let’s get to it so that we can obtain these campaign promises made by the FNM.
It is important that the Government puts people over politics. These are real people who has real problems in real life. Let’s ensure that the policies and legislation passed is done so in the best interest of the Bahamian people.
God Bless you and God Bless the Commonwealth of the Bahamas -
MOFA Statement to the 47th Regular Session of the OAS General Assembly
“Strengthening Dialogue and Concerted Action for Prosperity”
47th Regular Session of the OAS General Assembly
Tuesday, 20th June, 2017Plenary Remarks
of the Honourable Darren Henfield, MP
Minister of Foreign Affairs of The Commonwealth of The BahamasCheck against Delivery.
Colleague Foreign Ministers,
Secretary General Almagro and Assistant Secretary General Mendez,
Permanent Representatives and other guests,
Mr. President, while I would contend that The Bahamas is the most beautiful country on earth, it is indeed a pleasure to be a guest in Cancun, and to experience its renowned beauty and the warm hospitality of its people, despite the rains.
I want to express profound gratitude for the excellent arrangements and reception afforded my delegation this week by the Mexican Government and People.
I wish to begin by thanking the Government of Chile for its generosity, which will help to educate our people towards improving our Caribbean region.
The Bahamas, as many of you know, held general elections 10 May, which resulted in a change of administration. Elections were held in a free, fair and peaceful manner, in keeping with The Bahamas’ long and proud history of democracy and the rule of law. I take this opportunity to thank the OAS for having mounted a Mission to observe the General Elections, and to support The Bahamas in its exercise of continued democracy.
We meet at a time, colleagues, where most of our countries still struggle with residual effects of lagging recession and other social ills, where our citizens have demonstrated an increasing impatience with and are demanding more from the Order that has been built around globalization, where norms around multilateralism and international partnership are being critically revisited and where some even openly question the relevance and credibility of this Organization.
The value of the OAS as a Political Forum
Mr. President, colleague Ministers, The Bahamas wishes to underscore its belief in the necessity of multilateralism, of peaceful settlement of disputes, of problem solving through dialogue and of collective efforts to address common challenges.
As such the OAS remains the most appropriate political forum for discussing and coming to common agreement on the issues of the hemisphere. Our dialogue must always be conducted in an atmosphere of mutual respect, trust and a common understanding and with due respect for sovereignty and the principle of non-interference.
Above all else, the Organization’s legitimacy as a political forum must be maintained and it should continue to function as a place where each Member State’s issues can be brought to the table and every country’s vote and voice carry equal weight.
Institutional Strengthening at the OAS
As inheritors of this, the world’s oldest regional body, it is our duty to ensure that it continues to be renewed in order to meet the needs of successive generations.
The good book wisely admonishes us not to pour ‘new wine into old wine skins’. We must heed these words as we continue to undergo a period of introspection regarding the improved functioning of our Organization.
We need an honest approach towards reform of the organization, with a focused and comprehensive dialogue on what is required to fashion the OAS that we all want. This includes dealing with issues such as strengthening the Permanent Council, reviewing the checks and balances governing the General Secretariat and, enhancing fiscal oversight mechanisms for the Secretariat’s work. In the end, we should have a Secretariat that better reflects the rich diversity of the hemisphere and an Organization that is equipped to meet the needs of a modern Americas.
Challenges to Prosperity
Security
Alongside our efforts to invigorate the architecture of the institution, we must also ensure that the Organization is addressing the real needs of our citizenry, namely the desire to live in safe societies which develop in an equitable and sustainable manner. Security, which is of utmost priority to The Bahamas should also be high on the agenda of the OAS. Whether it is security issues such as drugs, crime, arms and human trafficking or existential threats such as the alarming impact of Climate Change and global warming, these are problems that are bigger than any one country, so we need a true partnership, involving all stake holders, to ensure security and prosperity.
In this connection, The Bahamas will continue to play a leading role, through its current Chairmanship of the Inter-American Drug Abuse Control Commission (CICAD), to combat the world drug problem, taking into account all dimensions. Furthermore, The Bahamas, in seeking to comprehensively address the effects of traditional and emerging threats to security, remains committed to its international obligations and will continue to pursue collaborative partnerships at the regional, hemispheric and international levels.
Development
Development is an important pillar for my Country and indeed for the region. The attainment of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals of the 2030 Agenda, which comprise more than 160 targets, is of utmost priority. In the spirit of partnership, we expect sustained and equitable focus by the Secretariat to support the development aspirations of member states. Therefore, we reject the notion that the OAS should not be in the business of development work, and that the important activities being carried out by the Executive Secretariat for Integral Development (SEDI) might best be facilitated by other Inter-American entities. Capacity building, technical cooperation, human development and political agenda setting are areas where the OAS has a clear comparative advantage when compared to other multilateral bodies and the work in these areas is already a signature of the OAS brand.
I referred previously to the existential threat of climate change, which is especially true for Small Island Developing States like The Bahamas. To be clear colleagues, if business remains as usual, 80% of The Bahamas, which is within 5 feet of sea level, will be submerged this century. While each nation must determine its own course on international matters, we reiterate our unwavering belief that there is a universal moral urgency to move from commitment to action, predicated upon the principle of common but differentiated responsibility. Each country, small and large, developed and developing, must find the courage to do their part. The Bahamas therefore reaffirms the Paris Agreement and anticipates that multilateral agencies such as the OAS and other agencies of the Inter-American System like the IDB, will assist wherever necessary with technical and financial resources for adaptation, building resiliency and mitigation efforts.
The economy of The Bahamas is exceptionally exposed to various types of vulnerabilities including, environmental, economic and social, and other external shocks, all of which at times disrupt the planned fiscal policy of the Government. The reverberations and duration of these shocks are protracted and much more profound on nations like The Bahamas. Too often in decision-making regarding development assistance and development financing the indicators used have been imbalanced. What we need is a broadening and modernizing of the development indicators used to assess development needs, beyond the outdated and crude metrics, such as GDP per capita, which lead to narrow economic classifications which do not account for the real development and governance challenges of states, especially the unique circumstances of Small Island Developing States that are most vulnerable. We call on the OAS to advocate on behalf of the changes needed in the international financial architecture.
Education is both an accelerator of sustainable development and the precursor to the successful achievement of societies that are safe, well governed and inclusive. We congratulate Member States for recently adopting the Inter-American Education Agenda in The Bahamas and we will continue to insist upon progress in implementing our shared goals for cooperation in education throughout our tenure as Chair of the Inter-American Committee on Education. We also join others in emphasizing the value of the OAS Scholarships and Training Programs.
Micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) are the backbone of the productive structure in the Caribbean region; in this connection the OAS project on the development of Small Business Development Centres in the Caribbean is an example of an effective OAS program which meets a real need in the region.
The Bahamas also supports the Development Cooperation Fund, of which we currently are Vice Chair, given it is the only source of funding available directly to member states for national priorities through the OAS. It should be supported in the next program cycle.
A call for a Renewed OAS
Mr. President, there will be much dialogue during the course of this Assembly but in order for our time here to truly count, in order for our work to fulfil its obligations to our citizenry, we must begin to move from talk to action.
We must commit to redouble our efforts towards reform and engagement and, if we truly believe in the Organization, to find new and innovative approaches to support its work, in accordance with each Member States’ capacity.
More now than ever we need an OAS that is as robust as it is agile; that enhances its credibility as a forum for political dialogue but also strives to meet the real needs of citizens on the ground in our societies; that continues to renew itself even while staying true to its core values.
The Bahamas reiterates its commitment to this Organization and to the fraternity of the nations of the Americas to do all it can, in concert with Member States, to help us realize this vision.Thank you, Mr. President.
-
Senator Darville Contribution to the 2017 – 2018 Budget
Senator, The Honourable Dr. Michael R. Darville
Contribution to the 2017 – 2018 Budget
Honourable Senate of the Commonwealth of the Bahama
Friday, 23rd June, 2017
Thank you, Madam President, and once again congratulations to you, and all Honourable Senators around the table.
Madam President, today I rise to make my contribution to the 2017 – 2018 Budget debate.
Madam President, after experiencing a major defeat at the polls a few weeks ago, and having an opportunity to reflect on our successes and mistakes, I remain resolute that Progressive Liberal Party is still the only political organization that can effectively navigate our country though the turbulent waters that lie ahead; and I remain confident that time will prove this statement to be true.
Madam President, upon coming to office in 2012, we met an economy riddled with debt.
Yes, Madam President, the previous FNM administration left behind close to a billion dollar in debt, which forced the PLP to put many of our capital works projects on hold during our first year in office. As minister, I felt the frustration of knowing very well that without real financial resources to drive our capital works projects, the construction industry would remain stagnant and the economic stimulus that was so desperately needed for Grand Bahama would have to be put on hold.
Madam President, the Minister of Finance and the people of this country must be reminded that in 2012, the FNM indeed left our economy in a wheel chair. But unlike this administration, we executed fiscal discipline as a cabinet, and opted to stay away from excessive borrowing.
Furthermore, Madam President, despite the political risks associated with the implementation of VAT, we made the tough decision, and took the necessary steps to do so. After three (3) years in office, and much consultation and technical support, The Ministry of Finance launched one of the well-structured Value Added Tax systems in the region, along with other transformative tax reform measures. To ease the burden on our people, duty on many imported goods, including food items, was reduced simultaneously across the board in some instances up to 15 percent.
Madam President, unfortunately, VAT was used as a tool for the FNM during the campaign, as they accused the PLP of stealing the funds derived from the VAT, and promised that they would repeal VAT on bread basket items, utilities, education and medical services. Resultantly, the people gobbled up these lies and promises and voted against the PLP.
Madam President, through you, I would like to remind the general public that the Free National Movement voted in favour of the implementation of Value Added Tax, and they understood its importance in rebuilding the country’s economy. Now that the campaign is over, the back peddling on their promises to the people has begun, as confirmed in the budget.
But, Madam President, what I find most troubling is after opting not to repeal VAT from bread basket items, this administration saw it fit to reduce business license fees, not for SME’s; but for businesses that make more than fifty million dollars a year, reduce duty on washing machines and aircraft parts, salmon, caviar, and other items, which would assist special interest groups and not the poor.
Madam President, it doesn’t matter how you try to sugar coat it even a blind man can see the play … it’s payback time!
Madam President, during our term in office, we made many of the tough, unpopular decisions, and laid a solid foundation for the new government to build upon.
I am therefore grateful to the Leader of the Opposition, the Honourable Philip Brave Davis, and party officials, for affording me this wonderful opportunity to serve once again in this upper chamber. This is serious business, Madam President, and I assure Progressive Liberal Party supporters throughout the country that I remain committed to the cause, and I would carry out my duties as an opposition Senator to the best of my ability.
Madam President, my mother always told me that those who fail to prepare, prepare to fail. Additionally, the late Dr. Myles Monroe, in one of his lecture series on Grand Bahama stated, “Be prepared so when opportunity knock at your door, you will be well positioned to succeed.” Both of these statements have proven true throughout my professional and public life. For the past few weeks, however, these statements have taken on new life, as I watched with great concern; this unprepared administration prove to the Bahamian people, and the world, that they are truly not ready to govern.
In fact, Madam President, during the budget debate, many ministers seemed unfamiliar with their constitutional and collective responsibilities, and failed miserably, in their contributions to demonstrate to the Bahamian people, their plans to move, their ministries and our country forward. I was pleased, nonetheless to learn that the FNM will build upon the majority of the plans and programs put in place by our administration.
Madam President, as an opposition Senator and shadow Minister of Grand Bahama Affairs, Education, Health and NHI, I assure you that I fully understand my constitutional responsibilities, and I will continue to defend the Progressive Liberal Party’s accomplishments, inside and outside of this honourable place. I also intend to support meaningful legislation, programs and plans brought forth by the current FNM administration, which would bring relief to the poor and ultimately improve the quality of life of all Bahamians irrespective of ethnicity, socioeconomic status or political affiliation.
On the other hand, Madam President, I will vigorously oppose policies and legislation that I believe will favour only special interest groups, and are not in the best interest of the Bahamian people, and specifically, the people of Grand Bahama, as I have done for the past decade.
Madam President, I will conduct myself in an honourable fashion, but I must warn you that I have strong convictions, and I intend to voice the concerns of Bahamians, particularly as it relates to the violation of their constitutional rights, and political victimization.
Madam President, the 2017 – 2018 budget, which was presented by the Honourable Member for East Grand Bahama. Let me say from the onset that I was extremely disappointed that the Members in the lower house used this budget debate, as well as their parliamentary privilege to vilify former cabinet ministers and the PLP, and continue the FNM’s political campaign in the honourable house of assembly.
Madam President, the budget communication was a golden opportunity for this inexperienced administration to rise above all the propaganda, accusations, and lies that they levied on the PLP during the campaign leading to the 2017 general elections, and take the high road. But instead of giving an accurate account of the financial affairs of the country, the budget communication was skewed, heavily political, and indicated little about the FNM’s plan for good fiscal stewardship.
In fact, Madam President, the majority of their contributions were about alleged PLP corruption, and who got what for government contracts. I believe the Bahamian people are saturated with all this political posturing and are ready for this government to plans in place that would bring relief to the poor create jobs.
Madam President, in an interview on the evening news last night, the Attorney General admitted that no formal complaint has been filed by any government official, or citizen, that would substantiate the claims made in the lower house.
It is my sincere belief, Madame President, that if the Free National Movement can proven acts of criminality by any former minister or public servant, they should forward the information to the police and allow the authorities to take legal action or make the allegations outside of these honourable chambers.
Madam President, the cabinet, supervised by the our Prime Minister who apparently says he cares about the people, somehow forgot about the tax cuts for the poor, which he promised on the campaign trail; because this budget proved to have nothing to do with “the people” whose time they said had come, but more to do with payback time for “their” people. This budget includes tax breaks for big business, and reductions in duties which would increase the bottom line of many who sit in cabinet; with a few crumbs falling from the cabinet table for “the people.” As Catherine Kelly, concluded in her column a few weeks ago, Dollars and Sense, “The FNM should be fired for the budget they are proposing to the people.”
Madam President, the budget communication sets the wrong precedence in the financial community; and if not corrected will come back to bite us all. It’s potentially damaging, and could impact local and international investment opportunities throughout the country, but more specifically on the island of Grand Bahama. As far as I am concerned, Madam President, this budget sends the wrong message to the business community and the rating agencies, who by the way, will be back at our door steps in a matter of months.
Madam President, at one point during his contribution, The Minister of Finance seemed unfamiliar with certain aspects of his own budget! This is evidence of preparing to fail and shows how out of touch the Free National Movement was, and still is, concerning the micro and macroeconomic indicators in the country, and their effect on the Bahamian economy. In hopes that the Bahamian people would give them a free pass to borrow close to a billion dollars within their first hundred (100) days in office, The member for East Grand Bahama presented a budget that unfairly blamed the PLP, and because of his political agenda, intentionally painted an overly grim picture of our economy.
Madam President, my question to this administration is what is the real reason behind borrowing a whopping seven hundred and twenty-two million dollars ($722,000,000.00) during your first year in office?
Madam President, this voodoo style economics of trying to borrow their way out of debt appears to be the first part of the FNM’s plan to turn the Bahamian economy around.
What is ironic Madam President, is that this same scenario was predicted by many local prophets during the election campaign, who clearly articulated that should the Free National Movement win the general election, the first thing they would do is increase borrowing. It appears now that these prophecies have come to pass.
Madam President, in contrast to our administration, who borrowed just over two billion ($2,000,000,000.00) dollars in our entire five (5) years in office, this inexperienced FNM administration could not resist the temptation, and with the passing of this budget, would have committed the Bahamian people to close to one billion dollars ($1,000,000,000.00) of debt in their first hundred (100) days in office. This is record breaking, and if continued throughout their term of office, could have serious implications to our local economy.
Madam President, when we move all of the drama around about alleged corruption with no proof form the budget debate and sum it all up, a blind man can see straight through the FNM’s game plan; which is to borrow excessively in their first year in office, use this borrowed capital to create a false perception that the economy is rebounding; then ride on the projected economic growth trajectory, while blaming the PLP for everything negative in the economy, all the way to 2022.
Madam President, the IMF projected that the Bahamian economy will expand by 1.4% this year followed by 2.2% in 2018. These projections proved that despite the challenges we faced with revenue collection and the economic impact of Hurricanes Joaquin and Mathew had on the country’s economy, we were able to do all the heavy lifting, and modernize the country’s tax structure. We were on the right track, and moving in the right direction; under the direction of the Former Minister, and Minister of State for Finance.
You know what is so sad, though, Madam President, the member for East Grand Bahama missed a great moment in history to demonstrate political maturity. However, at no point in his contribution did he give any credit to our team for the transformational work done on the country’s new tax structure, and our ingenuity in holding the fragile economy together, despite the devastating effects of two (2) Category 4 hurricanes in five (5) years.
But God don’t like ugly, Madam President; and after all the PLP bashing and accusations of corruption without any factual proof, He allowed the truth about the devastating effects that Hurricanes Joaquin and Mathew had on our local economy, and the 2017 projected deficit to finally be revealed. The issue with the projected deficit was clearly outlined by the Former Minister of Finance, during his last midterm budget communication, but if my memory serves me right, both the present Prime Minister, and his Deputy were absent from the house that day.
Therefore, Madam President, the fact that the 2016 – 2017 projected deficit would increase was no new revelation; and the evidence supported that this increase has nothing to do with the mismanagement of public finances. In fact, Madam President no administration could budget for major hurricanes, their effects on government infrastructure, and the social ramifications associated with the devastation.
I now turn my attention to the economy of Grand Bahama.
Madam President, Grand Bahama is the sleeping giant in the north, and is filled with great potential. I remain optimistic about its future, its economic recovery and wish the Minister of State, and the government well, as they tackle the complex issues surrounding the island’s recovery. But I must warn the Minister of State that the outdated economic template currently in place in Freeport must change in order to bring about sustainable development. In fact, research, prior to the 2012 general election by the Progressive Liberal Party, confirmed that the success of Grand Bahama required bold and aggressive policy changes; centred around a shift in the management of the free trade zone, and the increase in the presence of a well-funded central governmental leadership team who must operate side by side stakeholders, guided by international business best practices in order to prevent the boom and bust syndrome.
Madam President, our plan for Grand Bahama was simple in principle, but challenging to implement on the ground because of all the stakeholders involved. We knew that the plan would require a lot of transformative work and strong government leadership. So, upon coming to office we established the Ministry for Grand Bahama in our first 100 days of governance.
Madame President, we hired both local and foreign consultants with global experience, advised us on policy changes necessary to receive maximum economic benefits from our strategic location, and free trade zones. As Minister, one of my main mandates was to drive these transformative policies around the cabinet table, thus creating both a short and long-term strategy that would promote the resurgence of the Grand Bahama economy.
Madame President, because of the unique legal structure of Freeport, these necessary changes required buy in from the Grand Bahama Port Authority, port licensees, the Grand Bahama Chamber of Commerce and other major stakeholders on the island. As a result of our research, we clearly understood that the recovery of Grand Bahama would take more than five years, but focused on the advancement of the industrial and tourism sectors, in order to create jobs.
Madam President, after listening to the budget communication, and the contributions from the five Members of Parliament from Grand Bahama including the Minister of Finance, I am still waiting to hear about any meaningful government plan for the island of Grand Bahama. All I am heard from the Free National Movement camp is the sudden revelation that the economic recovery of Grand Bahama is “no quick fix” and “will take time and collaborative effort.”
Additionally, Madam President, I was hoping that the Minister of Finance, in his substantive contribution, would have been eager to share something about the FNM’s strategic plan for Grand Bahama. On the contrary, it seems that the new template alluded to in the speech from the throne does not exist; and a workable one must be developed.
Well, Madam President, that’s not good enough because during the political campaign, the FNM told the residents of Grand Bahama that they would bring immediate change to the island, jump start our economy, and get people in the tourism sector back to work.
My question is, Madam President, will the FNM fail Grand Bahama again?
Madam President, the FNM also pledged to repeal the Grand Bahama Investment Incentive Bill, which they said would level the playing field for business owners in Freeport.
Madam President, I strongly suggest that this administration moves with caution to review the evidence research, look carefully at the MOU and Heads of Agreement signed by the major stakeholders, before potentially pushing the economy of Grand Bahama back another ten (10) years. Although I concede that the bill is not a perfect one; all bills brought to this honourable place are subjected to amendments along the way. Many of the issues the Chamber and the Grand Bahama Port Authority had with the bill were brought to our attention, and we were addressing them via some amendments, and with the regulations. However, Madam President, I believe that to repeal the bill will go contrary to the evidence based research, and possibly derail almost three (3) years of hard work by the government. A few days ago, during a press conference in Freeport, the Prime Minister spoke about the government plans for extending the requirements necessary under the Grand Bahama investment bill for another six months, which I fully support. Going forward, Madam President, I would be willing to give my input as the former Minister for Grand Bahama, a licensee of the Grand Bahama Port Authority, and a citizen in the community who is deeply concerned about moving the economy of Grand Bahama.
Yes, Madam President, the Grand Bahama Port Authority would have issues with any changes to their current mode of operations. But this is the 21st century, and they must come to grips with the reality that some aspects of Hawksbill Creek Agreement are proving to be counter-productive to national development, and as a sovereign nation we must address then for the common good of all Bahamians.
Madam President, the FNM touts that their focus for Grand Bahama is investments. This was on top of our agenda as well. In fact, Madam President, our administration, along with the McKenzie Group, did a lot of work on the modelling of the new Grand Bahama Investment Promotion Board, and the one stop shop, as recommended by stakeholders.
Nevertheless, Madam President, to accomplish this requires funding, policy changes and reform. So, the big question to the side opposite is, other than a two hundred thousand dollar ($200,000.00) increase for investment promotion on Grand Bahama, where is the funding to support the establishment and maintenance of the operations of the much-needed investment promotion board for Grand Bahama, and the one stop shop, which was mentioned in the speech from the throne??
Madame President, it will take significant budgetary allocations to successfully improve the ease of doing business in the country, and by extension the island of Grand Bahama. In fact, Jamaica was able to accomplish this important milestone with the help of a substantial IDB loan.
Madam President, the Grand Bahama Investment Promotion Board, and the one stop shop must be a priority for the government, because once properly implemented and competently staffed, they can play a significant role in the resurgence of the Grand Bahama economy.
Madam President, with so very little funding allotted in the budget for this very important mandate, I ask this FNM administration once more, are you planning to fail Grand Bahama again?
Madam President, Grand Bahama is in need of an immediate economic injection. We left a plan in place for grant funding for small businesses impacted by Hurricane Mathew, and a low interest loan facility for existing SME’s. Sadly, this much-needed economic injection is not evident from the allocations in the budget for the Ministry for Grand Bahama, Office of the Prime Minister or the Ministry of Finance.
On the other hand, Madam President, I am pleased that one million dollars ($1,000,000.00) is allocated in the budget, under Head 74, line item 791270, under SME’s, for what is apparently the reactivation of the FNM’s Jump Start Program.
Madame President, while I agree that this can certainly help small businesses in East and West Grand Bahama; I find it hard to ignore that during the former FNM administration, this same program was poorly managed.
Madam President, a review of the former Jump Start Program would verify that it turned out to be a political slush fund; and as a result, many of the so-called businesses never existed, or failed, leaving only a hand full of functioning businesses after wasting millions of dollars of tax payers’ money.
So, Madame President, the Honourable Minister of State will certainly have his hands full managing this line item. I wish to inform him, through you, that we will be following this very closely during your entire term in office. Remember it’s the people’s time, and accountability and transparency must be the order of the day.
Madam President, in the speech from the throne, the challenges Grand Bahama faced over the last fifteen to twenty (15 – 20) years were recognized. But if the truth be told, the local economy was on a downward spiral for a much longer time. Yes, natural disasters contributed to the economic downturn of Grand Bahama’ but poor planning, government neglect and yes, the dinosaur on the ground, the Hawksbill Creek Agreement, all contributed to where we are today.
Madam President, historic examination of Freeport and the workings of the Hawksbill Creek Agreement confirmed that the government’s policies of duty free concessions were, and still are the engine behind Freeport’s success over the years. But a study done in December 2015, by Oxford Economics proved that even though concessions are truly the catalyst for economic growth and development, they should no longer be blanketed. Rather, they should be properly incentivised with a penalty clause in place for protection against land speculation or rogue investors. Otherwise, these concessions could become counterproductive and instead of facilitating, could hinder growth and development in the free trade zone. This principle was incorporated into the drafting of the Grand Bahama Investment Incentive Bill, 2016 and that is why we must move with caution before repealing it.
Madam President, the stark difference between East and West Grand Bahama, and the city of Freeport, substantiates our hypothesis that concessions stimulate economic growth.
As a result, Madam President, in June 2014, by way on an amendment to the Tariff Act, our administration honoured our promise, outlined in our Charter of Governance to extend duty free concession for new and existing businesses in East and West Grand Bahama; thus levelling the playing field, after sixty (60) years, for all business owners on the island of Grand Bahama. The entrepreneurial and employment opportunities created as a result are notable.
Madam President, the aging government infrastructure throughout Grand Bahama was also a top priority on our administration’s transformative agenda, and shortly after being named Minister, I spoke specifically about the five major government funded capital works projects air marked for Grand Bahama.
Firstly, The Fishing Hole Road, which has been a vexing problem for the people of West Grand Bahama for decades, as during adverse weather conditions, many are cut off from essential service, due to flooding. According to the Minister of Works, this project is now on hold because of budget restraints. I implore the government to complete this project hastily, as the hurricane season is upon us.
Secondly, the Freeport Fire Station, an essential facility which was destroyed in 2004.
Thirdly, The Smith’s Point Sea Wall, to address coastal erosion in that residential and touristic area. However, on Thursday, June 8th, 2017, it was reported that Smith’s Construction, a reputable company, who was awarded the contract to construct the sea wall in the coastal settlement of Smith’s Point, Grand Bahama, was ordered off the construction site by representatives from the Ministry of Works and assisted by the Royal Bahamas Police Force. This incident was extremely unfortunate; and I am advised that the contractor is pursuing legal action concerning this matter, which I support 100% percent.
Madam President, we are asking the government to move swiftly to resolve this pressing situation, to protect the people of Smith’s Point, and prevent further coastal erosion in that community, especially since the hurricane season is once again upon us.
Additionally, the junior high school in West Grand Bahama. And finally, the Freeport Community Clinic, which is the first phase of the hospital for Grand Bahama.
Madam President, much has been said to try to discredit the Urban Renewal program on Grand Bahama. The member for East Grand Bahama spoke about victimization of Urban Renewal Workers on Grand Bahama by the PLP in 2012, but the truth of the matter is all who were willing, completed their contracts; a number of them reapplied, and some, including the wife of the former Member of Parliament for Eight Mile Rock, were rehired based on their past performance.
Speaking about victimization, Madam President, all government vehicles were taken from centre managers, and parked at the police headquarters in Freeport. Without transportation and support, all the centres are practically non-functional, and it is my understanding that many of the staff are merely waiting for ‘judgment day.’ This is typical of the FNM administration’s agenda of stop, review and cancel.
Madam President, many of the social initiatives in the communities, which were geared toward the youth, seniors and shut-ins in the communities were led by Urban Renewal centre managers and staff. Without transportation, continuing this essential outreach in the community is extremely difficult.
Additionally, Madame President, as part of the relief program in the aftermath of hurricane Mathew, Urban Renewal also played an intricate role in social assessment, clean-up, and rebuilding efforts; and worked closely with the restoration technical team, and KPMG, the accounting firm that was hired by the government to oversee the hurricane relief efforts on Grand Bahama. It is my understanding, and the Minister of State could correct me if I am wrong, that this initiative is almost at a standstill, and as a result, many residents, who are in need of roof repairs or building supplies, are experiencing great difficulty, as Grand Bahama has had rainy weather over the past few weeks. As an administration, we did our part, and I implore the new administration to stop procrastinating, pick the baton and continue the race. After all, it is “the people’s time!”
Madam President, Urban Renewal’s small home repair program impacted many lives, particularly those of the elderly. the indigent and unemployed; and because of the need in the family islands, Urban Renewal Grand Bahama eventually extended its operational responsibilities to Eleuthera, Bimini, Cat island, South Andros, Exuma and Abaco to meet those needs.
Madam President, if the new government wishes to dismantle or water down the people’s Urban Renewal Program, they should just go ahead and do so; but in doing so, they should refrain from demoralising the staff, and immediately create an alternative for those Bahamians who were beneficiaries of all the programs. After all, it’s the people’s time!
Madam President, I now turn my attention to Education
Madam President, during his budget contribution, the Minister of Education, indicated that he would adopt and improve upon the majority of policies implemented by the former Minister of Education the Honourable Jerome Fitzgerald who left behind the substantial blueprint for education in The Bahamas; which includes the introduction of The National High School Diploma, the doubling of investment in scholarships, and the chartering of The University of The Bahamas.
Madam President, I recognize Minister Lloyd’s enthusiasm for education, and his passion for the implementation of a preschool pilot program. Research has proven that a sound preschool education is critical to the development of a child; and for this reason, all countries serious about education, must put both financial and manpower resources behind developing programs that will address this level of instruction. I therefore support the government’s commitment to inject some two million dollars ($2,000,000.00) into this pilot program. It’s unfortunate, however, that the proposed program will be Nassau centric, and as a result, children in Grand Bahama and the family islands will be left behind. I am imploring the government to expand the pilot program to incorporate the rest of the country, especially Grand Bahama.
Madam President, the previous administration recognized the importance of technology in the classroom; and subsequently, spent a little over six million dollars ($6,000,000.00) to upgrade computer labs in schools throughout the country; the single largest investment in technology by any government in the history of The Bahamas. During my tenure as Member of Parliament for Pineridge, I purchased computers for the Hugh Campbell Primary School from my constituency allowance, which facilitated a digital program that was launched by the Ministry of Education, to assist students with reading problems. The private sector also assisted with donations of equipment, including smart boards for primary schools in East and West Grand Bahama, which assisted in deferring the cost for technological upgrades in many of our primary schools. The creation of these interactive 21st century classrooms has enhanced the education experience; the results of which are evident in the improvement in GLAT scores. For this reason, I fully support the use of Bahamian experts to develop new technology inclusive curricula, particularly in Bahamian history, art and culture; and we are looking forward for the complete implementation of the technological programs mentioned in the budget, which would create a digital platform for early childhood education.
Madam President, The Minister also referenced the employment of hundreds of personnel at The Ministry of Education, and the Department of Education on a contractual basis; some within the past year. I wish to admonish the Minister that persons were hired to address the gaps that were found in the system, including the need for support staff and teacher’s aids; and plead with him and the present administration not to terminate those hard working Bahamians, because of their perceived political affiliation.
Madam President, the Minister also referenced the scholarship loan program, and the government’s intent to go after those who defaulted on payments.
Madam President, this issue is a complicated one, which started with the FNM. It is my understanding that the former Minister of Education Alfred Sears brought some order to the problem, but it remains unresolved. I suggest the Minister of Education move with caution, and seek further legal advice before executing his plan.
Madam President, thanks to evidence based planning and the implementation of a number of policies to address learners of varying abilities by former Minister of Education, the educational system, although not perfect, seems to be on the right track. I wish the Education Minister well; but like all other ministers, I intend to hold his feet to the fire, and ensure that what was promised to the Bahamian people in Free National Movement’s 2017 Manifesto, is delivered.
Madam President, I now turn my attention to The Ministry of Health and NHI
Madam President, the journey to the launch of NHI began more than thirty (30) years ago with the Progressive Liberal Party. Plans for the implementation of this essential service were articulated in the speech from the throne in 1983; and in 1984, the first working team on NHI was established who later reported their findings to the then government in 1987. This was followed by the Manitoba Report, and in 2001 a feasibility report on a catastrophic health insurance fund was presented. In 2002, the Blue-Ribbon commission on NHI was established, and the report was submitted to the government in 2004, which resulted in the NHI steering committee presenting its final report. In 2006, the NHI Act was passed in parliament. Unfortunately we lost the 2007 election, and the Free National Movement, despite voting for the bill; opted to implement the National Drug Prescription plan, and spoke about the implementation of a catastrophic care plan.
Nevertheless, Madam President, in our 2012 Charter of Governance, we indicated that if elected we would launch NHI, and in 2013, guided by our consultants, we established the NHI framework, inclusive of healthcare strengthening; drafted and passed the National Health Insurance Bill, 2016, which laid the necessary legal framework for the establishment of the National Health Insurance Authority’s functions and powers, and the regulatory criteria for health care administrators and providers.
Madam President, according to printed media and during the budget debate, the Minister of Health, created the impression that the Bahamian people did not get value for money from our consultants before and after the implementation of NHI.
Yes, Madam President, The Minister of Health is entitled to his opinion, but I was a member of the cabinet steering committee for NHI, and I beg to disagree. I am keenly aware of the extensive amount of work put in place by the competent team at the NHI secretariat, who were supported by both local and foreign consultants; and I stand by these competent professionals, who made their contributions to the successful launch of universal primary care, by way of NHI. I state unequivocally that we did not waste the taxpayers’ money.
I must remind the Honourable Member for Elizabeth, that hind sight is always 20/20 vision, and that much of the complications and delays we experienced were due to external factors that were completely out of our control, including Hurricanes Joaquin and Mathew, the damages to clinics in the South and Central Bahamas, Grand Bahama, North Andros and New Providence in their aftermath, and the general economic impact they had on the country. These and other factors played a part in the postponement of the launch of NHI, which resulted in the extension of the consultancy with the KPMG Health Group.
Madam President, understanding the need for more quality secondary and tertiary care services in the country, our administration proceeded with the recommendations from our global healthcare consultants, with the launch of Universal Primary healthcare services first, followed by the phasing in of selective catastrophic care, and finally the full benefit coverage.
Madam President, much of the work for selective catastrophic care was completed during our administration. In fact, our discussions with the key Bahamian consultant physicians from both the public and private sectors, including the present Minister of Health, were completed before leaving offices. A final report on the way forward for selective catastrophic care was presented to cabinet for final approval.
Nevertheless, we opted not to execute our selective catastrophic plan or put the authority in place until after the general elections.
Madam President, history would reflect that Universal healthcare coverage by way of National Health Insurance will be one of the greatest social initiative since NIB, in our country, once fully implemented. As I stated earlier, governance must be continuous. We launched NHI, and now it’s time for the FNM to continue the journey to full implementation.
Madam President, I must admit that I was disappointed that only forty million dollars ($40,000,000.00) was allocated in this year budget for National Health Insurance as compared to the one hundred and twenty plus million dollars ($120,000,000.00) proposed by our administration.
Madam President, with a mere fifteen million dollars ($15,000,000.00) allocated for primary healthcare, as well as catastrophic care, and ten million dollars ($10,000,000.00) for the full implementation of NHIA, it is obvious that the program has been watered down. This is unfortunate, Madam President, and goes against the government’s election promises to adequately fund NHI, and implement a full catastrophic care program. It is evident, by these figures that their priorities have obviously shifted!
Madam President, I now turn my attention to the disingenuous assertions of both Ministers of Finance and Health that our administration had no plan to pay for NHI, and that healthcare contracts issued by the Government months before the elections were deals to fix up our supporters. I take great exceptions to their remarks because they are absolutely untrue.
Madam President, the NHI secretariat made it very clear to the Bahamian people that the government’s plan was to launch universal primary healthcare services first free of charge, with no cash at point of service. Once it was fully up and running across the country, and the economic indicators in the country verified that our people could handle the additional tax burden; as a responsible government, we were committed to go back to the Bahamian people with a palatable plan to ensure that NHI would be sustainable. At no point did we mislead the general public in believing that NHI would be a free service on full implementation.
Madam President, post hurricane Mathew, the country’s focus was restoration, and many capital works initiatives around the country were put on hold, including our healthcare strengthening program, which was a vital component prior to the launch of NHI.
Madam President, it is public knowledge that on May 8th, 2017 a civil works contract for the Mini hospital in Eleuthera was issued, during the ground-breaking ceremony in Palmetto Point Eleuthera. This was a negotiated contract for land preparation, and the scope of work was overseen by a registered quantity surveyor, based on completed architectural drawings by Alvin Rolle and Associates. This work was in the making for over a year, and yes, we executed the contract on the eve of the general election, when the money became available. Although the contract for the vertical structure was never issued, I was pleased to learn that the current administration is committed to completing this much need mini hospital that would improve the delivery of quality of healthcare for the residents of Eleuthera.
Madam President, because of the urgency of the repairs needed at many of our outlying clinics across the country, cabinet agreed that the contracts would be negotiated based on amounts outlined in the architect and quantity surveyor’s reports. Of the forty-three (43) clinics identified, twenty-five (25) in the family islands and Grand Bahama were prioritized for immediate attention, along with the four (4) polyclinics in New Providence
Hence, Madam President, out of the twenty-five (25) priority clinics air marked by our consultants for repairs, in order to meet the NHI licensing requirements, contracts were executed for the following clinics:
- The Inagua Clinic
- Landrail Point and Colonel Hill clinics, Crooked Island
- Abraham’s Bay clinic, Mayaguana
- Deadman’s Cay clinic, Long Island
- Smith’s Bay clinic, Cat Island
- Spanish Wells and Harbour Island clinics Eleuthera
- Nichols Town and Mangrove Cay clinics, Andros
- Marsh Harbour mini hospital
- Spring Pint and Salina Point clinics Acklins
- West End, Eight Mile Rock clinics and the Freeport Community Clinic
- Fleming Street, Elizabeth Estate, Flamingo Gardens and the South Beach clinic
Madame President, I am proud of the steps we took to ensure that Bahamians across the country would finally experience equity in the delivery of essential quality primary healthcare services in all our family islands.
Madame President, I wish to reiterate that the workings of these negotiated contacts, which were approved by cabinet, were fully transparent; and all the signed contracts are at the Ministry of Finance and the PHA. The workmanship was professional, and fully supported by technical teams from the Ministry of Works, the PHA’s capital works unit, the Department of Public Health, The Ministry of Finance, our consultants from KPMG, the NHI secretariat, and the Minister for NHI.
Madam President, contrary to what is being said, no deals were cut; we did nothing wrong; and the public records are there to prove it. In fact, most of the work throughout the Family Islands is near completion, and work is still ongoing at the polyclinics in Nassau, Cat Island and Grand Bahama.
Additionally, Madam President, a negotiated civil works contract was issued, and work was started at Freeport Community Clinic site. The tender process of the actual clinic and the quantity surveyor’s report for this new sixty-two thousand (62,000) sq. ft. clinic was completed in our term in office. Funding was in place from the private sector, as arranged through the Ministry of Finance. During the budget communication, however, nothing was said about this important clinic; and I don’t see any allocation in the PHA or the Ministry of Works capital budget for its construction in this budget year. So, I am asking the Minister, through you, Madam President, to please follow through with this essential healthcare facility for the people of Grand Bahama.
Madam President, I now turn my attention to the remarks made by the Minister of Health in the honourable lower chamber, concerning an alleged tens of millions of dollar worth of healthcare contracts that were issued weeks before the general election. He further went on to imply that we did this at the expense of compromising the country’s immunization supplies, and the health and well-being of the Bahamian people.
Madam President, these statements are misleading and investigations into the allegations confirmed that at no point was the health and wellbeing of the general public ever intentionally compromised.
First and foremost, Madam President, the government never issued ninety million dollars ($90,000,000.00) worth of healthcare contracts weeks before the general election.
Secondly, Madam President, no contract in the sum of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000.00) per month was ever issued for the maintenance of the Marsh Harbour mini hospital.
Thirdly, Madam President, no monthly contract in the sum of four hundred and fifty six thousand dollars ($424,000.00) was ever issued for the Exuma mini hospital.
Madam President, these false statements were reported in the print media and went viral on social media, sending the wrong message to the Bahamian people. Although the Minister did the honourable thing in the lower chamber by withdrawing the statement, much of the damage was already done.
Closing Remarks
Madam President, as I wrap up my contribution to this budget debate, I do so by restating that as an administration, we did some heavy lifting and made the unpopular decisions that brought us back on the road to recovery.
Yes, Madam President, the people of the country rejected us on Election Day. Nevertheless, we have accepted our loss at the polls, and have begun the rebuilding process. Although the opposition forces may be small, we will continue to fight to ensure that this government, who spoke a lot about transparency, and accountability on the campaign, put words into action.
Madam President, the FNM promised the Bahamian people the world, thus creating unrealistic expectations; while painting the picture that those of us in the former administration were dishonest and crooked.
However, Madam President, the campaign is over and it is time to govern; and you can rest assured that we will hold this FNM administration’s feet to the fire; beginning with this budget, which clearly demonstrates their priority, which is to support the rich, and put the small man on the back burner.
Madam President, I end with admonishing this new administration; it’s prime time now, so stop making excuses, stop blaming the PLP for your short comings and start governing!
After all, it’s the people’s time!
Thank you.
-
Contribution By The Hon. Glenys Hanna Martin 2016-2017 Budget Debate
Nassau, Bahamas – Minister Of Transport And Aviation And Member Of Parliament For The Englerston Constituency Contribution By The Hon. Glenys Hanna Martin 2016-2017 Budget Debate delivered on Thursday, 16 June, 2016 in the House of Assembly:
Mr. Speaker, I rise in this Honourable House to contribute to this 2016/2017 Budget Debate:
Mr. Speaker, I rise to contribute to this 2016/2017 Budget Debate; I do so as Minister of Transport and Aviation in this Government and as the Member of Parliament for the Constituency of Englerston.
Mr. Speaker I have had the privilege to gain entry into this honourable House for three consecutive terms through the auspices of the good people of Englerston.
A significant portion of this representation (which included two stints as a Minister of the Government) has occurred during what may come to be known as among the most difficult times in the history of our country thus far.
I certainly know that for many of the people that I represent being out of work and the concomitant issues that accompany this has had a debilitating effect but Mr. Speaker, in the midst of it all they have remained proud and held steadfast knowing that God will carry them through the hard times into prosperity, that weeping endureth for a night but joy comes in the morning.
Mr. Speaker, I have had the opportunity to speak recently with the Prime Minister, the Member for Centreville, who has expressed a shared desire to bring a deepened involvement of the Urban Renewal initiative in the Englerston community and elsewhere throughout the country.
I prefer to refer to this initiative not as Urban Renewal but as an Urban Transformation; this initiative is to include the comprehensive rehabilitation of streets through paving, it includes the resolution of vexing drainage issues throughout the constituency which currently lead to chronic flooding; it requires the enhancement of public safety through the repair of street lights and the erection or replacement of signage; it will require the refreshing of road markings to bolster road safety; the installation of speed bumps where appropriate but also to include school zones so as to ensure better and safer traffic management within residential communities in particular; it will require an aggressive programme of cutting down overgrown and bushy areas which create serious safety concerns, and the demolition of abandoned structures, the removal of all derelict vehicles, this initiative will mandate the strict enforcement of laws as it relates to unlicensed roadside garages which today create noise pollution and the emission of toxic fumes and other environmental health issues and nuisance to adjoining properties and to neighbourhoods in general, the initiative will require a focused programme, street by street for the removal of garbage mounds and bulk waste; and the taking of all necessary measures for the eradication of rodents and mosquitoes and other pests which pose public health risks;
Mr. Speaker, in addition I have spoken to the Deputy Prime Minister who is also the Minister for Urban Development who himself has been contemplating a methodology and means for an accelerated programme of small house repair so as to impact as many homes as possible in the shortest period of time in an effort to radically reform substandard living conditions and also to eliminate once and for all every outside toilet.
In the course of these activities it is envisioned that economy will be generated within Englerston and in other communities by the creation of employment while at the same time procuring an enhanced quality of life for many people now living in poverty conditions including thousands of children.
This approach combined with the aggressive training programme which will target young men and women and create new economic opportunities as announced by the Prime Minister but also to include self-help initiatives through entrepreneurial activities and in the creation of new cottage industries will, I believe, go a long way in reducing the misery index in our country and will ultimately endure to the collective good of the entire whole.
Mr. Speaker, this must be a multi- ministerial effort involving many agencies and to include the private sector, particularly those which operate businesses in these communities and who as part of the collective whole will similarly benefit from these initiatives.
Mr. Speaker I will be moving after this Debate to procure the coordination of these efforts in the Englerston community to effect true Urban Transformation.
Mr. Speaker, The alleviation of poverty conditions is a philosophical mandate of the Progressive Liberal Party; it is embedded within our commitment to wipe every tear from every eye.
It is engendered by the understanding that there exists historic structural inequities and that the policies of the State must do all that it must not to support and nurture a status quo but to radically transform human society.
If we do not address these issues the collective whole, our nation, will remain diseased and ailing for we as a people are as strong as our weakest link.
Mr Speaker, I have pledged in this fiscal year to continue in my support of the schools in the Englerston community; I believe I have the distinction of having more schools in my constituency than any other member of this House; these schools are namely EP Roberts Primary, CH Reeves Junior High, RM Bailey Senior High, AF Adderley Junior High, Ridgeland Primary, CW Sawyer Primary, Yellow Elder Primary, the Coconut Grove Preschool and until recently Mable Walker Primary. Additionally, there are two other schools which are just outside of the constituency boundary but which also service the community namely Government High School and Claridge Primary School.
Mr. Speaker, I have sought over the years to build-up strong alliances with these schools and through the use of constituency funding and otherwise to lend support to various initiatives important to these schools and to assist in achieving their stated goals and objectives.
These schools continue to hold their own and many of which are showing progressive improvement in overall performance.
Mr. Speaker, as a result of this involvement I have watched over the years the progress of so many young people.
It has been a joy to see young people excel despite the odds, knowing that oftentimes they come from difficult backgrounds and where they have to work sometimes10 times harder than many of their peers to overcome their obstacles and setbacks to achieve their high success.
Mr. Speaker in this regard I will take the risk in this contribution of singling out two young men, one from Ridgeland Park West and the other from Palm Beach Street – Justin Smith and Danavio Neeley.
Neither of these young men come from what can be described as “privileged” backgrounds and in the case of Danavio, he lost both parents as a young boy. Just last week, however, both graduated from CR Walker High School with distinction, Justin as Head Boy and Danavio as Deputy Head Boy. They have both won awards and honours throughout their school years including their final year of graduation. And they have both been accepted to tertiary institutions internationally.
Mr. Speaker, I cannot tell you how proud I am of these young men.
After these many years of personal witness I am convinced that our children who are born into and grow up in inner city communities with all of its concomitant challenges require just the right involvement, and just the appropriate stimuli to cause for them to excel and reach their incredible potential.
You can well imagine, therefore, when I see this objective not realized or attained, how distressing, frustrating and painful it is to see otherwise talented children fall by the wayside .
That is why Mr. Speaker, I will advocate with great vigour and force for more and more resources to be invested into Englerston and other such communities so as to improve quality of life and enhance opportunities for a promising future for our children.
And so Mr. Speaker, I am very pleased that a commitment has been made to this end.
Mr. Speaker, I also seek to give my support to as many of the churches as possible in the Englerston constituency and to their varying programmes including food programmes and other outreach programmes because I know the work that many of these churches do as they are physically positioned in the heart of the people.
I know the involvement many churches have in the community and the shelter they provide in the time of storm.
In the case of the schools and many of the churches I have sought to develop a meaningful mutual partnership for the upliftment of the community.
Mr. Speaker, there is a third entity, however, which I consider a partner in my work as Member of Parliament and that is the Urban Renewal offices in Englerston East and Englerston West headed by ASP McKenzie and ASP Pratt, respectively.
Theses senior officers lead multi-agency teams as well as with the involvement of community stakeholders in a number of important initiatives in their respective areas: they routinely conduct community policing on foot throughout the community, going door to door to residences and to business places; they have developed alliances with all of the schools, they conduct mobile patrol, they provide follow up with and support for victims in the aftermath of a crime; they oversee a number of youth programmes – sporting, cultural and academic. Englerston West manages a school suspension programme for children who have been suspended from school.
Mr Speaker, I have come to learn that many times these children who have been suspended from school are not just rude teenagers; far too often they are emotionally or psychologically injured human beings. The stories that I have encountered are heart-breaking and I have learned over the years that we ought not create stereotypes in an as assessment of each case because we run the risk of misperceiving precisely what we are dealing with.
Mr Speaker, we must speak truth: Many of these young people are traumatized child victims of sexual or physical abuse or neglect and many suffer emotional disturbances as a result;
Mr. Speaker, I recall in particular a young man I met at the Centre a couple years ago who was part of that school suspension programme; he had the terrible misfortune as a young boy of witnessing the murder of two people, one being his mother and the other his father. He was being raised by his grandmother. If I had not heard his story for myself I would have found it hard to believe that any Bahamian child could have possibly have had this nightmare as part of his early experience
Mr. Speaker, the suspension programme places these children in a caring and disciplined environment as opposed to simply dumping then onto the streets.
Mr. Speaker both Urban Renewal Centres offer after-school academic assistance programmes. In this regard I wish to recognize two very wonderful people; the first is a remarkable young man by the name of Chet Pratt who has been working in the Englerston community for several years.
Chet tutors, without charge, many young students, preparing them for BJC’s or BGCSE’s and the results of this intervention have been outstanding. Chet is often assisted by his father and his sister, The Pratt family is truly a caring and giving family.
The other person is Vernal Brathwaite, a lecturer at the College Of The Bahamas who has chosen to take himself into the Englerston community to provide invaluable tutoring to a group of young teenagers in BGCSE Maths and Science.
Mr Brathwaite extends this generosity on a purely voluntary basis
Mr. Speaker, these men are demonstrating Christian love and concern and responsibility in a way that is most inspiring.
They are providing access and opportunity to so many young people who would ordinarily not have ever been able to avail themselves of such and perhaps not even in their or their parents’ wildest dreams.
And because of their efforts these children will do well, Mr. Speaker
Outreach Programmes such as these exemplify the African proverb that it takes a village to raise a child. And today Mr. Speaker, the child in this 21st century village faces issues and pressures that were never imagined when that proverb was first articulated so many years ago but its truth is as relevant today as it was then.
So Mr. Speaker, I have partnered with these various entities in a shared effort to open windows of opportunity, to alleviate suffering and to provide hope of a good life.
And in the midst of it all I have tried to maintain as close an access to the people I represent as is possible.
This has often proven to be very challenging considering the vast geography, the huge population and the distinct communities comprising the Englerston constituency particularly as created by the boundary changes made in the last General Election.
But I am humbled that the people of this constituency have seen fit to send me as the Progressive Liberal Party candidate to this House to be their standard-bearer for all these years.
I am particularly anxious for the training and employment project to commence at the earliest opportunity as I have many, many constituents who are looking forward with the great anticipation for the opportunity to become productively employed.
Mr. Speaker, before I leave my constituency, I have over the years been very fortunate to have a cadre of very loyal people who have stood in the trenches with me, win, lose or draw. Mr. Speaker these people are no fakers. They are not cowards. One such person who has been with me since he was a very young man and every step of the way in my political representation died suddenly a few days ago, Ian Hanna aka Ian Johnson of Charles Vincent Street and Englerston at large. Ian was only in his early 30’s but he was an incredible leader in his own right, and extremely bright. He was loyal without question and consistent in his support of me and in his defense of my representation over the many years and was beloved by all in the community.
I take this opportunity to salute him and to send my heartfelt condolences to his mother, Patricia and his sisters, his grandmother and his aunts and extended family and all of his friends including those from the Patch.
Mr Speaker, I think it only appropriate that I say a few words about the recent referendum exercise. I wish to say that I accept unreservedly the decision-making of those who participated in the exercise. I have sought to analyse the results which blanketed the nation including the majority of voters who did not participate at all in the Referendum process.
I believe I understand the issues of concern including that of citizenship and I am well aware that the Bahamian people jealously guard and protect our citizenship.
I also understand the fear that the amendment to question 4 would allow for interpretation by our courts that marriages between persons of the same sex would become lawful although there are competing legal views on that issue.
I do have a concern, however, and will find it unacceptable that there may have been in some quarters a resistance to the principle that women are entitled to the same rights, privileges and protections under the law of our country as men are entitled to. This I cannot accept. This is unacceptable. And I am trusting that as we grow and progress as a country that whatever has not been achieved in the proposed amendments that there is a clear understanding and acceptance that while men and women are different, we are nevertheless entitled to the same protections, rights and opportunities without discrimination
Women represent more than half of the population: our journey over the generations to be accorded and afforded the same human rights as are accorded to men has been a difficult one. We must remember there was a time women could not vote simply because they were women, married women could not hold property. It is reputed that a man could chastise his wife with a rod the width of his thumb but no larger. When we look at the alarming rate of rape in The Bahamas, a crime of sexual violence, it must cause for concern.
I am convinced we must look this issue clearly in the eyes and seek to address and confront issues such as this and domestic violence and other dysfunctions in male-female relationships particularly as it relates to the rearing of children, too many of whom are growing up with absentee fathers and suffering the effects of this abandonment in a most negative way.
And so I accept and respect the views of the voters even though I supported all 4 amendments. We must continue to ensure, however, that all forms of discrimination against women are eradicated. We will not progress as a country otherwise.
Mr. Speaker, as Minister of Transport and Aviation, I am winding down to the final year of this term which I believe may be shown to have been a productive one.
Mr. Speaker, we are a small island developing state with limited resources. We must carefully choose our priorities and pursue them diligently in the interest of our national progress. It is very unhelpful, however, for political voicings to seek to create false expectations or capitalise on frustrations. This may create dissent but it will certainly make it more difficult to stay on course as people in light of our peculiar challenges.
These political noises are also most annoying when the facts show that much of what is complained about were actually created by their policies or by their own egregious inaction. But I guess this is what we call “politics” but I think most Bahamians see through this.
Mr. Speaker, In order to fully understand our efforts in this Ministry therefore you will have to appreciate the state of things when we took office and to view and assess the progress of this administration by that measuring stick, understanding that it has been uphill.
Mr Speaker, this Ministry concerns many sectors and hence comprises many agencies or departments which are important to the economy of The Bahamas. These include the aviation sector, the maritime sector, ground transport, the postal system and the Department of Meteorology.
Mr. Speaker, the aviation sector is a key component in our national life: it facilitates the tourism economy and assures our social cohesion as an archipelagic people.
It is no surprise, therefore that we would have some 56 airports in this country, 29 of which are government owned and operated.
We have done well. I do not agree with the Member for St Ann’s that our airports are a “joke” as he put it yesterday. But we cannot argue that the need for a massive overhaul and resource-injection is overdue. It was overdue when the FNM held office 4 years ago but if you were to listen to them in this Honourable House you would think something happened overnight while they were asleep in their beds.
We have been actively engaging in a process to modernize the aviation sector in our country.
In the last 4 years this modernization process has involved multiple approaches on all fronts: it has involved the restructuring of the civil aviation agencies that oversee and operate the aviation machinery in The Bahamas.
Mr. Speaker you will recall we recently debated and unanimously passed legislation in this House for the creation of a regulatory body, the Civil Aviation Authority, to be responsible solely for the oversight of safety and security protocols and systems at aerodromes and in aviation nationwide; the legislation also creates an air navigation agency the BANSD for the management of air traffic nationwide and for the maintenance and management of ancillary equipment and technology such as radars and navigation aids and communications equipment for the facilitation of air traffic management; You will recall that Family Island airports and their operations will transfer to the Airport Authority into their newly created Family Island Division; and an accident and investigation unit has been created out of the office of the Minister of Aviation which will be mandated to investigate aviation accidents and in the promotion of aviation safety.
The process is in its final phases and it is expected that within the next 6 months the transition will have been fully effected. Mr. Speaker, this will have the effect of creating a transparent and reputable aviation sector in The Bahamas that is fully compliant with ICAO standards.
From a technical point of view, however, the Civil Aviation Department over the last 4 years has been very busy building capacity – human, technological and infrastructural in the aviation sector for our country and in the interest of our people.
To this end the Government has Purchased and installed and the Bahamian people now own a new, state of the art ASR12 Radar system from IndraSistemas of Spain.
This major technology acquisition has remediated what has been in effect a tenuous situation with our radar system for many years.
Additionally the new APP Building, the Approach Control Centre has been constructed from which radar controllers will operate and where controllers are being trained with the state of the art simulators housed in that building.
Air traffic Controllers and airway facility staff have already completed training in Spain.
We have recruited 10 new air traffic controllers who have completed their training and they are now undergoing on-the-job training. A process is now underway for the recruitment of an additional 10 new air traffic controllers as we seek to develop a strong cadre of air traffic controllers in this important sector of our economy.
We have recruited 5 new radar technicians who will join and supplement the unit with responsibility for the maintenance and repair of our radar system.
To bolster and strengthen the safety oversight mechanisms in The Bahamas, over the last 4 years we hired the first ever cadre of aerodrome inspectors, six in total with responsibility bringing for the first time a specialized and focused oversight of safety and security at all airports in The Bahamas.
We have added to the total complement of Airworthiness Inspectors for Flight Standards Inspectorate and most recently the hiring and training of two (2) additional Airworthiness inspectors for the Flight Standards Inspectorate, the Hiring and training of one (1) Operations Inspector for the Flight Standards Inspectorate and the Hiring and Training of one (1) Cabin Safety Inspector for the Flight Standards Inspectorate. We are in the process of recruiting after a public advertisement process another 2 additional airworthiness inspectors and one operations inspector.
Over the last 4 years we have undertook a number of infrastructural projects and improvements including the Mayaguana runway improvement project, the Reconstruction and extension and increase of capacity of the Staniel Cay, Exuma runway inclusive of solar lighting and perimeter fencing, the Refurbishment and reconstruction of San Salvador airport. The redevelopment of the Bimini Airport inclusive of an enlarged terminal building and an extended runway from 5,400 feet to 6,400 feet and made ready for night flights; the completion of the Marsh Harbour International airport which will be renamed next month as the Leonard M Thompson International Airport as part of the official Independence celebrations; the completion of phases 2 and 3 of the Lynden Pindling International Airport. Now underway are the redevelopment projects for the Exuma International Airport, the North Eleuthera Airport, the Moore’s Island airport, the Great Harbour Cay Airport and the Mayaguana terminal.
Mr Speaker I mentioned at the outset that the Government has responsibility for 29 airports: this requires tremendous capital investment from the public treasury. To this end My Ministry has obtained grant funding from the IDB for the conduct of a study (technical and financial) to determine the feasibility of attracting private investment through a PPP scheme for family island airports, and to develop a financial model of selected airports and concession alternatives.
The first phase involved a preliminary outlook of potential opportunities for PPPs and focused on 13 airports:
Governor’s Harbour North Eleuthera
Rock Sound Bimini
Marsh Harbour Treasure Cay
Exuma
San Salvador New Bight
San Andros Andros Town
Deadman’s Cay Great Harbour Cay
Mathew Town
The study consisted of:
* a Market assessment
* Preliminary demand projections
* review of infrastructure development plans (Stantec Report combined investment of approximate $160 million)
* selection of most feasible options for airport(s)
The following elements were reviewed:
*capital expenditure required,
*Earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA)
* Net Present Value
* Internal rate of return
Phase 2 will now involve :
a detailed market assessment & traffic forecast
independent capital expenditure verification
Environmental assessment
Concession financial model
Teaser for potential private operators.
The intention is to seek public private partnerships which will attract the capital for infrastructural redevelopment of select airports while at the same time maintaining government ownership, oversight and controls. It is a hoped for “win-win” situation for the Bahamian people.
We are preparing for the acquisition of a number of crash fire rescue trucks for Exuma, Marsh Harbour, North Eleuthera, Rock Sound airports for a total cost of $2.5 million.
Mr. Speaker the last 4 years have seen great strides in the aviation sector and I believe the platform is being created for great economic growth and development throughout our country.
In addition to these important initiatives, the Civil Aviation Department has promulgated regulations for the use of drones in The Bahamas. I am pleased to advise the Department has now completed the process for an online facility for the registration of unmanned aerial systems (UAS) or drones at www.bcaa.gov.bs.
Once logged in the applicant will be required to create an account and provide the necessary information about themselves and the UAS that is being registered.
At the end of the process the applicant can print out the registration certificate which they will sign notifying that the Small UAS/ Drone has been registered with the Department of Civil Aviation. The certificate must be in the possession of the operator when the small UAS/ drone is being operated.
Mr. Speaker, my inquiries thus far indicate that we are the only country in the region which has promulgated regulations for the use of drones despite the fact that this has been a pressing and troublesome issue worldwide to aviation safety.
Mr. Speaker, finally you will have heard both the Prime Minister and myself speak over the various budget periods about the establishment of an aircraft registry and an aircraft mortgage registry. We have now in hand the final report with recommendations from consultants engaged to study the feasibility of such an imitative within the context of the Bahamian economy: The ICF Report recommends that The Bahamas enter the aircraft mortgage registration business and has recommended an implementation plan spanning 28 months. However, before the Plan is initiated the following must be done:
* Modify legal & tax regulations (either ratify Cape Town Convention or enact legislation that mirrors the Convention to provide aircraft owners and financiers the level of protection over interest in their assets; and waive or eliminate the 10% customs duty on the importation of new aircraft)
* Update the current fee schedule for aircraft registration as current schedules are insufficient to cover the cost the current registry and will create a large deficit with an expanded registry;
* Develop robust registration processes (detailed and thorough processes)
* Develop partnerships & relationships with stakeholders (Bahamas Financial Services Board- Ministry of Tourism – Business & Commercial Aviation networks- Bahamas Maritime Authority)
The government must now make a decision on when and how we will proceed to implementation.
Mr Speaker, during this period we have also sought to redress a number of anomalies in salaries in the department of civil aviation, we have sought to bring a focus to resolving career path issues, we have invested tremendous resources in training and human development, we have completed an industrial agreement with BATCU and have procured the relocation of the department and staff members to new physical premises
Mr. Speaker, I believe these 4 years have been fairly productive years and that our energies and the investment of public resources have been in the interest of the Bahamian people and will have the effect of substantively taking our people forward.
Mr. Speaker the Road Traffic Department is a critical agency as a revenue generator to the Public Treasury and for the establishments of standards for ground transport in The Bahamas. It is an agency, however, that has received little investment for an extended period of time and as a consequence operates with antiquated systems and in a deteriorated environment.
When I spoke in this House in 2012 in our first Budget debate I observed then in the 5 years of sitting on that side of the House in Opposition the then government barely made mention of this critical Department in budget speeches or otherwise.
The sad truth is (and the Opposition knows this) that the findings in the Auditor General’s Report could very well be descriptive of the state of operations 5 years ago and even 10 years ago.
What the current Auditor General’s Report notes but omitted, however, in previous reports is that there has not been a vehicle register for many years in that Department according to my advice.
This observation, that is the absence of a vehicle register, as far as we have been able to ascertain, is for the first time ever mentioned in any report; this observation also formed the basis of a forecast of loss of revenue of some $10 million based on an extrapolation founded upon assumptions.
Mr. Speaker, this formula could very well have been deployed at any time in the past although this was not the case. It is very possible therefore that the Report may have the effect of not putting in a correct context the operational realities of that Department which have been long standing.
In any event the Controller ,who has day to day oversight, has given a full analysis to the Report and has now shared the pertinent information provided by the Auditor General with the Royal Bahamas Police Force to investigate findings of alleged malfeasance as outlined in that Report.
Additionally the Controller has introduced new internal controls based upon recommendations contained in that report. He has updated the Department’s Procedures Manual and implemented Internal Control Procedures to improve accountability and improve revenue collection.
In addition the department will implement additional measures at its headquarters’ site as well as the two additional sites in New Providence (Carmichael Road and West Bay Street).
Mr Speaker, I have previously communicated to this Honourable House as to the project now underway which will radically transform the operations of this critical agency including creating greatly improved efficiencies, enhanced customer experience and a higher degree of accountability in the collection of public revenue and the avoidance of fraud. This will be the case not only in New Providence but throughout the country. This is known as The Ministry of Transport and Aviation – Road Traffic Department modernization process of Drivers Licence and Motor Vehicle Registration-Licence system which is soon to be officially launched. Vehicle Licencing will begin roll out at the beginning of October and Drivers Licence at the beginning of December. The roll out will be completed by February 2017.
User acceptance training will begin June20th and subsequent training of additional staff will take place in July, August and September
Training for all staff will entail Basic and Intermediate Computer, system training, and Customer Service
This system will provide a fully integrated IT system that will greatly improve internal controls in the department and thus improve revenue collection of the department.
Total Amount budgeted for the project $8, 371,908.00
Total Amount Budgeted for Data Torque $3,622,278.00
Amount Expended to Data Torque to date $1,942,410.82
Amount Expended to Smart Consulting $261,250.00
Amount Expended for Printers and Consumables $846,934.00
Mr Speaker for all the critics and especially for those who wish to take parasitical advantage of this dire situation that has been allowed to persist in this critical agency including those who will conjure up phantom tales about previous efforts and alleged companies from Singapore, I call upon you to be honest with yourselves and the Bahamian people about these circumstances and support the government in its quest to address this long-overdue reform process.
While this process is underway, however, the Controller has undertook to focusing on the implementation of additional measures to effect greater efficiencies within the department; included among these are.
* Increase counter space at main Road Traffic office by the end of the first quarter 2016/2017 (funding from budget – Allocation $6,600)
* Creation of a new satellite office in Eastern new Providence and Family Islands (Bimini and Cat Island)
* Creation of a Customer Care Unit in the first quarter by July 31, 2016
Mr. Speaker, the Government has just agreed to the entering into of a public private partnership for the acquisition and redevelopment of a signature site for the Road Traffic Department on the Tonique Williams darling Highway. This new location will allow for a state of the art premises which are spacious and facilitate rational operations of the department including inspections, examinations and licensing. Included in this also will be a driving range which will allow for testing of new drivers which is currently done at the Fort Charlotte location.
The historic and comprehensive review of the legislation governing road traffic, vehicles and public service licences and offences, the Road traffic Act is nearing its final completion and I am hopeful will be brought to this house within the next several months after consultation.
We continue our efforts for the reform of the public transport system on this island. The Inter-American Development Bank has provided a Grant of $500,000.00 to finance a six month Pilot Project that will form the basis for the island wide roll out of the comprehensive unified public (bus) transportation system on the island of New Providence.
Part of the Grant will be used to contract a transportation specialist consultancy firm which has already been selected to provide technical support to the Ministry of Transport and Aviation for the implementation of:
* comprehensive reform of the public bus service in New Providence
* commence with the operation and organization and concomitant evaluation of a Demonstration Pilot Project of the proposed Bus Unification initiative
* the preparation of the technical documents in support of a credit request to the IDB for island wide roll out of the reformed unified bus system
Specifically the consultant will be required to:
* conduct a review of the existing policy documents of the proposed Unified Bus system
* defining the roles of different stakeholders in the proposed Unified Bus system
* operationalizing and ensuring the coordination and implementation for the pilot demonstrative initiative
* effectively lead the initiative to plan, manage, design, execute implement
* the pilot initiative, including conducting all necessary workshops, surveys and designs for its implementation
* continuously evaluating the pilot initiative and make recommendations for the island wide rollout
* developing the infrastructure designs, institutional systems as well as the legal framework, to support the reforms with a compendium of terms of reference as required
* assisting the Government of The Bahamas with the preparation of a loan application to the IDB to finance Government investments required for the island wide rollout of the Bus Unification System
* assisting the Government of The Bahamas in the execution of the implementation plan, and
* assessing the need for changes in additional legislation to implement the proposed reforms
It is my hope and expectation that the consultant will be in place to enable the project to commence in the new school year.
In the meantime Mr. Speaker let us be proactive as concerned citizens. I have seen and heard much lamenting about infractions in the public transport system. I urge yet again that we take responsibility for our transport system and where you see abuses or infractions to call our hotline established specifically for this purpose – 322 7623 – 322 ROAD. The Controller will take it from there.
Mr. Speaker, the Controller is bringing a renewed focus on road safety included in this is the implementation of crossing guards in school zones
* Yellow Elder Primary – Two (2) Guards
* Sandilands Primary – One (1) Guard
* Stephen Dillet Primary – One (1) Guard
* Thelma Gibson Primary – One (1) Guard
* Columbus Primary – One (1) Guard
* Carmichael Primary – One (1) Guard
* Albury Sayle Primary – One (1) Guard
* Woodcock Primary – One (1) Guard
Additional 16 Crossing Guards are needed at the following schools:
* C. W. Sawyer Primary
* Carlton Francis Primary
* Centreville Primary
* Cleveland Eneas Primary
* Columbus Primary (additional 1)
* E. P. Roberts Primary
* Oakes Field Primary
A review has been completed for family island schools and implementation will take place In Grand Bahama, Abaco, Exuma and Eleuthera in the first instance.
Mr. Speaker among the findings in the Auditor General’s report related to the long-standing system of production of licence plates. Although not mentioned in that report, we have been ahead of this concern and have completed a Request for Proposal (RFP) process was published on Monday January 25 in the News Papers and on The Bahamas Government website. Two companies submitted proposals to the Tenders Board on Friday 19 February, 2016. Following the submission of same an evaluation committee made up of personnel from the Ministry of Finance, The Bahamas Correctional Service and Road Traffic met and completed the evaluation process. The selected submission will be shortly submitted to the Tenders Board and thereafter be submitted for Cabinet approval The Estimate cost $800,000 to $1 M
Taxis duty exemption, call up increased fares
Moratorium review
Mr Speaker the Ministry has completed its . Small Island Traffic Study through its consultant Caribbean Civil group which has conducted a survey on five small islands currently facing growing concerns about traffic management (Harbour Island, Spanish Wells, Elbow Cay, Green Turtle Cay and Great Guana Cay).
The draft report has been submitted to the Ministry and is being assessed I n preparation for consultation with local communities and the implementation of strategies and legislative measures in these communities.
Total Amount Budgeted for Project $115, 115.30
Taxis duty exemption, call up increased fares
Moratorium review
Surreys duty exemption
Mr Speaker the maritime sector is an intrinsic feature of our national identity. We are a maritime people. My Ministry is engaged in building technical and infrastructural capacity nationwide. At Prince George Dock, the busiest cruise port in the region, infrastructural works are constantly underway including most recently the upgrading of the CCTV system, fencing upgrades, refurbishment of surfaces and kerbing, improved signage for enhanced safety. With the growth of the Prince George Dock as a world premiere port facility action must be taken to cause for a more efficient and commercially based management of this facility. This has been much talked about but we are at the stage where an appropriate management paradigm must be struck to achieve the desired objective without divestment of the facility to private hands.
Continued work is underway for the repair of the Marsh Harbour and work has already been completed in the installation of CCTV, in the erection of perimeter fencing and the completion of a guard house. Security officers are now being recruited several whom are expected to undergo training very shortly before assuming post
The Three Island Dock has been completed and is under the oversight of an officer seconded from the RBDF along with other staff. The Fresh Creek Dock Works have been completed and recruitment is underway for staff to manage that facility. We are increasing the complement and hence the capacity of the Exuma Port to more adequately address the growing maritime activities on the mainland and the Cays and for the first time ever a Port Office in Bimini has been established and additional recruitment will be underway to more adequately staff that office. The Potters Cay Dock redevelopment is well advanced and the completion of phase 2 is nearing its end
The Potter’s Cay Dock Project is steadily progressing as the site is now being visibly and physically transformed to meet the facility’s objectives. Which is the promotion of safety, functionality, efficiency and security. Also the upgrading of the aesthetics of the area.
Once completed the transformation will include, adjustments to the entrance and exit causeways, creation of loading zones and curbing’s, creation of alternative parking, sidewalks, bulk heading of the Eastern Section (Concrete Barrier) signage, road markings, asphalt paving and security check points. Passenger holding, bathroom facilities and a freight depot which are components of Phase Ill.
Work Specifics:-
Construction of bulkhead/curbing completed;
Installation of drainage and catch basin — 90% completed; Roadway and parking lot base is completed awaiting asphalt paving;
Boardwalk has begun;
Landscape preparation is ongoing.
Phase 11
i. Bulkhead and curbing completed;
Paving of roadway at Eastern Section is completed;
Planters and sidewalks – 90% completed;
Freight depot parking lot – 75% completed; Garbage disposal site re-location completed; Roadway stripping has begun.
Note:
G & Construction
Constructed Sum
Contingency Sum
Total Approved Funding
$585,000.00
$58,500.00
$643,500.00
Island Pavers
Contractual Sum
Contingency Sum
$1,326,891.26 $199,033.69
Total Approved Funding $1,525,924.95
Phase 3 involves and will be completed
Mr Speaker, we are also finalizing a complete review of the complement of maritime legislation in this country. You will have seen the ISPS Regulations which were recently laid in this parliament and which forms a part of this compendium of amendments and enactments. These regulations are historic and for the first time codify into law the ISPS Code for Port Security. The proposed amendments will enhance standards for maritime safety in both leisure and commercial maritime activity and there will be a ratings system for crewing. Increased efforts are underway nationwide for revenue collection.
Training
Lightering
Water sports – booths Maritime Policy
The Port Department will be recruiting new staff for the Port Facility in Marsh Harbour, Abaco, Exuma, Andros and Eleuthera.
The Port Department will also be putting controls in place with a view to collecting all outstanding revenue in the Family Islands.
The Berry Islands has the potential to bring in revenue from two (2) Marinas, commercial vessels and docks in the amount of $200,000.00
Automation The Department has a registry of approximately Eighteen Thousand registered vessels which include Mail Boats, Cargo Vessels, Commercial Vessels, Ferryboats and Pleasure Crafts.
The Port Department is engaged in building capacity for the strengthening of regulatory oversight to assure maritime safety throughout the nation, to enhance revenue collection and to procure infrastructural developments that keep us compliant with IMO standards.
Mr Speaker, the Post Office has been plagued by many chronic issues chief of which is the physical conditions of the General Post Office on East Hill Street. The government has now identified a solution to this long-standing problem with the relocation of those operations to be undertaken to the former City Market Shopping Centre situated on the East west Highway junction with the Tonique Williams Highway – plans are now under review and timelines being developed for each phase of the relocation. The Minister for Accommodations will speak further to this development but it is our hope that relocation will be effected in full by December of this year.
Mr Speaker the Auditor General undertook an audit of the Post Office Savings Bank which has highlighted deficiencies in the system and possible malfeasance. A Police investigation is underway.
But the most critical issue is that the computerized records crashed in 2008 causing for a manual system to be implemented. I believe it is because of this that the Auditor General stationed at the General Post Office two of his officers to conduct daily reviews of operations but despite this vulnerabilities persisted which highlights the stubborn weaknesses inherent in manual accounting systems which are widespread and complex.
The Ministry engaged an accounting firm which has for several months been involved in the meticulous process of digitizing accounts and preparing accounts for full digitization.
With these fundamental reforms underway, the Post Office will now seek to strengthen its human resource complement by additional staffing and comprehensive training. New products are lined up including a proposed partnership with an internationally established fast mail company so as to create modern products within the operational capability for the Post Office.
Mr. Speaker, The Bahamas Department of Meteorology is a critical agency for The Bahamas having regard to our low lying geography and our consequent vulnerabilities to sever weather patterns, climate change and to hurricanes. The Department’s Mission is “to provide high quality meteorological and climatological information on a timely basis to be used by special interest agencies and the public at large for research, education and the protection of lives and property.” The Department plays a significant role in aviation.
To successfully accomplish this mandate, on a twenty-four hour seven days a week (24/7) basis, the BDOM must possess a range of resources: including an ample compliment of trained staff in all areas, fully operational equipment, modernized technology and suitable workplace environments.
For many years there had been a critical shortage of manpower in the Forecasters and Observers Ranks resulting in the Forecasters and Observers working for extended periods which placed enormous pressures on officers.
To this end, between 2014 to 2015, the Department hired 15 persons, all of whom were to be trained as meteorological observers. Already 4 of the trainees have completed the Entry Level Technicians Course (Meteorological Observers Course) at the Caribbean Institute for Meteorology and Hydrology (CIMH) in Bridgetown, Barbados. They returned in December 2015 and are completing their on-the-job training before CIMH provides them with their official certification. The other 11 trainees are to attend CIMH in August 2016. :
Further, of these 15 persons hired, 4 will be assigned to the Electronics Section after their initial training and 2 of the remaining persons will be assigned to our Freeport Office. The electronics section of the Department will now take on a critical importance as the Government has now agreed to the acquisition of 4 new Doppler radars to be positioned throughout the archipelago including Mayaguana, Grand Bahama and Long Island. This will provide a comprehensive, real time coverage for observers and forecasters which will arm the Department with the ability to instantaneously warn for the protection of life and property.
Mr Speaker additionally ICAO has mandated that by December 2016 all Aviation Forecasters must be qualified to at least a Bachelor of Science (BSc) Degree in Meteorology or a BSc Degree in an accepted science with certification in the Basic Instruction Package for Meteorological Technicians (BIP-MT). In this regard, one of the Department’s officers has completed the BIP-MT certification at CIMH in 2015; Another officer is to complete studies at the BSc Degree level in Meteorology at the University of the West Indies, Mona Campus by 2017; and another officer based at the Freeport office, will leave to pursue a BSc Degree in Meteorology at the University of the West Indies, Barbados, Cave Hill Campus, in August 2016.
The Department is building technological, infrastructural and human resource capacity to position this Department as a powerful tool in the arsenal of the COTB.
Presently, BDOM’s Forecast Office is located in the Old Terminal Building at LPIA, and on Friday/01/July/2016 NAD will begin renovations to a space in the new domestic terminal, previously occupied by Sky Bahamas, in which to relocate the Forecast Office. These renovations should be completed within 4 weeks.
LPIA Statue
FIR
Lighthouses
Mr Speaker has a most destructive style of politics: it appears a philosophy where they will throw out the baby with the bath water. It is in my view the worst form of political pandering and worst form of opposition politics. In this regard I give credit to the former Minister because he knows the issues.
I understand the new Senator had some disparaging comments about me and my ability as a Minister of this Government. I do not want to take too much time because I know his family very well and for that reason I will be measured in my response. My advice to the Senator it “take your time”, you are not there yet. You are trying. Like the old people used to say when you do not know someone you call them Mr or Mistress. I could be very explicit although I choose not to be. You are on TV with great regularity and despite your inexperience as some resident expert, May I suggest that the next time you prognosticate and postulate and opinionate remember The Bahamas knows you were rejected twice by the Bahamian people. Now that does not mean you do not have a future but it means you have some things to learn, you must bring some humility to this enterprise especially if you are untested and unproven.. My observation of Bahamian politics is that The Bahamian people do not like arrogance very much. And until you have gotten your hands dirty, and have exited in your air conditioned office, be wise and circumspect in your ways.
Mr Speaker, I now end this presentation. I do so by thanking once again the people whom I have the honour and privilege to represent and the good people of The Bahamas in general. I thank the Prime Minister who has given me the opportunity to serve in his Cabinet. I thank each and every member of the Cabinet but in particular the Minister of Works, the Minister of Tourism and the Minister of State for Finance all of whom frequently work closely with the aims and objectives of this Ministry. I thank the Permanent Secretary and her administrative team in the Ministry. I thank each Department head and their teams. We have worked in the interest of the Bahaman people. They have worked hard often under difficult circumstances. But we have committed to and are achieving many things which will fundamentally and positively impact the qualitative state of our country. We are modernizing critical systems, we are building human and technological capacity, we believe in Bahamians. We believe in our country and we know that we can attain greatness if all hands are on deck.
-
2017 BUDGET PRESENTATION BY I.CHESTER COOPER, MP
2017 BUDGET PRESENTATION
I.CHESTER COOPER, MP – EXUMA & RAGGED ISLAND AND SHADOW MINISTER OF FINANCEMr. Speaker,
It is with great pleasure that I formally address this House for the first time. It is among the highest honours of my life and I pray that my time here will be fruitful and to the benefit of the Bahamian people.
I must thank the people of The Exumas and Ragged Island for reposing their faith in me in what has been a tense and competitive race.
For the hard work of my campaign team, for the confidence placed in me by the former Prime Minister Christie, Leader Philip Brave Davis, for the support of the Progressive Liberal Party and its National General Council, for the unfailing strength and commitment of my wife Cecillia, the sacrifices of my children and the help of Almighty God, I will be forever grateful.
Mr. Speaker, as we look around us, it is evident that the FNM had the momentum going into and coming out of this election, I congratulate PM Minnis and his Colleagues on their victory.
People often ask me how we were able to secure Exuma and Ragged Island for the PLP, while other traditionally PLP areas, fell like dominoes on election night. Some say, ‘Well, Exuma was pretty much always PLP, and it was expected.’
I want you and The Bahamas to know, Mr. Speaker, I don’t believe that for a second.
I was born and raised at Forbes Hill, Little Exuma, Mr. Speaker.
I know every inch of the place, and if there’s someone on Exuma of voting age I haven’t met or spoken with in the past year, only the slimmest circumstance of fate must have kept us apart.
I talked to everyone, I listened to everyone, I laid out eVision2030 – a sound vision & plan and I made solemn and earnest promises to the people of Exuma to fight to make life better for them, every day – every step of the way.
I know my people, as I said, Mr. Speaker, and my victory was secured by about 110 votes.
I learned through campaigning, that people are tired of political rhetoric.
They’re tired of empty promises and little action.
They’re tired of being disregarded while Parliamentarians waste time attacking people’s character and doing not enough to better the lives of Bahamians. They are tired of the blame game every five years.
I don’t believe in wasting time, Mr. Speaker.
Not that of others and certainly not my own.
So, I didn’t come here for fun. And for MP plates and to suit up and figure out my best angle to look handsome on TV.
I didn’t come here to make FNMs feel bad about themselves, in any personal sense; so if I do I offer a blanket apology in advance for the next five (5) years.
And I didn’t come here to sulk about the PLP’s loss.
The election is over. The FNM won, the PLP didn’t; it’s now all of our jobs to see that the Bahamian people benefit.
Because this is their House, their Parliament, their budget, their money, their ‘tings’. And it’s our job to protect them and to make sure in the end the Bahamian people benefit. Not our egos.So now; I am reporting for duty, I am happy to get to work
Because that’s what I came here to do, I came here to work.
I came here to help.
To help The Bahamas, and in particular the people of Exuma and Ragged Island, and so it’s time for me to do just that!Mr. Speaker, to put it simply but respectfully, this budget communication by the honourable member for East Grand Bahama in my view was the wrong speech, at the wrong time at the wrong place.
I have listened intently and read carefully the Budget Communication and much of it comes off as rally talk, but the rallies are over. I expected a mature assessment of the state of the economy. We have come to appreciate careful deliberations in this important communication so as not to talk down or undermine the economy. We anticipated a call for unity to move forward together to resolve whatever challenges that may exist. A budget communication is an opportunity for serious and mature conversation! The consumers of this report are not just the electorate but the international rating agencies, the business community and the investment community at home and abroad. This is one reason why it was the wrong speech.
Trust me, I’ve been dealing with rallies for months now and we all have our fill of it.
Let’s give it a rest. Less rally talk in here
more governance talk. More let’s work together to help the Bahamian people talk.
Firstly, why on Earth would the government come in here and put forward resolutions to borrow $722 million on day One!
Day One!
Let me say it slowly so it sinks in for those who haven’t grasped it yet – SEVEN HUNDRED AND TWENTY-TWO MILLION DOLLARS!
That is three quarters of a billion dollars, within the first thirty (30) days of Gov’t.
And they say that’s the PLP’s fault? They berate the PLP for $2bn in five years (including the $500m that the PLP said was theirs). Well I tell you at a clip of $722m in first 30 days, but they have yet to explain how and why – they have a duty to do so! I am frankly frightened as to how much will they borrow over a 5-year period?No sooner was the ink dry on the minister’s communication that Moody’s issued a statement which effectively said “At these levels [referring to the borrowings], the Bahamas’ debt/GDP ratio will be the highest for an emerging market sovereign rated Baa”. It’s clear to me where that discussion is headed. Wrong Speech – Wrong Time!
Let’s shift ourselves from the rally stage.
Why? Why would you already plan to borrow, before the fact, for the upcoming year, over $300 million dollars?
And why would you think Bahamians would just nod their heads and go along?
Let’s get serious.
Let’s look at what the FNM said it would do.
I don’t have the entire list here. I doubt we have time for that, but let’s look at the rally talk, then let’s look at the budget talk.
Whilst I have the greatest respect for East Grand Bahama, when I say again that this is the wrong speech. I wonder whether this is the speech we will take with us when we go to defend the int’l rating of the Bahamas. Is this the one that we will take to the debt market? You don’t tell me you broke, you busted, you unemployed and that the “cupboard is bare” then ask me to borrow $722m.From the rally stage, the FNM said it would cut expenditure.
That’s the rally talk too.Real talk: There are no significant cuts. In fact, this budget appears to build on the post hurricane deficit.
Before a dollar has been spent or collected, they already plan to overspend revenue collection by hundreds of millions of dollars.
If the PLP was so reckless, so spend happy and bleeding money, surely the FNM could have identified some significant cuts, savings and efficiencies. Hopefully, before this exercise is done, the minister can reconcile how wasteful the PLP was, but how the FNM can hardly identify areas in which to cut waste.
As an administrative and perhaps a constitutional point, I note the published “draft estimates by revenues & expenditures” this one that is labelled “entering a new era of public accountability”. However, I was unable to discern reasonableness versus prior periods as I have not seen the gazette allocation of responsibilities. For example, we don’t know whether Regattas is in MOYSC or whether it is in MOA&MR; I don’t know whether the landfill is under MOH or the MOH&E; I wondered whether that was part of the impetus of a joint press release by two Ministers. Similarly, we don’t know at this point whether the BIA is a part of OPM, Finance, Financial Services or Tourism. I believe it’s a matter of constitutional correctness Mr. Speaker, that anticipate that this be gazetted post-haste. We need to know.
In this “new era of accountability” I know that the MOF being a decorated Chartered Accountant with seek to modernize the budgeting and reporting process, transition to the accrual basis, a proper income statement and proper assessment of the assets and liabilities of our country. A transparent and accountable framework engenders Understandability, Relevance and Comparability. He certainly has his work cut out.CONSULTANCIES
With great emphasis Mr. Speaker – great emphasis; the honourable Minister castigated the Gov’t for spending $10m on consultants related to NHI. I make a few points in relation to this matter. Firstly, I wasn’t there (I’m new here) so I accept the MOF and his word. Secondly, I was a part of the private sector who said we support universal healthcare – but get it right. Well if the expertise is not resident in Gov’t how you expect them to get it right. Thirdly, I am not clear at this point whether the Gov’t has been able to be enlightened by this body of work to help to guide them as to the prudent next steps for NHI, funding strategies and a roadmap to success. Whilst I hear the inclination towards catastrophic health care I would be listening intently to the Hon. Min. of Health as he explains how it will be paid for, or whether there are provisions already in the budget for what I anticipate will be an expensive undertaking. This is sure way to bankrupt a small country. We must still get this right. Fourthly, successive Gov’t (successive I say) have hired foreign consultants sometimes at the exclusion of the local professional community. Let me go on record as saying that this is often lamented (as a sore point) as an affront to local professionals and it is my view that there should be a move effort to supporting our qualified locals where the expertise exist which will also build capacity for our country for the future. And finally, on the subject of consultancies Mr. Speaker, I wonder whether the MOF in due course would investigate and advise whether the previous Gov’t spent in excess of $30m on the consultancy to sell BTC to CWC and whether it was those consultants who advised leaving $15m of free cash in the bank for the new buyer? That is a question Mr. Speaker.THE DEFICIT
Rally talk: The FNM was going to cut the deficit.
Real talk: I’d be impressed if the government held the line at $323 million in deficit spending for the upcoming year as it projects. In fact, they recklessly promised to reduce taxes, yet have no apparent plans to make that revenue neutral, let alone reduce spending in any significant way.
You also promise “free stuff”. Free tertiary education; free money for family island student accommodation, (my people in Exuma are waiting for that) free pre-school, free catastrophic health care, tax-free zones in the inner city. Maybe no one else told you. So, let me be the first. There is no “free” in government services. Someone must pay. And that someone is always ultimately the Bahamian people and our Children. I suppose at some-point, you’ll get around to telling the people that.
Rally talk: The FNM is going to promote economic growth.
Real talk: You just came in here last week and suggested the PLP gave away too much in concessions. So where is your plan to attract foreign direct investment? Where is your plan to end concessions and at the same time encourage Foreign Direct Investments, and spur economic growth? Perhaps next year, eh?
When I say the wrong speech at the wrong time; I looked through the presentation and don’t see much in this budget communication that gives me confidence that the people who we are here to represent will be any better off in five years than they are today. I see no initiative to alleviate poverty or bring relief in the inner city. When I say the wrong time; I hear very little optimism (at a time we need it most) and see very little plan for Economic growth. Instead I noted an unprecedented level of negativity, partisanship and tribalism if you will. What is more troubling, when I look at the projections for the national debt and the deficit 2 to 3 years out I see that this Gov’t is not predicting that it will get much better. There is no real plan to reduce the national debt despite all that rally talk.BAHAMAR
What I find incredibly curious though Mr. Speaker, was that there was no mention of Baha Mar in the speech from the throne and the only real spark of optimism in the Budget Communication itself in terms of economic growth is its reference of Baha Mar over the next few years. With this in mind, I ask the Minister of Finance and the Minister of Tourism in particular, if they would go on record in supporting Bahamar and helping the Bahamian people to put the recent squabbles of the former Developers aside as “water under the bridge” and do all in their power to dissuade any protracted legal battles and ensure that Baha Mar is a productive and successful business free from legal entanglements. Baha Mar must succeed. It would be comforting if the Minister of Tourism would commit on the record to using the incredible power and influence of his office in protecting this only ray of optimism in his Government’s budget.Here’s the thing:
The Bahamian people – especially the Millennials and the young people across the Bahamas don’t care anymore, about who blames who. They want solutions. So, we’ll sit here and more than likely hear 30 or more epistles about how bad the PLP was but not really any plan to fix it. The reality is Mr. Speaker that if it broken you’re the Government now. Fix it! I say Fix it Mr. Speaker. The FNM won the mandate from the Bahamian people so it’s now the FNM Gov’t job to fix it. So, let’s have some real solutions that will fix it! Fix it Mr. Speaker.VAT EXEMPTIONS:
Here’s some more rally talk for you: The FNM will repeal value-added tax on breadbasket items, water, education, electricity, and healthcare.
Real talk now: How? You say not now because of the fragile state of the economy. But I suspect, upon coming to office, someone quickly gave the FNM an education on how VAT works and told them that’s just not going to happen.
But here’s my question? Did no one think about this all along on the campaign trail, that this wasn’t viable? Did everyone just say it for fun? To win? No one advised better than this?
I can tell you, Mr. Speaker that I cringed at some of the promises I heard during the Campaign. It is with that in mind that I predict that this Government will champion the largest budget deficits OR largest increases in taxes OR the greatest amount of broken promises ever seen in the history of modern Bahamas.
I trust that it is not all of the above; but I am not persuaded that there are well-crafted plans for delivering those promises. I surely don’t see them in this budget.
But, I take some comfort, however, that if the Bahamian people feel like you “Swing Dem” in 2017 in not delivering on the notion of the “People’s Time” they will judge you harshly in 2022 and if they determined that you didn’t act right – expect to be fired too! That’s the beauty of our democracy.
But let’s not get ahead of ourselves.
Let’s stick to VAT for a minute, because I’m still wondering who made them make these promises.VAT EXEMPTIONS
Firstly, I don’t think anyone was surprised that this budget did not deliver on the promised VAT exemptions.
During my time as chairman of the Bahamas Chamber of Commerce and Employer’s confederation we lead negotiations with the government on VAT on behalf of the business community and the private sector.
In consultation with the Chamber and other stakeholders the PLP Gov’t was able to lead the way in responsible tax reforms. The IMF praised the Gov’t on its successful implementation.
How about this, let’s not wreck the system by tinkering with things you seem to think can be solved with fanciful rally talk.
Instead let’s give the system a full opportunity to prove itself, until there is a comprehensive orientation on the complex triggers and a thorough examination of the impact of such proposed exemptions.
A system with limited exemptions enables a more efficient tax scheme. We’ve been through this over and over again. It’s too late to be playing catch up on how VAT works.
Varying rates and/or exemptions, would require system amendments and increases the complexity of the tax collection and filing process, which is already a sore point for the business community. A change will likely impact the level of system related costs and compliance rates experienced with VAT. Fewer exemptions and more elimination/reductions of Customs duties might be the way to go to create a more comprehensive VAT.As it now stands it would be beneficial to have an even more simplified system of both reporting and filing. A system where the cash flow of the business follows the payment of the VAT. One where the business community does not have to provide free short-term financing to the government while it waits to receive payment for its credits. A VAT system that does not increase the cost of doing business but is efficient. The majority of business owners are in support of reasonable taxes, and supports a refined system so that they can get on with the business of doing business.
BREADBASKET ITEMS
With respect to the promise of removal of VAT on breadbasket items, retailers will tell you that these represent roughly 60% to 70% of the sales. This would mean that VAT input credits currently enjoyed by the retailers of these items would no longer be credits. This, in turn, increases the operating costs, which will be passed on by way of increased prices at the grocery store. Therefore, the exemption of VAT will not result in the perceived reduction of cost of 7.50%. The same analysis may be made for exempting electricity and if not done properly might lead to the unintended consequence of increasing the cost of electricity with the unintended consequence of adversely impacting the lower income households.
It is my view that the PLP Gov’t got it right when they increased the minimum wage from $150 to $210, a whopping 40 percent; and improved social services benefits in a dignified manner with the cash loaded cards. This was the right approach to offset the potential adverse impact on this demographic.Again, I ask, who analysed this campaign promise? They would have had access to the great body of work by the Chamber and its Oxford Economists, the IMF, the IDB and the Compass Lexecon (U.S. consultants engaged directly by the government) and others who rely on empirical analysis.
Should the government start tinkering where it needs not, I foreshadow that it would likely result in the increase of VAT to as high as 15 percent. We must not inflict this injustice on the Bahamian people.
Further, Mr. Speaker, I noted the political gimmickry and mischief making about VAT money throughout the campaign. Curiously, the Gov’t launched many forensic audits but did not launch an investigation on “where the VAT money gone”. I believe the Minister of Finance now has a duty to report to the Bahamian people on the matter.CUSTOM DUTY REDUCTIONS:
Let’s look for a minute on the areas where there were tax reductions. What is the mechanism to ensure that businesses are passing on these savings rather than using them to improve their profit margins?a. Paint for example. In prior years the Gov’t increased duty on bottled water to protect industry and jobs. A reduction in duty on paint by 20% will potentially harm the local manufacturing industry resulting in job losses and adversely impacting Lower income households. As the shadow Minister for Industry I want to know why? And who stand to benefit? Without suggesting anything untoward, before I vote on this budget Mr. Speaker, we would be grateful if the Gov’t would declare whether any members of the Cabinet has a substantial interest in a paint distributor who might stand to gain?
b. On potato chips, I wonder whether it was determined that this food presents some nutritional value and encourages healthy life styles.
c. On Bread, I wonder whether the MOF will now be subsidizing bread imports because they say they are reducing imports on bread, but its already zero. I would suggest that that may have been an oversight, rather than an attempt to show the People that the Gov’t is for them?
d. With respect to reduction is Customs duty on foreign art. At first glance Mr. Speaker it is tempting to see this again as a tax break for the rich and counter to the encouragement of the creative talents of local artists and artisans. On reflection however, I am aware that there are substantial interests promoting bi-partisan support for the concept of the Bahamas being a centre to store Art in a shared vault scheme similar to what is done in Switzerland. If this is in fact the intent of this provision, as the shadow minister for Financial Services, I would be minded to support it as an innovative idea in context of value added to our financial services and home office businesses which is designed to attract High Net Worth (HNW) individuals.RECAP
So let’s just quickly recap: The FNM said they were ready to govern. They said they could do a better job. They said the PLP spent too much. They said the PLP borrowed too much. They promised reduction in VAT and a lot of free stuff.
And what did we get?
No real plan or programs to grow the economy.
No new incentives – they just continued the Family Island Incentive Act and City of Nassau incentives Act for another year. Not revolutionary stuff. Nothing new. Nothing original. With respect to the stamp tax on exemptions to home owners it appears that all that is being done is codifying into law what was already a PLP policy?
[I will turn my attention to the business license issue shortly]
We got more borrowing, the largest ever at one time, I do believe.
We get no real expenditure cuts.
No reduction in pre-hurricane deficit.
No real plan for debt reduction.
We got a record time backtrack on VAT reduction promises.
We got some reductions on salmon and shrimp. I’m sure hurting low income families will appreciate that.
We get a budget communication that sounds like a rally speech with a built-in narrative of fiscal constraints as an excuse not to fulfil all of the unrealistic promises they blurted out night after night.
And No real plan to find savings and efficiencies.NO RELIEF FOR THE POOR
Mr. Speaker, I expected relief for the poor, the down trodden and incentives for the inner city. Based on the rally talks we expected elimination of VAT on bread basket items, on electricity and health care. We got not one IOTA of relief for the poor. I see very little that improves the life of the low-income household in the inner city. They say “not now”.Meanwhile over on the other side of town Mr. Speaker the Business License (Amendment) Bill 2017 seems to provide a tax reduction to businesses with turnover exceeding $50m from 1.5% to 1.25%, but does not make any reduction to business license for Small and Medium Sized businesses. I would imagine Mr. Speaker that the list of businesses who will benefit from this exemption is decidedly small and it would be very very interesting to look at that list of businesses to examine who might be the beneficiaries of this tax break. If I am mistaken, I stand corrected Mr. Speaker but if I am right this implies that there goes another tax break for rich big business who might be cosy with this so called People’s Time Government, whilst there is no reduction for Small and Medium Sized businesses who also employ people but struggle every day to keep their doors open. As is the case with most modern economies small business account for as high as 70% of jobs in the private sector and is considered the engine that drives organic economic growth.
For business license, may I suggest incentives geared towards small business and other businesses that operate at a loss. Let us be mindful, that this tax is on turnover not profits it is conceivable that businesses may be loss making and on the brink of closure and still have to pay business license fees to their further detriment.THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM
Mr Speaker,
The elephant in the room is that there are some needed restructuring and reforms required in our economy, our budgeting process and business model, that will take some heavy lifting by sober and diligent policy makers.Roughly 60 percent of the budget goes to salaries and emoluments, another 20 percent for other unbreakable commitments like rents and most of the rest for capital expenditure. This leaves very little wiggle room. This is not sustainable.
I don’t know if any business can survive if 60% of its revenue goes to salaries. There are some simple rules to the survival of any enterprise worth having. A third of revenue to salaries, a third of revenue to overheads and a third of revenue to growing the business. As it stands it puts the government consistently in debt and our children’s future at risk.This is why I am so hard on the point that we must be focused on growing our economy. We must do more with the existing infrastructure and the government is now faced with the reality that the economy must grow, the pie must expand. And magic and fanciful campaign dream selling don’t make for sound fiscal and prudent management. Governance is serious business Mr. Speaker.
It just makes us look bad at home and in the eyes of the international community who seem to have no problem downgrading our credit ratings on the fly.
In that vein, I caution you to provide responsible fiscal leadership in order to harmonize our business model, grow our economy, improve ratings in the international community and confidence with the business community and Bahamian Public.EXUMA MATTERS
Turning to Exuma, Mr. Speaker, I trust that in the presentation of the ministers we will hear some announcements that address the numerous pressing PRIORITY issue in Exuma including:
1. Running water for Little Exuma
2. With urgency, the full opening of the mini hospital at George Town, inclusive of more Doctors and technical staff
3. Continuation and completion of the Forest Road and other essential road works
4. Construction of a new straw market in George Town
5. Advancement of a Public Private Partnership (PPP) to expedite the construction of new airport terminal at George Town; and the
6. Expansion of the airport run way at Black Point
7. The tourist product has outgrown the infrastructure in Exuma we need today more taxi plates and more SD plates.
RAGGED ISLAND MATTERS
Let’s not forget Ragged Island, Mr. Speaker.
She is a clear case for development of a model for handling the peculiar issues of Small Islands in the Bahamas and the region. With a population of about 65 and 44 registered voters, Ragged Island requires the same level of government services. There is an ongoing issue with the closure of the post office due to the Post Mistress being on maternity leave. Whilst in the grand scheme of things you might consider this minor. I invite you to consider the disconnect that Ragged Island already feels with no direct flight services and no banks making the Post Office the only option to get money to Nassau so that supplies can come on the mail boat. This is just one example but I will bring to the attention of the relevant Ministers the various “small issues” that continue to create discomfort for our people on Ragged Island, like providing more reliable water supply and much needed repairs to the clinic, nurse’s residence and police station. No doubt there are grants or resources accessible through our international affiliates like the IDB for subsidizing connectivity of remote areas. We must not forget our brother and sisters in places across the Bahamas like Ragged Island. The strong must bear the infirmities of the weak Mr. Speaker.As I close, Mr. Speaker, I do want to point out some good things the government has proposed and a few suggestions.
On the issue of Campaign Finance Reforms – I was delighted to hear mention of this, but there can no longer be lip service to this issue.
• Ease of doing business – I do await the government’s plans on this. We recognize that this is all of our problem and I and the private sector are prepared to help in a structured bi-partisan way to improve our rankings.
• Natural Disasters: With great pains the Minister outlined the potential volatility that may be caused by natural disasters. I pray that God spares us this year. We must then get to work in a bi-partisan way with the help of our friends in the private sector to find a solution to mitigate the impact of such events as we live in the hurricane belt.
• More Funding for the Venture Fund and technical assistance to entrepreneurs Empowerment of Bahamians
• Family Island Development,
o Getting projects out of the pipeline particularly for Exuma where there is more than $500m announced which is earmarked to create hundreds of jobs.
o Strengthening of local Gov’t inclusive of more funding. Exuma collects hundreds of million for the public treasury but its local Gov’t only gets $400k. This is not equitable and it was with great delight that I hear mention of islands receiving a percentage of their collections in the speech from the throne. I trust that the Minister of Local Government in his presentation will bring life to this important issues
o Second home owners and home rentals have boosted room availability through the use of engines like AirBNB and VRBO. We must require these entities to collect a tax and remit to the Gov’t this might be a significant way to get more funding for local government in our islands.
o NDP: The lack of reference to the National Development Plan is very alarming. This is the tool to pool ideas and formulate strategies, to innovate and to maximise partnerships. Adequate funding, bi-partisan support is required here in creating a common set of goals. We must avoid the polarization that has stifled us as a country and demonstrate political maturity in mapping out progress and ultimately our fiscal successes.CONCLUSION:
So, Mr. Speaker, my takeaway is: This is not a good start for the Free National Movement Gov’t. It’s the Wrong Speech, at the Wrong Time in the Wrong Place. I sincerely hope this will be the last administration to come to office and claim it did not know what was left behind by the previous one.As I mentioned earlier, the majority of the Bahamian people don’t care. As the Gov’t we just want you fix it if we deem it to broken. Fix it! Fix it!
We the Bahamian people will not accept excuses. We do not take kindly to the notion that the FNM Opposition did not know; effectively an admission of not doing its job. This is why we have a Public Accounts Committee, on which I now sit.
This is why we have a Public Treasury Committee, Why we have a mid-year budget exercise and Central Bank reports.
Mr. Speaker, claiming you did not know is no longer good enough. Not a good defense Mr. SpeakerFor the record Mr. Speaker, I am not so pessimistic about the future of our beloved Bahamas. I am hopeful that once the new Gov’t finds its footing and adjust to its role of being responsible for the future of our economy they will see and harness the silver linings of healthy reserve levels unemployment trending downwards and the prospects for a successful Baha Mar. The Bahamian people want action. Not rally talk and empty promises. A healthy dose of real talk and actual work would go a long way.
Mr. Speaker, I was sent by the people I work for with a very clear job description – to present their concerns and help to make the Bahamas a better place to live, work and Play. I promised them each day that I will do my part in holding the Government’s feet to the fire and with that in mind, I expect that this honeymoon will be a decidedly short. We have a country to build!Mr. Speaker I rest, on behalf of the good people of Exuma & Ragged Island.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
-
REMARKS OF THE LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION
REMARKS
OF
THE LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION
PHILIP BRAVE DAVIS MP
REAPPOINTMENT OF THE OPPOSITION SENATORS
GOVERNMENT HOUSE
NASSAU, BAHAMAS
May 23rd, 2017Your Excellency:
I am honoured yet again to be received with such gracious hospitality at Government House this afternoon.
I am most grateful, Your Excellency, for the courtesies you have extended, not only to me to and my colleagues in both House of Parliament but to the many guests that are gathered here to witness these proceedings.
May I also express my thanks to the new Opposition Senators for answering my call to give service as Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition in the Upper House.
I am keenly aware of the many personal sacrifices this will entail but I know that the four appointees are, without exception, equal to the challenge that is implicit in the high office they assume today.
This Opposition senatorial team, though small in number, is imbued with energy and vision. Moreover, they are all deeply schooled in what it means, philosophically, to be standard-bearers for their Party.
They, therefore, enter upon their Senatorial careers with a deep respect for the founding principles of our great party, a genuine love of our country, and fresh and innovative ideas for solving the challenges we face.
Be their service in the Senate however long or short, I have every confidence that they will distinguish themselves as members of the Upper House.
As I have already had occasion to mention, where we can cooperate and support the new government, the Progressive Liberal Party intends to do so, generously and in good faith.
We are, after all, instruments of nation-building, not agents of national disunity or unnecessary conflict.
At the same time, however, I wish to emphasize that as Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition in both Houses of Parliament, we have a responsibility to provide vigorous dissent in those instances where it is warranted.It is also our duty to correct misinformation lest it obscure the truth or lead to what is now popularly referred to in the public discourse of our great neighbour to the North as “the alternative reality”.
We will have no tolerance for that. And there will be no acquiescence in that either.
On the contrary, you will find that our Senators and MPs alike will not hesitate to set the record straight when the occasion demands it.
Moreover, we shall at all times promote and project the core values that have united us as a Party across the generations.
Indeed, I am more convinced than ever that the core values that inspired our founders to uplift and to protect the great mass of Bahamian humanity from social and economic injustice and to provide equal opportunity for all are as relevant today as they were more than 64 years ago when the PLP was birthed.
Your Excellency:
I have the honour to present to you and the Bahamian people a team of Senators that represents a microcosm of the national community.This team encapsulates intellectual gravitas, demographic balance, and a healthy mix of mature wisdom and youthful talent.
I am particularly proud that that, even though we had but four appointments available to us, the final selection takes note of the fundamental composition of our populace, signifying in this respect that our Party really is committed to being the Party for ALL Bahamians.
I’m also happy that, between them, our four Senators recognize the three main population centres of our country: New Providence, Grand Bahama and the Family Islands.
I’m also delighted that in making our final selection we were able to strike an even balance between the more traditional, establishment wing of the Party with what can best be termed the “New Wave” PLP as personified by those who represent the leading edge of our Party’s future.
Your Excellency,
Turning now, if I may, to the members of the Senate team:
Frederick Mitchell will serve as Leader in the Senate. His deep knowledge of the history of our country, his outstanding experience in the international arena as a Minister for Foreign Affairs, Immigration and Public Service, and his reputation for intellectual honesty and tenacity in parliamentary debate, all give me great confidence in his ability to guide our team in the Upper House.
Dr. Michael Darville, the nation’s first Minister for Grand Bahama, presents the Opposition’s voice on matters concerning that part of the country in the Senate.
We continue to believe that Grand Bahama faces distinct challenges and therefore deserves focused attention and solutions. In addition, Dr. Darville will provide an energetic and expert voice across a wide range of policy areas.
Clay Sweeting is a young businessman and fisherman from Spanish Wells. His ongoing advocacy for those Bahamians who make their living at sea contributed to major investments in our nation’s Defence Force, resulting in a significant upgrade in our nation’s ability to protect our borders and to defend itself against foreign poachers.
As a proud Eleutheran, he intends to be an advocate for Family Islanders everywhere, and, as a successful entrepreneur, he is committed to promoting opportunities for young Bahamians who are in search of economic empowerment for themselves.
Last, but by no means least, I am delighted that Mrs. Jobeth Coleby-Davis, a sincerely motivated young woman, will be joining our team in the Upper House.
She is a new voice, but she will be a formidable one, I assure you. She is ready to bring her extensive expertise in law, energy policy, and financial services to the Senate
she comes from a distinguished line of progressive thinkers, including the late Scherlin Bootle MP; the late President of the Senate, Edwin Coleby;
….and on her husband’s side of the family, the late Lionel Davis MP. She can therefore lay claim to a proud and distinguished pedigree in the PLP.
But far more than that, she is a dynamo of a lady who will bring her considerable talents to bear on her work as a Senator.
I predict for her a bright future in the political life of our nation.
Your Excellency:
In closing, I thank you once again for your warm hospitality and may I ask you, please, to convey my appreciation to the fine staff of Government House for always going the extra mile to make these occasions so pleasant and memorable for all concerned.
May God bless us all as we work together to serve the needs of our People and continue to build a better and brighter tomorrow for our beloved Bahamas.
May God continue to Bless The Commonwealth of The Bahamas.
—-END—–
-
ADDRESS BY THE RT. HON. PERRY G. CHRISTIE AT NGC
ADDRESS
BY
THE RT. HON. PERRY G. CHRISTIE
TO
THE NATIONAL GENERAL COUNCIL
OF
THE PROGRESSIVE LIBERAL PARTY
May 15th, 2017
Stalwart Councillors, Mr. National Chairman and Party Officers, Members of the National General Council, Ladies & Gentlemen:
I began my life in politics way back in the early 1960’s when I became the youngest member of what was known as the radical wing of the PLP, a group that called itself The National Committee for Positive Action.
I was just a young lad back then but the inspiration of warriors in the Party like Lynden Pindling, Arthur Hanna, Cecil Wallace-Whitfield and Arthur Foulkes, among others, filled me with a great desire to play my part in the surging struggle for Majority Rule. And so I did.
A little later, after going off to the University of Birmingham in England to read law, I conceived the idea of a radical pressure group to agitate for fundamental political, economic, and social change in our country. I convinced my dear friend, B.J. Nottage, who at the time was studying Medicine at Aberdeen University in Scotland, to join with me in this venture.
The result was the formation of a group called “UNICOLL”. Launched in 1966, it later evolved into what became known as UNICOMM. It was unquestionably the most consequential political think-tank and pressure group of its time. And out of it many of our nation’s future leaders emerged as well.
After I was called to the bar, I threw myself, mind, body and soul, into politics. I did so under the banner of the PLP and played my part in the historic movement for Independence, including the tumultuous General Election campaign of 1972.
In 1974, I made my initial entry into Parliament when I was appointed to the Senate for the PLP. I served our Party there until 1977. That was the year – 40 years ago this year – that I was first elected for what would turn out to be eight (8) consecutive terms as the Member of Parliament for Centreville under its various name-changes.
It was not until May 10th – Wednesday of last week – that I was defeated for the first time in what I had earlier announced would be my last election campaign. Based on the recount, I lost my bid for re-election by a mere 4 votes.
Despite that loss, I am thankful to the people of Centreville for having given me their support so faithfully over the course of 40 years – longer than any other person has ever served continuously as a member of parliament for the same constituency in our country’s history.
And just for the record, although I am advised that that there are good grounds for doing so, I will not be taking the Centreville election any further; there will be no petition to the Election Court. Instead I accept the result of the Centreville election.
In so doing, I extend my congratulations to Mr. Reese Chipman and wish him every success as the new MP-elect for Centreville.
I also re-affirm what I said on Wednesday night, namely, that I accept the will of the Bahamian people, as expressed in the results of the General Election as a whole. I therefore wish our new Prime Minister, Dr. the Hon. Hubert Minnis, and his government every success in tackling the onerous challenges that lie ahead. I am a PLP but I am first and foremost a patriot who wishes my country well at all times irrespective of which Party is in power.
I also extend my thanks to the many thousands of Bahamians who, against great odds and obstacles, still saw their way clear to throw their support behind the PLP last Wednesday. I know how difficult it must have been for many of them to do so. I am grateful for their support and deeply moved by their loyalty to our Party.
I extend these same sentiments to my colleagues in the PLP who stood shoulder to shoulder with me, either as candidates or as campaign generals and workers. I am grateful for your many sacrifices and for your loyalty and support not only during the campaign but all through the years.
I reserve for special thanks the Stalwart Councillors and other members of this National General Council who have been by my side for the 20 years that I was given the honour of leading our Party. You always had my back. You were always there for me. I thank you for your loyal support and for your wisdom and guidance and, most especially, for your unstinting love all through the years of my leadership.
I save the best and most important for last – for Bernadette, my dear wife of 43 years, our children, and our family, words cannot convey the depth of my love and appreciation for you. I know how much this whole election experience has impacted you. I only wish that I could have spared you the outrageously false and vicious lies that were propagated against you all through the campaign. Forgive me for not being able to protect you from these vile assaults.
As for those who voted against us, or who did not come out to support us at the polls, I want you to know that I hold no bitterness toward you. On the contrary, I think I have a much deeper understanding now of what many of you were saying to us.
It is important to our Party that it understands the messages of the electorate. We need to come to terms with the mistakes we made and humble ourselves before the people with an admission of our failures even as we speak of our successes. This is critical to the re-building of our Party.
Our Party has responded to this challenge of re-building before and I am supremely confident that our Party shall do so again.
I recall most poignantly in this regard the great defeat our Party suffered in 1997, winning only 5 seats out of 40 in the General Election of that year. But who can forget that just five years later, we came storming back, under a new Leader, winning a 28 seat victory in the General Elections of 2002.
Going back even further in time, we can recall that in 1965, when our Party was in opposition, four of our parliamentary members broke away, later forming a new party – the NDP – under the leadership of the late Hon. Paul Adderley.
That reduced our numbers in the House to just 4 members – the same number we have today. And yet in less than two years we won the government for the first time with our historic victory in the General Election of January 10th, 1967.
So, we have been in this place before. And we have been there more than once. We can win again just as we did in 1967 and in 2002 after coming back from a decimation of our numbers in Parliament.
So, I want you too keep those historical precedents before you as you set about re-building the Party.
There is another part of the nation’s recent political history that should give us great encouragement as well. It is this: we have not had a two-term government now for 20 straight years. Every single General Election since 1997 has produced a government for just one term. This means that the historical odds favour a return of the PLP in the near future – but only if we do the right things to re-build our Party to prove itself worthy once again of the trust of the Bahamian people.
We did this most notably after our crushing defeat in 1997 out of which came an authentic “New PLP” as we proclaimed it then. And as I have said, and say again, in just five short years we rose from the ashes under new leadership to once again lead our nation.
Mr. National Chairman, Fellow Councillors:
During the course of my four decades in the House of Assembly, I was given the great honor to lead our nation as Prime Minister for two non-consecutive terms: from 2002 to 2007; and again from 2012 to May 2017.
I can never thank the Bahamian people enough for having accorded me that signal honour, not once but twice. I shall forever be grateful.
I was also given the high honor of serving in various PLP administrations between 1977 and 1992 as a Minister holding diverse portfolios, including Tourism, National Insurance, Agriculture, Trade & Industry. I gratefully record my thanks and appreciation of the late Sir Lynden Pindling and the people of The Bahamas for having afforded me these opportunities as well.
Looking back on my service to the people of The Bahamas over all these many years, I am moved to say this: to the extent that I was able to improve and strengthen our nation and its people during my time in Parliament or in government, whether as Prime Minister, as a Minister of the Government, or as the Leader or as a member of the Opposition, I am so very grateful to have had the opportunity to do so.
Equally, however, let me say this: to the extent that I failed to meet the expectations of our people in any respect at any time, I am truly and deeply sorry.
In the current climate, so soon after what was, by most accounts, the most acrimonious General Election in recent memory, I cannot, and do not, expect a balanced assessment of my successes and failures. That would be asking too much, too soon.
It is nonetheless my prayerful hope that when, many years from now, the verdict of history is rendered on my service to the Bahamian people, the good that I did will be seen to outweigh the bad.
I am particularly proud of the transformative things that I was able to introduce during my time in public life, particularly during the term in office just ended.
Things like:
- NATIONAL HEALTH INSURANCE which, more than anything any government of The Bahamas has ever conceived before, promises not only to improve, but to actually save the lives of thousands of Bahamians for generations to come. Yes, there is still a long way to go with NHI, but at last we have now put in place the essential parts of a functioning system that will – provided it isn’t scrapped – stop poor, struggling Bahamians from dying simply because they have no health insurance. I’m really so very proud of what our PLP Government did to bring us closer to that reality through National Health Insurance.
- URBAN RENEWAL is another innovation of which I am especially proud to claim as part of what I hope will be my enduring legacy. This programme, much replicated now around the world, has done so much to re-engineer community upliftment and inner-city support for the young and elderly alike, while, at the same time, broadening the involvement of law enforcement agencies in a way that inspires greater public confidence in them as agents for good.
- BAMSI is another innovation that fills me with pride as I look back on my accomplishments tonight. We have talked a great deal about economic diversification and self-reliance over the years but BAMSI, with all its growing pains, bears every promise of finally bringing us to a realization of these long-held aspirations. BAMSI has, at the same time, awakened the sleeping giant of Andros so that it can better actualize its vast potential for the development of our agricultural and marine resources.
- The National Training Agency is another innovation that I was proud to introduce during our term in office just ended. Already more than 3000 Bahamians have been trained to take up well-paying jobs in our economy as they become available.
- Tax Reform is another area of achievement that we can look upon with pride. I am only too well aware that VAT has been an exceptionally painful thing for ordinary, struggling Bahamians to contend with in their daily lives. But it was absolutely correct for us to bring in VAT when we did. Without VAT, our nation’s revenue system might well have sunk. Instead, with VAT, and thanks to VAT, we now have a greatly expanded revenue base that will better enable us to meet the financial costs of public administration, including the civil service payroll, debt-service and support for our vital national institutions well into the future. Where did the VAT money go? The new administration will soon find out that every penny earned from VAT went straight into the Consolidated Fund and came back out to meet the same three things I just mentioned : the financial costs of governance (including the civil service payroll), debt-service, and support for our vital national institutions.
The National Development Plan is another innovation that I’m so very proud of. Thanks to this, we now have for the first time in our history a comprehensive blueprint for the systematic development of our nation over the next 25-30 years. In place of the knee-jerk, ad hoc model for national development we have followed all through the years, we now have a rational, clearly thought-out plan to guide the government of the day, be it PLP, FNM or anybody else. This, I believe, is going to be positively transformative for our nation in the years ahead – provided we stick with it and follow the plan. It is a roadmap for sustainable progress for generations to come.
Securing our Borders is another major objective that we were able to bring great success to in our term in office just ended. In particular, with the expansion of the fleet of the Royal Bahamas Defense Force, we are now achieving major success in curbing the encroachments of foreign fishermen in our waters while at the time making us much more effective in intercepting migrant-laden vessels.
Taking Control of our Airspace is another vitally important thing that happened during this last term in office. Not only does this fortify our sovereignty over our airspace but it also provides the framework for substantial new revenue streams from the commercial use of our airspace.
- The modernization of the National Flag Carrier’s fleet is another achievement during our term in office of which we should feel very proud.
- The Agreement with Carnival Cruise Lines for a brand new 200 million dollar port in Grand Bahama is yet another accomplishment that we should feel proud of having introduced on our watch.
- Saving Baha Mar is the 11th and final accomplishment of my administration that I should like to mention tonight. In saving Baha Mar, we have helped create a new and major source of employment and entrepreneurial empowerment for our people, especially our young.
The list of accomplishments goes on and on, particularly in the areas of educational development and Foreign Affairs, but time does not permit a comprehensive litany of all that we did to advance the interests of our country in ways that will only become evident in the months and years ahead once all the noise has died down and a serious, balanced study of our administration is undertaken.
Mr. National Chairman, Fellow Councillors:
Having said what I have, I come now to this:
- I accept full responsibility for our Party’s defeat in the General Election of May 10th, 2017.
- I also accept, without reservation, that the best traditions of our democracy, no less the impulses of my own conscience and value-system, dictate that I resign as the Leader of our Party. This is the correct and only thing for me to do from both a political and moral perspective.
- I ask you all, please, to respect the finality of my decision. It is absolute and irrevocable. And it is the right thing to do.
- Accordingly, I hereby resign as the Leader of the Progressive Liberal Party with immediate effect.
And so, tonight, my beloved fellow Councillors of our great Party, I bid you farewell as your Leader. I have run my course. I have finished the race. The time has come for me to move on.
I have given my entire adult life to the service of the Bahamian people. There have been ups and downs along the way but all in all, I’ve had a good run, and helped a lot of our people along the way. I wish to God that I could have helped more but God knows that for all my faults and failings as a Leader and as a man, I tried my best to do the best that I could do for the Bahamian people, my people, the best people in whole wide world.
It is therefore with deepest love and undying gratitude that I say to you once more, thank you so much for everything that you have done for me and for our Party all through our many years together.
I pledge my support for our Party and for its future leadership. I make this pledge without equivocation.
My prayers go with you as you continue your political journey and may Almighty God continue to watch over you, and direct your steps, as you set yourselves now to the re-building of our Party under new leadership.
I love you all.
Thank you and good night.
-
REMARKS OF PHILIP BRAVE DAVIS MP AT SWEARING-IN AS LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION
REMARKS
OF
PHILIP BRAVE DAVIS MP
AT
SWEARING-IN AS LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION
GOVERNMENT HOUSE
NASSAU, BAHAMAS
May 19th, 2017
You’re Excellency:
As in all things I give thanks, firstly, to Almighty God for all His many blessings. I declare that I repose my faith and confidence in Him as I assume the high office that has been bestowed upon me today.
Next, I thank Your Excellency for your graciousness in appointing me the Leader of Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition. I am most grateful. And may I also thank you most sincerely for extending the hospitality of Government House for this swearing-in ceremony and the reception that is to follow.
I also give thanks to all my family and friends who are here to witness my swearing-in but I thank most especially my dear wife, Anne Marie, and my children. You have been an unswerving source of love, loyalty and support, and I want you too know how grateful I am.
Next, I extend thanks to the great people of Cat Island, San Salvador and Rum Cay. It is only through their continued support of me as their Member of Parliament that I am able to stand here this morning to assume my new office as Leader of the Opposition. I am most grateful to them for continuing to believe in me.
I want also to thank the members of the Progressive Liberal Party, most especially the Stalwart Councillors and other members of the National General Council, and my fellow Party Officers, for their many expressions of support following my elevation to the leadership of the Party on Monday past.
I also want offer a very special word of appreciation to my predecessor as Leader of the PLP, the Rt. Hon. Perry Christie, under whom I had the high honor to serve as Deputy Prime Minister until Wednesday of last week, and as Deputy Party Leader until his resignation as Party Leader on Monday past. My admiration for him as a patriot and one of the great builders of the modern Bahamas is profound. I know that in characterizing him in this way, I speak not only for myself but for many thousands of our people throughout our nation. I therefore take pride in expressing, on their behalf and mine, deepest gratitude and appreciation for the illustrious service that he gave our nation for more than 40 years.
Your Excellency, Ladies & Gentlemen:
The work of shaping history is never easy, or without setbacks.
Small in number though we are at this time, my parliamentary colleagues and I understand that the work of building our nation – which is the work of building and inspiring justice, dignity, opportunity and lasting progress for all – requires constant re-invention and innovation.
Less than a week after our nation’s General Elections, we find ourselves – the Party that founded an independent and modern Bahamas – at a new beginning.
This is therefore a time for reflection but it must be much more than that. It must be a time for reform, a time for rebuilding, a time for renewal.
Indeed last week’s results should prompt real and thorough self-examination. And we must not be timid or reticent about acknowledging the mistakes we have made. That is a necessary foundation for re-building and renewal. Confession is good for the soul. So is humility.
We have to renew the promise of our Party for a new generation of activists and supporters and fellow citizens. This process must begin on the ground and extend into every community throughout our country.
And let’s be clear: We need a dialogue, not a monologue. We need to listen and learn, especially from those who believe in the ideals of social and economic justice our party has always stood for.
And this dialogue and collaboration in our season of renewal must be authentic. It must also be all-embracing. We must reach out and embrace the entire Bahamian community, leaving no class or race outside. We must be the Party for ALL the people of The Bahamas, irrespective of what age you may be, what island you may be from, or what the colour of your skin may be. All Bahamians are our brothers and sisters. We must prove that not only by our words but by our actions.
I want to share with you how encouraged I am by the extraordinary number of people who have reached out over the last few days, eager to participate in renewing and rebuilding the PLP. I do not hear despair. On the contrary, I hear determination and excitement about the future of our Party.
So, I believe profoundly in our capacity for renewal, and I believe we will see an outpouring of creativity and ingenuity from all those ready to be part of this journey.
While we are doing this critical work, we must also at the same time hold the new government to account. That is the primary function and duty of Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition. I have every intention – as do my colleagues in the House – of proving ourselves equal to that duty from Day One and throughout our time in opposition.
As citizens and patriots, we wish the new government well. Where we can find common ground with them they will have our support.
But they should not look at our small numbers in Parliament and draw the wrong conclusions.
Let me be even clearer about our intentions:
- We will not sit quietly by and allow the new Government to misrepresent or denigrate our record of achievement in government.
- We will not acquiesce if they pursue policies or practices that hurt poor Bahamians.
- We will not allow them to compromise our sovereignty as a nation.
- We will not sit quietly by and allow them to victimize our supporters.
This must be a time for energy and optimism. If we conduct ourselves well and do our job the right way, brighter days lie ahead for all of us.
Your Excellency:
I thank you once again for the courtesies that you have so kindly extended too me, my family, and those here assembled for my swearing-in as Leader of the Opposition.
Be assured, Your Excellency, that I shall at all times endeavor as best I can to prove myself worthy of this high and important office in the constitutional life of our beloved nation.
And let us all work together for a better and brighter tomorrow. May God Bless you, your Excellency, and The Commonwealth of The Bahamas.
-
Kelly Burrows continues…
Fortunately, with the appropriate treatment, here I am, living life to the fullest 11 years after being diagnosed with a cancer that my Doctors thought would be the cause of my death in three to four years.
There were those fleeting moments of wondering, is this payback for having a good life? Despite imperfect behaviour and decisions from time to time? Retribution from whoever or whatever has the power? And that power comes from God!
My Oncologist. Dr. Jose Lutzky from the Mt Sanai. Cancer Centre, then put me on a high dose chemotherapy called “Revlimid” @ a cost then, of $8634.00 for a 21 days’ supply that I stayed on for 3 years, it is very exorbitant. One “1” “Revlimid” pill alone is more than $500.00. And they are not easy to acquire, only seven Pharmacies throughout the United States, ship the powerful drug, and to become a customer requires a detailed background check and Hospital authorization. Today the cost is $15.800 for a 21 day supply at a daily cost of $752.38.
Developed from Thalidomide, the drug banned in the sixties when it was found to cause birth defects in women being treated for morning sickness. For someone who had been taking only a regular aspirin, daily Vitamins, and Enalapril for blood pressure, within a few weeks I was taking seventeen pills a day. Drug therapy for M/M is advancing rapidly M/M is a complex cancer, as all are, but this one has a daunting entry in any medical reference book.
Myeloma as a description has its origin with the Greek medical genius “Hippocrates” who did the earliest known work on cancer, which he called Karkinoma “carciunoma” in ancient Greek. My doctors tell me “yes” said I’m going to beat this-and I know it’s true. But that’s the current estimate for your condition, there’s been great progress in treating this. And we’ve learned 50% more than we knew before. People are living with this well beyond the estimates. 3-4 years.
Multiple myeloma, may be a small-population cancer representing only 1% of the cancers recorded and affecting twenty thousand people a year, but Angela, my wife and I keep encountering others who have the disease or who are related to myeloma patients.
Being told that you have cancer; cancer has its own calendar and insidious rhythm, the very word cancer-has no redeeming qualities, when given the diagnosis it felt like a death sentence was passed on you. It is a dangerous and mysterious condition, it is not a “mind over matter” disease, nor is it a disease that has succumbed to the declaration of war against it. “The truth, uncomfortable and inconvenient as it may be, is that medical science has never faced a more inscrutable, more mutable, or more ruthless adversary. It is a unique disease, cancer is, in a way, the body’s war on itself” On leaving Mt Sinai, back to Ft Lauderdale Airport after getting my results after an exploration of tests over a 6-month period, was the darkest moments of my life, my thoughts were on dying, I called my wife and children with the news, I kept checking my emotions, I was approaching 151st Street on I-95 around Miami Gardens area. I then pulled over to the embankment to collect my thoughts. Washed away in tears.
Asking the question? “Why me God?”, when this silent voice answered?” “If not you, why not you?” From that moment, I came to grips with my condition. Once you get over the fear, you must face the facts of your life and deal with them. In my case, what I was facing wasn’t pretty. I’ve always been a fighter, and with all the prayers and support, a winner and told God, right then and there, whatever is your will, let your will be done. God only gives us what we can handle and that it helps to have a good sense of humour when we run smack into the absurdity of life. And to this day, that’s where I left it, it was no longer my problem; I put it in God hands and left it there.
These are the dilemmas for cancer patients, who and what to believe? A particular treatment is not fool proof, or, as many medical experts reminds us, it is not math, with a fixed and certain outcome. I quickly learned multiple myeloma would dictate the terms of my life, from physical fitness, to summer schedules, to appetite, to energy, to appreciation of my surrounding. Patients with complicated conditions would do well to adapt the “trust, but verify” reminder.
I hoped that as time passes I would be able to raise the cancer shade and allow more light into my daily life, until then it is cancer every waking moment and the realization that it will be with me until the end, by whatever means , and a reminder of the mortality zone I now occupy. We had the glory years, and then were ambushed by the cancer years.
This cancer ordeal has reminded me of the mental and physical dividends of good health, every morning I awake longing for the days not so long ago, when I would go for my 5 mile run. I am seldom at a loss for words, but no comments in passing would be worthy. Cancer is such a vicious disease that it can rob us of even small moments of humanity, for my part, with the exceptional support of my family, medical team and friends. I am very optimistic about the future and look forward to continuing my life. Day after day, friends are asking. “How you’re doing” by the way, “you look great” Really? I look better with cancer than I did without?
When I read that someone has been diagnosed with cancer or died of it. I will know there was nothing routine about his or her experience. The charts showing the improved survival rates for various forms of cancer are instructive, if not always comforting, until the day your physician declares you’re healed, and then it is not money-back guaranteed.
The stem cell journey started with 9 of us, unfortunately 6 have since departed, due to, or from their advanced stage, their immune system being knocked out, old age, lack of good physical conditioning on whit-standing the rigorous tremor of chemotherapy!!!
My cancer is manageable, after having 2 stem cell procedures the first on April 21st of 2009, with the transplant on June 11th 2009, with a scheduled discharged date for July 10th 2009 at the Regional Memorial Hospital Cancer Institute in Pembroke Pines, where I remained for 3 months, in a leased Apartment for both procedures, proximity had to be not more than 30 minutes from the Hospital, in case any problems arises, After completing my first pre-transplant work up on 2nd September 2009 the results showed a 37.5% of the cancer were still in the bone marrow, the Doctor and his t I went for my first check in mid-September, where 37.5 % of the cancer were still in the bone marrow, the Doctor and his team were not pleased with that, so I had to do a second scheduled autologous transplant process for the 15th September 2009, under the capable and professional care of Dr. Lyle Feinstein and his proficient team, followed by a high dose chemotherapy their goal was 20% or less. Where I remained for 9 weeks, however, many stories I hear of patients resuming normal lives while keeping multiple myeloma in remission. The numbers, not the anecdotes, tell the hard truths, it’s estimated that 24, 050. M/M cases were diagnosed in 2014, and in the same year 11,090, died of the cancer. The much more encouraging news is that the 3-4 year-survival rate has been improving steadily, from just over 26% of M/M patients in 1975, to approaching 65% now.
As the eternal optimist, I have beaten the odds & with Gods help, intend to hang around for longer than the 3-4 years, having been diagnosed from 2006. Has cancer changed me? Am I a better person? I leave that for others to judge! All I know that having a supportive family, access to excellent medical care, and the resources to pay for it. I remain a fortunate guy.
It is this uncompromising reality that should motivate every cancer patient, and patients afflicted with any kind of complicated condition, to constantly ask “Is this the right approach? Am I making the progress expected?” most important, are all the parts of my treatment team working together?
“Aging sucks” and it doesn’t come alone? It’s accompanied by all its alphabetical friends. Born in 1946, I am not a boomer, but the tailwinds of that generation swept through my age group as well, and we became part of the “always young” cohort. Aging was not in the game plan. I have learned that when friends and relatives have cancer you can be sympathetic, but you cannot be truly empathetic until you have it yourself. Cancer is an unwelcome companion to the so-called golden years of life.
“George Thompson, “a former reporter at the New York Times, wrote a widely praised book called the “Cancer Chronicles” and followed it in the “Sunday Times” with an article “Why everyone seems to have cancer?” He reminds us that age becomes the catalyst for cancer. “As people age their cells amass more potentially cancerous mutations, given a long life, cancer will eventually kill you-unless you die of something else”
Your concentration on the disease is the weapon that will do more harm than good, if you dwell on your condition, and not accept it for what it is, will do more damage than the cancer itself, these are the trials that test a family, and define the character of the individual members, my profound trust and faith in God. The support of my wife Angela, of “42” years. Now. I am endlessly intrigued by their distinctive strengths and instincts, my children in the weeks, months, and years ahead I would need the combined strength, they represented as each played a distinctive role.
Prayers of my family and friends, and good wishes sustained me. Personally. I never drifted from my prayer life, but I was deeply touched by friends, who kept the faith in a quiet way and offered their prayers as well, gave me hope and played a major role in my recovery, in facing this new challenge during this difficult period of my life. I ask humbly for your continued prayers and love.
Currently, my life is troubled free, of which I have earned that right to just relax, do as I please in moderation. I go out occasionally for a social outing to enjoy a few libations, just to get out, from what can easily become a dull life. I look forward and treasure the times I am able to spend with my children and grandchildren, and to still be around to see my third generation, 3 beautiful great grands. Life goes on.
I have always, and still enjoy the quality of the finer things of life, in its abundance. That I’ve become accustomed to, and all that life have to offer in all its fullness, and I intend with God’s help to enjoy every day, as though it’s my last. I subscribe to the Lord’s Prayer “Give us this day”
Nowadays, with God’s grace and mercy, after going through and experiencing 2 stem cell procedures. And the extraction of 10 million cells, over a 6 days period, that completely wiped out my immune system throughout the process, and is still compromised. I can appreciate stem cell, which is a very, very demanding serious and expensive procedure. To my dismay when the attendant from the blood bank came to collect my cells for harvesting, and returning it, she was accompanied by a Police officer on every occasion. Every so often the treatment for cancer can cause other serious problems, my test results over the last 8 years were negative, the latest being the 6th of March 2017 with no trace of the cancer. I can positively say that God is good. To him I give the glory. I am feeling and doing extremely well.
However, being on daily medication. Thalidomide, at a monthly cost of $585.00. I keep active by going to the gym 4 times a week, my lifestyle have been altered somewhat, but God have been good to me over these last 70 years, for which I am grateful. I have enjoyed a good life, with no regrets or complaints. I have done everything that my heart desires: traveling, cruising extensively, and continue to do so at every opportunity, knowing this too shall pass. So far the early reassurance about my condition is holding up. I will die someday, but it is not likely to be from the result of multiple myeloma.
I do think about my mortality in ways I did not before being diagnosed with M/M. It no longer seems a faint, distant reality, in part because I’ve experienced the ruthless nature of cancer, simultaneously at age “70” I’ve moved into the neighbourhood of life where there are a few longer leases. It is not enough to “rage” rage against the dying light?” it is also time to quietly savour every waking moment with emotional and intellectual pursuits worthy of the precious time we have.
Life, what’s Left?
Bring it on!
Kelly D. Burrows
Freeport. Grand Bahama
- Box. F 42977
Telephone 373 7126
keldo@coralwave.com
-
Statement by Bishop Laish Boyd
THE DIOCESE OF THE BAHAMAS AND THE TURKS AND CAICOS ISLANDS
THE BISHOP’S CHARGE TO THE ONE-HUNDRED AND FOURTEENTH SESSION OF SYNOD
AT THE SYNOD OPENING EUCHARIST IN CHRIST CHURCH CATHEDRAL, NASSAU
ON MONDAY, 6TH FEBRUARY, 2017, AT 7:30 P.M.
We welcome you all into Christ Church Cathedral this evening at this Opening Service of the 114th Session of the Synod of the Anglican Diocese of The Bahamas and The Turks and Caicos Islands.
We welcome:
Her Excellency, the Governor General, Dame Marguerite Pindling
The Rt. Honourable Perry Christie, Prime Minister
The Honourable Deputy Prime Minister
Cabinet Ministers
The Honourable Loretta Butler-Turner, leader of the Opposition and Mr. Turner
The Honourable Hubert Minnis and Mrs. Minnis
Senators, Members of Parliament
Senior Government Officials
We welcome:
Dr. Ranford Patterson, President of the Bahamas Christian Council, who just brought us greetings, and Mrs. Patterson
Various Heads of denominations or their representatives, with their spouses.
Archbishop Drexel Gomez and Bishop Gilbert Thompson, Archdeacons, Canons, Clergy of the Diocese and their spouses
The Chancellor, Justice Bernard Turner, the Vice Chancellor, Mrs. Diane Stewart, the Registrar, Mrs. Tonya Bastian-Galanis, other diocesan officials and their spouses
The Director of Education, Mrs. Italia Davies, the new Chief Development Officer for Anglican Schools, Mrs. Jennifer Basden, who joined us in January 2016; Principals, Administrators, and students of our four schools
Lay Delegates to the 114th Session of Synod.
We welcome the hard-working Diocesan Office Staff, acknowledging especially Archdeacon James Palacious and Mrs. Sonja Balfour, Financial Comptroller, and Miss Linda Farrington, who leads the Synod preparation process, and all those others who have helped us to be where we are this week.
Catechists, Lay Readers, Servers, My brothers and sisters
We welcome those sharing in this service via ZNS TV 13, in The Bahamas, The Turks and Caicos Islands, the Caribbean and South Florida, and those who join us via live stream and on Facebook all over the world. Thank you for sharing with us.
We are grateful to the Very Rev’d. the Dean, Father Colin Saunders, Precentor, and Staff of the Cathedral, Mr. Adrian Archer, Mr. Henderson Burrows, Mr. Christopher Smith and all of the ministries that have come together to make this service possible.
It is our privilege to convene this 114th Session of Diocesan Synod and to declare it open in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
To God be the glory.
Micah 6:8, “…and what does the Lord require of you but to do justice…”
Micah spoke at a time when Israel and Judah, after a long period of peace, were coming under attack from the expanding Assyrian Empire. Micah challenged his hearers to pursue justice for all because national well-being was not just withstanding the Assyrians, but also how ordinary citizens fare. Power in the hands of countries, leaders and citizens must be used to enable the well-being of all citizens. This remains the responsibility of the state, the Church and of all citizens, not to further inequality but to empower and to liberate.
Micah was inspired by a basic premise: “God has been so good to you and so the least that you can do is to give back to God through your society. You have been blessed in so many ways. What is it that is required of you, from your position of blessing?” The response is, “Do justice!”
The Hebrew word used here is mispat. Justice is something we do. It is not enough to yearn for justice, to talk about justice, to wish for justice, or to complain about the lack of it. There is a dynamic concept here which calls us to DO JUSTICE: to work for fairness, equality, a level playing field; work for it, strive for it, agitate for it, on behalf of those who cannot get it otherwise or who cannot achieve it for themselves, for the weak the disenfranchised, the powerless.
Doing what is right is the job of all of us in the church and in the state. The Church is called to preach the gospel and to instruct and encourage members to bring their lives into line with Christ’s expectations. When this happens, our personal lives, our relationships, our work, our studies all take on their full potential. And we are empowered to do what we need to do in terms of impacting the wider community, changing lives, addressing national issues, speaking out against wrong, speaking the truth to Power and to Influence…But it begins with our faithfulness to the gospel. Then, our faithfulness to the gospel spills over into every other area.
In this regard, I want us to look at a number of issues which face us all:
The National Birth Rate
Mr. Richard Lightbourn, Member of Parliament for Montagu made some remarks at the Free National Movement’s Convention in July 2016. The Venerable James Palacious, Archdeacon for Administration for the Anglican Diocese, made some remarks at the 50th Majority Rule Day service. There were varied reactions to these remarks, but one thing is certain: the remarks speak to a national issue that has far-reaching and crippling implications on the current reality and on the future of our beloved Bahamas: While the birth-rate per capita has actually declined over the years, as a general rule, too many people are having children that they cannot afford to maintain materially, parentally, emotionally or financially.
We know that the right to have a child is a personal one and that no one can stop anyone from mothering or fathering a child. We know also that many single parents have done a fine job raising children but, if we are honest, we have to admit that this is becoming less and less the case today as too many young people are having babies. They are not fully mature themselves. They are not socially stable in terms of their living circumstances. They are not financially self-sufficient. They cannot create a stable, ordered environment for a child to grow up in. Yet they are having babies because “they is man!” or they is woman!”
Some not-so-young persons are mothering and fathering children and do not have all of the resources to care for a child. Too many people are having children and have not asked,
“Can I afford a baby or another baby?”
“Do I have the order and stability in my life to sustain a child?”
“Do I have what it takes to provide for this child?”
“Is this child going to have a fighting chance?”
For too many of our children the game is over before it even starts. They are born into “no-win” circumstances.
Dear friends, these are the realities that are affecting this country every day, creating hopelessness, giving no options for success, recycling poverty and underdevelopment and hurting Bahamaland. We cannot build a sound society on a shaky foundation.
Not every mother or father is doing this. There are many fine parents, single and married, who are doing the skill of parenting proud. But far too many fall into the category that I have outlined.
No one has all of the answers to this dilemma. We ALL have to work together on this. The government through its efforts and agencies is trying its best but let us all redouble our efforts. I do know that we have to talk more to our young people from the primary school and high school levels. I am not talking about conversation for the sake of having it, but real, honest, frank, practical discussions on this topic and on related issues. Yes it has to happen in schools and churches and Sunday Schools and Sabbath Schools and youth groups. And it has to happen OUTSIDE of those walls as well. We have to teach the value of life and healthy choices and responsibility for one’s actions. We have to teach that the body is still the Temple of the Lord and, for those with no Christian foundation, just let them know that the body and its functions and its capabilities are precious.
Teach that sex is not a recreation, it is a sacred act; and that a baby is not something you have to prove that “you is man” or that “you is woman”; that it is a bad idea to have a baby to keep a man or as a meal ticket – because the long term responsibility is too big for one moment of satisfaction.
We have to talk aggressively and to teach this: parents, teachers, clergy, youth groups, curriculum people.
And we need a national information/education initiative to reach those who are out of school, to the wider citizenry.
We cannot just have children because we have the biology. We have to consider the long-term implications.
This is a matter of foundational national urgency, never mind how politically sensitive it is or how much furore it generates on the talk shows. There is urgent need for a more Comprehensive National Family Planning Programme.
I wish to say a word to the media which in print and word and image responded to the remarks of Messrs. Lightbourn and Palacious. Instead of generating excitement, I think the media should have led us into a keen discussion on the national reality. Why not interview experts from the field: the Department of Statistics, Social Services, the Healthcare system, the Ministry of Education, the Police? These are the people who can speak to the issue.
As a nation, let us have the discussion. Let us do the right thing.
50th Anniversary of Majority Rule
The Anglican Church joins with the country in celebrating the 50th Anniversary of Majority Rule. The event was a part of a process that began long before January 1967, and continued long afterwards – even up to the present day. The process marked, among other things, the transfer of political power from a minority group to the majority group.
It was not simply a racial event since the majority attained by the Progressive Liberal Party was comprised of white and black men. It was about allowing all Bahamians to have a stake and to feel a sense of ownership.
The era of opportunity for advancement and education ushered The Bahamas into a new chapter of economic growth, national development and diversification. With more people having more opportunity and access, it meant that they ultimately had more options for self-determination and for power. This meant that poor, middle class and merchant class and wealthy Bahamians benefitted from Majority Rule from the very beginning.
In my opinion Majority Rule is the single greatest historical event outside of emancipation in 1834-38 – such was its exponential effect upon The Bahamas.
It is unfortunate that Majority Rule, an historical evolution and an event impacting all Bahamians in a way that I have just outlined, has become so politicized and appears at times to belong to one party, over and against the other, and not to the country as a whole – especially since ALL Bahamians ultimately benefitted from it.
Because it has not been set up as a national institution based on historical reality – and because, in my view, neither government has even made an attempt to do this, then what happens: unwise or indiscreet PLP’s get to behave like its theirs to use for political mileage, especially in seasons like this; unwise or indiscreet FNM’s seek to distance themselves from it because someone is behaving like it is all about Pindling and the PLP.
This is unfortunate and many of us are guilty because we have not done a good job of presenting it as a national historical event or setting up its celebration like it is a national historic event.
We have to be so careful that the fact and spirit of the Majority Rule Process is not lost in our mishandling of it. We have to be careful that in all of our efforts we achieve the real empowerment, equality and opportunity that the original process sought to accomplish.
It is not too late to do this. Let’s do the right thing!
Independent Boundaries Commission
I wish to renew my call for an independent Boundaries Commission. Successive governments continue to use their majority influence over the boundaries exercise as a way to attain political advantage, e.g., chop off here and add on there to make sure my person gets in. Boundaries Commission work should be based on numbers, demographics and geography, not political whim. I was once told by a sitting Prime Minister that he wanted it but that the Members of Parliament on both sides were all vehemently against it. I cannot say that I am surprised if it can be used to personal and partisan advantage. But we need an independent body, especially in a country where there is so much familiarity, inbreeding, corruption and circumventing of laws and procedures – when it suits our fancy. We need an independent Boundaries Commission that draws lines objectively and that reports on time.
Let us do the right thing!
Campaign Reform
I call again for serious campaign finance reform. Parties need to be held accountable for what they collect and what they spend, with appropriate limits put in place for each. The Opposition and the Governing Party need to say where their money has come from. This is foreign to us and may even seem offensive, but it is standard practice in well-run democracies worldwide. It also keeps everyone honest and encourages campaigns and countries to be run on issues rather than by special interests and self-preservation.
TURKS AND CAICOS ISLANDS
And now, let us turn our attention to the Turks and Caicos Islands for a few moments.
New Governor
We welcome to the Turks and Caicos Islands and to The Diocese the new British Governor, His Excellency Dr. John Freeman and Mrs. Corinna Freeman. We wish them a happy, productive and peaceful time here in our midst.
Elections 2016
On 15 December 2016, the Turks and Caicos Islands held general elections, the second since the new Constitution was introduced in 2011.
The Hon. Sharlene Cartwright-Robinson is the new Premier leading the People’s Democratic Movement (PDM) majority, the official Opposition is the Progressive National Party (PNP) and is led by the Hon Washington Missick.
On Thursday 29 December, 2017, I had the privilege of attending the National Ecumenical
Service held at St. Mary’s Pro-Cathedral in Grand Turk, followed by the first session of the new Parliament. At that time, I said in my sermon what I now repeat: all must work together to build TCI.
Positive Election Atmosphere
The country is to be commended for:
- A free, fair and more efficient election-day process
- Much less acrimony among people than in the 2012 elections – indicating a more mature citizenry
- A smooth handing over of Government with modest winners & gracious losers
When the British government was forced to suspend portions of the Constitution and to take over the running of the country, it was an upsetting time, but, in my view, the British government did the best thing. The process of streamlining, of stricter management and more accountability and transparency has been a good thing for the country, and has put it in a better place. The Bahamas could learn many things from this.
Commendation for Accomplishments
At this time of post-election transition the country must be commended for what the interim British administration and the former PNP government were able to accomplish as we recognize the stewardship of both.
- bringing the country back from the brink of bankruptcy
- paying off a $170 million debt that the government had incurred through mismanagement before the suspending of the Constitution
- having preparation in place to start a Sovereign Wealth Fund (Reserves)
- achieving a second consecutive BBB + Standard and Poors (S +P) rating
- pursuing infrastructural works of which some are completed, e.g., the first phase of the Long Bay High School in Provo. There are others in progress, e.g., the Lighthouse Road in Grand Turk
- having more young Turks and Caicos Islanders in key leadership positions
- the reemploying of many skilled and suitably- educated locals who were made redundant from the civil service four years ago
- increasing the minimum wage and increasing salaries for some public servants
These are but a few of the noteworthy accomplishments
Moving Forward
I call on the new PDM government, among other things, to have the following as its focus:
- Notwithstanding a clear majority, commit to work with the Opposition and other stakeholders
- Commit to be ever mindful of Christian morals which MPs must promote and maintain to be true to their baptismal vows.
- Heed the counsel of the Church and the religious leaders to build the spiritual fabric of the nation
- Respect and provide the resources for the various agencies that ensure good governance – The Integrity Commission & The Office of the Complaints Commissioner
- Be a Government for all the people: practice fair and transparent decision-making and give equal opportunity for all citizens
- The Constitution is a living organism. It should be reflected upon, analysed and reviewed as a matter of routine.
- Seek to resolve the financial and overseas travel issues associated with the functioning of the National Health Insurance scheme
- Seek to study and to resolve the many issues surrounding illegal immigration.
- Address crime, especially since there are now more guns on the streets
- Enforce the law in every sphere: work permits, business licenses, customs duties, road traffic regulations, etc.
- Ensure that the country remains among the top regional competitors in attracting tourists; and arrest the decline of cruise ship passengers arrivals
- Continue to encourage sound, sustainable, TCI- beneficial foreign investment
- Continue to insist on the best use of crown land
- Pursue AGGRESSIVELY, efficiency and productivity of the Public Service – facilities and processes cannot be stalled because only one person has the required key responsibility in a department and he /she is away from office.
- The performance of employees, including those in senior positions, must be appraised with a view to improving the Public Service
- The British-appointed Chief Financial Officer is expected to leave in March. Fiscal prudence and accountability must be maintained, monitored and enforced.
In addition to these challenges to the PDM government, I stress the need for the British Government to give more assistance with national security: resources and training for the police and prison officers, better resources to detect illegal boats which bring illegal immigrants, poachers and guns.
The overarching reality that all stakeholders must address and seek to ameliorate is improving understanding and dialogue between the various national groups. If you have a country of 35,000 and more than one half is expatriates and you have 19,000 persons on work permit – that is cause for discussion, understanding, working together and fair opportunity. It is a dialogue that ALL of the stakeholders in the nation need to be involved in to find a just, and optimum way forward where native TCIs are not disenfranchised but where those same native TCIs take a realistic and sensible view of reality AND are prepared to pull their weight and play their part.
I have found that sometimes, some local Turks & Caicos Islanders have a sense of entitlement that is unrealistic and unhelpful to real national development.
God bless the Turks and Caicos Islands.
And now, back to the Bahamas.
Pre-Election Behaviour
As the “silly season” kicks into high gear I wish to urge all involved to conduct themselves in a decent Christian manner: dignified, respectful, and commanding respect. Be a person that our young people and the entire population can look up to and emulate. This is not unreasonable or farfetched. It is what people have a right to expect from their leaders. Stick with the issues and leave personalities out!! There is no place in our society for the character assassination that has characterized Bahamian politics over the years. Our people deserve better than some of us give to them. The electorate needs to know how you will govern the country and is not interested in how well you can demonize and malign your opponent.
Of course, persons who stand for public office must examine very closely what their motives are: real, honest contemplation on why you are offering yourself and what you can really offer. We need more statespersons and fewer political animals. The citizens ought to be able to hold their elected officials in the highest regard because of content of character and integrity rather than what they can get out of the deal for themselves.
And now, back to The Bahamas.
Local Government
It is time for Local Government to be implemented in New Providence so that these populated communities could have more of a sense of ownership of their areas rather than an unhealthy reliance upon Central Government or the local M.P. Let us begin to discuss this seriously. Remember that the best leaders/management systems DELEGATE duties and responsibilities rather than hoard them.
Immigration
Over the past year, we have seen an increase in the number of illegal immigrants being picked up at sea or stranded on one of our islands. While we are sympathetic to our brothers and sisters who leave their country in search of a better life for themselves and their families, we have to protect our borders so that the country would not be overrun by a migrant population.
Once again, I call upon the government to continue to enforce the Immigration laws of our country and to repatriate people who are here illegally, while we give status to others who might have legitimate claim to it. Persons born in this country to non-Bahamians should not have to wait so many years before they receive a reply to their application for some kind of permanent status – if they return a reply at all.
We must commend the Immigration Department in its valiant efforts to apprehend and repatriate illegal immigrants. We must also say special thanks to the Royal Bahamas Defence Force for stepping up its patrol of all over the archipelago and for apprehending poachers and others.
In light of the huge increase in the number of Cuban nationals picked up recently, I strongly urge the government to appoint a Citizens Advisory Committee that would visit the Detention Centre regularly in order to check on the overall management of the facility and the welfare of the detainees. This is particularly important in light of the negative publicity we have had from Cuban Americans who accused our officers of cruelty to their compatriots. Such a committee could speak truth to the issue and the government would not have to defend itself against false accusations.
Royal Bahamas Police Force
The Royal Bahamas Police Force is doing a tremendous job and we wish to commend them highly. We encourage them to keep up the good job they are doing; we are all encouraged by the overall decrease in serious crime for the past year, but there is still too much crime. Lots of work needs to be done to reduce that rate even further and all of us have a part to play. It is not just the job of the Police force. Folks, help them out. Let’s do the right thing! And let us heal more of the wounds of our society and thereby stem the spread of crime at its root.
Bahamas Christian Council
I highly commend the Officers and members of the Bahamas Christian Council for their ecumenical thrust. There is so much more that we could achieve when we work together for the common good. We need to tackle cooperatively the national issues AND some of the problems experienced by residents of the inner city; crime, overcrowding, lack of education, poverty, unsanitary living condition, poor parenting, etc.
I am pleased to note the efforts at community involvement and development that members of the North Eastern Pastors Alliance are spearheading. The Rev. Beverley Strachan of the Assemblies of God is the current President. Their efforts in the training of mentors for young people and at parenting classes have been very helpful. Their establishment of centres for children suspended from school is worthy of praise. This started from humble beginnings in the Kemp Road area and there are now 13 of these across the island. The Ministry of Education is partnering with the group in this regard. Our own Rev. Angela Palacious works closely with this group, which is co-directed by Pastor Dale Moss of the Church of God of Prophecy. The headquarters for this programme is housed in St. George’s Church’s Outreach Building on Montrose Avenue opposite the Church.
It is very easy for us to engage in a continuous analysis of what’s going wrong in the society. To use the words of the late Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., we must not become victims of the “paralysis of analysis.”
We must rise up and confront these issues. We don’t need people to predict rain and bad weather. Anyone can do that. We need some Noahs to build arks and take our people to safety. We must be equal to the task!! Let’s do the right thing!
Taxation
We commend the government for its effort in collecting taxes and urge the government to keep the pressure up. I call on citizens and residents to pay their taxes that they owe. On the other hand, no stone should be left unturned in the effort to wipe out corruption, theft, wastage of time and resources from the various government departments and agencies. The cost of doing business is still too high and the time it takes to process things is still too long.
It is just totally unacceptable to have so much money unaccounted for in some of these agencies. People need to be held accountable for our money and publicly prosecuted when theft takes place. The culture of deceit, dishonesty and corruption is too deeply entrenched in our so called “Christian Nation.” My brothers and sisters, we cannot build a country with this handicap.
While taxes are necessary for the government to fund goods and services that it delivers, many more people would be less hostile to paying taxes if we could be more convinced that the money was being spent wisely!! There needs to be more reporting of these matters to the public and real, dispassionate accounting, not pat phrases and sound bites given in passing.
National Health Insurance (NHI)
I wish to commend the government’s effort to bring National Health Insurance on stream. It is LOOOONG overdue – and even that is an understatement. Since 1983 successive governments have made key decisions in this direction, so there is bi-partisan agreement on its necessity. Let us have wide collaboration, sound planning, realistic deadlines, clear accountability, attainable milestones and a heart for the nation’s well-being as we move forward. Remember that, in addition to the scheme itself, systems, facilities, attitudes and work ethic must be in place for it to work.
Regardless of how effectively the National Health Insurance will work, ultimately we are each responsible for our good health. We are our own primary health care giver. Let us take more care of our own health. We have the dubious distinction of being the most obese people in the Caribbean. Non-communicable diseases like diabetes and hypertension are rampant.
All of us must be on board to make it work for all of us.
National Development Plan
I wish to commend the work of the Vision 2040 exercise which is the National Development Plan of The Bahamas. The Secretariat, based in the Office of the Prime Minister, is lead by Dr. Nicola Virgill-Rolle.
The exercise looks at the current state of The Bahamas and seeks to lay out a plan of development that will chart the future of the country as a whole, irrespective of which government is in power.
Every citizen and resident should be KEENLY interested in this.
Persons from the Secretariat will be addressing the Synod in our Practical Ministry segment on Wednesday afternoon. Throughout the history of these islands the Anglican Church has been a key player in national development and we cannot stop now.
CONCLUSION
Dear people of God, Justice is something that we DO. The Church, the government, the schools, the private sector, social and civic organisations must individually and collectively agitate and work for it in every area so that, in the words of the Prophet Amos, Justice will “roll down like a river” (Amos 5:24) all over the Bahamas and The Turks and Caicos Islands
Key in all of this in our personal choice: choosing to follow in our own lives, living our faith. This should spill over into everything else that we do.
As the bishop of the Diocese, I call on all Anglicans, and upon the wider community, to focus on that personal relationship with God: nurture it, strengthen it, rekindle it if you have to, or start it for the first time. Live for God. Let His light shine into our lives…and then let His light shine FROM our lives. We have to get back to basics. We have to live for God. We have to live the Gospel. We have to put arms and hands and legs on the Gospel.
Our theme in the Diocese this year is “We have a Goodly Heritage – Build on it!” Our Christian heritage is rich. God has been SOOO good to us. He has given us life. He has given us this Church that has shaped us all, and given us each our wonderful identity. He has given us His Son, Jesus, who died for our redemption. My friends, let us claim God, name and claim Gods’ place in our lives, and move forward from this foundation to live for Him, to build on the glorious faith with which we have been entrusted.
In this year I call on the whole Anglican Family, individually, in parishes, in your various ministries and in every sphere of existence, to build on God’s heritage in your life.
Set about building a spiritual house. Set about ordering your affairs in God’s ways.
Again, my sisters and brothers, we have to speak it. We have to live it. We have to bring our lives and our living into line with what God wants from us, and we have to help each other along the way…to be what God wants us to be.
This is the only way that the Church and the state can DO JUSTICE, as Micah calls us to do. Won’t you commit to this task today?
-
ADDRESS BY FRED MITCHELL AT 52ND NGC
ADDRESS
BY
THE HON. FRED MITCHELL MP
MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND IMMIGRATION
52ND NATIONAL GENERAL CONVENTION
PROGRESSIVE LIBERAL PARTY
MELIA NASSAU BEACH RESORT25 JANUARY 2017
Check against delivery
Mr. Session Chairman
Brothers and sistersI am pleased to be here tonight. This Convention has been long in coming and I hope that this is the beginning of a renewed commitment to this process of an annual get together; the kind I remember from my youth: through rain, sleet or snow. Let us provide the opportunity for the fellowship one to another and the building up of the institution by at least one annual gathering where we meet and greet, learn to sing from the same hymn sheet and choose our leaders.
I am pleased also that democracy is at work in the party and that dissent is possible with a minimum of acrimony and with mutual respect for the ideas within a big tent. The number of young men and women who have chosen to come forward is a real blessing.
I want to pay tribute to the people of Fox Hill without whom none of this would be possible. We have a full delegation here. We had a very sober and compelling, frank conversation last week as we prepared for this. We know our job is to win. We also know that no matter what is being said in the wind about how easy it is, there is a battle ahead of us. The anecdotal evidence suggests that this election will be each man hold their man. We have our marching orders.
On Monday 23 January, a noted Queen’s Counsel Fred Smith tried to fool the Bahamian public that he was apologising to them for these remarks delivered on 15 January at the Coral Beach Condominium Association in Freeport. He was speaking a group of foreigners, some 65 of them. The minutes of the meeting reflect that he knew that he was being taped, and he knew also that the tape would be circulated. Yet, drunk with the wine and intoxication of the crowd, he spoke the truth and his honest and reasonable belief as he saw it, from his heart. Loose lips sink ships.
He said: “You’re all white for the most part… and it’s a big problem for the Black Bahamians that you’re down here. Believe it or not they want your money, they want you to spend it but they don’t like you alright. A lot of them don’t. The fact is The Bahamas is a very racist, a very xenophobic, a nationally insecure and a very hateful place to foreigners”
Listen to it for yourselves and you judge whether it was taken out of context. (play voice insert)
This morning, The Tribune published the apology in full and called for me to apologise to him. When you examine the so called apology, it is not an apology at all. It is really an explanation for why he said what he said and he sought to justify it by seeking to become a victim. Let me make it clear, hell will freeze over before there is any apology from me.
True to form when my initial remarks were first reported in the House of Assembly, the press did not report what I said. Thank God for Andrew Burrows of ZNS that the story got out. The Tribune buried the story in the back. The Guardian reported it on their Business page. When Mr. Smith responded with his so called apology that made the front page.
The broader point I make then is that the PLP does not control the narrative in the process of this political battle and in shaping public opinion. This then is the time to take stock of how things really run and why there is this overwhelmingly negative tone around everything that we do. We must reverse this and begin to more effectively mould and shape public opinion.
That story of the QC is but one example.
The negative twists in the wonderful success of BAMSI in Andros and Bahamar at Cable Beach are other examples.
I think therefore that this party has a compelling case to tell Fred Smith QC and his fellow travellers to take his so called apology and shove it.
Why is this important to this convention?
In March last year, I went to the House of Assembly and revealed that I had been informed that an organization Save The Bays was masquerading as an environmental organization but was really a front organization being funded by a rich Permanent Resident in The Bahamas to destabilise and overthrow the PLP. That was said in the House of Assembly and is the subject of a Parliamentary Committee’s investigation. The Committee should call without delay for the bank accounts, subpoena these people, and compel them to disclose the true nature of what they are doing in The Bahamas.
Save The Bays, the phoney environmental organization, has the same people who run the Grand Bahama Human Rights Association, who are the same people who have run to the Inter American Human Rights Commission to complain saying their lives are in danger then refuse to cooperate with the police.
These are the same people who want openness, transparency and freedom of information who have sued newspapers in libel to silence them and then have run to the courts to stop Members of Parliament from speaking in the House.
This is a clear and present danger to the PLP. In other words, the question is where does the money come from to pay for all this litigation which is leading to the inability of your MPs to do their jobs? We must follow the paper trail wherever it goes.
The Government – the PLP has to find out where they are getting this money from; what is their true purpose and motive; are they acting according to law? We must seek to stop any unlawful behaviours dead in its tracks. This is a matter of this PLP’s survival.
Now why is this so important and what does this have to do with building and empowerment and moving this country forward? Well this matter is about the national identity and sanctity and protection of our country. We must defend our country from those who are without who would destroy us and those who are within.
At the same time, as the so called apology was being given, the same Lawyer Fred Smith was duplicitously making a pointed personal attack on this minister, under the headline: Mitchell Embarrasses The Bahamas.
The only embarrassment is by Mr. Smith himself.
So ladies and gentlemen, brothers and sisters, the Department of Immigration, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs is pledged to defend our country. We do so without fear or favour. It is not only against the illegal migrants who come from the north of Haiti, the desperate economic migrants from Cuba and the monied smugglers from Latin America, China and the Far East, but against those who come as legitimate traders and end up working outside the scope of their work permits, robbing Bahamians of legitimate job opportunities.
This is a problem in the Exuma Cays, in Eleuthera and Harbour Island, in Grand Bahama, in Abaco and in New Providence. You come in as a tourist then start to work without a work permit.
It is also to defend against those who are abusive to Bahamians. The department will revoke the permits of those found by the Department of Labour to abuse Bahamian workers.
Fifty years ago Sir Lynden Pindling and the PLP struck the most decisive blow for the freedom of the black people, when he won the government and ushered in majority rule. Aleta Continua… the struggle still continues. Forward Ever! Backward never!
The symbolic march down Burma Road is continuous. It never stops as long as obstacles to freedom and social justice and economic justice stand in our way. We will stand on the shoulders of those great warriors for justice and freedom and continue their noble work of building, empowering and moving this country forward together. There can be no compromise on this.
I am a Burma Road Baby. We are all the children of Burma Road. Let us continue to pledge to work to protect the heritage, the dignity of this country for all people.
PLP All The Way!
-
THIS WEEK CONTINUED…
PLP EMERGES COMMITTED TO “MOVING FORWARD TOGETHER”
The Progressive Liberal Party closed out its 52nd National General Convention on Thursday with thousands of supporters in attendance. Session Chairwoman Cheryl Bazard opened the night emphasizing the party is united behind Party Leader and Prime Minister the Rt. Hon. Perry G. Christie – who defeated Alfred Sears in an internal party vote Thursday afternoon 1264 to 169. Sears conceded, and the Party declared it is committed to moving FORWARD TOGETHER – the theme of the final night.
Hon. V. Alfred Grey, Minister of Agriculture and Marine Resources spoke about the benefits of BAMSI, “BAMSI empowers people to become employers not employees.”
Chester Cooper took the stage with strong contingent of Exuma constituents, sharing why he is a member of the Progressive Liberal Party. “Why the PLP?” he asked, “because it’s a story of empowerment.”
Dr. Bernard Nottage, Minister of National Security acknowledged that despite the progress in the last 5 years, there was still much to do on crime. “There must be prevention, detection and effective prosecution and rehabilitation.” Keith Bell, Minister of State, echoed by saying “all the institutions must work together…Even if it’s one murder it’s one too much.”
Obie Wilchcombe, Minister of Tourism lauded the progress of the tourism industry, saying “There is no island country in the world that has had so many brand hotels come to their country.”
Prime Minister Perry Christie embraced a message of moving forward and tackling the difficult issues that affect Bahamians. He spoke candidly about the progress the PLP has started, but indicated there is still more to do. “People are expecting more from their government and from each other…but we are now able to move forward.”
The Prime Minister continued by indicating he has the best team, “They have not let me down, and they have not let you down,” pointed to major innovations like NHI, BAMSI and NTA – though there is room for more. He reaffirmed that new jobs were created across the country, with record levels of investment. On security, he said new courts and new anti-gang units have helped double conviction rates, as did strengthening of swift justice. All this, but there is still more to do. “We must keep going and we must go further.”
AG THANKS DAME ALLEN FOR “VISIONARY LEADERSHIP”
Speaking at a special sitting of the Court of Appeal on Thursday of this week, Attorney General and Legal Affairs Minister Senator Allyson Maynard-Gibson thanked Appeals Court President Dame Anita Allen for her years of “visionary leadership” as president of the Court of Appeal.
“When you became President you enunciated a vision that included the expansion of Court of Appeal facilities, greater use of technology and streamlining of this Court’s processes. We stand here today in one of 3 courts that now exist in the Court of Appeal (up from 1 in 2012)” said the Attorney General as she paid tribute to the Dame.
Highlighting some of the accomplishments of the judiciary, Mrs. Maynard-Gibson pointed to the concurrent sitting of 10 criminal courts; 114 more matters disposed of in 2015 than in 2012; and a doubling of the conviction rate from 31% in 2012 to 66% in 2016 (with the conviction rate for murder being 72% in 2016).”
The Attorney General also hailed Justice Allen’s defense of the judiciary’s integrity, indicating that in 2014, Allen cautioned that “concomitant with judicial independence is judicial accountability”, and that the judiciary must be as “punctilious” about its accountability to the Bahamian people as it is about “asserting its independence.”
ENHANCED BAHAMAS E-PASSPORT SYSTEM GOES LIVE
Canadian Bank Note (CBN), the company awarded the $18 million contract to produce a comprehensive border management system, was in Nassau this week to launch the new security enhanced e-passport system. The press conference was held at the Passport Office on Thursday of this week.
Foreign Affairs Minister the Hon. Fred Mitchell who has responsibility for passports promised improved customer service generally as the department moves to expedite the backlog of passport applications.
CBN representatives said the new laser based system can generate fifty passports per hour and can facilitate an application in five to eight days. There is a mobile facility that will move through the family of islands, meeting the needs of Bahamians there. Additionally, the team of seventy-two will make house calls for senior citizens and other Bahamians with physical mobility issues.
There are still 29,000 Bahamian passport holders with hand-written passports who are urged to upgrade their travel documents to e-passports. Current e-passport holders are not affected by this new roll out – they are fine until the expiration date and the fees remain unchanged.
NEW BOARD FOR BAHAMAS CIVIL AVIATION AUTHORITY NAMED
On Friday the Minister of Transport & Aviation, the Hon. Glenys Hanna Martin announced the appointment of three distinguished Bahamians to the Board of the Bahamas Civil Aviation Authority.
“The principal functions of the Board will be to develop policies, and to give general directions on the implementation and achievement of the objectives of the newly-formed Bahamas Civil Aviation Authority (BCAA) and the Bahamas Air Navigation Services Division” said the Ministry in a press statement.
The board will be chaired by thirty-eight year banking veteran Mrs. Wendy Craigg CBE, former Governor and Chairman of the Board of the Central Bank of The Bahamas.
The two remaining board appointees include attorney and aviation legal expert Mr. Michael Allen of Higgs and Johnson law firm and industry veteran and former owner of SkyBahamas Limited the Rev. Heuter Rolle, currently the pastor of Salem Union Baptist Church.
Minister Hanna Martin offered high praise for this “distinguished team of professional Bahamian trailblazers,” expressing confidence that the team will “serve with distinction, in ensuring the necessary regulatory oversight of the aviation sector, and the continued development of air navigation services in the country.”
In Passing…
Seeking to energize supporters ahead of national convention, Prime Minister Christie last Sunday declared that his administration has created nearly 32,000 jobs this term. Mr. Christie said the figure was supported by data released from the Department of Statistics, and evidenced that the country was on the path to recovery notwithstanding the devastation wrought by two major hurricanes.
The Bahamas “does not tolerate” tax crimes and “cannot operate in isolation from rest of the world” in financial services said Minister of Financial Services Hope Strachan, warning that it must respond to evolving international regulatory standards if it is to remain competitive. She also said that the country will remain compliant. She was responding to an AP article.
Former Deputy Police Commissioner Marvin Dames Monday called on the Government to install metal detectors in every junior and senior high school and have all students screened in the wake of a stabbing at Government High School. In responding, Southwestern District Superintendent Julian Anderson said he did not believe that would arrest the problem permeating on school campuses.
Following an altercation at Government High School last week that resulted in one student being stabbed and two others injured, FNM candidate for Montagu Dionisio D’Aguilar yesterday suggested public schools be removed from government responsibility and placed under private control.
Qualified residents in Mayaguana will receive their Visa prepaid cards by February 3, 2017, Minister of Social Services and Community Development Melanie Griffin announced on January 20, at a Department of Social Services motivational seminar at Church of God Auditorium.
The Valley Boys Junkanoo group plans to take legal action against the Junkanoo Corporation of New Providence (JCNP) over the change in the 2017 New Year’s Junkanoo Parade results, after the Roots Junkanoo group was declared the official winner of that event.
Police Commissioner Greenslade has denied claims that Thursday’s (19th January) stabbing incident at Government High School was linked to gang-related activities, insisting that the students involved were “wannabes”.
The Government has committed $2.5 million to speeding up repairs on Freeport’s Memories resort, with its operator part of a potential $110 million bid to acquire the Grand Lucayan property. Obie Wilchcombe, Minister of Tourism, confirmed the size of the government (taxpayer) investment in accelerating Memories’ reopening during a brief interview with Tribune Business Sunday.
The Government’s revamped mortgage relief program has assisted 350 Bahamian homeowners since it was reintroduced, Prime Minister Christie revealed yesterday. With less than five months until the next general election, Mr. Christie said this facet of the Government’s program reduced the homeowners’ monthly payments by 25 per cent making them now affordable – where they were once unmanageable.
Transport and Aviation Minister Hanna-Martin on Monday refuted assertions that accused the PLP government of being responsible for the country’s loss of millions of dollars in overflight fees, charging that The Tribune is engaging in “fake news” and a “perverse misrepresentation of the facts.”
The University of the Bahamas (UB) is moving to expand its consultancy and research capacity, a top official said yesterday, adding that its Government and Public Policy Institute will be launched in the next few weeks.
Simon Townsend of KPMG (Bahamas) partner urged the Government on Monday to privatize management of its 100 public health clinics, opining that there was “no reason” for the government-owned clinics to be managed and operated as they are currently.
Responding to complaints from Alfred Sears that he was being shut out at convention, PLP Trustee Valentine Grimes yesterday said “no candidate” is allowed to speak at the party’s convention this week.
Prime Minister Christie promised on Monday to introduce more relief for struggling Bahamian homeowners before his administration’s term in office expires, as he touted the revised Mortgage Relief Plan for assisting 350 borrowers to-date. He also revealed that the Government has approved $8 billion in tourism projects that will eventually create 15,000 new jobs in the country. Speaking at the annual Bahamas Business Outlook, Christie outlined several development projects that his administration has entered into that will boost employment numbers in the country. He also pledged that NHI will be a “positive boost” to the Bahamian economy, saying this was supported by a recently-completed study from the Government’s KPMG consultants.
Bahamasair Chairman Valentine Grimes shot down questioning on whether taxpayers were footing the bill for PLP supporters travelling on the airline to attend the ratification of Prime Minister Christie and others last week.
The financial services industry was said to be in the “initial stages” of determining whether The Bahamas’ ‘no tax’ model and “closed Bar” provide the best platform for ensuring its survival.
Baha Mar’s new owner on Monday said it had finalized an agreement for Grand Hyatt to manage 1,800 rooms at two of its hotels, adding that its acquisition of the project was “not a one-shot opportunity”.
FNM MP Edison Key, one of the “rebel” seven Opposition MPs, declared he was “done and finished” with the FNM, while praising the governing PLP as an organization with a strong base that seemed to be doing “good things.” He attended the 52nd PLP convention.
Official Opposition Leader Butler-Turner yesterday confirmed that she will run in Long Island as an independent candidate.
Prime Minister Christie last night dismissed concerns from leadership challenger Alfred Sears, QC, that the deck has been stacked against him at the PLP’s convention, telling The Tribune that the former attorney general has had more time to canvass party delegates that he has.
Kenred Dorsett, Minister of Environment, Tuesday admitted that while the Bahamas may have been “slow out of the gate” on renewable energy, it was not moving aggressively to close the gap.
In an attempt to silence repeated calls for the Government to detail exactly how VAT revenue has been spent since its implementation in 2015, Minister of State for Finance Michael Halkitis provided a breakdown of what he claimed was the Government’s use of the money when he addressed the PLP convention Tuesday night.
Deputy Prime Minister Philip Davis said Tuesday night he is grateful for the trust and confidence the party and its leader, Prime Minister Christie, have reposed in him and he is privileged to serve as deputy leader, contending that in the PLP “we ain’t like the other side.”
Labor Minister Shane Gibson Tuesday defended Prime Minister Christie’s announcement that the Christie administration created 32,000 jobs this term. Amid criticisms that the figures were exaggerated, Gibson said people are quick to question the accuracy of the Department of Statistics whenever it shows improvement made by the Christie administration.
The Government has warned almost three years ago that most Family Island airports could not continue operating as they were, and that “significant attention” was needed to address multiple deficiencies. A report by the consultancy group, Stantec, says it delivered “a strong message” to the Government and key aviation industry stakeholders on April 30, 2014, when it presented its initial technical assessments on some of the 28 airport facilities.
CEO and Executive Director of the Bahamas Financial Services Board (BFSB) Tanya McCartney said that efforts made to implement the common reporting standard in 2018 along with other compliance regimes should lessen the risk of The Bahamas by the European Union.
Prime Minister Christie suggested Wednesday that he is not yet ready to set an election date, telling The Tribune shortly after being re-elected party leader that the pace of voter registration was still too slow.
Former FNM Cabinet Minister Phenton Neymour suggested that he was denied the nomination to run as the party’s candidate for Exuma in the upcoming general election because of FNM Leader Dr. Minnis’ attempts to purge the party of those individuals who served under the previous Ingraham administration.
Foreign Affairs and Immigration Minister Fred Mitchell Wednesday night promised that the PLP would triple the country’s immigration force, expanding it from “300 to 900” in the next term if elected. The Foreign Minister also delivered a scathing speech about Fred Smith, QC, and his organization, including Save The Bays (STB), urging the House of Assembly’s Committee on Privilege to investigate its funding and activities, insisting “this is a matter of this PLP’s survival”.
Minister of Education Jerome Fitzgerald touted the PLP’s record on education over the last four and a half years, boasting that the government doubled the investment in scholarships, overseen the transition of The College of the Bahamas to a revered university and spent more than $6 million to modernize the learning tools in public schools throughout the country.
The Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) has approved a $35m loan designed to improve infrastructure at four airports on the Family Islands. According to a press release from the IDB, the loan will contribute to the archipelago’s regional and international integration through upgrades at the airports of Exuma, North Eleuthera and two in Abaco: Marsh Harbour and Treasure Cay.
The Bahamas was rated as being least corrupt in the Caribbean Community (Caricom), according to the latest figures released by Transparency International on Wednesday.
Court of Appeal President Justice Dame Anita Allen on Thursday boasted a 70 percent completion of more than 1,700 appeals since her appointment to the post in November 2010. Speaking to members of the judiciary and other guests during the annual special sitting of the Court of Appeal, Dame Anita revealed that it would be her last as she confirmed that she is set to retire from the bench in December.
Attorneys for Prime Minister Christie have filed a motion in the Supreme Court asking that Justice Rhonda Bain recuse herself from hearing an ongoing judicial review into allegations that Lyford Cay resident Peter Nygard illegally increased the size of his property.
One of the country’s top judges has commended the executive for creating the reality of the Office of Public Defender, which she had called for as early as four years ago. The Office of the Public Defender was officially opened on January 19 and was part of a $20m Citizen Security and Justice Programme loan facilitated by the IDB.
Trade Union leaders Thursday slammed the Government’s proposal to create a legal impediment to strike polls as “taking the labor movement back to pre-1942”. Obie Ferguson and Bernard Evans were united in their “vehement opposition” to the proposed Industrial Relations Act amendment.
Nurses at several clinics in The Bahamas called in sick Thursday after becoming “fed up” with the Government’s failure to address several longstanding issues, according to Bahamas Nurses Union (BNU) President Amancha Williams.
After receiving a petition signed by over 100 customs officers requesting they be paid money agreed to by the Bahamas Customs and Immigration Allied Workers Union (BCIAWU), Labour Minister Shane Gibson said yesterday that he has recommended that the officers be paid, despite the union’s failure to conclude and sign an industrial agreement.
About the author: Elcott Coleby is a Deputy Director at the Bahamas Information Services. He holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Chemistry (B.Sc) and a Masters of Business Administration (MBA). He provides frequent commentary on public policy and communicates the works of the government. Address all comments to the following email: egcoleby44@gmail.com -
THIS WEEK CONTINUED…
Prime Minister and Deputy among sixteen ratified by their party
It was a festive and jovial atmosphere on Thursday night at party headquarters as the governing Progressive Liberal Party ratified sixteen more candidates for the upcoming general elections.
Expressing confidence at the polls, Mr. Christie urged hundreds of supporters to ramp up voter registration efforts as the path will be clear towards the next general elections once the party emerges from its national convention next week. Also urging Bahamians to ramp up registration efforts were National Security Minister the Hon. Bernard J. Nottage and Labour Minister the Hon. D. Shane Gibson. Following is the list of sixteen ratified:
- Mr. Perry G. Christie: Centerville
- Mr. Philip Davis: Cat Island, Rum Cay and San Salvador
- Dr. Bernard Nottage: Bain and Grants Town
- Mr. Obie Wilchcombe: West Grand Bahama and Bimini
- Mr. Alfred Gray: MICAL
- Ms. Glenys Hanna-Martin: Englerston
- Mr. Shane Gibson: Golden Gates
- Dr. Michael Darville: Pineridge
- Dr. Perry Gomez: North Andros and the Berry Islands
- Mr. Khaalis Rolle: Pinewood
- Mr. Alex Storr: Elizabeth
- Mr. Picewell Forbes: South Andros and Mangrove Cay
- Ms. Reneika Knowles: Killarney
- Rev. Preston Cooper: East Grand Bahama
- Mr. Norris Bain: Marco City
- Mr. Clay Sweeting: North Eleuthera
School brawl renews call for government tracking system
A brawl at the Government High School on Thursday resulted in one student detained in hospital in critical and two more were treated and later discharged. Parents were understandably outraged as they showed up to the school to check on and collect their children.
Assistant Commissioner of Police Stephen Dean told the media that police are still attached to the schools but cannot be everywhere at the same time.
Speaking mostly to Parliamentarians and Cabinet Ministers at the NGC meeting of the PLP on Thursday night, PLP Chairman Bradley Roberts expressed sadness at the level of murder and support for the families of the injured in the school melee. He called on the government to act with haste in establishing the school tracking and remediation component of the Citizen Security and Justice Initiative.
“Councilors, I am deeply saddened over the number of murders so far in 2017 generated mainly by young black men who have lost their way and senses. The event at the Government High School today was tragic and deeply troubling. The news of the incident travel fast and furious. On behalf of the PLP I extend support to the families of the victims as they struggle and travail to make sense of what occurred today.”
Mr. Roberts urged the government “to act with haste in the introduction of a new program for at-risk youth to be located at the former Bahamas Academy Seven Day Adventist School located on Wulff Road. This tracking and remediation system in addition to a comprehensive parole system – all part of the Citizens Security and Justice Program – will allow for better oversight and management of our at-risk youth and the reintroduction of ex-convicts into civil society.”
Office of the Public Defender officially opens
“With the creation of this office, my government’s commitment to executing a multifaceted strategy in the fight against crime and to providing equal access to justice takes a critical step forward.” This according to Prime Minister the Rt. Hon. Perry G. Christie at the official opening of the Office of the Public Defender, located on the corners of Bay and Virginia Streets. The ceremony took place on Thursday, 19th January 2017.
Insisting that with a reported reduction in serious crime since 2004—a 26% decline; the concurrent operation of 10 criminal courts; a doubling of the rates of conviction and an increase in the amount of cases disposed of by the Supreme Court, the country is moving in the right direction in tackling crime.
“Today we stand at an intersection where, uniquely, a decrease in serious crimes, a rise in conviction rates and an increase in how swiftly we dispose of trials are all happening together. We are moving in the right direction.”
Mr. Christie said that his government has taken a “holistic approach to addressing the challenge of crime” and the opening of the Office of the Public Defender is a part of this strategy where the poor can access legal representation, ensuring their constitutional rights under the law.
Attorney General briefs industry on automatic exchange of financial data
The status briefing to industry stakeholders on the implementation of the Automatic Exchange of Financial Account Information Act 2016 took place on Friday at the British Colonial Hilton on Bay Street. Senator Allyson Maynard-Gibson, Attorney-General, told stakeholders that the Bahamas government implemented this law rather quickly.
“I am pleased to advise that that the government of The Bahamas successfully enacted the Automatic Exchange of Financial Account Information Act 2016 (“Act”) to implement the Common Reporting Standard for the automatic exchange of financial account information in December 2016” said Mrs. Maynard-Gibson.
Basically this piece of legislation allows for the implementation of the Common Reporting Standard (“CRS”) approved by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (“OECD”) in 2014 for the automatic exchange of financial information in tax matters (with the home country) of foreign nationals living in the Bahamas.
Many OECD countries have vowed to put an end to what they termed “cross-border tax evasion” by their nationals who hold financial accounts in foreign countries like The Bahamas. This piece of legislation demonstrates the commitment of The Bahamas, one of twenty non-OECD countries, in cooperating with the OECD countries in meeting this 2018 deadline as it strengthens the financial services sector as a highly regulated jurisdiction with probity and transparency as the key watch words.
Minister Strachan announces trade information desk and portal
The government is one step closer to improving the ease of doing business in and from the Bahamas with the establishment of The Bahamas’ Trade Information Service Desk and Electronic Portal. Minister of Financial Services with responsibility for international trade, the Hon. Hope Strachan, provided an update to industry stakeholders on the status of this initiative. The information session was held at Superclub Breezes on Wednesday, 18th January 2017.
These government services are aimed specifically at those Bahamian businesses currently exporting and those interested in exporting to international markets. The service desk and trade portal promises to simplify this process.
“Although the official launch of the Trade Portal is tentatively scheduled for early March 2017, when my Office advised of plans to convene a meeting of current and potential exporters in order to encourage participation in the Portal’s Exporters’ Directory, I thought it an opportune time to offer a few remarks to you and to the business community at large about the importance of this Trade Portal for The Bahamas and what the Government of The Bahamas and the Bahamas Chamber of Commerce & Employers Confederation envisage that the Trade Portal can do to assist local businesses” said the Minister.
The establishment of the Trade Portal is a part of the Government’s ongoing efforts to diversify the Bahamian economy by expanding trade with regional, hemispheric and international trading partners said the Minister.
Bahamas Foreign Affairs Ministry responds to Huffington Post article
The following statement was released by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Friday 20th January 2017.
“The Ministry has seen the article of 19 January 2017 that appeared in the Huffington Post “For immigrants trapped in the Bahamas, a paradise lost” by Kerry Kennedy, President of the Robert F Kennedy Human Rights. The article is replete with errors and exaggerations. The Robert F. Kennedy organization is not a credible source of information. Mr. Kennedy is well known to be associated with a rich individual who is a disgruntled permanent resident, who is funding money to Mr. Kennedy and Save the Bays, a so called environmental organization, who are running a campaign of disinformation and destabilization. The Government puts no reliance therefore on their objectivity or commitment to the truth.”
In Passing
Speaking at the New Providence Women’s Branch of the Progressive Liberal Party on Sunday (15th January), Prime Minister Christie spoke of his energy and enthusiasm to serve another term; the poor state of the economy in May 2012; and the strides the country has made together over the last four and one half years. Speaking on transition, Prime Minister Christie said he will pass the baton when the time is right. As the only united and most stable political organization, he urged party supporters not to “squander” the opportunity to win the general election.
On Monday, Baha Mar began the process of recruiting 1,500 Bahamians in its first wave of hiring for the once stalled $3.5 billion resort according to Robert Sands, the resort’s Senior Vice-President of Government and External Affairs. In an interview, Mr. Sands said the entire process will be conducted online through the company’s website careers.bahamar.com. The amount of applicants numbered more than 4,500 by Tuesday.
BTC presented its Smart City concept to the RBPF this week. The company’s executive management team met with the Commissioner and Senior Officers of the Royal Bahamas Police Force to discuss new trends and how the Force could make use of modern technology.
The Minister of Tourism says the immediate fate of Freeport’s major hotels is still “waiting on Hutchinson Whampoa” to provide confirmed repair and reopening dates.
Freeport News reported that Minister of Tourism, Obediah (Obie) Wilchcombe had high praise for Schumacher Electric Corporation, which donated $1.5 million in power conversion products in the aftermath of Hurricane Matthew.
The Bahamas non-resident Ambassador to the Holy See, Sean McWeeney QC, attended the annual gathering of the diplomatic corps accredited to the Holy See in the Apostolic Palace of the Vatican last week. The high point was the annual “state-of-the-world” address delivered on Monday to the ambassadors by Pope Francis, followed by the traditional exchange of greetings between each of the Ambassadors and the Pope.
Aviation officials on Sunday said they were investigating the circumstances that led to a twin-engine Piper Aztec aircraft skidding off the tarmac shortly after landing at the Lynden Pindling International Airport on Saturday.
Targeting the “racist and misogynistic” statements made by Anglican Archbishop James Palacious last week, noted Bahamian attorney, author and United Nations expert Marion Bethel called for the elevation of women’s voices and institutions to push back against the predominant misogynistic and discriminatory climate in the country.
The Grand Celebration resumed cruise services to Grand Bahama on Saturday (14th January), bringing some 1,300 passengers to Freeport for the first time since the passage of Hurricane Matthew. The ship’s return is good for Grand Bahama because it brings $45m in business every year to the island, according to veteran tourism executive David Johnson.
The Bahamas Fly Fishing Industry Association’s (BFIA) president has again fired back at critics of new industry regulations, labeling the oppositions as “absolute foolishness”.
Resorts World Bimini (RWB) is holding a two-day career fair in Grand Bahama this week in search of potential candidates to fill over 30 positions at the resort and build a talent bank for future employment opportunities.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration last night announced that the government is to introduce a new series of passports at the end of this month. The new passports will have enhanced security features, but will not impact the current holders of e-passports.
Christina “Muffin” Fernander, Chairman of the One Family Junkanoo group – the first woman to lead a major Junkanoo group – was officially recognized as the “Queen of Junkanoo”, a move government officials said effectively “shattered the glass ceiling” for the advancement of women in the traditional cultural expression.
The Water and Sewerage Corporation (WSC) is continuing to undertake a series of water supply improvements on several Family Islands. The Corporation has signed a $1.69m contract with Bahamas Hot Mix to extend and improve water supply to San Salvador after a tender process that started in August.
Chairman of the Consumer Protection Commission (CPC) Senator Jerome Gomez asserted the need for fair competition within the retail banking sector amid consumer complaints over fees charged for certain banking services.
Both The Bahamas Journal and Bahamas Weekly reported that Minister Draville said that Senior Assistant Commissioner of Police Emrick Seymour confirmed that crime is indeed down by 49% since September 2016 in Grand Bahama.
The government signed a $18.4m contract last August with AllScripts and their partner, Infor Lawson, for Integrated Health Information Management Systems (IHIMS) propriety software. The Minister of Health said healthcare modernization had taken a “giant leap forward” through the implementation of an $18.4 million Integrated Health Information Management System (IHIMS). A workshop on this integrated system was held on Tuesday.
Police Commissioner Greenslade on Wednesday called the country’s murder count so far this month a “disgrace”, but stressed that many of the country’s recent killings stem from feuds over drugs and relationship. He urged family members, friends and associates of serial criminals to “turn them into the police before you become targets”.
Staff of the Parliamentary Registration Department who deny people the ability to register to vote because of their dress must be sent home, National Security Minister Dr. Bernard Nottage said in the House of Assembly yesterday. Although Dr. Nottage said he has instructed Parliamentary Commissioner Sherlyn Hall to send staff home who have set baseless criteria limiting people’s ability to register to vote, he said “people are still doing it”.
The Constituencies Commission has stalled the release of its boundaries report in the hope that the sluggish voter registration will pick up considerably over the next few weeks. House Speaker Dr. Kendal Major, who is also the commission’s chair, stated yesterday that he was confident that members will be in a position to table the report “within two weeks or very shortly”.
Repatriations of Cuban nationals skyrocketed last year, according to statistics from the Department of Immigration, which indicated that total repatriations increased by some 80 percent over 2015. Minister of Foreign Affairs and Immigration Fred Mitchell said the department believed that the more than 700 percent rise in repatriations of Cuban nationals in 2016 was driven by anticipation that the United States’ “wet foot/dry foot” policy was coming to an end.
Bahamas Hotel, Catering and Allied Worker Union (BHCAWU) executives Wednesday said they are still seeking a meeting with management at the One & Only Ocean Club to ascertain the status of the 61 persons terminated back in December.
Foreign Affairs and Immigration Minister Fred Mitchell responded in the House on Wednesday to the “hateful” criticism attorney Fred Smith, QC, made about The Bahamas recently. Mitchell was referring to comments Mr. Smith allegedly made during a meeting of the Coral Beach Condominium Association on January 15.
The Bahamas Maritime Authority (BMA) has contributed $82 million to the Public Treasury since its inception, Glenys Hanna Martin said in the House on Wednesday, adding that its income increased by 6.26 percent to just over $17 million in the 2015-2016 fiscal year.
An American woman is suing the Atlantis Paradise Island Resort after she was allegedly bitten by a “colony of bed bugs” living in the mattress of a hotel bed.
Despite a significant decline in hotel room capacity on Grand Bahama, a tourism executive said there is no plan for a pullout by Sunwing Airlines, which is linked with the currently close Memories Resort.
The Bahamas Hotel, Catering and Allied Workers Union (BHCAWU) yesterday said it was “positioning” itself to become the bargaining agent for Baha Mar’s 5,000-plus workforce.
Bahamas Weekly noted that Minister Dorsett spoke on the management of hazardous waste as being of paramount importance to the health of Bahamians, the environment, and to the sustainable development country, as noted in the National Development Plan.
The release of the sealed Supreme Court Baha Mar documents is “most definitely” expected before the opening of the $3.5bn West Bay Street mega resort, Attorney General Maynard-Gibson said yesterday.
Hope Strachan, Minister of Financial Services and Local Government, Thursday conceded that the Government had been forced to “reconsider” plans to double the permanent residency investment threshold to $1 million, due to the “considerable pushback” by realtors and developers.
The Government has decided it is “high time” that The Bahamas implement a policy requiring more citizens to assume top posts within the financial services industry, Hope Strachan said yesterday.
The Road Traffic Department will introduce its new automated vehicle and driver’s licence system on February 6 in Grand Bahama.
Road Traffic officials are in discussions about the introduction of a points system against traffic violators, according to a Road Traffic Controller Ross Smith. He noted that the points system will be linked with police activities.
-
Communication by Fred Mitchell MP Minister of Foreign And Affairs and Immigration
Communication by Fred Mitchell MP
Minister of Foreign And Affairs and Immigration
18 January 2017On Immigration Matters
Check against delivery
Mr. Speaker,I wish to address the House on Immigration matters that are now in the public domain.
I wish to lay on the table the statistics for repatriations, arrests and releases for the years 2015 and 2016.
They are broken down by nationality.
The general categories are in 2015- 4,957 people were arrested; 3379 were repatriated; 571 were released. Important to note that amongst those who were released are many who owed work permit fees.Compare and contrast the figures from 2015 to those of 2016: 7357 people were arrested; 6869 were repatriated; 488 people were released.
The major categories were Cubans and Haitians.
I give these figures for comparison year to year—2015 as compared to 2016: Cubans 1287 in 2016 repatriated compared to 153 in 2015
Haitians 2015 – 3,183 and 2016- 5,241You will see that there is a substantial jump in the figures of Cubans. We believe that this was largely driven by Cubans anticipating the end of the so called wet foot/dry foot policy.
I wish to record the statement released by the government on the announcement by the United States government on the end of that policy which gave Cubans who landed in the United States a fast track to Permanent Residence.
The officials here have said there have not been any interdictions of Cubans since that policy was announced. We continue to watch the situation.
The statement read as follows:
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
12th January 2017
FROM THE MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS & IMMIGRATION
ON US WET FOOT / DRY FOOT POLICY COMING TO AN ENDThe United States government through its Charge in The Bahamas Lisa Johnson communicated to the Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell this afternoon that with immediate effect, the so called “wet foot / dry foot” immigration policy of the United States with regard to Cuban nationals landing in the United States will come to an end.
The United States told the Foreign Minister that the decision comes following the renewal of diplomatic relations between the two countries the United States and Cuba.
The effect of the policy is that Cuban nationals will now be treated like any other foreign nationals landing in the United States illegally. They will be returned following the appropriate screening to determine whether they qualify for refugee status.
The Bahamas Government welcomes this decision, particularly as it is believed that this policy was believed to be driving the rise in Cuban landings in The Bahamas.
The Government is mindful however that the decision is taken just as the Political Administration in the United States is about to change. The Government waits to see whether the policy will continue beyond the current administration before the Government can determine what the policy’s full effects are.
End
I wish also to address various records that have circulating by e mail and social media about the actions of the immigration Department in Grand Bahama.
In a meeting of the Coral Beach condominium association, Fred Smith Q. C said the following inter alia:
“It is inappropriate the government to get involved in the private financial or private disputes in a condominium association like this. Why is Fred Mitchell the Minister of Bahamas Immigration getting involved in a dispute that exists between condominium owners? Why is he picking on Bruno Rufa or Sandra or Nancy or others? Make no mistake when the new board decides to enforce a lien against some Bahamian who refuses to pay the maintenance you will be will the next one that the immigration is going to try and deport. And that’s why I understand…you see they are winning. Those who are seeking to undermine the effectiveness that the board of directors has been able to achieve over these years are now winning. Because they now think and they do because they got a new board and the new board may be a little naïve and this is not a criticism a little naïve or a little innocent and just doesn’t know the way of these people. It is a very difficult environment to live in. Most of you… you’re all white for the most part… and it’s a big problem for the Black Bahamians that you’re down here. Believe it or not they want your money, they want you to spend it but they don’t like you alright. A lot of them don’t. The fact is The Bahamas is a very racist a very xenophobic, a nationally insecure and a very hateful place to foreigners. So you can’t just bury your head in the sand.The record states that there were 65 people at that meeting. Most of them were non-nationals it appears.
As this matter is now circulating in the public domain this must be addressed.
First, Mr. Smith is incorrect and disingenuous when he says that Fred Mitchell, this Minister, is picking on anyone. That is a falsehood.
The record shows that Bruno Rufa about whom he speaks, a Canadian citizen, is now before the criminal courts of The Bahamas on a charge of working in The Bahamas without a work permit. That is an offence in law.Prior to my becoming a Minister, Mr. Rufa was removed from the Bahamas under procedures that appear to have been accepted then but were challenged when those procedures were used by the Department to do so when I became minister. There are several complaints on file about his conduct.
Secondly, for the purposes of the condominium association owners and all foreign nationals, residents and permanent resident, The Bahamas government makes decisions on permanent residence on a quasi-judicial basis. There is the rule of law in The Bahamas and no one’s rights are infringed upon. When someone violates the laws and procedures of The Bahamas, then the Department of Immigration acts. Such an individual against whom a decision is made has a right in law to review their case and the Government acts according to law.
The Bahamas government is not involved in any dispute with the Coral Beach Condominium Association.
A complete record will show that this is the case of Bruno Rufa. Mr. Rufa has availed himself of the Courts of The Bahamas. And the records show that Mr. Smith has been paid handsomely for his work, with the minutes of the meeting’s record showing that some 270,000 dollars in fees have been collected by him and his firm for work for the association; some 1 million dollars in outstanding fees are unbilled.This is the point that I have made as Minister for Immigration: it is obvious that this is a valuable country that we have, when people are willing to spend that kind of money to stay here, even in the face of alleged infringements of the law.
There are several cases which are still before the courts involving the subject person.
We have followed the law at all times.
But it is the last more general remark of which the international audience must be disabused. Mr. Smith, Q C, who is himself a naturalized citizen of The Bahamas, and was given shelter in this country, has indicated the following and I quote:“The fact is The Bahamas is a very racist, a very xenophobic, a nationally insecure and a very hateful place to foreigners.”
This is absolutely untrue. This is a statement that comes from someone who presents himself as a human rights activist. He makes his living and a livelihood in The Bahamas. This is the equivalent of a fisherman calling his own fish stink.
Given the wide circulation of the documents, no immigration minister can allow this comment to stand unchallenged, particularly as it was delivered in the face of 65 foreign people who live in The Bahamas and are valued investors here. It is hateful. It is deceitful. This is ungrateful. It is dishonest. It is unpatriotic,
All fun and jokes aside Mr. Speaker, as a public policy maker, as a Member of Parliament, as a Minister of the government. I am sworn to defend The Bahamas and its constitution and its people without fear or favour. I do not appreciate in the least this attempt to smear me and to smear the government and the wider Bahamian people, no matter how it is dressed up.
We are a blessed people, a stable democracy. Our first obligation is to The Bahamas.
I have had occasion before to point out what Section 18 of the Immigration Act empowers the Minister to do when someone who is in The Bahamas acts incompatibly with the status that has been bestowed upon them.
I have exercised that right once already and will not hesitate to do so again where the law allows and circumstances warrant.
Mr. Smith should be given an opportunity to resile from this vile and hateful, derogatory and defamatory language.
If not, then the professional body of which he is a part ought to examine carefully the record of his statements with regard to this matter and see whether this is appropriate conduct for one such as this.
I thank you Mr. Speaker.
End