The Central Bank and the banking sector of The Bahamas continue to lose their collective minds by announcing yet again that they propose to stop the use of cheques in The Bahamas. The government should move by legislation to prevent this, if the banks do not stop.
I have taken my leave of the public officials in Andros Town otherwise known as Fresh Creek after a successful meeting with PLP Branch officers at Brian Hew’s Lighthouse Club. Thank you to MP Leon Lundy, NGC Wayne Cleare and Chair Samantha Mackey. Good to see my old friend Bishop Raymond Mackey. 15 October 2024
The Central Bank announced on 3 October 2024, the first tentative steps at limiting the reliance on fees of banks charged by banks. This comes after public demands from Fred Mitchell, Chairman of the PLP, for transparency and accountability. These steps are simply not enough but they are a start. The public must continue to agitate for change and supervision:
The Central Bank has directed Supervised Financial Institutions (SFIs) to comply with the following directives, which will take place with immediate effect:
i. Provide customers with a minimum notice of 30 days of the schedule listing any variation in transaction fees or account charges to be imposed on any product or service, including but not limited to deposit accounts, credit facilities, or any payments-related transactions using cheques, credit cards, debit cards, and digital wallets.
ii. Provide customers with a schedule outlining the estimated or forecasted change in revenue associated with each varied fee or charge.
iii. Provide the Central Bank with the schedule of proposed variations in fees and forecasted revenues, a minimum of 60 days before the proposed change.
iv. Disclose or make readily available to customers the comparable schedule of the varied fees for the same or similar financial products at competitor institutions, as of the date of the notice.
The Central Bank of The Bahamas stated that the conditions of this direction shall take immediate effect for all SFIs.
Last week every damn fool who supports the idea of a cashless society should be doing penance this week, Because of some glitch in the systems of Microsoft, the whole platform of interconnections for business especially in the flying business collapsed. Flights in the thousands were cancelled worldwide and some banks could not operate their accounts. So much for digital transformation. We keep saying that while digital is fine when it works, sometimes it doesn’t work and in such times cash should be king. So while those who want to be digital can be digital, those who want to use cash should be able to do so and to write cheques. John Rolle who is leading the fool’s errand at the Central Bank of The Bahamas could only stand by helplessly last week to say that the Central Bank was watching the chaos. Fat lot of good that did.
Last week the tone deaf and dumb Central Bank was at it again pushing their agenda to abolish cheque writing. This time they published the results of a survey in which they said the people surveyed claimed that they can stop writing cheques by 2024 and don’t need to go until 2026. Let’s get this clear, this is a fool’s errand by the Central Bank. There is no need to fix what isn’t broken. It doesn’t matter what survey you come up with. Anyone can pay people to come up with the results you want. Leave cheque writing alone. Survey be damned.
File photo when the then Central Bank Governor Wendy Craigg announced on 10 June 2015 that the Central Bank was to regulate credit unions.
The eight Credit Unions in The Bahamas with a combined 350 million or so of assets under their control, are having an issue with the supervision of the Central Bank. The Bahamas decided that they would transfer the supervision of credit unions established under the cooperatives legislation to the Central Bank, to satisfy the demands of the Europeans and the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development that loose money was not being passed around without the developed world being able to monitor the funds. The Central Bank has since that time been trying to dissolve the credit unions, the eight of them and make them one. That is a nonstarter for the credit union movement. These credit unions were started with the funds of ordinary workers at various establishments and they are run well. There is no need to consolidate them. But as we see how badly the Central Bank allows consumers in banks to be treated in this country, so they are now attacking the credit unions. The PLP should not allow this to happen.
There is no secret that in this space we do not have any regard for the Central Bank and its management of the monetary system in our country. They do not do a good job at regulating the banking sector and protecting the Bahamian consumer. Services have deteriorated and prices have gone up and they have done nothing. They are trying to force everyone to go digital in a world where nothing digital works in The Bahamas. But it was a breath of fresh air then and to our surprise when last week the Central Bank announced that they were scrapping the deposit requirements for mortgages in The Bahamas. They had put them artificially high and the mortgage market had dried up as a result of it. You would have thought that the banks would welcome it. No can do. The banker’s immediate response was bah humbug, that it is was not going to make a difference, that we shouldn’t start celebrating. There is something wrong with this crabby commercial sector that we have.
We again call on the Central Bank to end the fool’s errand of seeking to abolish the use of cheques in The Bahamas. Here is the latest as reported by The Tribune 5 October 2023 from the Governor of the Central Bank John Rolle. We agree with Ethric Bowe, the Central Bank should do something else with your time and money and stop wasting time on that.
“We will share more details in our various surveys that provided public feedback soon,” Mr Rolle told this newspaper. “However, there was a compelling fraction of the public who wanted more time to transition away from cheques. The Central Bank and financial institutions will provide more details on what the interim milestones are that are being targeted for progress on payments system developments.”
#The Central Bank, in a release on the issue, said the deadline shift resulted from a “consensus” among members of the Steering Committee appointed to oversee the transition away from cheques that more time is needed to ready and educate Bahamians. The delay will also give Bahamian commercial banks and other financial providers more time to better roll-out the digital payments infrastructure that will replace cheques as a means of settling transactions.
Ethric Bowe, an engineer with multiple business interests including Advanced Technical Enterprises, an insurance agency/brokerage and a family farm, told Tribune Business “there was no purpose” to the year-end 2024 elimination target and the Central Bank should drop the idea “period”.
“That’s a good decision,” he added. “All they need to do is digitise the cheques. The same information you have on the cheque is the same information that you have on the debit and credit card. It doesn’t make sense.” eChecks have been a feature of the US financial system for several years, and Mr Bowe previously added: “Instead of moving away from cheques, they’re getting deeper into them. I think it’s [their elimination in The Bahamas] a bad plan.”
In the House of Assembly on Monday 24 April 2023, Fred Mitchell spoke on the debate on the Amendment to the Central Bank Act. He used it as an opportunity to send a direct but respectful message to the Central Bank to change course with regard to its regulation of the banking sector in The Bahamas. He spoke of the widespread dissatisfaction with the bank in its role as the regulator of banks.
Mr. Mitchell outlined a tale of woes. He said that over the past decade bank services had deteriorated. They had become more costly, less personal, de-Bahamianized and many communities in The Bahamas were effectively debanked. The Central Bank presided over all of this. He said that the Central Bank has hired a consultant to work for it for two years to teach us why we should not be writing cheques. He called this a fool’s errand.
He indicated that constituents were so angry about this that the legislature might have to intervene to solve it. However, the preferable method was for the banks to act along with the Central Bank to solve the problems.
So you would have thought we have the third most senior individual in the Government speaking to this matter, that the Central Bank would get the message and change course. Instead, there was a presser with the Governor of the Central Bank John Rolle, widely reported in the Nassau Guardian and elsewhere and the Central Bank is digging in its heels.
In a follow up note on Friday 5 May 2023, Mr. Mitchell spoke again and said since the Central Bank does not get it, push must come to shove and Bahamians will have to petition the Government through the House of Assembly to change the law.
We agree.
(Editor’s Note: Al Dillette previously supplied the figures for those who access this site. Alas he has passed away. Rest in peace) These newest stats continue in his honor.
Al Dillette Weekly Website Report:
Number of hits for the week ending Saturday, 6th May , 2023 up to midnight: 404,128; Number of hits for the month of May up to Saturday, 6th May, 2023 up to midnight; 404,128; Number of hits for the year 2023 up to Saturday, 6th May, 2023 up to midnight: 7,331,122.
While the services to consumers in the country from the banks deteriorate, the Central Bank is on a fool’s errand. It is not looking out for consumers but is now going to hire a consultant and a public relations woman to convince us on why we should not be writing cheques over the next two years. This should be stopped dead in its tracks as a complete waste of money. Foolishness.
The Tribune reported last week that the Central Bank has abandoned its foolish project to end the use of cheques in The Bahamas. The Central Bank apparently has no end of stupid projects in which it engages in the name of modernity. They do anything at the Central Bank but protect consumers. However, there is a cautionary tale in all of this modernity. Last week there was an article from a Canadian writer about the crisis of payments systems in Canada when the whole internet went down. You could process nothing. The writer urged people to keep cash on them. We say the same thing here. There is no substitute for cash and the business of trying to force people to make digital payments is a fool’s errand in our view. Quite apart from the unreliability of our internet in The Bahamas, there are the privacy concerns of the nanny state getting to know if you went to the drug store to buy condoms or not. So the decision to stop the end of cheques is wise.
John Rolle, the Governor of the Central Bank, despite the bank’s unpopularity with consumers in The Bahamas, seemed a happy man during the past week as he announced that at the start of May 2022, the reserves in The Bahamas reached the princely sum of US 3 billion. This is a first for the country. This is the highest ever. He also said that in the first quarter, there was a net increase in the reserves of 524 million dollars. That also must be a record.
The Tribune’s Business Section, usually a font of doom and gloom , was forced to point out that the previous doom and gloom report, the economist Marla Dukharan. from Trinidad and Tobago who used to work for the Royal Bank of Canada, had done an economic forecast for The Bahamas. This most recent forecast did not include what she had included before in ones from the recent past that the experts expected The Bahamas to be in an IMF structural adjustment programme within two years.
Remember when the economist made that last forecast, Michael Halkitis, the Minister for Economies Affairs answered back: not on my watch.
Meanwhile the Minister of Tourism Chester Cooper was able to announce that the British Colonial, recently branded a Hilton and which closed its doors in February will reopen shortly under a new name. He also announced that the hotel in Freeport, the white elephant bought by the FNM, would soon be sold and open.
What a difference, a day, a week and a year make. We also all know that 24 hours in politics is a lifetime.
The point is while much can change, there is good news in the economy. On Saturday 7 May 2022 there were job fairs in both New Providence and Grand Bahama. Looks like the demand for jobs is high.
Let’s hope this continues. Let us wish Prime Minister Philip Davis well as we witness the fix of this economy. Let us dispatch the curmudgeon Hubert Minnis to the scrap heap of history.
The Central Bank is in need of new, visionary, caring and patriotic leadership.
I am all for digitization and for use of *appropriate technology*. But these efforts by the Central Bank and geared towards control. People should be able to choose among options in a democracy. Money and checks are required in The Bahamas. The electronic payment methods are not sufficiently reliable. Central Bank leadership are out of touch with the regular Bahamian economy.
Money comes in many forms. Money needs to be reliable – able to be accepted for the transaction not 98% of the time but 100% of the time. Cash always works!
I can easily see transactions being delayed or denied because of *”system issues”*. Why are we always trying to force things on our citizens rather than persuading them? There are some people in this country that will never go digital.
I myself have moved back from digital transactions. I paid a landlord by direct bank transfer. There was acknowledgement of the funds transfer by my bank. A month later the landlord inquired about the rent. He had not received the funds. When we checked, the funds were never transferred by the bank even though there was acknowledgement of the transfer. I provided post-dated checks to the landlord to ensure he is paid on time every month. I do not trust the banks!
Recently my debit card bounced because of *”system issues”*. I do not trust the debit cards. They know the system is dysfunctioning and they fail to notify you.
The communication systems do not work reliably. You are on a phone call and the phone just disconnects or they start playing some phone company ad.
The Bahamas is not a real place. The Central Bank oversees a system where it takes two days to clear a check and they think this is okay. They brag about it. We can manually clear checks in less than 10 minutes if it was managed properly. We have no standards and cannot be trusted to do our jobs properly. Any day that someone doesn’t come to work, the system stops around here.
If the Central Bank wants to help, they should cause the banks to set standards where a business account would be opened in less than 30 minutes or done online. They can cause the banks to introduce systems where a person can scan a check and communicate that check to the bank for processing using their phone.
The Central Bank of The Bahamas is an instrument of slavery. Everything, every programme, every system they introduce us designed to deliver you into the hands of someone who will extract money from you for services you don’t want or need or worse – for no service at all. We are economic batteries being exploited for our labour!
We need choices. We need options. The banks need competition. We need financial freedom.
Why do they confiscate your money if you try to take it out of the country without telling them? This is a stupid law but an element of financial slavery. We need to be empowered.
The Central Bank needs to be re-engineered! The Central Bank needs new, progressive, nationalistic leadership!
The Bahamian people need to keep a keen eye on The Central Bank of The Bahamas. It is an instrument of slavery!
It is time for us to look at new leadership at the Central Bank. It appears that the leadership at the bank does not get or understand the dire straits in which we now find ourselves as consumers in the banks of The Bahamas. The consumers in this country are not served well. They are mistreated, with bad service and overcharged. The Central Bank is supposed to be the closest we get to a protector, yet they stand aside and look. Last week in a tepid response to the complaints, they published a set of fees of each of the banks. What that was supposed to do is not entirely clear but the publication essentially pleased no one. The fees are usury and they are unnecessary. The Central Bank should be the protector, stopping the fees or ordering their removal or reduction with immediate effect.
Last week the Royal Bank of Canada was at it again in The Bahamas. They announced a temporary pause in some services for their customers which seemed designed once again to stop face to face contact with human beings in the bank. The Central Bank said nothing in response to this. They are the regulator and the closest we have got to a watchman over the conduct of the banks. They do nothing and have done nothing since the deterioration of services began in this country under the pretext of digitalization. We again call for a proper watchdog for the interest of consumers as the banks make rapacious profits and provide poor services in return.
From the institution which is supposed to be [protecting the integrity of our banking system and currency and the consumers who use it, comes the next edict. They want to ban the use of cheques. That means after 2024, they are going to stop using cheques in the banking system if we allow them. The PLP cannot and should not allow them to continue to prosecute this foolish and stupid idea.
We reviewed two articles during the week by Charles Littrell, the head bank and trust company overseer at the Central Bank of The Bahamas, reported in The Tribune on 10 November 2021. He is Australian we understand and maybe a plant there forced on the bank by the International Monetary Fund. Problem is his language is that of a jackass. It is clear that he is a specialist in indelicate language and if he does not like the country he is working in, he should be given his walking ticket. The Governor of the Central Bank should speak to this jackass and tell him either he shuts his friggin mouth or go out the back door back to Australia and the Outback. Here are his words to Bahamian consumers: If people are too lazy to switch, then it’s their own damn fault. Don’t come complaining to us about fees when you could have switched.” His other language on the double standard between the U S and ourselves on banking, misrepresents what the position of the Government of The Bahamas is on the question of the standards being applied to the financial services sector. While, you can have your private opinions as a public official it is not in his place to make those comments about the United States. Lest there be any doubt they do not as far as we know represent the official position of the government of The Bahamas. What was most offensive however was the attack on Bahamian consumers. Mr. Littrell blames Bahamian consumers for having a more expensive time banking because they choose to go to the bank rather than bank on line. Again not his business and people are free to do what they want to do. Anyway that’s our thought on the matter. Get our ass back home to Australia if you don’t like it here and if you think we are dumb and stupid.
The following statement was issued by the Chairman of the Progressive Liberal Party Senator Fred Mitchell, after the Government sought to take credit for putting the image of the Most Hon. A D Hanna on the 100 dollar bill. Not so said the Central Bank. The PLP is not satisfied with the arrangements that they intend to make to honour Mr. Hanna. He must get the full statement funeral and nothing less will do or be acceptable. The flags should now be flying at half staff
11 August 2021
I spoke to our leader the Hon Philip Davis last evening and to the former Prime Minister and Minister of Finance Perry Christie last evening. Both confirmed that the decision to put the image of Arthur Hanna on the 100 dollar note was one taken by our previous PLP Cabinet.
This has now been confirmed in a public statement by the Central Bank.
If the Minnis administration wanted to be brave, they should have announced the removal of Stafford Sands from the ten dollar bill and its replacement with the image of Dame Doris Johnson.
In typical fashion the FNM and Dr. Minnis are seeking credit for the PLP’s work. Shame on them.
Our leaders in the House will determine whether the Prime Minister misled the House and what the consequences of that should be.
So in the heat of a dispute with the Central Bank, the Union President Theressa Thompson must have said something that upset the Governor of the Bank and his Deputy. They gave instructions for their lawyer Ferron Bethel to threaten the Union President to sue for libel. Really! These folk ought to get real. What was worse though, why is it that these FNM firms and these FNM ideologues keep getting Government work? How does the firm of Harry B Sands get to be doing this work with Ferron Bethel who sits on the Board of BPL at the helm of an action against a union leader. The work should be withdrawn from Harry B Sands and the Central Bank Governor and his deputy should withdraw the threat against the Union President. Our advice to her to them: sue and be damned.
The head of the Central Bank is John Rolle. His wife is Dr. Nicola Rolle. She is the head of National Insurance, the largest institutional investor in the country by far. They have U S investments overseas pursuant to the loosened restrictions of the bank, prior to Mr. Rolle’s arrival. Now comes Covid 19 and the reserves in the Central Bank under Mr. Rolle; the reserves appear to be threatened. First the Central Bank said no foreign bank could repatriate their profits to their home countries. Then last week, they said the National Insurance Board and and other Bahamians should liquidate their US holdings and bring the money back home. Is this really good advice?
We think that the Minister of
Finance Peter Turnquest is lost in the midst of this crisis. We think that the Central Bank is not being
aggressive enough, much too passive. We
asked for advice on the subject and here is the advice we got
Suggestions:
A
limited fiscal response to COVID 19 would not prevent the Bahamian economy from
going into a recession and possibly a depression as there is no guarantee that
global economy would automatically rebound from this shock. It is far
more likely that the recovery would be long and drawn out like the financial
shock of 2008 which at the onset of COVID 19 was still being felt in The
Bahamas.
The
measures announced by the Government puts very little cash in the hands of
Bahamian businesses and citizens. More worrisome is that many of the
measures have no basis in legislation, creating an environment for misuse and
misappropriation of funds.
Legislation
is needed to:
i. To support
the payment of unemployment benefit to self -employed persons. The
expansion of the programme is welcome, and its effectiveness would be increase
if it was governed by legislation as this would give persons certainty on
eligibility and provide a mechanism to appeal any denial of benefits.
ii. Govern
the relationship between the SBDC and financial service providers in the
disbursement of the $20 million in loans to Small and Medium Businesses.
The SBDC role as a wholesale funder for financial institution poses certain
risks which should not be ignored, especially as there is no standard protocol
in place for the adjudication of credit to the various businesses.
iii. To allow
large hotels and businesses to pay unemployment benefits and then be reimbursed
by NIB/ Government. For this to happen would constitute a loan to NIB/the
Government by the private sector and this programme, if the National Insurance
Board follows through on the Prime Minister’s encouragement, needs to be treated
as a loan to the Government, with the appropriate legislation, House of
Assembly approval and documentation.
iv. Put into
law the Business Licence and VAT deferral and credit programme. This
programme which does not put cash in the hand of businesses something which
they desperately needed. Businesses need cash to pay expenses to allow
them to operate and employee expense is just one of these expenses. It is
likely that 25% of these businesses which are predominantly in the distribution
sector would not return without cash support. A better structured
programme would allow these businesses to trade the ability to defer or offset
any tax for cash and would provide those businesses with an extended repayment
cycle measure in years not months.
A
more comprehensive solution is needed.
Monetary
and Banking Policy
The
Discount Rate and Prime Rate needs to be reduced dramatically.
Neither the Prime Rate nor the Discount Rate have any real meaning in the
domestic economy. They only serve a reference point for Government
debt. At the current levels they are artificially increasing the cost of
Government debt. A reduction would give the Government the head room it
desperately needs to put resources in the economy.
Legislation
is needed to ensure that all financial institutions offer the same level of
concessions to borrowers impacted by the COVID 19 virus. One financial
institution is already on record stating that it would offer no programme but
treat borrowers on case by case basis. This is unacceptable and instead
all borrowers should be afforded a six-month holiday on principal and interest
payments. Interest should not be capitalized but deferred until the
principal is fully repaid. In addition, all fees should be waived
including those fees for online banking and late payments.
The
banks in The Bahamas are well capitalize and they should commit some of this
capital to stave off an economic collapse.
Fiscal
Policy
The
Government needs to get money to its citizens. The unemployment benefit
only provides 50% of base salary and for many families this would put them
below the poverty line. The Government should supplement this with an
income replacement programme. A potential source of this payment could by
the various IDB loans already approved by Parliament, but which projects are
not being executed because of the indifference of the Government.
The
fact that the Government has been unable to execute its IDB loan programme has
been highlighted and many of the projects which are funded are now subject to
cancellation. The Government should restructure these loans into a single
facility ($50 million) and use this facility to purchase critical medical
equipment for the fight against COVID 19 and provide cash to its citizens
impacted by COVID 19.
The
sole focus of the Government should be on maintaining the level of demand in
the economy. This is accomplished by putting money into the economy.
Despite the Standard Poors decision to downgrade our investment grade status, the Central Bank of The Bahamas said that the state of the reserves was sufficiently robust to lower the Bahamian prime interest rate. The decision is significant in that it lowers the cost of borrowing by four tenths of a percent. This will have the immediate effect of lowering the cost of borrowing for existing loans with banks tied to the prime rate. The statement of the Bank follows:
PRESS RELEASE
22 December 2016
Central Bank: Reduction in the Discount Rate by 50 basis points to 4.00%
The Central Bank wishes to advise the public of its decision to reduce the Discount Rate, by 50 basis points to 4.00 percent, effective immediately. The Bank expects financial institutions to follow suit with a corresponding reduction in the Prime Rate, from 4.75 percent to 4.25 percent and adjustments in lending rates on new credit facilities. Interest rate reductions for existing facilities should be accorded in line with contractual provisions that govern the timing of such changes.
This policy action is intended to position the domestic business sector to take more advantage of growth opportunities in the near to medium term, and to provide more support to housing sector investments.
In taking this action, the Bank considered several factors, including the prospects for a pick-up in growth in the coming year resulting mainly from the expansion in the tourism plant and the potential for increased foreign currency inflows to buttress the external reserves, which stand currently at $928.6 million or an estimated 17.4 weeks of total merchandise imports—well above the 12.0 weeks benchmark. The economy also faces reduced pressures on the balances given the significant reduction in the oil import bill, which is expected to be sustained in large part over the medium-term.
Other prudential constraints remain in place to ensure sustainable credit trends. This includes the maximum debt servicing ratio limit of 40%-45% percent (on the aggregate of personal loans, mortgages, rent and property maintenance) and the minimum down payment requirement of 15% percent for such loans. The recent, temporary easing in these requirements still only applies for hurricane recovery facilities. Lending policies should also continue to be conservative, as commercial banks manage the expected gradual reduction in the overhang of non-performing loans.
The Central Bank will continue to closely monitor economic and monetary developments and will, where prudent, make further adjustments in its monetary stance in order to ensure the stability of the financial sector and contribute to sustainable economic growth. The Bank will also continue to explore other interventions to increase the private sector’s access to financing of a growth enhancing nature, having regard to activities that strengthen net foreign exchange earnings potential.
22 December 2016
viagra nurse times;”>The Prime Minister Perry Christie announced last week that John Rolle, the former Financial Secretary, widely credited for shepherding the country through the introduction of VAT is now the Governor of the Central Bank, responsible for monetary policy. He succeeds Wendy Craigg who the Prime Minister praised for her service. Simon Wilson, who served as Deputy Financial Secretary under Mr. Rolle, has been appointed the Acting Financial Secretary succeeding Mr. Rolle.
cialis sales troche times;”> buy cialis times;”>Congratulations to the MP for Central and South Andros Picewell Forbes who joined his constituents to officially open the Central Andros Cancer Society Care Centre in Love Hill on 4th December.The president of the local chapter is Elizabeth Hanna.Joining them were Doris Adderley former educator and Fr. Neil Nairn of St. Stephen’s Anglican parish in Andros.
CENTRAL ANDROS, viagra buybuy The Bahamas — Her Excellency Dame Marguerite Pindling, viagra sales Governor General, received a warm welcome from students and faculty of schools in Central Andros on Tuesday, illness April 14, 2015. She was entertained with songs, drama and dance performed by young people from primary through the high school.
His Excellency Picewell Forbes, hospital Bahamas Ambassador to CARICOM and Member of Parliament for Mangrove Cay and South Andros, brought remarks. He told the students about the dreams the late Sir Lynden Pindling, first Prime Minister, had for Andros and his vision in building schools to educate Bahamians all across The Bahamas.
Warm welcome to Governor General Dame Marguerite by school students.
Dame Marguerite, centre, and next to her, His Excellency Picewell Forbes.