Tag: politics

  • The Politics of Permanent Crisis

    The Politics of Permanent Crisis

    During the Senate Budget Debate this week, Attorney General Wayne Munroe delivered what I considered to be a masterclass on the role of government and the democratic process. His remarks served as a timely reminder that democracy depends not only on an effective government, but also on an effective opposition. Each has a constitutional responsibility to serve the Bahamian people.

    The debate itself was noticeably more civil than those in the House of Assembly. Government senators defended the budget, highlighted investments and pointed to measurable achievements. Opposition senators challenged those claims, questioned the government’s priorities and argued that the country is moving in the wrong direction. That is democracy at work.

    Yet, as I listened to both sides, I found myself thinking less about the budget and more about the philosophy of opposition politics in The Bahamas.

    Every opposition eventually reaches a crossroads. It can dedicate itself to holding the government accountable while presenting better alternatives, or it can make its mission to oppose virtually everything the government does. One approach strengthens democracy. The other gives rise to what I call “the politics of permanent crisis”.

    The politics of permanent crisis assumes that every government decision is a mistake, every policy is destined to fail, and every success must be minimized or dismissed. It is a political strategy, but is it a healthy democratic philosophy?

    If the government announces a new hospital, must it automatically be condemned because it came from the government? If unemployment falls, should that not be acknowledged? If crime decreases, is the response simply that it is still not enough? If foreign investment increases, should it be viewed only with suspicion? Conversely, when the government falls short, should the opposition not also explain, in practical terms, what it would do differently?

    These are not questions about party politics. They are questions about democratic maturity.
    The role of an opposition is not to make the government comfortable. It is to make the government better. That requires rigorous scrutiny, honest criticism and meaningful alternatives.

    Accountability without solutions eventually becomes noise.
    An opposition that recognizes progress where it exists does not weaken itself. It strengthens its credibility. Likewise, an opposition that proposes practical solutions does more than criticize today’s government—it demonstrates that it is preparing to become tomorrow’s government.

    Perhaps that is the real test of political leadership. Is the FNM preparing to lead this country? Well, I would answer that in this way. An opposition cannot simply be against everything. Eventually, it must tell the Bahamian people what it is for. That is the difference between a movement seeking headlines and one preparing to govern.

    -Abigail Cartwright

  • The FNM and the Politics of Grief

    The FNM and the Politics of Grief

    ABAGAIL CARTWRIGHT DEAN’S BLUE HOLE

    Since May 12, I have been closely observing the political climate in The Bahamas, and one conclusion continues to stand out: the FNM has not yet come to terms with its electoral defeat.

    To understand what we are witnessing, it may be helpful to revisit the work of Swiss-American psychiatrist Dr. Elisabeth Kübler-Ross, who introduced the five stages of grief in 1969: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance.

    While originally developed to explain how people process loss, the model has since been applied to organizations, institutions, and even political movements facing significant setbacks.

    Importantly, the stages of grief are not linear. People move between stages, often revisiting emotions before ultimately arriving at acceptance.

    Over the past several weeks, the FNM appears stuck somewhere between denial and anger.

    Consider a few examples:

    1. A social media post recently featured a young woman identifying herself as “Victim Number One” of the new PLP administration, despite the government barely being out of the starting blocks.
    2. Several FNM-aligned radio personalities continue to devote hours of passionate, hate-filled, angry outrage, unsubstantiated accusations, and campaign-style attacks, recycling narratives that voters clearly rejected at the polls.
    3. Another FNM commentator attempted to argue that the PLP is somehow a “minority government” because of voter turnout figures, suggesting that electoral victory does not equate to a legitimate governing mandate. (Clearly, they don’t understand, or don’t want to accept, how we are affected by the continuous voter register).

    These arguments may energize a disappointed base, but they do little to explain why voters delivered such a decisive verdict – a sound rejection of the FNM.

    More importantly, they distract from the serious reflection required after any electoral loss.

    The healthiest political organizations eventually move beyond grief and toward introspection. The FNM may wish to consider that step soon.

    Until then, perhaps the party should explore a national group discount on grief counseling. Because judging by the public commentary, acceptance remains a long way off.

    -Abigail Cartwright

  • MORE WOMEN IN POLITICS SAYS THE PM

    MORE WOMEN IN POLITICS SAYS THE PM

    The Prime Minister Philip Davis was questioned about the issue of more women coming into the forefront when the general election takes place.  The Prime Minister indicated that he was not in favour of a set aside but in favour of a meritocracy when it comes to women candidates. Women have to come forward: ““I would like to see as many as I could have,” Mr. Davis said when asked how many women he wants the Progressive Liberal Party to nominate ahead of the next general election. “But you know, it is for them to come forward and for them to be able to win the hearts and minds of the electorate and the constituency [in which] they wish to run. For me, it’s not just about running women candidates. It’s about somebody who’s willing to step forward. And the gender doesn’t matter to me, but yes, I would like to see that more females would become a part.”  He was speaking to The Tribune.  The remarks were published on Wednesday 30th April 2025

  • THE REALITIES OF POLITICS OR RELATIONSHIPS

    THE REALITIES OF POLITICS OR RELATIONSHIPS

    The Bahamas is in a very strange place when it comes to values. Every week, the young men are killing one another over some stupid fight for chump change in their neighbourhoods. The society seems to have become immune to it. The press reports that the murder count will exceed 100 again for this year.  In the last week, at least four people in the Fox Hill area or from Fox Hill have died from gunshot wounds. The slaughter goes on and no one seems to be able to figure out how to stop it.  It sure makes the place feel unsafe and lawless. Then there are the incessant demands of politicians from their would-be constituents to give money or else.  People don’t even seem to be prepared to bury their dead but think that it is the responsibility of politicians to bury their dead for them.  In these days, loyalty, and faithfulness seem to be nothing.  Just money, money, money.

  • WHEN IT’S  TIME TO MOVE ON IN POLITICS

    WHEN IT’S  TIME TO MOVE ON IN POLITICS

    Former Prime Minister Perry Christie tells the press that he disagrees with party policy on Wednesday 11 October 2023

    The former Prime Minister Perry Christie lost the leadership of the PLP following the general election of 2017.  That should have been the final curtain, at least as far  as the public stage and the public policy is concerned.  This past week, we learned that the Bahamian saying “ every goodbye is not gone” is more true than ever.

    There is a spirited debate, not so secret, going on with unseemly haste about who will succeed Obie Wilchombe following his untimely passing on 25 October 2023.  The vultures were busy picking over the bones, before the body was under the ground. One of them is a former Member of Parliament who until recently was nursing the MICAL seat, of a sitting PLP Member of Parliament.

    The Party issued a statement saying that the Leader’s position on the West Grand Bahama and Bimini seat was that of no former Member of Parliament was being considered for the seat. In another PLP dispensation, under Pindling, under Christie, it would have been unthinkable that this would be publicly contradicted by one so prominent in the party. That is the kind of stuff you whisper in the king’s ear. Yet, there it was in stark relief in the  strap line of The Nassau Guardian, the former Prime Minister Perry Christie, contradicting the Leader of the Party.  This was the very thing that the PLP was trying to avoid, an unseemly fight over a seat that was not yet officially declared vacant.

    In 2002, the very same man, then Leader of the PLP said that he would not run Whitney Bastian because of a background of allegations. He did not.  The PLP lost the sea.  He said that he would rather lose doing  the right thing than win doing the wrong thing.  That was a point of principle.

    Now that Philip Davis is the Leader of the Party, that principle seems to have been forgotten and yes  it appears that there is a spoil for a fight, when  clearly the principle of when it is time to move off the stage is one which should be embraced. This is Davis’ time.

    Number of hits for the week ending Saturday 14 October 2023 up to midnight: 373,983;

    Number of hits for the month of October up to Saturday 14 October 2023 up to midnight: 681,161;

    Number of hist for the year2014 up to Saturday 14 October 2023 up to midnight: 17,342,217;

  • THE HISTORY OF THE POLITICS OF BERMUDA AND THE BAHAMAS

    THE HISTORY OF THE POLITICS OF BERMUDA AND THE BAHAMAS

    *Two Countries, one people, one party.*

    In the late 1940s, students from around the Caribbean / North Atlantic attended University in London. These persons included Errol Barrow of Barbados, Eugenia Charles of Dominica, Michael Manley of Jamaica, Lynden Pindling of The Bahamas, and Lois Browne of Bermuda.

    Together with others from around the region, they not only studied law but, more importantly, dreamed of their peoples’ social, economic, and political liberation living under unfair and unjust colonial oppression.

    Upon returning to their respective islands, Ms. Lois Browne and Mr. Lynden Pindling established their legal practices and, as importantly, their political careers.

    In 1953 the Progressive Liberal Party became the first political party in The Bahamas. Ten years later, in 1963,  the Progressive Labour Party became the first political party in Bermuda.

    *Tied at the hip*

    The parties’ ideals were identical; workers’ rights, voters’ rights, and social and political upliftment of the working class people.

    Ironically, the Bahamas had the United Bahamian Party during this era, and Bermuda had the United Bermuda Party.

    Having had previous experience in winning elections, the PLP Bahamas spared no expense or effort in flying to Bermuda to assist their sister party PLP Bermuda in learning how to grow membership, set up branches, canvass, and run campaigns.

    Such was the bond between Pindling and Browne.

    In 1965 Pindling came to Bermuda with a delegation to support the PLP and speak at their Annual Delegates Conference (ADC)

    In 1973, when The Commonwealth of the Bahamas gained its independence, Mrs. Lois Browne-Evans took a delegation, including her young children, to see the Flag of a Nation raised for the first time.

    In 1990 when PLP Bermuda reopened its Headquarters at Alaska Hall, Bahamian Prime Minister Sir Lynden Pindling and then Minister Perry Christie came to be a part of the ceremonies.

    When the PLP Bermuda eventually won government in 1998, Fred Mitchell journeyed to Bermuda to join their brothers and sisters in their next step. He has been to every election since then but two whether the PLP was in or out of power in Bermuda and in The Bahamas,

    At the passing of Sir Lynden in August 2000, a delegation led by Bermudian Premier Dame Jennifer Smith attended the state funeral.



    *Two countries, one party*

    For many General Elections in Bermuda, a delegation from the Bahamas, led by Minister of Foreign Affairs Fred Mitchell, travelled to show moral support on polling day.

    In August of 2022, Bermuda PLP Deputy Premier Walter Roban and MP Chris Famous travelled to the Bahamas to attend the first regional climate change conference. During their visit, they were able to make the emotionally significant trek to walk the halls of the PLP Bahamas Headquarters and visit the grave site of Sir Lynden Pindling.

    In October 2022, Prime Minister Philip Brave Davis followed the footsteps of Sir Lynden Pindling in being the keynote speaker at the Annual Delegates Conference. His opening remarks spoke to the spirit of Dame Lois and Sir Lynden smiling down on their political children joined at the hip and the need for continued unity.

    The next day, the delegation visited the Governor of Bermuda, Her Excellency Rene Lalgie, and held a special joint Cabinet meeting with Premier David Burt. However, the most moving part of their day was visiting Alaska Hall and St. John’s Cemetery, the final resting place of two former PLP Leaders, Arnold Francis and Dame Lois Browne-Evans.

    Essentially, we are not just two political entities; we are one family, borne out of the vision of two young students who bonded together during the dark days of colonialism in the cold streets of post-war London.

    Bermuda, and The Commonwealth of the Bahamas, are separated by 900 miles of the North Atlantic ocean. Two countries, yet we are inseparable, one family, one party. As such, both parties share the very same motto that guides and inspires us all.

    PLP all the way!! 

  • DIONISIO D’AGUILAR BLIND DEAF AND DUMB POLITICS

    DIONISIO D’AGUILAR BLIND DEAF AND DUMB POLITICS

    So the Auditor General issued a report to the House last week in which he made observations about the Health Visa Scheme of Hubert Minnis and the FNM.  He said the FNM broke the law.  He said that monies were not transferred to the Government on a timely basis.  That translated for Dionisio D’Aguilar, the former Tourism Minister, under whose hand the imperfect scheme was authored, that the PLP’s criticisms of the regime fell flat.  Mr. D’ Aguilar is  living in cloud cuckoo land as are the owners of the payment platform Kanoo.  Next step is a police investigation.

  • Fred Mitchell On Good Will In Politics Reported By The Tribune

    Fred Mitchell On Good Will In Politics Reported By The Tribune

    By TANYA SMITH-CARTWRIGHT

    tsmith-cartwright@tribunemedia.net

    FOREIGN Affairs and Public Service Minister Fred Mitchell said the Free National Movement lost the goodwill of the Bahamian people early in its term and the party “couldn’t see the forest for the trees” and just went downhill.

    Mr Mitchell, also the Progressive Liberal Party’s chairman, said he hopes his party remembers that lesson on goodwill.

     “Goodwill is that je ne sais quoi which causes life to move in the right direction,” Mr Mitchell said yesterday. “A political party and political leaders need that goodwill to operate.

     “Early in the term of Hubert Minnis and the FNM, 35 to four seats in the House and 12 to four in the Senate, the FNM lost the goodwill of the Bahamian people. Once the Oban deal was found to be fake, it was downhill from there.

     “They were so self-absorbed, of course and full of hubris, that they continued with this folly by firing PLPs and then trying to put three of our former parliamentarians in jail. They couldn’t see the forest for the trees and life for the FNM went downhill.”

    Mr Mitchell said with 57 months to go, he hopes the PLP government continues to enjoy the goodwill of the Bahamian people.

     “They never recovered because they lost the goodwill of the Bahamian people,” Mr Mitchell said. “A hundred days have gone since we were elected on the 16th of September this year. We have 57 months to go and the quality of those 57 months will depend on whether or not we continue to have the goodwill of the Bahamian people for the rest of our term.

     “I believe, I hope, the PLP remembers this lesson about goodwill. The message of power and goodwill. I would argue that goodwill in the business of politics is, if not more valuable, at least equal to money. And, you know what the Americans say, there are two rules in politics. Rule number one is that you need money to operate. Rule number two is see rule number one.”

    Mr Mitchell said as someone who has lost an election and come back victorious, he understands the need to be there for constituents.

     “I try as best I can to deal with every call, text message and any inquiry even in the dark of night. Goodwill is what causes me to be able to win again and to serve.

     “For my other colleagues, through the darkest days of opposition politics, that lady who sent you a meal for lunch, the man or woman who sent you unsolicited small contributions in the envelope for the party, people who saw adverse decisions being made against you by the last administration and warned you to duck.”

    He gave examples of political goodwill and goodwill in general.

     “Even FNMs would call and say, ‘I don’t agree with what my party and my leader are doing,’” he said. “An example of goodwill I often use with students of politics is I say a police officer sent to guard a politician can do his or her duties in two ways.

     “One, they can see the stone about to be thrown and stop it, or they can allow the stone to be thrown and then go and arrest the person.

     “The outcome, of course, depends on the goodwill of the officer doing his duty, but the outcome is practically different if the stone hits you.”

  • Fred Smith Q C—Slime Ball Politics

    https://www.facebook.com/joette.penn/videos/pcb.10154945966737021/10154945965882021/?type=3&theater

    Anyone who is not now convinced that Fred Smith Q C is a pretty sick individual should now be convinced beyond a shadow of a doubt.  This is now time for someone to move under the provisions of the Mental Health Act have him committed to the crazy hill for the political lunacy which he has conducted over the last week.

    Mr. Smith showed up at the Immigration Detention Centre, obviously to make a scene and to have it recorded.  The press duly obliged.

    He was booted out of the facility because he had no right to be there.  The so called client which he was seeking one Rony Jean was in fact sent back to Haiti on a plane. He was not there. So no client to see. So right to go in.

    Mr. Smith stood screaming like a mad man at the gate about he was being prevented from seeing his client.  They should have locked his stupid ass up.

    Then he went asking for the international community to help. So the stupid clucks that they are, they went chasing after his mad ravings and started issuing statements. The so claimed client was not in The Bahamas, so what is the offence.

    The FNM dominated Bar Association headed by Khalil Parker then went into overdrive, supported by one of the Bostwicks who said that Mr. Smith was being denied some fundamental right, that of not seeing his client. That is a lie. There was no client there to see.

    Then you have the talk shows.  Mr. Smith went on a talk show and engaged in his obsession and fascination with Fred Mitchell.  Is this a gay thing or what?  Seems little funny business to us. Every other word out of his mouth is Fred Mitchell this, Fred Mitchell that. What he is going to do with Fred Mitchell.  He claims that he bought the election out in Fox Hill against Mr. Mitchell. Then he claimed that he used voodoo on Mr. Mitchell.  This is all sickness, madness.  This is a man who needs to be put away.

    His preoccupation with Fred Mitchell is like one of these little girls in the playground who likes a boy and he won’t give her the time of day so the response is to attack the little boy. Sick and infantile.

    Callers on Rodney Moncur’s Talk Show called back and roasted Mr. Smith telling him to carry his stupid ass back to Haiti. They called him a Haitian and said his citizenship should be revoked.  They called him everything but a traitor and told him one day he must stand up for The Bahamas.

    The second half of the ventriloquist and dummy pair of Joe Darville and Fred Smith, was out with his expected press release saying how poor Mr. Smith had been abused.

    The only abuse here is the abuse of the Courts by a vexatious litigant. How he gets these courts to agree to this nonsense in which he engages is beyond reason.  Mr. Smith belongs not in the open air but put away privately.  It is that bad.

    He is an embarrassment not the Bahamian people.  He is an embarrassment not only to himself but also to his family. No one should feel sorry for him

    His stock in trade is making money off administrative errors by the state.  He plans to bankrupt The Bahamas. He has said it over and over again. Sandilands maybe too nice a place for him. He really belongs in jail with a long custodial sentence, so perhaps he may come to his senses.

  • Theo Neilly Is Bowing Out Of Politics

    This was by all accounts a good representative.  He started out long ago as a PLP Young Liberal then converted to FNM.  The talk was that Brent Symonette was funding his campaign and his representation and helped to win him over to the FNM.  The truth is that anyone who knows Brent Symonette knows that he is amongst the more parsimonious of money owners.  In other words he is a cheapskate.   So that was not true.  Mr. Neilly has had one term, viagra usa elected in the face of a popular swing against the party he joined in 2012.  Within the party, it’s been pretty nasty, with them saying all sorts of things that brothers and sisters should not say about one another.  The final straw was the FNM convention which saw a slash and burn campaign the likes of which The Bahamas has not seen.  Mr. Neilly decided he had had it, threw in the towel and communicated the same to his branch in North Eleuthera.  No word on a replacement from the FNM but the PLP’s Clay Sweeting is waiting in the wings and from the FNM side, they are again saying the daughter of former MP Noel Roberts is in the lead as a replacement.  We wish Mr. Neilly well.  Yes indeed politics is not all it’s cracked up to be.

  • LATRAE RAHMING ON THE NATURE OF BAHAMIAN POLITICS

    buy viagra thumb times;”>plp

    look times;”>This is a thoughtful piece by a young PLP on the make.  He has volunteered to run for one of the Vice Chair positions in the PLP. While the theory on charismatic leadership is true to some extent, viagra the more basic fact is that the PLP is structured around a council where the votes are simply skewed toward the leader of the party.  This was so under Lynden Pindling and since the new leader took over, the situation has moved by his specific design to be even more skewed toward that leader.  That is what makes the challenge impossible, or barring a miracle from God.  Nevertheless have a read: 

    The Nature of Bahamian Politics

    Bahamians have a very peculiar liking for Charismatic centric leaders surrounded by this fictional belief that being charismatic equates to good leadership. This is the continued struggle of the black political culture that suggests social and political change is impossible in the absence of charismatic leadership. This is where leaders of liking of Dr. Minnis and the Hon. Brave Davis are profoundly challenged in a political era throughout the Caribbean where charisma is indispensable for keeping the audience engaged.

    The reason why a leader can be unbeatable on a political convention floor or entirely is really down to the fact that charismatic leaders influence by charm rather than reason. Leaders capable of charming their followers become addicted to their love and their followers, on the other hand, become addicted to the leader’s charisma and charm. Charisma disguises poor leadership, so they manage to get away with it. Leaders who handle the media poorly and are under expose is at a disadvantage in Bahamian politics, making charismatic candidates look more competent than they actually are. The Bahamian people must look for the hidden talent and avoid the charisma trap. Many people pay attention to Bahamian politicians or political wannabes charisma and pay little attention to the intellectual content of their politics and policies. Bahamians must be careful of the kind of leadership that can inspire with its words and fail in its action. Charismatic leadership alone cannot and will not liberate the Bahamian from its economic and social misery only transformational leadership can do that. Bahamians need the kind of leadership that empower them to liberate themselves.

    Self-examination is a crucial process for political organizations if they are going to maintain a sense of relevancy and electability. The absence of a succession policy in political parties can foster political unrest, internal conflict, and divisive behavior. It is unsustainable for any political organization to undermine and ignore the significance of limited political leadership. The habitually election of leaders in The Bahamas over the last 40 years has created the culture of perpetual incumbency.

    Despite the appearance of an electoral process to create a theoretically succession through party elections, the combination of being party’s leader and a broad pillar of political maneuvering indicates the process is flawed and unbalanced. We have to demonstrate the political and democratic maturity despite the infancy of our democracy, to discuss the contestability of the political elites at the top. The systematic challenge of political succession in our country stifles the flowering of visions and ideas from ambitious men and woman who want to shape the direction of the Bahamas. The philosophy and ideologies of political organization can only coexist in an environment where the structures that feed the hunger for power at the center is at a controllable level. If we refuse to create a pattern and attitude for succession for the Prime Ministerial office in our country from one generation to the other the consequence will be the creation of an office to die for.

    The quality of the National Conversation on how we get to being a Better Bahamas is absolutely a reflection of the level of education in our country. The lack of intellectualism is killing the national discourse. There’s no meaningful conversation on policy development and creating an industrial sector in The Bahamas to improve economic growth. In the main we Bahamians get along pretty well, as long as we don’t try to talk to one another about anything complicated. In that event, the name-calling begins. We’re at each other’s throats. The Bahamas needs a serious mental paradigm shift in our country. Anti-intellectualism is the cause of social dysfunction we witness today. The days of the nation state are numbered and we continue to avoid conversations about the real issue. The circle of conversations is counterproductive to nation building. When we rather discuss whether Ingraham will come back or when Christie will go and place issue like education, social policy, and economic policy on the back burner we have a serious issue in our country. We should all be frustrated having to always discuss the surface issues never getting to the root of the nation’s problems.