Last week every damn fool who supports the idea of a cashless society should be doing penance this week, Because of some glitch in the systems of Microsoft, the whole platform of interconnections for business especially in the flying business collapsed. Flights in the thousands were cancelled worldwide and some banks could not operate their accounts. So much for digital transformation. We keep saying that while digital is fine when it works, sometimes it doesn’t work and in such times cash should be king. So while those who want to be digital can be digital, those who want to use cash should be able to do so and to write cheques. John Rolle who is leading the fool’s errand at the Central Bank of The Bahamas could only stand by helplessly last week to say that the Central Bank was watching the chaos. Fat lot of good that did.
Fred Mitchell, Chairman of the PLP has been on a relentless campaign to halt the nonsense supported by the Central Bank of The Bahamas and others that we must move to a cashless society. He has argued that almost certainly this is unlawful in The Bahamas. But yet businesses and especially government agencies are marching to the gangplank. The British Government issued a statement last month about the importance of a law that demands that there be access to cash. There was also a report that in Belize the Central Bank is taking aggressive steps on the fees that banks charge their customers. There is a similar story in Barbados. In Nassau though, CIBC announced that they are changing their hours of operation on Fridays. Normally the bank closes at 4:30 p.m. CIBC or First Caribbean as they are called in The Bahamas has decided they will close at 3 p.m. now instead. This is another example of the lousy banking nature in The Bahamas and the tone-deafness of the Central Bank.
Fred Mitchell, Chairman of the PLP, returned to the theme of the cashless society. This report appeared in The Tribune. You can watch the original on You Tube:
18 August 2023
By JADE RUSSELL
Tribune Staff Reporter
jrussell@tribunemedia.net
FOREIGN Affairs Minister Fred Mitchell said Friday he does not agree with the country being a “cashless society.”
“I get floods of emails and voice notes every day about the banking sector that demand that we become a cashless society,” Mr Mitchell said in a voice note.
“This is done despite the Prime Minister and other ministers, including this one, who’ve said over again and made a claim we do not agree with a cashless society. Nor forcing people to use the Customs App, nor consigning our folk in the Family Islands to the Sand Dollar.”
A cashless society is one where physical money such as cash and coins are not accepted for financial transactions, but rather all transactions are digital.
Mr Mitchell said there is a “relentless march” by businesses to have a cashless society.
“Everywhere you go, including government-owned entities, there is this relentless march to a cashless society. Even though given the Central Bank Act it is almost certainly unlawful since Bahamian currency is supposed to be good for all lawful debts. The public is again entitled to ask the question if the tail is wagging the dog,” he said.
Meanwhile, Mr Mitchell said there are other issues to address before considering whether the country should be a cashless society.
“Take the issue of the telephone and data services in the country they are manifestly unreliable. This in the same society that folks want us to go cashless. The folk in Mangrove Cay complained that their BTC service has been down for three weeks, complained to BTC, complained to URCA, the MP complained, nothing happened.”
For the past few weeks, we have described in pretty harsh terms the issue of the Central Bank trying to force this country to become a cashless society. There seemed to be a temporary respite when the bank seemed to climb down from the fool’s errand of abolishing cheques. But from remarks attributed to the Central Bank Governor, it appears there was simply a pause in the onward movement. The Central Bank has failed in its mission to protect the poor of The Bahamas. They have left islands in the country with no banks. They abolished the penny which was inflationary. Andrew Allen, the attorney, tells the story of his going to the parking lot of the Lynden Pindling Airport and being forced to buy a 20-dollar card in order to get out of the parking lot. He said he refused and told them to take cash or stuff it. His argument is and we agree that no licensed business in this country can refuse to take cash. The Bahamian dollars are legal tender for all debts in the country. We must continue to fight to ensure that in a country where the internet doesn’t work, where the electricity supply is unreliable, and where increasingly there are concerns about privacy, the country must not go cashless.
The Central Bank has climbed down on its desire to stop people from using cheques. This is according to a report in the Business Section of The Tribune which says that he announced public consultations on the issue has been ceased. The Central Bank Governor John Rolle is unrepentant on the subject saying in a subsequent public statement that the decline in the use of cheques by 7 per cent is evidence that the public is becoming less reliant on cheques. The PLP opposed the abolition of the penny. It was unnecessary and inflationary. Then the Bank has failed to stop the inflationary rise in service offered by the clearing house banks including charging people for getting their own money out of the bank and putting money in the bank. Then the bit about cheques. The fact is right now you can scan a cheque into an ATM machine and it records what is written, puts it on your account. So why do you need to abolish it? What is the mischief you are trying to cure. It’s a fool’s errand.