Tag: privilege

  • GOING TO AMERICA IS A RIGHT NOT JUST A PRIVILEGE

    GOING TO AMERICA IS A RIGHT NOT JUST A PRIVILEGE

    The United States Secretary of State Marco Rubio who is the son of immigrants to the United States, who exercised their right to leave Cuba and come to the US to raise their family including him, now says that there is no entitlement to get a visa to visit the US. It is a privilege extended to others who respect their US laws.

    On one level that sounds fine, assuming that the laws are applied in an objective fashion, and without prejudice and discrimination.  The problem is that U S laws are not rational and therefore are in conflict with the universal declaration of human rights that gives the right of anyone to leave their country and while not saying so explicitly, the corollary is that you have the right to enter another country provided you respect the process of entry.

    The United States is a powerful military behemoth and economic hegemon.  The Bible says that the U S (and these day they say they follow the Bible):  to whom much is given, much is expected. The problem is that the US is now is failing that test as well.

    The hostility toward immigrants is not a good thing.  It betrays the greatness of the country that was founded on the invasion of another people’s land, herded and killed those people and created a new state with high ideals.

    Today does that new country actually live up to those high ideals when it appears to be acting in an irrational and arbitrary and prejudiced fashion?

    The Secretary ought to think on these things.

    Number of hits for the week ending on Saturday 19 April 2025 up to midnight: 724,973;

    Number of hits for the month of April 2025 up to Saturday 19 April 2025 up to midnight: 1,917,817;

    Number of hits for the year 2025 up to Saturday 19 April 2025 up to midnight: 1,917,817;

  • Mitchell Again On Parliamentary Privilege

    https://youtu.be/dAD54L8axYE
    Captured by C Allen Johnson

    Editor’s note: there are transmission blips at the start which correct themselves after approximately 30 to 60 seconds. We apologise. The text appears below.

    Statement to the House by
    Fred Mitchell MP Fox Hill
    15 August 2016
    On A Point of Privilege

    Check against delivery

    Joseph Darville writing in the press this morning and in a note sent to my e mail address has appealed to you as Speaker to stop what he says is “ madness”, cialis sale that is the attempt inter alia to cause the officers of Save The Bays and their Attorneys to be summoned before the Parliament for contempt.

    Firstly as I recall it, sildenafil there is no such order by you.

    He is wrong in that respect.

    He is also wrong in seeking to cast what has happened with this matter as some crusade for the privacy of citizens of The Bahamas.

    That is not only wrong but foolish and disingenuous.

    This matter has gone way beyond the private legal action of Joseph Darville and Fred Smith. A judge of the Supreme Court has ruled that Members of Parliament can be injuncted from speaking in the House of Assembly. That is what this is about.

    So suddenly, the defenders of freedom of speech are fine on freedom of speech so long as freedom of speech is defended for everyone except Members of Parliament.

    The matters about which he complains have been lawfully referred to the Committee on Privileges which is now fully constituted and can sit to adjudicate the complaints of the Members of Parliament.

    I remind everyone that the constitution gives Parliament the power to define the extent of the privileges of Members.
    Parliament has done that. That definition says that no sanction whether criminal or civil can arise from what is said in this place by members of parliament. For a judge to give permanent injunction saying that Members cannot speak about certain matters is anathema and not correct in law. It is also outside of the scope of the Judge’s power. To give effect to this injunction would be to give this judge the authority to in effect injunct Parliament and prevent it meeting.
    Members of Parliament are bound to stand up to this. Parliament must renounce and dismiss this without equivocation.

    In law and as it pertains to this matter, the Speaker is functus officio. Meaning that, having sent this matter to the Committee on Privilege the Speaker is relieved of any further action on the matter until the Committee reports. The matter cannot be called back to the Speaker, as Mr. Darville seems to think.

    When a matter comes before the House, the Speaker takes a look and reviews the documents and decides whether its probative worth outweighs its prejudicial value. The power to make this decision is in the exclusive domain of the Speaker. In the case of the e mails, he determined its probative worth and in the larger public interest and tabled the e mailsMr. Darville and his compatriots ought to respect the ruling and the Speaker and move on.

    Secondly, the matter was referred by resolution of the House to the Committee on Privileges so in any event it cannot be overruled by any other authority. Proceedings of the House are not subject to Judicial Review, this is an established necessity in order for the doctrine of the separation of powers to have its intended effect.

    The public needs to be reminded that MPs of Parliament uncovered what they in their own deliberate judgment saw was a plot by rich foreigners connected with Louis Bacon to use the law firm of Callenders and Co in which Fred Smith Q C is a partner to pass the sum of 8 million dollars through that firm in the space of a number of months to destabilize the government of The Bahamas. Those MPs thought in the interest of the sovereignty of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas the matter should be brought to Parliament. That is the privileges that Members of Parliament enjoy.

    That is also what this is about. The Committee has the power of summons, and witnesses are obliged to appear, in order to get to the bottom of that.

    No member of parliament has violated any law to bring these matters to the House. As poorly written as the Judgment is, not even the Judge could find that as a fact.

    It is my hope that every person involved will do their best to cooperate with the so as to bring this matter to a speedy conclusion.

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

  • Parliamentary Privilege Row Makes The Gleaner

    generic cialis times, serif;”>This editorial appeared in the Jamaica Gleaner 10 August:

    The Bahamas is exercised by a constitutional row that is not only likely to go all the way to the Privy Council, but, depending on its outcome, could have profound implications for the privileges legislators enjoy in that country’s Parliament, as well as the right of citizens to protect their privacy.

    That, though, may only be the beginning, should those who instigated the case prevail. They won the first round in the local Supreme Court. Ultimate victory would probably open the door to recourse by people who believe they have been defamed in Parliament. And the impact would probably not be limited to the Bahamas, but spread to jurisdictions with similar Westminster-style constitutions, including Jamaica’s.

    The issue involves an environmental organisation called Coalition for the Protection of Clifton Bay, but generally referred to as Save the Bays (STB). It generally agreed to be funded by wealthy residents of the Bahamas, but mostly by the private foundation of the billionaire hedge fund manager, whose brother is a leading figure behind Save the Bays.

    But, more significantly, the Progressive Liberal Party (PLP) of Prime Minister Perry Christie perceives STB as not being genuinely concerned with the issue it says it stands for, but operates as a sort of political action group, in league with the PLP’s opponents.

    In mid-March, a PLP MP and Cabinet minister read in the House private emails from STB members, purporting to establish a pattern of behaviour against the government. Earlier, another government MP, Fred Mitchell, gave the legislature information about the STB’s financial affairs. The group believed that the information was hacked from its systems, as well as from the computer of its legal adviser, Fred Smith.

    Significantly, Justice Indra Charles issued the STB applicant and Mr Smith a temporary injunction, barring disclosure or publication, including in parliament, of private information belonging to the group, setting off a firestorm of criticism from legislators, including a threat to bring Justice Charles before Parliament for possible censure. Last week, Justice Charles, after a full hearing of the case, made the injunction permanent. 

    INFRINGEMENT OF THE CONSTITUTION

    Legislators believe that that ruling represents an infringement of the constitution and the efficacy of Parliament to do its work, unfettered by other branches of government, and thereby an erosion of the separation of powers.

    The important thing here is that Section 53 of the Bahamian constitution allows Parliament, by law, to “determine the privileges, immunities and powers of the Senate and the House of Assembly and the members thereof”.

    The Bahamas Parliament Powers and Privileges Act says that parliamentarians enjoy the same immunities and privileges as members of the UK Parliament, but states further: “No civil or criminal proceedings may be instituted against any senator or member for words spoken before, or written in a report to, the Senate or the House, respectively, or a committee, or by reason of any matter or thing so brought by him by petition, bill, motion or otherwise.”

    The wording in the Bahamian act is similar, not exact, to the construction of Section 48(3) of the Jamaican Constitution, under which parliamentarians have, up to now, enjoyed an umbrella of absolute privilege, such as when, in the 1980s, the then prime minister, Edward Seaga, accused a young foreign service officer, Leonard Burey, who was never charged with a crime, of conspiracy to murder as part of a Cuban-Soviet plot.

    However, in the Bahamian case, Justice Charles agreed with the claimants that parliamentary privilege is not absolute and that it is bound to respect the privacy of individuals.

  • The Video Of The House Presentations On Privilege

    generic viagra times, serif;”>(Captured by C Allen Johnson)

    Speaker Dr. Kendal Major

    Fred Mitchell MP

    Jerome Fitzgerald MP

    Gregory K Moss MP