Equal Protection, Different Solutions

ABAGAIL CARTWRIGHT FROM DEAN S BLUE HOLE

The fire in South Andros last week, from which a 74-year-old woman, Ms. Forbes, narrowly escaped injury, again raises a troubling question about the availability of essential services throughout our archipelago.

Ms. Forbes believes her residence and belongings could have been saved had a fire truck been available. Earlier this year, a similar incident occurred at the Fish Fry in Nicholls Town, where a fire truck was reportedly present but inoperable.

Coupled with unreliable mailboat services in Long Island and recurring flooding in Pinewood, these incidents raise a fundamental question: What minimum level of public service should every Bahamian be entitled to, regardless of where they live?

The Bahamas faces a unique geographical challenge. Our scattered population and the limited economies of some islands make duplicating New Providence’s infrastructure financially impractical. Yet geography should never determine the value of a Bahamian life.

A fire truck is essential, but purchasing one is only the beginning. Maintenance, equipment and trained personnel carry recurring costs. Should every inhabited island have identical resources, or should government explore innovative approaches that guarantee comparable protection?

Perhaps it is time to examine how other archipelagic nations address similar challenges and duplicate those models. Could smaller, specially equipped emergency-response vehicles, community-based firefighting teams or shared maintenance services provide affordable alternatives?

The gaps in critical services, particularly emergency response in the family islands have caused devastating consequences, and it is time for them to be addressed.

Government has a responsibility to serve every Bahamian, regardless of where they live. While we cannot reasonably duplicate everything available in New Providence, we must find practical, economically sustainable ways to close these gaps.

Our geography may make public services expensive, but the real test of governance is not simply what we provide where most people live, but how well we protect those who live where few do.

-Abigail Cartwright

Similar Posts