Tag: 2017

  • ANDREW ALLEN WRITES: OUR 2017 VOTE CAUSED THIS MESS

    ANDREW ALLEN WRITES: OUR 2017 VOTE CAUSED THIS MESS

    This letter first appeared in The Nassau Guardian

    Dear Editor,

    Anyone who can’t see that it was the Bahamian people, rather than the PLP, who were the big losers of the 2017 election must either be a member of Minnis’ Cabinet or an enthusiast of its most ambitious project to date: legalized weed.

    Four years of gimmicks and distractions from the big issues facing this country (which I have long said is the primary function of the FNM from the standpoint of its vested financiers) have left the population broke and the public domain defunded at the worst possible time.

    The COVID-19 crisis came on the heels of the ejection from office of an administration that was for the first time in our history directing the wealth of this country into an advanced and transformative universal healthcare system. It was opposed by wealthy lobbies who benefit from our current parasitic insurance/healthcare industry and their polished puppets in the FNM.

    Today, after the Public Hospitals Authority’s “cost-cutting” (FNM-ese for transferring the costs to the poor, via fees), the cessation of the National Health Insurance program to upgrade clinics and facilities nationwide and the degrading treatment of medical professionals, the wealthy Bahamas finds itself at the bottom of the regional league in an emergency pandemic, “borrowing” vaccine doses from tiny, poor Antigua.

    Meanwhile, we just paid $66 million on a shuttered hotel and borrowed billions more with nothing to show for it.

    Don’t be stupid again, Bahamas.

    — Andrew Allen 

  • Senator Darville Contribution to the 2017 – 2018 Budget

    Senator, The Honourable Dr. Michael R. Darville

    Contribution to the 2017 – 2018 Budget

                      Honourable Senate of the Commonwealth of the Bahama

                   Friday, 23rd June, 2017

     

    Thank you, Madam President, and once again congratulations to you, and all Honourable Senators around the table.

    Madam President, today I rise to make my contribution to the 2017 – 2018 Budget debate.

    Madam President, after experiencing a major defeat at the polls a few weeks ago, and having an opportunity to reflect on our successes and mistakes, I remain resolute that Progressive Liberal Party is still the only political organization that can effectively navigate our country though the turbulent waters that lie ahead; and I remain confident that time will prove this statement to be true.

    Madam President, upon coming to office in 2012, we met an economy riddled with debt.

    Yes, Madam President, the previous FNM administration left behind close to a billion dollar in debt, which forced the PLP to put many of our capital works projects on hold during our first year in office. As minister, I felt the frustration of knowing very well that without real financial resources to drive our capital works projects, the construction industry would remain stagnant and the economic stimulus that was so desperately needed for Grand Bahama would have to be put on hold.

    Madam President, the Minister of Finance and the people of this country must be reminded that in 2012, the FNM indeed left our economy in a wheel chair. But unlike this administration, we executed fiscal discipline as a cabinet, and opted to stay away from excessive borrowing.

    Furthermore, Madam President, despite the political risks associated with the implementation of VAT, we made the tough decision, and took the necessary steps to do so. After three (3) years in office, and much consultation and technical support, The Ministry of Finance launched one of the well-structured Value Added Tax systems in the region, along with other transformative tax reform measures. To ease the burden on our people, duty on many imported goods, including food items, was reduced simultaneously across the board in some instances up to 15 percent.

    Madam President, unfortunately, VAT was used as a tool for the FNM during the campaign, as they accused the PLP of stealing the funds derived from the VAT, and promised that they would repeal VAT on bread basket items, utilities, education and medical services. Resultantly, the people gobbled up these lies and promises and voted against the PLP.

    Madam President, through you, I would like to remind the general public that the Free National Movement voted in favour of the implementation of Value Added Tax, and they understood its importance in rebuilding the country’s economy.  Now that the campaign is over, the back peddling on their promises to the people has begun, as confirmed in the budget.

    But, Madam President, what I find most troubling is after opting not to repeal VAT from bread basket items, this administration saw it fit to reduce business license fees, not for SME’s; but for businesses that make more than fifty million dollars a year, reduce duty on washing machines and aircraft parts, salmon, caviar, and other items, which would assist special interest groups and not the poor.

    Madam President, it doesn’t matter how you try to sugar coat it even a blind man can see the play … it’s payback time!

    Madam President, during our term in office, we made many of the tough, unpopular decisions, and laid a solid foundation for the new government to build upon.

    I am therefore grateful to the Leader of the Opposition, the Honourable Philip Brave Davis, and party officials, for affording me this wonderful opportunity to serve once again in this upper chamber.  This is serious business, Madam President, and I assure Progressive Liberal Party supporters throughout the country that I remain committed to the cause, and I would carry out my duties as an opposition Senator to the best of my ability.

    Madam President, my mother always told me that those who fail to prepare, prepare to fail.  Additionally, the late Dr. Myles Monroe, in one of his lecture series on Grand Bahama stated, “Be prepared so when opportunity knock at your door, you will be well positioned to succeed.”  Both of these statements have proven true throughout my professional and public life. For the past few weeks, however, these statements have taken on new life, as I watched with great concern; this unprepared administration prove to the Bahamian people, and the world, that they are truly not ready to govern.

    In fact, Madam President, during the budget debate, many ministers seemed unfamiliar with their constitutional and collective responsibilities, and failed miserably, in their contributions to demonstrate to the Bahamian people, their plans to move, their ministries and our country forward. I was pleased, nonetheless to learn that the FNM will build upon the majority of the plans and programs put in place by our administration.

    Madam President, as an opposition Senator and shadow Minister of Grand Bahama Affairs, Education, Health and NHI, I assure you that I fully understand my constitutional responsibilities, and I will continue to defend the Progressive Liberal Party’s accomplishments, inside and outside of this honourable place. I also intend to support meaningful legislation, programs and plans brought forth by the current FNM administration, which would bring relief to the poor and ultimately improve the quality of life of all Bahamians irrespective of ethnicity, socioeconomic status or political affiliation.

    On the other hand, Madam President, I will vigorously oppose policies and legislation that I believe will favour only special interest groups, and are not in the best interest of the Bahamian people, and specifically, the people of Grand Bahama, as I have done for the past decade.

    Madam President, I will conduct myself in an honourable fashion, but I must warn you that I have strong convictions, and I intend to voice the concerns of Bahamians, particularly as it relates to the violation of their constitutional rights, and political victimization.

    Madam President, the 2017 – 2018 budget, which was presented by the Honourable Member for East Grand Bahama.  Let me say from the onset that I was extremely disappointed that the Members in the lower house used this budget debate, as well as their parliamentary privilege to vilify former cabinet ministers and the PLP, and continue the FNM’s political campaign in the honourable house of assembly.

    Madam President, the budget communication was a golden opportunity for this inexperienced administration to rise above all the propaganda, accusations, and lies that they levied on the PLP during the campaign leading to the 2017 general elections, and take the high road. But instead of giving an accurate account of the financial affairs of the country, the budget communication was skewed, heavily political, and indicated little about the FNM’s plan for good fiscal stewardship.

    In fact, Madam President, the majority of their contributions were about alleged PLP corruption, and who got what for government contracts. I believe the Bahamian people are saturated with all this political posturing and are ready for this government to plans in place that would bring relief to the poor create jobs.

    Madam President, in an interview on the evening news last night, the Attorney General admitted that no formal complaint has been filed by any government official, or citizen, that would substantiate the claims made in the lower house.

    It is my sincere belief, Madame President, that if the Free National Movement can proven acts of criminality by any former minister or public servant, they should forward the information to the police and allow the authorities to take legal action or make the allegations outside of these honourable chambers.

    Madam President, the cabinet, supervised by the our Prime Minister who apparently says he cares about the people, somehow forgot about the tax cuts for the poor, which he promised on the campaign trail; because this budget proved to have nothing to do with “the people” whose time they said had come, but more to do with payback time for “their” people. This budget includes tax breaks for big business, and reductions in duties which would increase the bottom line of many who sit in cabinet; with a few crumbs falling from the cabinet table for “the people.”  As Catherine Kelly, concluded in her column a few weeks ago, Dollars and Sense, “The FNM should be fired for the budget they are proposing to the people.”

    Madam President, the budget communication sets the wrong precedence in the financial community; and if not corrected will come back to bite us all. It’s potentially damaging, and could impact local and international investment opportunities throughout the country, but more specifically on the island of Grand Bahama. As far as I am concerned, Madam President, this budget sends the wrong message to the business community and the rating agencies, who by the way, will be back at our door steps in a matter of months.

    Madam President, at one point during his contribution, The Minister of Finance seemed unfamiliar with certain aspects of his own budget! This is evidence of preparing to fail and shows how out of touch the Free National Movement was, and still is, concerning the micro and macroeconomic indicators in the country, and their effect on the Bahamian economy. In hopes that the Bahamian people would give them a free pass to borrow close to a billion dollars within their first hundred (100) days in office, The member for East Grand Bahama presented a budget that unfairly blamed the PLP, and because of his political agenda, intentionally painted an overly grim picture of our economy.

    Madam President, my question to this administration is what is the real reason behind borrowing a whopping seven hundred and twenty-two million dollars ($722,000,000.00) during your first year in office?

    Madam President, this voodoo style economics of trying to borrow their way out of debt appears to be the first part of the FNM’s plan to turn the Bahamian economy around.

    What is ironic Madam President, is that this same scenario was predicted by many local prophets during the election campaign, who clearly articulated that should the Free National Movement win the general election, the first thing they would do is increase borrowing. It appears now that these prophecies have come to pass.

    Madam President, in contrast to our administration, who borrowed just over two billion ($2,000,000,000.00) dollars in our entire five (5) years in office, this inexperienced FNM administration could not resist the temptation, and with the passing of this budget, would have committed the Bahamian people to close to one billion dollars ($1,000,000,000.00) of debt in their first hundred (100) days in office. This is record breaking, and if continued throughout their term of office, could have serious implications to our local economy.

    Madam President, when we move all of the drama around about alleged corruption with no proof form the budget debate and sum it all up, a blind man can see straight through the FNM’s game plan; which is to borrow excessively in their first year in office, use this borrowed capital to create a false perception that the economy is rebounding; then ride on the projected economic growth trajectory, while blaming the PLP for everything negative in the economy, all the way to 2022.

    Madam President, the IMF projected that the Bahamian economy will expand by 1.4% this year followed by 2.2% in 2018. These projections proved that despite the challenges we faced with revenue collection and the economic impact of Hurricanes Joaquin and Mathew had on the country’s economy, we were able to do all the heavy lifting, and modernize the country’s tax structure. We were on the right track, and moving in the right direction; under the direction of the Former Minister, and Minister of State for Finance.

    You know what is so sad, though, Madam President, the member for East Grand Bahama missed a great moment in history to demonstrate political maturity. However, at no point in his contribution did he give any credit to our team for the transformational work done on the country’s new tax structure, and our ingenuity in holding the fragile economy together, despite the devastating effects of two (2) Category 4 hurricanes in five (5) years.

    But God don’t like ugly, Madam President; and after all the PLP bashing and accusations of corruption without any factual proof, He allowed the truth about the devastating effects that Hurricanes Joaquin and Mathew had on our local economy, and the 2017 projected deficit to finally be revealed. The issue with the projected deficit was clearly outlined by the Former Minister of Finance, during his last midterm budget communication, but if my memory serves me right, both the present Prime Minister, and his Deputy were absent from the house that day.

    Therefore, Madam President, the fact that the 2016 – 2017 projected deficit would increase was no new revelation; and the evidence supported that this increase has nothing to do with the mismanagement of public finances.  In fact, Madam President no administration could budget for major hurricanes, their effects on government infrastructure, and the social ramifications associated with the devastation.

     

    I now turn my attention to the economy of Grand Bahama.

    Madam President, Grand Bahama is the sleeping giant in the north, and is filled with great potential. I remain optimistic about its future, its economic recovery and wish the Minister of State, and the government well, as they tackle the complex issues surrounding the island’s recovery. But I must warn the Minister of State that the outdated economic template currently in place in Freeport must change in order to bring about sustainable development. In fact, research, prior to the 2012 general election by the Progressive Liberal Party, confirmed that the success of Grand Bahama required bold and aggressive policy changes; centred around a shift in the management of the free trade zone, and the increase in the presence of a well-funded central governmental leadership team who must operate side by side stakeholders, guided by international business best practices in order to prevent the boom and bust syndrome.

    Madam President, our plan for Grand Bahama was simple in principle, but challenging to implement on the ground because of all the stakeholders involved. We knew that the plan would require a lot of transformative work and strong government leadership. So, upon coming to office we established the Ministry for Grand Bahama in our first 100 days of governance.

    Madame President, we hired both local and foreign consultants with global experience, advised us on policy changes necessary to receive maximum economic benefits from our strategic location, and free trade zones.  As Minister, one of my main mandates was to drive these transformative policies around the cabinet table, thus creating both a short and long-term strategy that would promote the resurgence of the Grand Bahama economy.

    Madame President, because of the unique legal structure of Freeport, these necessary changes required buy in from the Grand Bahama Port Authority, port licensees, the Grand Bahama Chamber of Commerce and other major stakeholders on the island. As a result of our research, we clearly understood that the recovery of Grand Bahama would take more than five years, but focused on the advancement of the industrial and tourism sectors, in order to create jobs.

    Madam President, after listening to the budget communication, and the contributions from the five Members of Parliament from Grand Bahama including the Minister of Finance, I am still waiting to hear about any meaningful government plan for the island of Grand Bahama. All I am heard from the Free National Movement camp is the sudden revelation that the economic recovery of Grand Bahama is “no quick fix” and “will take time and collaborative effort.”

    Additionally, Madam President, I was hoping that the Minister of Finance, in his substantive contribution, would have been eager to share something about the FNM’s strategic plan for Grand Bahama. On the contrary, it seems that the new template alluded to in the speech from the throne does not exist; and a workable one must be developed.

    Well, Madam President, that’s not good enough because during the political campaign, the FNM told the residents of Grand Bahama that they would bring immediate change to the island, jump start our economy, and get people in the tourism sector back to work.

    My question is, Madam President, will the FNM fail Grand Bahama again?

    Madam President, the FNM also pledged to repeal the Grand Bahama Investment Incentive Bill, which they said would level the playing field for business owners in Freeport.

    Madam President, I strongly suggest that this administration moves with caution to review the evidence research, look carefully at the MOU and Heads of Agreement signed by the major stakeholders, before potentially pushing the economy of Grand Bahama back another ten (10) years.  Although I concede that the bill is not a perfect one; all bills brought to this honourable place are subjected to amendments along the way. Many of the issues the Chamber and the Grand Bahama Port Authority had with the bill were brought to our attention, and we were addressing them via some amendments, and with the regulations.  However, Madam President, I believe that to repeal the bill will go contrary to the evidence based research, and possibly derail almost three (3) years of hard work by the government. A few days ago,  during a press conference in Freeport, the Prime Minister spoke about the government plans for extending the requirements necessary under the Grand Bahama investment bill for another six months,  which I fully support. Going forward, Madam President, I would be willing to give my input as the former Minister for Grand Bahama, a licensee of the Grand Bahama Port Authority, and a citizen in the community who is deeply concerned about moving the economy of Grand Bahama.

    Yes, Madam President, the Grand Bahama Port Authority would have issues with any changes to their current mode of operations. But this is the 21st century, and they must come to grips with the reality that some aspects of Hawksbill Creek Agreement are proving to be counter-productive to national development, and as a sovereign nation we must address then for the common good of all Bahamians.

    Madam President, the FNM touts that their focus for Grand Bahama is investments. This was on top of our agenda as well. In fact, Madam President, our administration, along with the McKenzie Group, did a lot of work on the modelling of the new Grand Bahama Investment Promotion Board, and the one stop shop, as recommended by stakeholders.

    Nevertheless, Madam President, to accomplish this requires funding, policy changes and reform. So, the big question to the side opposite is, other than a two hundred thousand dollar ($200,000.00) increase for investment promotion on Grand Bahama, where is the funding to support the establishment and maintenance of the operations of the much-needed investment promotion board for Grand Bahama, and the one stop shop, which was mentioned in the speech from the throne??

    Madame President, it will take significant budgetary allocations to successfully improve the ease of doing business in the country, and by extension the island of Grand Bahama. In fact, Jamaica was able to accomplish this important milestone with the help of a substantial IDB loan.

    Madam President, the Grand Bahama Investment Promotion Board, and the one stop shop must be a priority for the government, because once properly implemented and competently staffed, they can play a significant role in the resurgence of the Grand Bahama economy.

    Madam President, with so very little funding allotted in the budget for this very important mandate, I ask this FNM administration once more, are you planning to fail Grand Bahama again?

    Madam President, Grand Bahama is in need of an immediate economic injection. We left a plan in place for grant funding for small businesses impacted by Hurricane Mathew, and a low interest loan facility for existing SME’s. Sadly, this much-needed economic injection is not evident from the allocations in the budget for the Ministry for Grand Bahama, Office of the Prime Minister or the Ministry of Finance.

    On the other hand, Madam President, I am pleased that one million dollars ($1,000,000.00) is allocated in the budget, under Head 74, line item 791270, under SME’s, for what is apparently the reactivation of the FNM’s Jump Start Program.

    Madame President, while I agree that this can certainly help small businesses in East and West Grand Bahama; I find it hard to ignore that during the former FNM administration, this same program was poorly managed.

    Madam President, a review of the former Jump Start Program would verify that it turned out to be a political slush fund; and as a result, many of the so-called businesses never existed, or failed, leaving only a hand full of functioning businesses after wasting millions of dollars of tax payers’ money.

    So, Madame President, the Honourable Minister of State will certainly have his hands full managing this line item. I wish to inform him, through you, that we will be following this very closely during your entire term in office. Remember it’s the people’s time, and accountability and transparency must be the order of the day.

     

    Madam President, in the speech from the throne, the challenges Grand Bahama faced over the last fifteen to twenty (15 – 20) years were recognized. But if the truth be told, the local economy was on a downward spiral for a much longer time. Yes, natural disasters contributed to the economic downturn of Grand Bahama’ but poor planning, government neglect and yes, the dinosaur on the ground, the Hawksbill Creek Agreement, all contributed to where we are today.

     

    Madam President, historic examination of Freeport and the workings of the Hawksbill Creek Agreement confirmed that the government’s policies of duty free concessions were, and still are the engine behind Freeport’s success over the years. But a study done in December 2015, by Oxford Economics proved that even though concessions are truly the catalyst for economic growth and development, they should no longer be blanketed. Rather, they should be properly incentivised with a penalty clause in place for protection against land speculation or rogue investors. Otherwise, these concessions could become counterproductive and instead of facilitating, could hinder growth and development in the free trade zone. This principle was incorporated into the drafting of the Grand Bahama Investment Incentive Bill, 2016 and that is why we must move with caution before repealing it.

     

    Madam President, the stark difference between East and West Grand Bahama, and the city of Freeport, substantiates our hypothesis that concessions stimulate economic growth.

    As a result, Madam President, in June 2014, by way on an amendment to the Tariff Act, our administration honoured our promise, outlined in our Charter of Governance to extend duty free concession for new and existing businesses in East and West Grand Bahama; thus levelling the playing field, after sixty (60) years, for all business owners on the island of Grand Bahama. The entrepreneurial and employment opportunities created as a result are notable.

     

    Madam President, the aging government infrastructure throughout Grand Bahama was also a top priority on our administration’s transformative agenda, and shortly after being named Minister, I spoke specifically about the five major government funded capital works projects air marked for Grand Bahama.

    Firstly, The Fishing Hole Road, which has been a vexing problem for the people of West Grand Bahama for decades, as during adverse weather conditions, many are cut off from essential service, due to flooding. According to the Minister of Works, this project is now on hold because of budget restraints. I implore the government to complete this project hastily, as the hurricane season is upon us.

    Secondly, the Freeport Fire Station, an essential facility which was destroyed in 2004.

    Thirdly, The Smith’s Point Sea Wall, to address coastal erosion in that residential and touristic area. However, on Thursday, June 8th, 2017, it was reported that Smith’s Construction, a reputable company, who was awarded the contract to construct the sea wall in the coastal settlement of Smith’s Point, Grand Bahama, was ordered off the construction site by representatives from the Ministry of Works and assisted by the Royal Bahamas Police Force. This incident was extremely unfortunate; and I am advised that the contractor is pursuing legal action concerning this matter, which I support 100% percent.

    Madam President, we are asking the government to move swiftly to resolve this pressing situation, to protect the people of Smith’s Point, and prevent further coastal erosion in that community, especially since the hurricane season is once again upon us.

     

    Additionally, the junior high school in West Grand Bahama. And finally, the Freeport Community Clinic, which is the first phase of the hospital for Grand Bahama.

    Madam President, much has been said to try to discredit the Urban Renewal program on Grand Bahama. The member for East Grand Bahama spoke about victimization of Urban Renewal Workers on Grand Bahama by the PLP in 2012, but the truth of the matter is all who were willing, completed their contracts; a number of them reapplied, and some, including the wife of the former Member of Parliament for Eight Mile Rock, were rehired based on their past performance.

    Speaking about victimization, Madam President, all government vehicles were taken from centre managers, and parked at the police headquarters in Freeport. Without transportation and support, all the centres are practically non-functional, and it is my understanding that many of the staff are merely waiting for ‘judgment day.’ This is typical of the FNM administration’s agenda of stop, review and cancel.

    Madam President, many of the social initiatives in the communities, which were geared toward the youth, seniors and shut-ins in the communities were led by Urban Renewal centre managers and staff. Without transportation, continuing this essential outreach in the community is extremely difficult.

    Additionally, Madame President, as part of the relief program in the aftermath of hurricane Mathew, Urban Renewal also played an intricate role in social assessment, clean-up, and rebuilding efforts; and worked closely with the restoration technical team, and KPMG, the accounting firm that was hired by the government to oversee the hurricane relief efforts on Grand Bahama. It is my understanding, and the Minister of State could correct me if I am wrong, that this initiative is almost at a standstill, and as a result, many residents, who are in need of roof repairs or building supplies, are experiencing great difficulty, as Grand Bahama has had rainy weather over the past few weeks.  As an administration, we did our part, and I implore the new administration to stop procrastinating, pick the baton and continue the race. After all, it is “the people’s time!”

    Madam President, Urban Renewal’s small home repair program impacted many lives, particularly those of the elderly. the indigent and unemployed; and because of the need in the family islands, Urban Renewal Grand Bahama eventually extended its operational responsibilities to Eleuthera, Bimini, Cat island, South Andros, Exuma and Abaco to meet those needs.

    Madam President, if the new government wishes to dismantle or water down the people’s Urban Renewal Program, they should just go ahead and do so; but in doing so, they should refrain from demoralising the staff, and immediately create an alternative for those Bahamians who were beneficiaries of all the programs.  After all, it’s the people’s time!

    Madam President, I now turn my attention to Education

    Madam President, during his budget contribution, the Minister of Education, indicated that he would adopt and improve upon the majority of policies implemented by the former Minister of Education the Honourable Jerome Fitzgerald who left behind the substantial blueprint for education in The Bahamas; which includes the introduction of The National High School Diploma, the doubling of investment in scholarships, and the chartering of The University of The Bahamas.

     

    Madam President, I recognize Minister Lloyd’s enthusiasm for education, and his passion for the implementation of a preschool pilot program. Research has proven that a sound preschool education is critical to the development of a child; and for this reason, all countries serious about education, must put both financial and manpower resources behind developing programs that will address this level of instruction. I therefore support the government’s commitment to inject some two million dollars ($2,000,000.00) into this pilot program. It’s unfortunate, however, that the proposed program will be Nassau centric, and as a result, children in Grand Bahama and the family islands will be left behind. I am imploring the government to expand the pilot program to incorporate the rest of the country, especially Grand Bahama.

     

    Madam President, the previous administration recognized the importance of technology in the classroom; and subsequently, spent a little over six million dollars ($6,000,000.00) to upgrade computer labs in schools throughout the country; the single largest investment in technology by any government in the history of The Bahamas. During my tenure as Member of Parliament for Pineridge, I purchased computers for the Hugh Campbell Primary School from my constituency allowance, which facilitated a digital program that was launched by the Ministry of Education, to assist students with reading problems. The private sector also assisted with donations of equipment, including smart boards for primary schools in East and West Grand Bahama, which assisted in deferring the cost for technological upgrades in many of our primary schools. The creation of these interactive 21st century classrooms has enhanced the education experience; the results of which are evident in the improvement in GLAT scores. For this reason, I fully support the use of Bahamian experts to develop new technology inclusive curricula, particularly in Bahamian history, art and culture; and we are looking forward for the complete implementation of the technological programs mentioned in the budget, which would create a digital platform for early childhood education.

    Madam President, The Minister also referenced the employment of hundreds of personnel at The Ministry of Education, and the Department of Education on a contractual basis; some within the past year. I wish to admonish the Minister that persons were hired to address the gaps that were found in the system, including the need for support staff and teacher’s aids; and plead with him and the present administration not to terminate those hard working Bahamians, because of their perceived political affiliation.

     

    Madam President, the Minister also referenced the scholarship loan program, and the government’s intent to go after those who defaulted on payments.

    Madam President, this issue is a complicated one, which started with the FNM.  It is my understanding that the former Minister of Education Alfred Sears brought some order to the problem, but it remains unresolved. I suggest the Minister of Education move with caution, and seek further legal advice before executing his plan.

    Madam President, thanks to evidence based planning and the implementation of a number of policies to address learners of varying abilities by former Minister of Education, the educational system, although not perfect, seems to be on the right track. I wish the Education Minister well; but like all other ministers, I intend to hold his feet to the fire, and ensure that what was promised to the Bahamian people in Free National Movement’s 2017 Manifesto, is delivered.

     

    Madam President, I now turn my attention to The Ministry of Health and NHI 

    Madam President, the journey to the launch of NHI began more than thirty (30) years ago with the Progressive Liberal Party. Plans for the implementation of this essential service were articulated in the speech from the throne in 1983; and in 1984, the first working team on NHI was established who later reported their findings to the then government in 1987. This was followed by the Manitoba Report, and in 2001 a feasibility report on a catastrophic health insurance fund was presented. In 2002, the Blue-Ribbon commission on NHI was established, and the report was submitted to the government in 2004, which resulted in the NHI steering committee presenting its final report. In 2006, the NHI Act was passed in parliament. Unfortunately we lost the 2007 election, and the Free National Movement, despite voting for the bill; opted to implement the National Drug Prescription plan, and spoke about the implementation of a catastrophic care plan.

    Nevertheless, Madam President, in our 2012 Charter of Governance, we indicated that if elected we would launch NHI, and in 2013, guided by our consultants, we established the NHI framework, inclusive of healthcare strengthening; drafted and passed the National Health Insurance Bill, 2016, which laid the necessary legal framework for the establishment of the National Health Insurance Authority’s functions and powers, and the regulatory criteria for health care administrators and providers.

    Madam President, according to printed media and during the budget debate, the Minister of Health, created the impression that the Bahamian people did not get value for money from our consultants before and after the implementation of NHI.

    Yes, Madam President, The Minister of Health is entitled to his opinion, but I was a member of the cabinet steering committee for NHI, and I beg to disagree. I am keenly aware of the extensive amount of work put in place by the competent team at the NHI secretariat, who were supported by both local and foreign consultants; and I stand by these competent professionals, who made their contributions to the successful launch of universal primary care, by way of NHI. I state unequivocally that we did not waste the taxpayers’ money.

    I must remind the Honourable Member for Elizabeth, that hind sight is always 20/20 vision, and that much of the complications and delays we experienced were due to external factors that were completely out of our control, including Hurricanes Joaquin and Mathew, the damages to clinics in the South and Central Bahamas, Grand Bahama, North Andros and New Providence in their aftermath, and the general economic impact they had on the country.  These and other factors played a part in the postponement of the launch of NHI, which resulted in the extension of the consultancy with the KPMG Health Group.

    Madam President, understanding the need for more quality secondary and tertiary care services in the country, our administration proceeded with the recommendations from our global healthcare consultants, with the launch of Universal Primary healthcare services first, followed by the phasing in of selective catastrophic care, and finally the full benefit coverage.

    Madam President, much of the work for selective catastrophic care was completed during our administration. In fact, our discussions with the key Bahamian consultant physicians from both the public and private sectors, including the present Minister of Health, were completed before leaving offices. A final report on the way forward for selective catastrophic care was presented to cabinet for final approval.

    Nevertheless, we opted not to execute our selective catastrophic plan or put the authority in place until after the general elections.

    Madam President, history would reflect that Universal healthcare coverage by way of National Health Insurance will be one of the greatest social initiative since NIB, in our country, once fully implemented. As I stated earlier, governance must be continuous.  We launched NHI, and now it’s time for the FNM to continue the journey to full implementation.

    Madam President, I must admit that I was disappointed that only forty million dollars ($40,000,000.00) was allocated in this year budget for National Health Insurance as compared to the one hundred and twenty plus million dollars ($120,000,000.00) proposed by our administration.

    Madam President, with a mere fifteen million dollars ($15,000,000.00) allocated for primary healthcare, as well as catastrophic care, and ten million dollars   ($10,000,000.00) for the full implementation of NHIA, it is obvious that the program has been watered down. This is unfortunate, Madam President, and goes against the government’s election promises to adequately fund NHI, and implement a full catastrophic care program. It is evident, by these figures that their priorities have obviously shifted!

    Madam President, I now turn my attention to the disingenuous assertions of both Ministers of Finance and Health that our administration had no plan to pay for NHI, and that healthcare contracts issued by the Government months before the elections were deals to fix up our supporters. I take great exceptions to their remarks because they are absolutely untrue.

    Madam President, the NHI secretariat made it very clear to the Bahamian people that the government’s plan was to launch universal primary healthcare services first free of charge, with no cash at point of service. Once it was fully up and running across the country, and the economic indicators in the country verified that our people could handle the additional tax burden; as a responsible government, we were committed to go back to the Bahamian people with a palatable plan to ensure that NHI would be sustainable. At no point did we mislead the general public in believing that NHI would be a free service on full implementation.

     

    Madam President, post hurricane Mathew, the country’s focus was restoration, and many capital works initiatives around the country were put on hold, including our healthcare strengthening program, which was a vital component prior to the launch of NHI.

    Madam President, it is public knowledge that on May 8th, 2017 a civil works contract for the Mini hospital in Eleuthera was issued, during the ground-breaking ceremony in Palmetto Point Eleuthera. This was a negotiated contract for land preparation, and the scope of work was overseen by a registered quantity surveyor, based on completed architectural drawings by Alvin Rolle and Associates. This work was in the making for over a year, and yes, we executed the contract on the eve of the general election, when the money became available. Although the contract for the vertical structure was never issued, I was pleased to learn that the current administration is committed to completing this much need mini hospital that would improve the delivery of quality of healthcare for the residents of Eleuthera.

    Madam President, because of the urgency of the repairs needed at many of our outlying clinics across the country, cabinet agreed that the contracts would be negotiated based on amounts outlined in the architect and quantity surveyor’s reports. Of the forty-three (43) clinics identified, twenty-five (25) in the family islands and Grand Bahama were prioritized for immediate attention, along with the four (4) polyclinics in New Providence

    Hence, Madam President, out of the twenty-five (25) priority clinics air marked by our consultants for repairs, in order to meet the NHI licensing requirements, contracts were executed for the following clinics:

    • The Inagua Clinic
    • Landrail Point and Colonel Hill clinics, Crooked Island
    • Abraham’s Bay clinic, Mayaguana
    • Deadman’s Cay clinic, Long Island
    • Smith’s Bay clinic, Cat Island
    • Spanish Wells and Harbour Island clinics Eleuthera
    • Nichols Town and Mangrove Cay clinics, Andros
    • Marsh Harbour mini hospital
    • Spring Pint and Salina Point clinics Acklins
    • West End, Eight Mile Rock clinics and the Freeport Community Clinic
    • Fleming Street, Elizabeth Estate, Flamingo Gardens and the South Beach clinic

    Madame President, I am proud of the steps we took to ensure that Bahamians across the country would finally experience equity in the delivery of essential quality primary healthcare services in all our family islands.

    Madame President, I wish to reiterate that the workings of these negotiated contacts, which were approved by cabinet, were fully transparent; and all the signed contracts are at the Ministry of Finance and the PHA. The workmanship was professional, and fully supported by technical teams from the Ministry of Works, the PHA’s capital works unit, the Department of Public Health, The Ministry of Finance, our consultants from KPMG, the NHI secretariat, and the Minister for NHI.

    Madam President, contrary to what is being said, no deals were cut; we did nothing wrong; and the public records are there to prove it. In fact, most of the work throughout the Family Islands is near completion, and work is still ongoing at the polyclinics in Nassau, Cat Island and Grand Bahama.

    Additionally, Madam President, a negotiated civil works contract was issued, and work was started at Freeport Community Clinic site. The tender process of the actual clinic and the quantity surveyor’s report for this new sixty-two thousand (62,000) sq. ft. clinic was completed in our term in office. Funding was in place from the private sector, as arranged through the Ministry of Finance. During the budget communication, however, nothing was said about this important clinic; and I don’t see any allocation in the PHA or the Ministry of Works capital budget for its construction in this budget year. So, I am asking the Minister, through you, Madam President, to please follow through with this essential healthcare facility for the people of Grand Bahama.

     

    Madam President, I now turn my attention to the remarks made by the Minister of Health in the honourable lower chamber, concerning an alleged tens of millions of dollar worth of healthcare contracts that were issued weeks before the general election. He further went on to imply that we did this at the expense of compromising the country’s immunization supplies, and the health and well-being of the Bahamian people.

    Madam President, these statements are misleading and investigations into the allegations confirmed that at no point was the health and wellbeing of the general public ever intentionally compromised.

    First and foremost, Madam President, the government never issued ninety million dollars ($90,000,000.00) worth of healthcare contracts weeks before the general election.

    Secondly, Madam President, no contract in the sum of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000.00) per month was ever issued for the maintenance of the Marsh Harbour mini hospital.

    Thirdly, Madam President, no monthly contract in the sum of four hundred and fifty six thousand dollars ($424,000.00) was ever issued for the Exuma mini hospital.

    Madam President, these false statements were reported in the print media and went viral on social media, sending the wrong message to the Bahamian people. Although the Minister did the honourable thing in the lower chamber by withdrawing the statement, much of the damage was already done.

    Closing Remarks

    Madam President, as I wrap up my contribution to this budget debate, I do so by restating that as an administration, we did some heavy lifting and made the unpopular decisions that brought us back on the road to recovery.

    Yes, Madam President, the people of the country rejected us on Election Day. Nevertheless, we have accepted our loss at the polls, and have begun the rebuilding process. Although the opposition forces may be small, we will continue to fight to ensure that this government, who spoke a lot about transparency, and accountability on the campaign, put words into action.

    Madam President, the FNM promised the Bahamian people the world, thus creating unrealistic expectations; while painting the picture that those of us in the former administration were dishonest and crooked.

    However, Madam President, the campaign is over and it is time to govern; and you can rest assured that we will hold this FNM administration’s feet to the fire; beginning with this budget, which clearly demonstrates their priority, which is to support the rich, and put the small man on the back burner.

    Madam President, I end with admonishing this new administration; it’s prime time now, so stop making excuses, stop blaming the PLP for your short comings and start governing!

    After all, it’s the people’s time!

    Thank you.

  • 2017 BUDGET PRESENTATION BY I.CHESTER COOPER, MP

    2017 BUDGET PRESENTATION
    I.CHESTER COOPER, MP – EXUMA & RAGGED ISLAND AND SHADOW MINISTER OF FINANCE

    Mr. Speaker,
    It is with great pleasure that I formally address this House for the first time. It is among the highest honours of my life and I pray that my time here will be fruitful and to the benefit of the Bahamian people.
    I must thank the people of The Exumas and Ragged Island for reposing their faith in me in what has been a tense and competitive race.
    For the hard work of my campaign team, for the confidence placed in me by the former Prime Minister Christie, Leader Philip Brave Davis, for the support of the Progressive Liberal Party and its National General Council, for the unfailing strength and commitment of my wife Cecillia, the sacrifices of my children and the help of Almighty God, I will be forever grateful.
    Mr. Speaker, as we look around us, it is evident that the FNM had the momentum going into and coming out of this election, I congratulate PM Minnis and his Colleagues on their victory.
    People often ask me how we were able to secure Exuma and Ragged Island for the PLP, while other traditionally PLP areas, fell like dominoes on election night. Some say, ‘Well, Exuma was pretty much always PLP, and it was expected.’
    I want you and The Bahamas to know, Mr. Speaker, I don’t believe that for a second.
    I was born and raised at Forbes Hill, Little Exuma, Mr. Speaker.
    I know every inch of the place, and if there’s someone on Exuma of voting age I haven’t met or spoken with in the past year, only the slimmest circumstance of fate must have kept us apart.
    I talked to everyone, I listened to everyone, I laid out eVision2030 – a sound vision & plan and I made solemn and earnest promises to the people of Exuma to fight to make life better for them, every day – every step of the way.
    I know my people, as I said, Mr. Speaker, and my victory was secured by about 110 votes.
    I learned through campaigning, that people are tired of political rhetoric.
    They’re tired of empty promises and little action.
    They’re tired of being disregarded while Parliamentarians waste time attacking people’s character and doing not enough to better the lives of Bahamians. They are tired of the blame game every five years.
    I don’t believe in wasting time, Mr. Speaker.
    Not that of others and certainly not my own.
    So, I didn’t come here for fun. And for MP plates and to suit up and figure out my best angle to look handsome on TV.
    I didn’t come here to make FNMs feel bad about themselves, in any personal sense; so if I do I offer a blanket apology in advance for the next five (5) years.
    And I didn’t come here to sulk about the PLP’s loss.
    The election is over. The FNM won, the PLP didn’t; it’s now all of our jobs to see that the Bahamian people benefit.
    Because this is their House, their Parliament, their budget, their money, their ‘tings’. And it’s our job to protect them and to make sure in the end the Bahamian people benefit. Not our egos.

    So now; I am reporting for duty, I am happy to get to work
    Because that’s what I came here to do, I came here to work.
    I came here to help.
    To help The Bahamas, and in particular the people of Exuma and Ragged Island, and so it’s time for me to do just that!

    Mr. Speaker, to put it simply but respectfully, this budget communication by the honourable member for East Grand Bahama in my view was the wrong speech, at the wrong time at the wrong place.

    I have listened intently and read carefully the Budget Communication and much of it comes off as rally talk, but the rallies are over. I expected a mature assessment of the state of the economy. We have come to appreciate careful deliberations in this important communication so as not to talk down or undermine the economy. We anticipated a call for unity to move forward together to resolve whatever challenges that may exist. A budget communication is an opportunity for serious and mature conversation! The consumers of this report are not just the electorate but the international rating agencies, the business community and the investment community at home and abroad. This is one reason why it was the wrong speech.

    Trust me, I’ve been dealing with rallies for months now and we all have our fill of it.
    Let’s give it a rest. Less rally talk in here
    more governance talk. More let’s work together to help the Bahamian people talk.
    Firstly, why on Earth would the government come in here and put forward resolutions to borrow $722 million on day One!
    Day One!
    Let me say it slowly so it sinks in for those who haven’t grasped it yet – SEVEN HUNDRED AND TWENTY-TWO MILLION DOLLARS!
    That is three quarters of a billion dollars, within the first thirty (30) days of Gov’t.
    And they say that’s the PLP’s fault? They berate the PLP for $2bn in five years (including the $500m that the PLP said was theirs). Well I tell you at a clip of $722m in first 30 days, but they have yet to explain how and why – they have a duty to do so! I am frankly frightened as to how much will they borrow over a 5-year period?

    No sooner was the ink dry on the minister’s communication that Moody’s issued a statement which effectively said “At these levels [referring to the borrowings], the Bahamas’ debt/GDP ratio will be the highest for an emerging market sovereign rated Baa”. It’s clear to me where that discussion is headed. Wrong Speech – Wrong Time!

    Let’s shift ourselves from the rally stage.
    Why? Why would you already plan to borrow, before the fact, for the upcoming year, over $300 million dollars?
    And why would you think Bahamians would just nod their heads and go along?
    Let’s get serious.
    Let’s look at what the FNM said it would do.
    I don’t have the entire list here. I doubt we have time for that, but let’s look at the rally talk, then let’s look at the budget talk.
    Whilst I have the greatest respect for East Grand Bahama, when I say again that this is the wrong speech. I wonder whether this is the speech we will take with us when we go to defend the int’l rating of the Bahamas. Is this the one that we will take to the debt market? You don’t tell me you broke, you busted, you unemployed and that the “cupboard is bare” then ask me to borrow $722m.

    From the rally stage, the FNM said it would cut expenditure.
    That’s the rally talk too.

    Real talk: There are no significant cuts. In fact, this budget appears to build on the post hurricane deficit.
    Before a dollar has been spent or collected, they already plan to overspend revenue collection by hundreds of millions of dollars.
    If the PLP was so reckless, so spend happy and bleeding money, surely the FNM could have identified some significant cuts, savings and efficiencies. Hopefully, before this exercise is done, the minister can reconcile how wasteful the PLP was, but how the FNM can hardly identify areas in which to cut waste.
    As an administrative and perhaps a constitutional point, I note the published “draft estimates by revenues & expenditures” this one that is labelled “entering a new era of public accountability”. However, I was unable to discern reasonableness versus prior periods as I have not seen the gazette allocation of responsibilities. For example, we don’t know whether Regattas is in MOYSC or whether it is in MOA&MR; I don’t know whether the landfill is under MOH or the MOH&E; I wondered whether that was part of the impetus of a joint press release by two Ministers. Similarly, we don’t know at this point whether the BIA is a part of OPM, Finance, Financial Services or Tourism. I believe it’s a matter of constitutional correctness Mr. Speaker, that anticipate that this be gazetted post-haste. We need to know.
    In this “new era of accountability” I know that the MOF being a decorated Chartered Accountant with seek to modernize the budgeting and reporting process, transition to the accrual basis, a proper income statement and proper assessment of the assets and liabilities of our country. A transparent and accountable framework engenders Understandability, Relevance and Comparability. He certainly has his work cut out.

    CONSULTANCIES
    With great emphasis Mr. Speaker – great emphasis; the honourable Minister castigated the Gov’t for spending $10m on consultants related to NHI. I make a few points in relation to this matter. Firstly, I wasn’t there (I’m new here) so I accept the MOF and his word. Secondly, I was a part of the private sector who said we support universal healthcare – but get it right. Well if the expertise is not resident in Gov’t how you expect them to get it right. Thirdly, I am not clear at this point whether the Gov’t has been able to be enlightened by this body of work to help to guide them as to the prudent next steps for NHI, funding strategies and a roadmap to success. Whilst I hear the inclination towards catastrophic health care I would be listening intently to the Hon. Min. of Health as he explains how it will be paid for, or whether there are provisions already in the budget for what I anticipate will be an expensive undertaking. This is sure way to bankrupt a small country. We must still get this right. Fourthly, successive Gov’t (successive I say) have hired foreign consultants sometimes at the exclusion of the local professional community. Let me go on record as saying that this is often lamented (as a sore point) as an affront to local professionals and it is my view that there should be a move effort to supporting our qualified locals where the expertise exist which will also build capacity for our country for the future. And finally, on the subject of consultancies Mr. Speaker, I wonder whether the MOF in due course would investigate and advise whether the previous Gov’t spent in excess of $30m on the consultancy to sell BTC to CWC and whether it was those consultants who advised leaving $15m of free cash in the bank for the new buyer? That is a question Mr. Speaker.

    THE DEFICIT
    Rally talk: The FNM was going to cut the deficit.
    Real talk: I’d be impressed if the government held the line at $323 million in deficit spending for the upcoming year as it projects. In fact, they recklessly promised to reduce taxes, yet have no apparent plans to make that revenue neutral, let alone reduce spending in any significant way.
    You also promise “free stuff”. Free tertiary education; free money for family island student accommodation, (my people in Exuma are waiting for that) free pre-school, free catastrophic health care, tax-free zones in the inner city. Maybe no one else told you. So, let me be the first. There is no “free” in government services. Someone must pay. And that someone is always ultimately the Bahamian people and our Children. I suppose at some-point, you’ll get around to telling the people that.
    Rally talk: The FNM is going to promote economic growth.
    Real talk: You just came in here last week and suggested the PLP gave away too much in concessions. So where is your plan to attract foreign direct investment? Where is your plan to end concessions and at the same time encourage Foreign Direct Investments, and spur economic growth? Perhaps next year, eh?
    When I say the wrong speech at the wrong time; I looked through the presentation and don’t see much in this budget communication that gives me confidence that the people who we are here to represent will be any better off in five years than they are today. I see no initiative to alleviate poverty or bring relief in the inner city. When I say the wrong time; I hear very little optimism (at a time we need it most) and see very little plan for Economic growth. Instead I noted an unprecedented level of negativity, partisanship and tribalism if you will. What is more troubling, when I look at the projections for the national debt and the deficit 2 to 3 years out I see that this Gov’t is not predicting that it will get much better. There is no real plan to reduce the national debt despite all that rally talk.

    BAHAMAR
    What I find incredibly curious though Mr. Speaker, was that there was no mention of Baha Mar in the speech from the throne and the only real spark of optimism in the Budget Communication itself in terms of economic growth is its reference of Baha Mar over the next few years. With this in mind, I ask the Minister of Finance and the Minister of Tourism in particular, if they would go on record in supporting Bahamar and helping the Bahamian people to put the recent squabbles of the former Developers aside as “water under the bridge” and do all in their power to dissuade any protracted legal battles and ensure that Baha Mar is a productive and successful business free from legal entanglements. Baha Mar must succeed. It would be comforting if the Minister of Tourism would commit on the record to using the incredible power and influence of his office in protecting this only ray of optimism in his Government’s budget.

    Here’s the thing:
    The Bahamian people – especially the Millennials and the young people across the Bahamas don’t care anymore, about who blames who. They want solutions. So, we’ll sit here and more than likely hear 30 or more epistles about how bad the PLP was but not really any plan to fix it. The reality is Mr. Speaker that if it broken you’re the Government now. Fix it! I say Fix it Mr. Speaker. The FNM won the mandate from the Bahamian people so it’s now the FNM Gov’t job to fix it. So, let’s have some real solutions that will fix it! Fix it Mr. Speaker.

    VAT EXEMPTIONS:
    Here’s some more rally talk for you: The FNM will repeal value-added tax on breadbasket items, water, education, electricity, and healthcare.
    Real talk now: How? You say not now because of the fragile state of the economy. But I suspect, upon coming to office, someone quickly gave the FNM an education on how VAT works and told them that’s just not going to happen.
    But here’s my question? Did no one think about this all along on the campaign trail, that this wasn’t viable? Did everyone just say it for fun? To win? No one advised better than this?
    I can tell you, Mr. Speaker that I cringed at some of the promises I heard during the Campaign. It is with that in mind that I predict that this Government will champion the largest budget deficits OR largest increases in taxes OR the greatest amount of broken promises ever seen in the history of modern Bahamas.
    I trust that it is not all of the above; but I am not persuaded that there are well-crafted plans for delivering those promises. I surely don’t see them in this budget.
    But, I take some comfort, however, that if the Bahamian people feel like you “Swing Dem” in 2017 in not delivering on the notion of the “People’s Time” they will judge you harshly in 2022 and if they determined that you didn’t act right – expect to be fired too! That’s the beauty of our democracy.
    But let’s not get ahead of ourselves.
    Let’s stick to VAT for a minute, because I’m still wondering who made them make these promises.

    VAT EXEMPTIONS
    Firstly, I don’t think anyone was surprised that this budget did not deliver on the promised VAT exemptions.
    During my time as chairman of the Bahamas Chamber of Commerce and Employer’s confederation we lead negotiations with the government on VAT on behalf of the business community and the private sector.
    In consultation with the Chamber and other stakeholders the PLP Gov’t was able to lead the way in responsible tax reforms. The IMF praised the Gov’t on its successful implementation.
    How about this, let’s not wreck the system by tinkering with things you seem to think can be solved with fanciful rally talk.
    Instead let’s give the system a full opportunity to prove itself, until there is a comprehensive orientation on the complex triggers and a thorough examination of the impact of such proposed exemptions.
    A system with limited exemptions enables a more efficient tax scheme. We’ve been through this over and over again. It’s too late to be playing catch up on how VAT works.
    Varying rates and/or exemptions, would require system amendments and increases the complexity of the tax collection and filing process, which is already a sore point for the business community. A change will likely impact the level of system related costs and compliance rates experienced with VAT. Fewer exemptions and more elimination/reductions of Customs duties might be the way to go to create a more comprehensive VAT.

    As it now stands it would be beneficial to have an even more simplified system of both reporting and filing. A system where the cash flow of the business follows the payment of the VAT. One where the business community does not have to provide free short-term financing to the government while it waits to receive payment for its credits. A VAT system that does not increase the cost of doing business but is efficient. The majority of business owners are in support of reasonable taxes, and supports a refined system so that they can get on with the business of doing business.

    BREADBASKET ITEMS
    With respect to the promise of removal of VAT on breadbasket items, retailers will tell you that these represent roughly 60% to 70% of the sales. This would mean that VAT input credits currently enjoyed by the retailers of these items would no longer be credits. This, in turn, increases the operating costs, which will be passed on by way of increased prices at the grocery store. Therefore, the exemption of VAT will not result in the perceived reduction of cost of 7.50%. The same analysis may be made for exempting electricity and if not done properly might lead to the unintended consequence of increasing the cost of electricity with the unintended consequence of adversely impacting the lower income households.
    It is my view that the PLP Gov’t got it right when they increased the minimum wage from $150 to $210, a whopping 40 percent; and improved social services benefits in a dignified manner with the cash loaded cards. This was the right approach to offset the potential adverse impact on this demographic.

    Again, I ask, who analysed this campaign promise? They would have had access to the great body of work by the Chamber and its Oxford Economists, the IMF, the IDB and the Compass Lexecon (U.S. consultants engaged directly by the government) and others who rely on empirical analysis.
    Should the government start tinkering where it needs not, I foreshadow that it would likely result in the increase of VAT to as high as 15 percent. We must not inflict this injustice on the Bahamian people.
    Further, Mr. Speaker, I noted the political gimmickry and mischief making about VAT money throughout the campaign. Curiously, the Gov’t launched many forensic audits but did not launch an investigation on “where the VAT money gone”. I believe the Minister of Finance now has a duty to report to the Bahamian people on the matter.

    CUSTOM DUTY REDUCTIONS:
    Let’s look for a minute on the areas where there were tax reductions. What is the mechanism to ensure that businesses are passing on these savings rather than using them to improve their profit margins?

    a. Paint for example. In prior years the Gov’t increased duty on bottled water to protect industry and jobs. A reduction in duty on paint by 20% will potentially harm the local manufacturing industry resulting in job losses and adversely impacting Lower income households. As the shadow Minister for Industry I want to know why? And who stand to benefit? Without suggesting anything untoward, before I vote on this budget Mr. Speaker, we would be grateful if the Gov’t would declare whether any members of the Cabinet has a substantial interest in a paint distributor who might stand to gain?
    b. On potato chips, I wonder whether it was determined that this food presents some nutritional value and encourages healthy life styles.
    c. On Bread, I wonder whether the MOF will now be subsidizing bread imports because they say they are reducing imports on bread, but its already zero. I would suggest that that may have been an oversight, rather than an attempt to show the People that the Gov’t is for them?
    d. With respect to reduction is Customs duty on foreign art. At first glance Mr. Speaker it is tempting to see this again as a tax break for the rich and counter to the encouragement of the creative talents of local artists and artisans. On reflection however, I am aware that there are substantial interests promoting bi-partisan support for the concept of the Bahamas being a centre to store Art in a shared vault scheme similar to what is done in Switzerland. If this is in fact the intent of this provision, as the shadow minister for Financial Services, I would be minded to support it as an innovative idea in context of value added to our financial services and home office businesses which is designed to attract High Net Worth (HNW) individuals.

    RECAP
    So let’s just quickly recap: The FNM said they were ready to govern. They said they could do a better job. They said the PLP spent too much. They said the PLP borrowed too much. They promised reduction in VAT and a lot of free stuff.
    And what did we get?
    No real plan or programs to grow the economy.
    No new incentives – they just continued the Family Island Incentive Act and City of Nassau incentives Act for another year. Not revolutionary stuff. Nothing new. Nothing original. With respect to the stamp tax on exemptions to home owners it appears that all that is being done is codifying into law what was already a PLP policy?
    [I will turn my attention to the business license issue shortly]
    We got more borrowing, the largest ever at one time, I do believe.
    We get no real expenditure cuts.
    No reduction in pre-hurricane deficit.
    No real plan for debt reduction.
    We got a record time backtrack on VAT reduction promises.
    We got some reductions on salmon and shrimp. I’m sure hurting low income families will appreciate that.
    We get a budget communication that sounds like a rally speech with a built-in narrative of fiscal constraints as an excuse not to fulfil all of the unrealistic promises they blurted out night after night.
    And No real plan to find savings and efficiencies.

    NO RELIEF FOR THE POOR
    Mr. Speaker, I expected relief for the poor, the down trodden and incentives for the inner city. Based on the rally talks we expected elimination of VAT on bread basket items, on electricity and health care. We got not one IOTA of relief for the poor. I see very little that improves the life of the low-income household in the inner city. They say “not now”.

    Meanwhile over on the other side of town Mr. Speaker the Business License (Amendment) Bill 2017 seems to provide a tax reduction to businesses with turnover exceeding $50m from 1.5% to 1.25%, but does not make any reduction to business license for Small and Medium Sized businesses. I would imagine Mr. Speaker that the list of businesses who will benefit from this exemption is decidedly small and it would be very very interesting to look at that list of businesses to examine who might be the beneficiaries of this tax break. If I am mistaken, I stand corrected Mr. Speaker but if I am right this implies that there goes another tax break for rich big business who might be cosy with this so called People’s Time Government, whilst there is no reduction for Small and Medium Sized businesses who also employ people but struggle every day to keep their doors open. As is the case with most modern economies small business account for as high as 70% of jobs in the private sector and is considered the engine that drives organic economic growth.
    For business license, may I suggest incentives geared towards small business and other businesses that operate at a loss. Let us be mindful, that this tax is on turnover not profits it is conceivable that businesses may be loss making and on the brink of closure and still have to pay business license fees to their further detriment.

    THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM
    Mr Speaker,
    The elephant in the room is that there are some needed restructuring and reforms required in our economy, our budgeting process and business model, that will take some heavy lifting by sober and diligent policy makers.

    Roughly 60 percent of the budget goes to salaries and emoluments, another 20 percent for other unbreakable commitments like rents and most of the rest for capital expenditure. This leaves very little wiggle room. This is not sustainable.
    I don’t know if any business can survive if 60% of its revenue goes to salaries. There are some simple rules to the survival of any enterprise worth having. A third of revenue to salaries, a third of revenue to overheads and a third of revenue to growing the business. As it stands it puts the government consistently in debt and our children’s future at risk.

    This is why I am so hard on the point that we must be focused on growing our economy. We must do more with the existing infrastructure and the government is now faced with the reality that the economy must grow, the pie must expand. And magic and fanciful campaign dream selling don’t make for sound fiscal and prudent management. Governance is serious business Mr. Speaker.
    It just makes us look bad at home and in the eyes of the international community who seem to have no problem downgrading our credit ratings on the fly.
    In that vein, I caution you to provide responsible fiscal leadership in order to harmonize our business model, grow our economy, improve ratings in the international community and confidence with the business community and Bahamian Public.

    EXUMA MATTERS
    Turning to Exuma, Mr. Speaker, I trust that in the presentation of the ministers we will hear some announcements that address the numerous pressing PRIORITY issue in Exuma including:
    1. Running water for Little Exuma
    2. With urgency, the full opening of the mini hospital at George Town, inclusive of more Doctors and technical staff
    3. Continuation and completion of the Forest Road and other essential road works
    4. Construction of a new straw market in George Town
    5. Advancement of a Public Private Partnership (PPP) to expedite the construction of new airport terminal at George Town; and the
    6. Expansion of the airport run way at Black Point
    7. The tourist product has outgrown the infrastructure in Exuma we need today more taxi plates and more SD plates.
    RAGGED ISLAND MATTERS
    Let’s not forget Ragged Island, Mr. Speaker.
    She is a clear case for development of a model for handling the peculiar issues of Small Islands in the Bahamas and the region. With a population of about 65 and 44 registered voters, Ragged Island requires the same level of government services. There is an ongoing issue with the closure of the post office due to the Post Mistress being on maternity leave. Whilst in the grand scheme of things you might consider this minor. I invite you to consider the disconnect that Ragged Island already feels with no direct flight services and no banks making the Post Office the only option to get money to Nassau so that supplies can come on the mail boat. This is just one example but I will bring to the attention of the relevant Ministers the various “small issues” that continue to create discomfort for our people on Ragged Island, like providing more reliable water supply and much needed repairs to the clinic, nurse’s residence and police station. No doubt there are grants or resources accessible through our international affiliates like the IDB for subsidizing connectivity of remote areas. We must not forget our brother and sisters in places across the Bahamas like Ragged Island. The strong must bear the infirmities of the weak Mr. Speaker.

    As I close, Mr. Speaker, I do want to point out some good things the government has proposed and a few suggestions.

    On the issue of Campaign Finance Reforms – I was delighted to hear mention of this, but there can no longer be lip service to this issue.
    • Ease of doing business – I do await the government’s plans on this. We recognize that this is all of our problem and I and the private sector are prepared to help in a structured bi-partisan way to improve our rankings.
    • Natural Disasters: With great pains the Minister outlined the potential volatility that may be caused by natural disasters. I pray that God spares us this year. We must then get to work in a bi-partisan way with the help of our friends in the private sector to find a solution to mitigate the impact of such events as we live in the hurricane belt.
    • More Funding for the Venture Fund and technical assistance to entrepreneurs Empowerment of Bahamians
    • Family Island Development,
    o Getting projects out of the pipeline particularly for Exuma where there is more than $500m announced which is earmarked to create hundreds of jobs.
    o Strengthening of local Gov’t inclusive of more funding. Exuma collects hundreds of million for the public treasury but its local Gov’t only gets $400k. This is not equitable and it was with great delight that I hear mention of islands receiving a percentage of their collections in the speech from the throne. I trust that the Minister of Local Government in his presentation will bring life to this important issues
    o Second home owners and home rentals have boosted room availability through the use of engines like AirBNB and VRBO. We must require these entities to collect a tax and remit to the Gov’t this might be a significant way to get more funding for local government in our islands.
    o NDP: The lack of reference to the National Development Plan is very alarming. This is the tool to pool ideas and formulate strategies, to innovate and to maximise partnerships. Adequate funding, bi-partisan support is required here in creating a common set of goals. We must avoid the polarization that has stifled us as a country and demonstrate political maturity in mapping out progress and ultimately our fiscal successes.

    CONCLUSION:
    So, Mr. Speaker, my takeaway is: This is not a good start for the Free National Movement Gov’t. It’s the Wrong Speech, at the Wrong Time in the Wrong Place. I sincerely hope this will be the last administration to come to office and claim it did not know what was left behind by the previous one.

    As I mentioned earlier, the majority of the Bahamian people don’t care. As the Gov’t we just want you fix it if we deem it to broken. Fix it! Fix it!
    We the Bahamian people will not accept excuses. We do not take kindly to the notion that the FNM Opposition did not know; effectively an admission of not doing its job. This is why we have a Public Accounts Committee, on which I now sit.
    This is why we have a Public Treasury Committee, Why we have a mid-year budget exercise and Central Bank reports.
    Mr. Speaker, claiming you did not know is no longer good enough. Not a good defense Mr. Speaker

    For the record Mr. Speaker, I am not so pessimistic about the future of our beloved Bahamas. I am hopeful that once the new Gov’t finds its footing and adjust to its role of being responsible for the future of our economy they will see and harness the silver linings of healthy reserve levels unemployment trending downwards and the prospects for a successful Baha Mar. The Bahamian people want action. Not rally talk and empty promises. A healthy dose of real talk and actual work would go a long way.
    Mr. Speaker, I was sent by the people I work for with a very clear job description – to present their concerns and help to make the Bahamas a better place to live, work and Play. I promised them each day that I will do my part in holding the Government’s feet to the fire and with that in mind, I expect that this honeymoon will be a decidedly short. We have a country to build!

    Mr. Speaker I rest, on behalf of the good people of Exuma & Ragged Island.

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

  • THIS WEEK IN THE BAHAMAS (13 – 17 MARCH 2017)

    THIS WEEK IN THE BAHAMAS (13 – 17 MARCH 2017)

    COMMENTARY BY ELCOTT COLEBY 

     

    This week in Parliament

    The Bahamas Parliament met on Wednesday of this week to consider Trafficking in Persons and labour legislation. 

    Amendments to the Employment and Industrial Relations Acts were tabled by the Hon. D. Shane Gibson, the Minister of Labor Labour. These proposed employee friendly amendments will among other provisions, increase redundancy pay by 67%. 

    Also, readers would remember the recent passage of Trafficking in Persons (TIPS) legislation in the House. Well, that passage in TIPS law required amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code to complete the process. These two pieces of legislation dominated the debate in the House on Wednesday of this week. 

    Deputy Prime Minister Philip Davis told House Members that Chinese nationals who entered the country to construct the $3.5bn Baha Mar resort had their passports and work permits withheld, adding that this was done as a means to “control” the foreign laborers.  

    Golden Isles MP Michael Halkitis accused FNM Leader Dr. Minnis of intentionally “provoking an altercation” between the FNM supporters and the campaigners for the PLP who were canvassing the Carmichael Road area on Tuesday. 

    An emotional speech by Fox Hill MP Fred Mitchell heightened speculation that the Government will “ring the bell” for the general election very soon. Mitchell thanked his colleagues in the House for their years of dedicated service and foreshadowed a win for the PLP at the polls. 

    Fort Charlotte MP Dr. Andre Rollins delivered his farewell address. In a parting shot he suggested that FNM Leader Dr. Minnis had not shown he is ready to lead the nation, pointing to his attendance at House proceedings. Rollins further urged Prime Minister Christie to “call out” Dr. Minnis on his inadequate performance. 

    Christie: “Additional need for more Customs Officers”

    Prime Minister and Minister of Finance, the Rt. Hon. Perry Christie has called on Assistant Comptroller of Customs in Grand Bahama, Sherick Martin to begin right away preparing another group of Customs recruits for another Customs Training program. 

    The appeal from the Prime Minister came during his address of the 22 new recruits who officially graduated on Wednesday, March 15, 2017, during a ceremony at the Bahamas Union of Teachers Hall. 

    Prime Minister Christie said his request for the formation of another immediate training program comes in light of the fact that the country’s expanding economy demands more Customs Officers, not just in Grand Bahama or Nassau, but throughout The Bahamas. 

    “In speaking with the Minister of Tourism and knowing the extent to which the economy is being expanded, which will create an additional need for even more Customs Officers, I’m minded to make policy right now on my feet,” the Prime Minister said at the beginning of his address.  

    “As I think of those areas where you only have one officer – which is even dangerous to that officer – you can see why there ought to be coverage that goes beyond one person. 

    “We’ve just indicated a new destination at Ocean Cay, which will require the appointment of more Customs Officers to that Port of Call. There are at least over 5,000 passengers a week on cruise ships going into that destination. 

    “By the Heads of Agreement we entered into with Baker’s Bay in Abaco, we have agreed to have a Port of Entry there at that destination as well. So, that also calls for more Customs Officers.  From a pure necessity point of view, we have agreed that we would establish a port of call in Mangrove Cay and that too will call for more Customs Officers.” 

    Minnis proposes “real sale” of Baha Mar Resort

    FNM Leader Dr. Hubert Minnis suffered a huge backlash and a slew of criticism during the course of the week from many quarters when he pledged to execute a “real sale” of Baha Mar to a purchaser that has the Bahamian people’s interests at heart, should the FNM win the general election. Minnis posted on Facebook: “Your Free National Movement government will engage and execute a real sale of Baha Mar to a qualified and respectable purchaser who believes in Bahamians; a purchaser who will utilize only Bahamian labor to complete the resort, and will put Bahamians back to work with real jobs as quickly as possible.” 

    Deputy Prime Minister Philip Davis lashed out at Dr. Minnis, accusing him of plotting for the resort’s demise for political benefit while spouting untruths. 

    The Chamber of Commerce’s chairman warned all politicians to “not blow up the country for the sake of winning the election.” 

    Education Minister the Hon. Jerome Fitzgerald slammed Dr. Minnis’ coments as “disgraceful”, arguing that it would disrupt employment for hundreds of Bahamians. Fitzgerald further argued that the FNM leader’s assertions showed he was not fit to become Prime Minister. 

    Prime Minister Christie told supports at a joint constituency meeting that he hoped Minnis would come to the House to defend his comments but the FNM leader was a no-show. 

    FNM Chairman Sidney Collie said while an FNM government would execute a “real sale” of Baha Mar if the current sale process is not complete, if and when it becomes the next Government of The Bahamas, nationalizing the resort is not in the party’s plans. 

    PLP Chairman Bradley Roberts charged that the FNM’s policy position on Baha Mar “is to disrupt the lives of many and the Bahamian economy to satisfy one man who proved he was unable to finish the job in the first place”. 

    Former Deputy Prime Minister Brent Symonette however defended his leader, insisting that “fault” sits with the “untruths and half facts” produced by the Christie administration in recent months. 

    Hanna-Martin: Doppler Radars “significant thrust” for Meteorology Department

    Four new Doppler radars are being installed to improve the functionality of the Department of Meteorology. The radar will be situated in New Providence, Grand Bahama, Long Island and Abaco. Currently, the only radar system, stationed on New Providence, is being refurbished and upgraded to be established in Ragged Island later. The contract for the radar system was awarded to Vaisala, a Finnish company, at a cost of $20 million. On completion, the entire Bahamas will be under full radar coverage.  In addition, the company will install nine more weather stations. 

    Minister of Transport the Hon. Glenys Hanna-Martin made the announcement during a press conference held at the Weather Station at Lynden Pindling International Airport on Wednesday, March 15, 2017. 

    She said that this project puts the country on the ‘cutting edge’ of technology and is a ‘significant thrust’ for the meteorology department as it sets out to build capacity. She also said that this project is part of a larger vision by the government to protect and more effectively forewarn the Bahamian people against major catastrophes such as hurricanes and other storm systems. 

    The Doppler radar will use the SmartMet and SmartAlert system, which means that several features will be built-in, including: automatic generation of weather forecast products, integrated display of various weather observation and data sources, advanced weather situational analysis and weather warning tools. The SmartMet/SmartAlert system is already in use in 10 Caribbean countries including Cuba, Antigua, Jamaica and Barbados. 

    Chamber boss wants government to “reconsider” amended labour laws

    The Chamber of Commerce has called the latest amendments to the labour laws “ultra vires” existing laws and has asked the Government to withdraw and “reconsider” the reforms as “not one employer” is in favour of the changes. 

    Bahamian employers were outraged at the proposed changes to the Employment and Industrial Relations Acts tabled in Parliament on Wednesday by Shane Gibson, the Minister of Labor. Criticism of the bills, which among other provisions, increases redundancy pay by 67%, employers argue that the amendments would deter Bahamian businesses from hiring and make it more difficult to tackle the 25 to 30 percent youth unemployment rate. 

    The Director of Labor however shot back that there was “no basis” to the Chamber of Commerce’s assertion that the labor law reforms were “ultra vires” because they had not been unanimously approved by all National Tripartite Council members. Mr. Farquharson pointed out that the 40% increase in the minimum wage was not unanimously agreed by the Tripartite Council as some members wanted a larger increase for workers. The minimum wage hike is now settled law.   

    Also weighing in was the Bahamas Hotel and Restaurant Employers Association (BHEA) who also expressed concern over the proposed amendments to the Industrial Relations Act and the Employers Act. 

    Elated union leaders said they were “ecstatic” over the reforms to the Employment and Industrial Relations Act, hailing them as a “victory for Bahamian workers”. 

    UB to host series of panel discussions on public affairs

    The Social Sciences Department at the University of The Bahamas (UB) is hosting a series of panel discussions and public forums featuring representatives from every political party. The meetings will focus on national debate, political polling and scientific research. The first in this series was held this week at the Harry C. Moore Library on the administration of justice. Keith Bell, Marvin Dames and Stephen Greenslade represented the PLP, FNM and DNA respectively.  

    Dr. Christopher Curry, chair of the School of Social Sciences at UB, said the concept is a step in the right direction for the country and its political climate, adding that the inclusion of the public and media at this level of the election process should translate into a more involved electorate.  

    Government assessment underway after landfill fire

    The Department of Social Services said that 290 heads of households applied for assistance out of the estimated 600 homes located in Jubilee Gardens. It was also reported that 1,200 persons are set to receive government assistance as a result of the fire.

    Meanwhile Anthony Ryan, a public analyst at the Department of Environmental Health Services, said officials conducted air quality tests on 19 homes closest to the dump. He said that there was nothing alarming found. 

    In related news, Geltech Solutions, a fire-fighting specialist, has been contracted by the Government to assist in extinguishing the massive blaze at the New Providence Landfill. 

    Commenting on the landfill’s remediation cost, Tall Pines MP Leslie Miller pegged the cost at about $5 million.

    Environment Minister, the Hon. Kenred Dorsett, said the government was preparing to move “full steam ahead” with both the privatization of operations at the New Providence landfill and “fine tuning” its remediation plan.

    Freak storm damages Bahamasair ATR aircraft

    A tornado hit the Lynden Pindling International Airport early Tuesday morning causing damage to the landing gear and fuselage of a Bahamasair ATR aircraft, parking lot booth and several cars at a nearby car rental agency. 

    Bahamasair’s Chairman expressed fears that its upcoming services for peak Easter travel period may be disrupted, after one of its 70-seater ATR planes was damaged by the early Tuesday morning tornado that struck the Lynden Pindling International Airport. 

    The Department of Meteorology did not issue a severe weather warning yesterday morning before severe weather around Lynden Pindling International Airport led to a tornado damaging a $20m Bahamasair aircraft, because the department did not “capture anything that would point to a severe thunderstorm warning”, according to Deputy Director of the Department of Meteorology Basil Dean. 

    In Passing…

    Baha Mar on Monday held its first day of casino dealer training prior to the property’s soft opening on April 21. It said the 170 recently-hired casino employees had been enrolled in a four-week gaming course to perfect their skills and refine their customer service expertise. 

    Graeme Davis, President of Baha Mar and the Bahamian subsidiary of CTFE, commented that Rosewood Hotel’s 2018 delayed opening was not a construction issue, but rather, a design and programming concern. CTFE is expected to inject an additional $35 million dollars into the completion of the Rosewood Hotel. 

    The National General Council (NGC) of the PLP unanimously endorsed Wayne Munroe over Senator Frank Smith on Monday night, ratifying the attorney for the Free Town constituency. That action completed the ratification process as all 39 of the party’s candidates are now ratified. In his concession speech, Senator Smith said that he has not always won all of his battles in life. Party Chairman Bradley Roberts characterized the process as “free, fair, transparent, democratic and compliant with the provisions of the Party’s constitution.”  In his victory speech, Munroe ridiculed the pledge made by FNM Leader Dr. Minnis over the sale of Baha Mar as dishonest and irresponsible, and accused the opposition party of pandering to the agenda of former developer Sarkis Izmirlian.   

    Transport and Aviation Minister Glenys Hanna Martin hit back at the most recent US State Department’s advisory against jet ski operators, charging that if left unchecked, it could overshadow the “significant progress” her ministry has made to address the issues within the industry.  

    Five hundred jobs are expected to be created when the second phase of The Pointe opens in late 2018, Deputy Prime Minister Philip Brave Davis said at the groundbreaking for the Downtown Nassau development.  Phase 2 will include the development of a 150-room branded resort and spa and the development of a 100-room, eight story condominium complex.  

    A new cruise port in East Grand Bahama will be constructed on the north shore west of Stat Oil in an area that has been determined to suffer the least devastating environmental effects. PM Christie revealed that the cruise port will take two years to build and will significantly benefit the island.  

    Emmanuel Komolafe, chairman of The Bahamas Insurance Association has estimated that The Bahamas will benefit from a $300M foreign currency inflow from reinsurers as a result of Hurricane Matthew.  He said that insurance claims incurred as a result of the hurricane stand at $176M and that the injection of foreign currency into The Bahamas through the industry could be seen as one positive from the storm.  

    Travel Daily highlighted that Royal Caribbean International formalized a multi-year agreement with the government of The Bahamas to grow tourism, increase the cruise line’s employment of Bahamian nationals, and invest in Bahamian hospitality training to develop talent at the recent signing ceremony attended by Prime Minister Perry Christie. 

    PM Christie said that relocating residents in Pinders Point is not something that government will consider as no such recommendation has been made to it.  He said that studies were undertaken in relation to the industrial pollution in Grand Bahama many years ago and more recently by the Pan American Health Organization and World Health Organization in 2015.  

    The Grand Bahama Chamber of Commerce’s President has expressed optimism that the island’s economy can be revitalized, even though Freeport is much different from the days when it was named the “magic city”. 

    Bahamas Junkanoo Carnival was officially launched last Friday (10th March), with the Bahamas National Festival Commission committing to its mandate to hold the annual festival with a two million dollar reduction in this year’s budget, from $7 million to $5 million. Scheduled for the 4th through 6th May 20176, the Bahamas Carnival Band Owners Association is still hoping some money in the Government’s $5 million budget has been allocated for them to market themselves. 

    Prime Minister Christie had been ordered to pay the full legal costs incurred by Save The Bays (STB) after his recusal application was rejected by the Supreme Court. The Prime Minister, in his capacity as Minister for Crown Lands – appear with several other senior officials and developer Peter Nygard – as a respondent in three Judicial Review cases brought by STB to challenge the environmentally destructive constructions works that were allowed to take place at Nygard Cay over the past three decades. 

    The Caribbean Journal reported that Silver Airways announced the launch of new nonstop flights between West Palm Beach and Bimini, the first flights to Bimini out of Palm Beach County.

    Elizabeth MP Ryan Pinder had not attended a sitting of the House of Assembly for the year, according to the attendance records of the House of Assembly. According to the rules of the House of Assembly, a member of the House shall vacate his seat in the House if he is absent from sittings of the House for a period of 90 days without leave of absence from the House.

    The business of tourism will be on display at the Baha Mar Convention Center on April 8 as the Ministry of Tourism presents the 17th Cacique Awards. 

    Foreign Affairs Minister the Hon. Fred Mitchell met with the President of the University of The Bahamas Dr. Rodney Smith and the university’s student union president Keyron Smith on Thursday afternoon at the Harry C. Moore Library’s conference room. The courtesy call came upon the return of a group of university students from an exchange field trip to Atlanta. Accompanying the Minister was the Bahamas’ Consul General to Atlanta HE Randy Rolle and the Director General of the country’s Foreign Service, Mrs. Sharon Brennen-Haylock. 

    The governing Progressive Liberal Party held another joint constituency meeting on Thursday of this week. The constituencies were Garden Hills, Tall Pines and Golden Gates. Delivering the keynote address was party leader and Prime Minister the Rt. Hon. Perry G. Christie who admonished supporters to be energized and focused because of the critical importance of this election. The Prime Minister berated FNM Leader Dr. Minnis over his noticeable absence from the House of Assembly on Wednesday, telling a crowd of PLP supporters that the Killarney MP has opted to hide behind social media in the wake of yet another massive error in his leadership tenure. 

    Marco City MP Greg Moss announced on Thursday night that he will not be seeking a re-nomination in the upcoming general elections for personal and business reasons, and has resigned as leader of the United Democratic Party. Interim Deputy Leader John Pinder said that the party will march on.  

    As Grand Bahama builds its industrial sector, at the Grand Bahama Shipyard in Freeport from 26 March to 6 April, Princess Cruises’ Caribbean Princess is to be fitted with interconnecting staterooms, Ocean Medallion technology, and newly renovated areas for children and teenagers. 

    Shane Gibson, Minister of Labor and National Insurance says The Bahamas only has “minor examples” of child labor, as he opened a joint two-day seminar on the issue. 

    The Bahamas’ new mobile operator will bring a $50 million capital raising ‘Aliv’ next week, its advisers “a very successful offering”. 

    Days after Island Luck CEO Sebas Bastian announced that he is working towards releasing an initial public offering (IPO), Chief Operating Officer (COO) of the Bahamas International Securities Exchange (BISX) Holland Grant explained the procedures for any company to enter the securities market. 

    Both the governing progressive Liberal Party and the opposition Free National Movement hosted candidate launch events on Friday night in Freeport Grand Bahama for that island’s candidates. The PLP worshipped at the Jubilee Cathedral while the FNM hosted their event at the former bowling alley. 

    On Friday FNM Chairman Sidney Collie accused the PLP government of using public funds to finance its election campaign, specifically charging that the BAMSI print ads were paid for by the public treasury. PLP Chairman Bradley Roberts “emphatically and unequivocally” refuted those claims, branding them as “patently false.” He stated that the PLP paid for the ads.  

  • THE SUNSHINE MARATHON 2017 VERSION

    Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell congratulates Franklyn Wilson for the Marathon hosting 15 January:

    The Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell with the team from the Hillview Seventh Day Adventist Church at the finish line 15 January 2017 at eh Western Esplanade.

    With constituent Eunice Johnson of Eastwood at the finish line of the Marathon on the Western Esplanade in Nassau 15 January 2017.

    Sunshine Chairman Franklyn Wilson with the Foreign Minister at the finish line of the Sunshine Marathon 2017 and a representative from the United Kingdom.  The runner made it back in just about three hours and thirty minutes.  A respectable time.  At the Western Esplanade in Nassau 15 January.

    Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell with Anisca Lundy, a constituent, who at the finish line at the Western Esplanade of the Sunshine Marathon was marketing the Banana Boat 50 plus sunscreen to Black people.  The Minister was given the gift of one. Even though Black people have dark skins, they still need the protection from the harmful rays of the sun.  The product is available in food stores like Super Valu.

    Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell with Leon Williams, CEO of BTC, the phone company, and a sponsor of the Sunshine Marathon 2017 at the finish line Western Esplanade in Nassau 15 January 2017.

    Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell with the runners from Italy at the finish line the Western Esplanade in Nassau for the Sunshine Marathon 2017.  Founder Franklyn Wilson is at the far left 15 January 2017.

    Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell with the runner from Brazil and his wife and daughter at the finish line Sunshine Marathon 2017 Western Esplanade in Nassau 5 January.

    The winning runner being presented with his trophy at the finish line of the Sunshine Marathon 2017 at the Western Esplanade 15 January 2017

    MP Leslie Miller at the finish line with BTC CEO Leon Williams, the co-sponsor of the Sunshine Marathon 2017 at the Western Esplanade in Nassau 15 January.

    Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell with Swiss runners at the finish line of the Sunshine Marathon2017 at the Western Esplanade in Nassau 15 January.

  • Fred Mitchell MP Fox Hill – Budget Debate 2017

    cialis sales times, viagra serif;”> 
    Video by C Allen Johnson

  • Intervention by Fred Mitchell MP Fox Hill – Budget Debate 2017

    discount cialis times, serif;”>Intervention by Fred Mitchell MP Fox Hill

    Minister of Foreign Affairs and Immigration

    Budget Debate 2017

    20 June 2017

    Check Against Delivery

    Tribute to Muhammad Ali, who was at the PLPs convention the first year that I spoke to the convention and who if he had arrived after I had spoken, would have left me with no audience.  Thankfully, he showed up just after I spoke to the audience was full.  Lynden Pindling jumped to his feet leading eh standing ovation.  He ran up to me to shake my hand and said: “My boy you are on your way.”

    Tribute to E Patrick Toothe Esq who was my pupil master and who died in April of this year.  I was unable to attend the service on 26 April but I wish to recognize his passing and to thank him for the training which he gave me as an attorney.  I extend my condolences to his family.

     

    I wish to say that just as I did in the Mid-Year Budget debate, I will lay a full copy of the review of the budget in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration on the table.  I do not propose to read the review of the figures.  I will however put them in the public domain by that device.

     

    Secondly, I have read the statement of the Opposition’s spokesman on Foreign Affairs the Member for St Anne’s.  The only reference that I saw to the Foreign Ministry’s work and that was tangential was that the Canadians had issued a further travel advisory for The Bahamas.

     

    We are aware of the advisory and of course it is regrettable that they felt the need to do so.  But as we have explained to the Bahamian public before advisories are not exceptional for any country.  The home governments have an obligation in law to say what they know about the safety and security of visitors to a country they’re visiting. 

     

    We can issue similar advisories about Canada and various neighbourhoods in Toronto I am sure.  We have done so with regard to the United States, particularly about Miami. After what happened in Orlando what would the Opposition’s spokesman have us do about that and what should we advise Bahamians about travelling to Orlando? I leave the point there, the answer is so obvious.

     

    We all continue to work hard to crack down on crime.

     

    I propose during this intervention to review some of the matters that have become public concerns about the work of the Ministry.  Seek to defend the budgetary allocations and the work we are called upon to do.

     

    I think the Ministry has performed well, given the fiscal challenges and difficulties from ordering toilet paper to having to replace a generator and all the bureaucracy and nightmare delays associated with it.  There is a creative fight in the bureaucracy over what some consider the over centralization that is occurring which tends toward less efficiency and not more.  The struggle continues.

     

    I wish to thank all those who work at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Department of Immigration both at home and abroad for their stellar work in the defence of this country.   Our team is led by Sheila Carey the Permanent Secretary, Sharon Haylock, the Director General, William Pratt, the Director of Immigration, William Nottage, Senior Policy Advisor on Immigration. They support a political team of me, the Parliamentary Secretary the MP for South Beach who has direct superintendence of the Detention Centre and The MP for South Andros who is the Ambassador to Caricom.

     

    I turn to Foreign Affairs

     

    On 12 June, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued the following statement:

    12 June 2016

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs expresses its sympathy to the people of the United States and the people of Florida and the city of Orlando, following the murders of 49 people in Orlando. Orlando is a city with which our country has significant trade and familial ties. The state of Florida is also our closest trading partner. In addition there are significant familial ties with Florida. Our offices in Florida will be monitoring events to ensure that Bahamians are afforded the legal protections in the state and in the city. A diplomatic note will be sent expressing the condolences from The Bahamas.

    End

     

    I have since issued a statement to the British expressing our sorrow and support following the assassination of a British MP, caused it appears by hatred because of her views in the referendum campaign now being held in Britain.

     

    I want to thank the MP for Elizabeth for his thoughtful statement delivered in this place last week when he said the following:

     
    Before concluding I want to speak briefly on the recent referendum. I am very disappointed in the results, in the way our people allowed phobias to complicate the issue. The inequalities on the transmission of citizenship are astonishing, and as a country, we are not in good company in this regard when compared to other countries around the world. I fear that we as a country and a people still may not have matured enough to make decisions in isolation for the betterment of the country, to reduce discrimination in the Bahamas. This was a matter of citizenship, nothing else.

     

    During the course of the campaign to amend the constitution, there was a campaign of deceit and misinformation in the country which was perhaps unprecedented.

    This was led largely by a group of clergymen who have simply disgraced themselves by the astonishing untruths which they perpetrated during the referendum campaign.  It was simply breathtaking.

    In a recent statement to the country, the Government was blamed for missteps in the process.  I reject that.  There can be no remedy for deceit other than truth.  The truth was plain to see but instead of the work of God being done, it appears the work of the devil has for the moment succeeded.

    While they crow from the rafters from stopping some shadowy hidden agenda, the people who have suffered are women and children, and the people of The Bahamas.  They have set us back a generation.  Aluta continua.

    I have called for them to find Christ and for them to apologize for that campaign of deceit.

     

    I repeat it here today.

     

    They blamed the United Nations.  False.  They blamed the yes campaigners.  False.  There is no one to blame really.  However, those who first practiced to deceive are now having to engage in tangled web  and blame others. 

     

    The results of the vote are what they are.  However, what concerns me now is the lingering hate which the debate has engendered and this is particularly against the backdrop of what just happened in the United States and the United Kingdom and how words of hate can lead to destructive behavior amongst the mentally ill and ignorant.

    People who are preachers should publicly separate themselves from violence and hate.

    This is a liberal democracy not a theocracy.  It is a secular state: where there is a separation from church and state.  Indeed the Judeo Christian tradition is to render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and unto God the things that our God’s.  You have to be careful how you trust theocracies when after all it was a theocratic power who handed Jesus Christ over to be crucified;  they were more interested in temporal power than in saving souls.

     

    I tell the story of the appearance on the radio after I said the preachers must find Christ. After telling them to find Christ, they went into full attack mode.   In defending themselves though, Jesus Christ was not mentioned once, not one soul did they seek to save; they not ask one soul to come to Christ. Busy talking about me and bashing me. Not turning the other check out straight out bashing.

     

    I say to them their role is to preach the gospel every day and sometimes use words. In other words, you should live the gospel.

     

    The gospel says all have sinned and come short of the glory of God.

     

    We have a substantial job to do in this society to separate ourselves from hate and violence.  It consumes us too often every day.  You will remember that two people were killed in Adderley Street in the Fox Hill community last week.  On the day that occurred a voice note went around saying something like this; “Bey! One nigga just put three in Smokie”

    There was a survey done at one of our local primary schools, here is the results of that survey:

    A sample of 212 students was surveyed from Grades 4.5 and 6 and the following results were produced:

    9 per cent of the students had lost a parent.  Of that group 70 per cent lost their father and 25 per cent lost their mother.

    How did their loved ones die?

    11 per cent of murder

    12.5 per cent from accidents

     

    52 per cent of the students surveyed and witnessed domestic violence

    20 per cent have a parent living in another country

    36 per cent experienced separation or divorce

    44 per cent had heard a gunshot

    35 per cent knows someone who owns a gun

    38 per cent have seen a gun

     

    Remember these are students not yet 12 years old.

     

    The violence is caused by a number of other faults.

    The lack of social skills for example.  One of the coaches at a high school told me the story of how appalled he was listening to a student athlete talk to a potential school coach in the US about a prospect of being given a scholarship opportunity.  This what he said to the US coach:

    “Ya… you get my numbers right? Just hit me up.  Let me know what’s good  but I ga be right here”

     

    Our country interrelates with the wider world.  We  cannot survive without the wider world.  Therefore I found the demonizing of the United Nations and other international institutions in the recent campaign to be puerile and just plain silly and ill advised.

    As Minister I defend our membership.

    Most of our people want to travel to the United States. That is a very legalistic country.  The United States exercises extra territorial influence and jurisdiction over many parts of our lives whether we like it or not.  It is the United States government that said that  rights trump culture.   So we can sit here and stew in our own fat or if we want to engage with the wider world, we had better get with the programme.

    The US has their responsibilities too. From a foreign affairs perspective, we follow what is going on in the US.  The statement indicates that we were concerned about the violence in Orlando because Bahamians frequent that city.   We also intervened with public statements in the Black Lives matter campaign because our young Black males go to the United States and if racial prejudice is being expressed in the United States against young Black males, then Bahamian young males ought to be warned and advised.

    The US has to resolve the issue of guns and gun trafficking as it wreaks havoc in our societies.   I think we have a thoughtful administration in the United States, headed by quiet a thoughtful leader Barak Obama.

     

    Recently he visited Hiroshima, the city which was the object of the first atomic weapon. The York Times columnist Thomas Friedman said this about that visit in his column 15 June: 

    “Hiroshima, Obama suggested, represents a world in which for the first time ever a country possessed the power to kill all of us — and if it had to be any country, I am glad it was America. But today, he said, we’re entering a world where small groups — maybe even soon a single super-empowered person — will be able to kill all of us; therefore we’d better start thinking about the moral implications of where technology is taking us.

    “Science allows us to communicate across the seas and fly above the clouds, to cure disease and understand the cosmos, but those same discoveries can be turned into ever more efficient killing machines,” the president noted. “The wars of the modern age teach us this truth. Hiroshima teaches this truth. Technological progress without an equivalent progress in human institutions can doom us. The scientific revolution that led to the splitting of an atom requires a moral revolution as well.”

    Mr. Friedman goes on:

    “And the only thing that can stop them is from the inside: a meaningful mass movement by Muslim governments, clergymen and citizens to delegitimize this behavior. It takes a village and only stops when the village clearly says, “No more!” And that has not happened at the scale and consistency it needs to happen.”

     

    Frank Bruni New York Times 16 June wrote about the fact that there is a responsibility to treat people with respect and dignity, and to acknowledge their existence not treat them as if they don’t exists because you don’t identify with who they are.  He said that even the church in Orlando refused to recognize  that it was LGBT people who got killed in Orlando.

     

    Here is what he wrote 15 June in the New York Times:

    …There were exceptions, including Bishop Robert Lynch of St. Petersburg, Fla., who wrote a blog post in which he conceded that religion, including Catholicism, “often breeds contempt for gays, lesbians and transgender people,” and that this contempt can lead to violence. Lynch stressed that the Orlando victims “were all made in the image and likeness of God.”

    “We teach that,” Lynch wrote. “We should believe that. We must stand for that.”

     

    Peter Bergen New York Times “Why do terrorists commit terrorism?” wrote on 15 June:

    “These stories underline how hard it is to satisfactorily answer the question of why terrorists commit heinous crimes. Human motivations are complex. As the philosopher Immanuel Kant observed, “From the crooked timber of humanity not a straight thing was ever made.” It’s a useful reminder to journalists and politicians alike that human beings often defy neat categorization.

     

    Finally, the Editorial New York Times Threat To Gay Americans:

    16 June

     

    “While the precise motivation for the rampage remains unclear, it is evident that Mr. Mateen was driven by hatred toward gays and lesbians. Hate crimes don’t happen in a vacuum. They occur where bigotry is allowed to fester, where minorities are vilified and where people are scapegoated for political gain. Tragically, this is the state of American politics, driven too often by Republican politicians who see prejudice as something to exploit, not extinguish.”

    Mr. Speaker what in my respectful view happened in The Bahamas is that a minority was demonized and dehumanized in this country to frighten people into  voting against the rights of women.

     

    I say again, that is not something to be proud about because the only ones who will suffer are women and their spouses, their children and men and their spouses.  The bills were simply about giving men and women the same rights in the constitution.

    You know that the Roman Catholic Archbishop can’t speak to doctrine unless the Pope approves. That institution is also a legalistic institution going back hundreds of years.  Episcopal to a fault.  The Roman Catholic church in The Bahamas therefore could not support any measure in this country which would  support same sex marriage. They are implacably opposed to same sex marriage.  Yet the word of the unschooled was preferred to the word of the Catholic Archbishop.  Things get curiouser and curiouser.

     

    The extent of the deceit goes further than the errant clergymen. Here was Bran McCartney who claims that he voted because Dame Joan Sawyer said so.  With respect, every who is in the know, knows that Dame Joan Sawyer has been overturned by the Privy Council more times than the garbage can outside my yard

     

    The Leader of the DNA Branville McCartney admits that he voted against the bills even though he supports same sex marriage called civil unions.  Here is what he told The Tribune 15 June:

    “I think people should have rights but that’s a very touchy situation and something I can’t see happening right now, civil unions and gay marriage. For me personally, when it comes to marriage I have a difficulty. But we must always be careful with rights for people.”

     

     “I have many friends who are lesbians and gays. It’s the world we live in. I pray to the Almighty that we exercise tolerance and we don’t put ourselves in the seat of judgment and we are not there to judge anybody. We cannot be judge and jury because they may have a different way of life. We should not discriminate against a person because he is gay.”

     

    So now having done the damage and voted no, he now says mea culpa.  We now know that was not the reason at all.  The only people though who suffer are not him but the women of our country and their children.

     

     

     

    The Leader of the Opposition in this matter was the most remarkable.  It can best be described as hiding in the tall grass as soon as the gun was fired.

     

    Let me remind him of the policy of the FNM  on these matters.

     

    Here is what Hubert Ingraham had to say on the subject. That statement by the then Prime Minister has not been controverted by any government in this country since then but it certainly has not been controverted by any leader of the FNM since then.

    8th March 1998:

    “I believe that the hysteria being created by certain individuals against gay persons visiting The Bahamas and who represents themselves as the leadership of the Christian Council, is becoming irresponsible. I believe that the hysteria is, as is usually the case with hysteria, unfounded. It is also un-Christian.

    “An individual’s right to privacy is a basic human right cherished by all people. It is a right which citizens of democratic countries expect to be respected by their Government. Quite simply, it is not the role of the Government to investigate and pass judgment on the sexual behavior of consenting adults so long as their activity is conducted in private.

    “Whether a private sexual act between consenting adults is homosexual or heterosexual is not my business, and I do not think it is your business either. We cannot, and ought not try, to dictate or to legislate morality. In any event, all past efforts to do so have always failed miserably. A good example is the success of the laws against adultery. Certainly, adultery is a far greater threat to a Bahamian family life today than is homosexuality. Could we build a jail large enough to house all Bahamian adulterers? Could we exclude all other adulterers from tourists welcomed in The Bahamas. Should we exclude them?”

    That was Hubert Ingraham.

     

    Fred Mitchell in Trinidad

    6 February 2014

     

    Nothing is more contentious than this issue in our politics that I now raise, given the religious aversion, and visceral reactions to discussion of LGBT issues in our region. Some people see it as striking at the very heart and fabric of our cultural identity. The Bahamas is not an exception to that aversion with many people seeing the discussion as a moral and religious one and not a human rights one. My own political career suffers because of my insistence that in this regard like all other aspects of human life, there must be tolerance at a minimum and we must uphold the principle that the general rights for which we fought as being rights for all people, particularly as a formerly enslaved and indentured people, cannot be derogated from because of someone’s sexual orientation. In other words, when the Charter in Article III says:

    “States shall, in the discharge of their legislative, executive administrative and judicial functions ensure respect for and protection of the human dignity of every person.”

    That in my view means literally every person and not just confined to what Article V says:

    “ No person shall be favoured or discriminated against by reason of age, colour, creed, disability, ethnicity, gender, language, place of birth or origin, political opinion, race, religion or social class.”

    The Charter is a 1997 document so orientation was not included and perhaps even in today’s atmosphere cannot be included but the conversation has begun and the pressure from other societies with whom we deal is upon us to consider what our stand is on the rights of all people. Do we as a society for example condone violence against people simply because of their sexual orientation? The answer to that must be no. And if the answer is not no to that, then the charter is not worth the paper it is written on.

    The Prime Ministers of Barbados Freundel Stuart and Dr. Denzil Douglas of St Christopher and Nevis have begun public discussions of these issues in their societies. The Prime Minister of Barbados even challenged the Anglican Church on the subject at their provincial synod. That was right and just. The Bahamas has decriminalized behavior associated with sexual orientation.

    We have available in aid and comfort to any change to amplify the discrimination provision in the Charter, the constitution of South Africa which admits to orientation as one of the named classes for which there can be no discrimination. There are profound changes throughout the United States and Europe our main trading and cultural partners on this issue. It would be unwise to ignore it.

    I often find that in drafting solutions to contentious problems that one solution is a generic one. One solution is that the Charter can become justiciable with enforceable rights across the community. Less coercively, it can be open to the Caribbean Court of Justice as the final arbiter of Community Law to adjudicate upon the Charter and declare the rights of individuals for any aggrieved individual seeking an opinion from the court declaring his rights and the wording of the provision at Article V can be reworded to read:

    “ No person shall be favoured or discriminated against by reason of including but not limited to the following: age, colour, creed, disability, ethnicity, gender, language, place of birth, origin, political opinion, race, religion, social class or some other characteristic which in the opinion of the Court deserves special protection.”

    Of course the short way to deal with this is simply to add orientation as one of the listed characteristics. I have no remit to pronounce on that, however and I do not do so.

    What is important is that our leaders have already begun the conversation and that conversation should continue. That conversation should be underpinned with the principles of tolerance and the protection of the law for another disadvantaged group.

    The late Myles Munroe went ballistic.  Never understanding what was being said

     

    Against that backdrop then do I wish to defend Dame Anita Allen in the face of the withering criticism in response to her thoughtful address at the College of the Bahamas.  Here is a Judge, doing what judges do all the time and that is in an academic setting to discuss the  pertinent legal issues of the day.  Her speech was thoughtful and useful.  Yet the backlash from the same group now, embarrassed that they find themselves on the wrong side of history.

    Here is what the Bahamas Information Services said about her remarks:

    “Dame Anita remarked that no provision of the Marriage Act provides that the purpose of marriage is exclusively between a man and a woman.

    “She said arguably, the laws of The Bahamas do not discriminate on the basis of sex and facilitate not only marriages of every description but also consummation of the same.

    “If indeed there is not law which embodies a qualification that parties to an intended marriage must be respectively male and female, then arguably same sex, transgender or inter sex couples could not legally be refused authorization to marry in either a civil or religious ceremony. And if refused, may well be entitled to mandamus ordering the relevant officials to grant them permission to marry,” she said.

     

    There is no reason in law for her to recuse herself from anything.  There is no case before her. She has not pronounced any result, nor fettered her discretion, nor is she involved in self-dealing.

     

    The reason I have gone this route is  to ask respectfully these preachers to step back from hatred and division and seek to restore love and peace in this society. And they may say they don’t preach hate. It’s not what you say, it’s how you say it, and the clear intent to is to demonize a minority group for political gain only because you don’t want women to have equal rights.  It is the modern equivalent of what led to the death of Thomas Becket when Henry II said: Who will rid me of this bothersome priest” Henry’s men took that as a signal that the King wanted Becket killed and they killed him.

    I say to them preach love and not hate.

    I implore them to preach love and not hate.

    Tolerance and not prejudice.

    Support the rights of women.

     

    While in the Dominican Republic last week, I was surprised to find that a member of the LGBT community was in the DR invited by the Organization of American States to represent the civil society of the Bahamas.  She made an impassioned plea for tolerance.

    She said how  people from her community in The Bahamas were being expelled from their parent’s homes, fired from their jobs, stripped of their dignity by constant taunting in school and at work and on the playing field. That the community is paying for a safe house  to ensure that people who find themselves expelled or disposed because of their orientation are properly housed.  Talked about the stigma associated with  obtaining medical treatment from health care professionals in the country because of moral judgments being made.

     

    I understand all of that. But my main concern is that the demonizing of any group of people must stop and the preachers must step back from their hate, intended or not. Martin Luther King said all that counts is the content of your character.  The message of hate has gone forth and they must instead preach love.  They must find Christ.

     

    I ask myself do these preachers actually look around and see who is in their churches.  Do they look to the left and  to the right?  Do they think that if these people decided to leave their churches they could survive a Sunday service.  Probably be no music for church.

    I say preach love, not hate.

    Mr. Speaker, the MP for Ft. Charlotte sent out a Facebook Message last evening which urged people to protest because he claims that there might be a secret deal to give economic citizenship to Chinese  in The Bahamas.

     

    Here is what he said:

    We know that the voices of the Bahamian people are powerful, whenever Bahamians decide to use them. However, there is no stronger message to any government than when its citizens decide to act en masse in voice and in deed.

    I urge all patriotic and concerned Bahamians to email, message, text or call all PLP members of parliament, especially Prime Minister Christie, and PLP Chairman Bradley B Roberts insisting that the government disclose ALL of the details surrounding the list of DEMANDS put to them by the Chinese investors and the terms of the DEAL they have agreed to sign with those Chinese investors.

    The GIVEAWAYS being negotiated include hundreds of economic citizenships, tax exemptions valued in the billions of dollars, thousands of acres of crown land, hundreds of work permits etc. Once PLP government officials hear your outcry, they will be forced to cancel a terribly bad deal that absolutely does not serve our national interest and that our country simply cannot afford.

    Do not believe that you can just wait until the general elections to take action. By that time it will be too late. The damage will have already been done. Some of the PLP parliamentarians and groups here on Facebook that you can contact include: Pinewood Pride, Jerome Fitzgerald, Ryan Pinder,Ken Dorsett Southern Shores, Kendal V O Major, Philip Brave Davis, CV Hope Strachan Seabreeze, Plp Women’s-Branch New-Providence, Plp Fox Hill Branch, Arnold Forbes, Michael Darville, Alex Storr, Young Liberals

     

    It has come to the point where these kinds of falsehoods  are trotted around lightly.  It was started by a talk show host and continues to have currency.

     

    First I intervened just as I did in this statement about prejudice and racism.  Instead of joining me in that call, the Opposition’s spokesman on Foreign Affairs said I was being hypocrite because I called them out for being anti-Bahamian.  But while he is entitled to that opinion about my words, I only want to know does he condemn racism.

     

    I again urge caution about racism in the public discourse.  Money has no colour and the history of this is quite clear, the Chinese investment came here with the welcome mat of Hubert Ingraham of the FNM, the conditions under which they came here were also negotiated by Mr. Ingraham and approved by him.

     

    There is no special magic in Bahamar’s failure. The developer proved he could not manage his business, he failed to pay the bank and the bank foreclosed. The bank is now a mortgagee in possession with a receiver in charge The Bank can sell it to whom they want. 

     

    The House will remember that long ago, the Government announced that economic citizenship was not a policy of this administration.  That continues to be the policy.  In order for that to change, it would require legislation.  That is simply not going to happen.

     

    The current law is that you have to reside in The Bahamas for at least 7 years before you can apply for citizenship of the Bahamas.  There are a number of ancillary  matters which you have to fulfill before you can do so, none of them have to do with how much money you invest in the country.  They all have to do with are you in fact a Bahamian in spirit and in truth.

     

    The truth then is there is no truth to the assertion of the MP on the matter of economic citizenship.

     

    Some of the press have asked about the Dominican Republic and the talks with the Government there.  The matter of the exchange of gunfire was discussed with the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the DR. He spoke immediately with the Commandant of their Navy.  The navy said that they received a report about the incident from the fishing company concerned and an investigation is underway.  Once that investigation is done then the results of the report will be shared with us. 

     

    The point I make though is not what the DR does is that we do.  We should enforce our laws with strength and vigour.  The RBDF has the equipment to do so  and the rules of engagement allow them to use weapons when  the call for force is necessary.

    I want to draw your attention to the section in the report on the passport office.  The passport office faces a number of challenges which means there is significant backlog for passports.  This is a combination of equipment breakdowns, transition to new equipment, lack of resources and manpower, the demand for the e passport.   The wait is now eight weeks.  The passport can be expedited with the payment of the 200 dollar fee.

     

    This fee cannot be waived by the minister.  The fee can only be waived on the grounds of medical emergency or student returning to school.

    Please plan your trips accordingly.

     

    I wish the public to be aware of the issues around US visas.  We are concerned about the anecdotal reports of arbitrary and capricious refusals of visas by personnel in the US consular section.   The Bahamas Ministry of Foreign Affairs cannot address individual complaints.  US Visa decisions are subjective.  But we have raised the concern that people who have been traveling all along unimpeded suddenly seem for no obvious reason to fall afoul of their decision making.  This has caused us concern.  We are in touch with US authorities about these concerns.

     

    I want to issue some advice especially to parents of high school aged athletes.  The US Embassy has told us that the rejection rate of applicants from this age group is about fifty percent.  It has raised the question in their offices about visa fraud.  The problem appears to be that some schools that students are applying for are not acceptable.  They have been engaged in practices which appear to violate trafficking in person’s laws.  They give students the promise of scholarships and then when the students get there their passports are withheld, the students have to work for their keep, their passports are withdrawn and they are withheld from access to their parents. 

     

    We are asking parents to exercise in light of those facts a great degree of caution in promoting the applications of students to these schools in the US.

     

    Before leaving Foreign Affairs, I would point out the allocation for UN Peace Keeping.  Last year this was inexplicably not included in the list of payees and we found out mid-year that we owed some 3 million dollars for UN Peacekeeping.  The allocation this year is 1.2  million and this is meant to help reduce that bill.

     

    In turning to Immigration, the issue I think is the fact that we got 1.5 million dollars last year for the Budget for repatriation.  This year that has been cut to 800,000.  We have made it clear that this is insufficient given that  we have spent 1.7 million this year and there is every indication that the migrant population is increasing, particularly from Cuba.   We have been assured that we will get the money we need and get it expeditiously.

     

    Further, the public should be advised that there is an uptick in the number of Cuban detainees coming through The Bahamas.  These people present serious security challenges for the detention centre.  We are working with the Cuban authorities to find more effective ways to move them out of The Bahamas and return them home.

     

    I have read the comments of the MP for Elizabeth on the services for work permits and permanent residence.  I agree with the complaints.  Efforts are being made to streamline the procedures and to make them more transparent.  I think that what is required is a substantial increase in the cost of permanent residence in  particular and I intend to make recommendations on this shortly.

     

    Finally, I wish to address the people of Fox Hill to whom I shall be asking for their support for the fourth consecutive time.

    I think that we have found the resources to substantially complete the Community Centre which has been used by the community since 2007.

     I hope that you are happy with my leadership and satisfied that I have done the best I could in trying circumstances to warrant re-election. I have tried to remain in touch.

    I will be dedicating the next campaign to the fight for women’s rights. Having seen what happened in the last referendum campaign I am more convinced than ever that there is a need to address this issue.  The issue is not just about the legal rights of women but about their self-image and self-esteem. I am concerned that the Euro centric interests are so dominant that it disfigures Black women and this should stop.  Young Black girls should know and appreciate their bodies and faces and see them in a positive image and likeness and not try to reach some ideal which does not exist and which is harmful to their self-esteem and this includes their hair.

    I say this against the backdrop of the work which women do in the politics of our country.  Like the church,  the politics of the country could not survive without the work and support of women. I pledge the remainder of my public life in that fight.

     

    At the same time, I am concerned that the little boys and young men in Fox Hill should be taught their role as protectors and keepers of the peace, not to create havoc and war. 

     

    This must start when the children are in primary school.  That is why so many of the resources of the state are spent on primary school education.  We still need at Sandilands Primary a pre-school.  This is a priority for me. Education generally is the key to forward progress.  I thank my colleague the Minister of Education for all the support given to the three schools n Fox Hill Doris Johnson,  L W Young and Sandilands Primary. The three principals James Clarke, Janet Nixon and Esther Cartwright.

     

    I single out Mrs. Nixon who will with the close of the school year end 45 years as an educator, the last 7 of them as Principal of the LW Young School. I thank her for her leadership and I wish her well in her future endeavours.

     

    I dedicate all that I do to find work for young men and women who bear the brunt of unemployment.  I dedicate my every working hour to addressing this problem.

     

    It is left only for me to say God Bless the Commonwealth of The Bahamas.  I will support these Budget resolutions.

     

    I now lay the report on the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration.

    end

  • The Bahamas to Host Ministerial Meeting on Education of the OAS in 2017

    1 Minister shaking hand of sec gen OAS after signing agreement in Washington

    2 Minister Fitzgerald Signs OAS Agreement to Host 2017 Ministerial Meeting on Education

    4 Minister speaking at roundtable on education OAS Washington

    buy viagra times;”>WASHINGTON, cialis usa D.C. April 29th, 2016. The Organization of American States (OAS) and The Bahamas signed an agreement at the OAS Headquarters by which the country was selected to host the next meeting of Ministers of Education of the Americas, on February 9 and 10, 2017 in The Bahamas.

    The signing took place last week during a Roundtable on Education in the Americas meeting, hosted by the OAS, where experts debated:

    • The common educational agenda of the member states

    • The role of teachers

    • Science and technology as catalysts for education and life opportunities.

    The event was opened by the Assistant Secretary General of the OAS, Nestor Mendez, and the Executive Secretary for Integral Development, Neil Parsan.

    Presentations were made by:

    • The Minister of Education of Panama and Chair of the Inter-American Committee on Education (CIE), The Hon. Marcela Paredes de Vásquez

    • The Minister of Education, Science & Technology, Bahamas, The Hon Jerome K. Fitzgerald

    • The President of the Caribbean Knowledge and Learning Network Agency (CKLNA), Kenneth Sylvester

    • The Principal Specialist of Economic Investigation at the Inter-American Development Bank, Samuel Berlinski

    • The representative of REDUCA, David Calderón

    • The General Director for Teacher Training of the Ministry of Education of Bolivia, Fernando Carrión

    The event was broadcast live on the OAS Website.

    After signing the document and accepting the position of host of the next Ministerial Meeting, Minister Fitzgerald noted that it was an honor to be nominated and elected as Chair of the Inter-American Committee on Education (CIE) and host for the upcoming meeting, and emphasized that for The Bahamas, “education and human development remain the most important ingredients for sustainable progressive economic and social development.” The Secretary General of the OAS, Luis Almagro, highlighted that “education is key to social mobility, inclusion and a more cohesive society.”

    Minister Fitzgerald currently serves as Chair of the 19th Conference of Commonwealth Education Ministers (19CCEM) and recently hosted the very successful meeting of ministers in June of 2015; the Minister will therefore simultaneously serve as Chair for two international organizations.

    Photo Captions:
    1. Minister Fitzgerald shaking hands with OAS Secretary General after signing agreement to host the 2017 Ministerial Meeting on Education. Pictured L to R: The Hon. Jerome K. Fitzgerald, Minister of Education, Science and Technology, Bahamas; Elliston Rahming, Ambassador, Permanent Representative of The Bahamas to the OAS; Luis Almagro, OAS Secretary General [Photo credit: Juan Manuel Herrera / OAS].

    2. Minister Fitzgerald and Luis Almagro, Secetary General, OAS, signing agreement for Bahamas to host the 2017 Ministerial Meeting. Pictured L to R: Elliston Rahming, Ambassador, Permanent Representative of The Bahamas to the OAS;

    The Hon. Jerome K. Fitzgerald, Minister of Education Science and Technology, Bahamas; Luis Almagro, OAS Secretary General; Juan José Arcuri, Chair of the OAS Permanent Council and Permanent Representative of Argentina to the OAS [Photo credit: Juan Manuel Herrera / OAS].

    3. Minister Fitzgerald addressing the audience during the Roundtable on Education in the Americas meeting, hosted by the OAS on April 27th – 29th, 2016 [Photo credit: Juan Manuel Herrera / OAS].

    4. Minister Fitzgerald pictured with other country representatives at the Roundtable on Education in the Americas meeting, hosted by the OAS on April 27th – 29th, 2016 [Photo credit: Filipe Major].