There is nothing it appears that constituents in The Bahamas think that MPs cannot do. The situation has become so unbearable that many people who have been doing the jobs as MPS are throwing in the towel after one term. The requests are simply too much: buying stoves, finding jobs, buying fridges, fixing roofs, buying food, paying for funerals, cutting down trees, paying for their children’s school fees. None of these from this list are the responsibility of MPs but constituents are constantly begging. The question is where does this begging come from. No one seems to understand that they have the responsibility to make their own sunshine. If there is a tree branch in the road, call the MP. Where in God’s name is the money to come from to do all these things? If you don’t, the first thing they threaten is they will not vote for the MP. Then when or if the MP gets in trouble, they are the first on the line to call the MP a thief. What a thankless job: poor salaries and ungrateful constituents.
The University of The Bahamas announced that they had a ransomware attack last week. This caused the collapse of parts of their digital platforms for over three days and there may be further delays. A source speaking to the press expanded on the problem, claiming that the term may have to be extended because of the attack. This is reportedly the second or third attack on Bahamas Government systems in the last year. Other attacks have caused monies to be paid where they should not have gone. This becomes serious when you start talking those kinds of facts. We cannot vouch for the authenticity of those latter claims. However, what this begs is the criticism that we have always pushed in this county, the mad rush to becoming digital, while fine on one level is crazy on another precisely because of these vulnerabilities and the inability to fix them when they go so badly wrong. We state again the cashless society is foolishness.
BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP AND ITS IMPACT ON BAHAMIANS WHO GIVE BIRTH IN THE UNITED STATES UNDER THE NEW EXECUTIVE ORDER
On January 20th 2025, United States President Donald J. Trump signed an Executive Order titled “Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship”1, initiating the process to end birthright citizenship which prevents automatic citizenship to children born in the United States to undocumented immigrants and those in the country on a temporary status (tourist, work, or student visa, etc.). The Executive Order will come into force 30 days from the date the Order was signed (after February 19th, 2025).
What is Birthright Citizenship?
According to the 14th Amendment Section 1 of the Constitution of the United States, passed by the US Congress on June 13th 1866 and ratified on July 9th 1868, it states:
“All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”2
Therefore, this suggests that anyone at birth is classified as a United States citizen. However, the new Executive Order will mandate at least one parent to be a United States citizen or Green Card holder for a child to qualify for United States citizenship at birth.
Impact on Bahamians Carrying a Non-Immigrant Visa
All Bahamians carrying a non-immigrant visa, including participants in the Visa Waiver Program, as well as F-1 students, and B-1, B-2, H-1B, H-4, L-1, L-2, E-1, E-2, E-3, TN, and O-1 visa holders, etc., will be affected by this Executive Order. President Trump ordered agencies not to recognise citizenship for children born after February 19th, 20253.
In accordance with Section 2(a) of the Executive Order, “It is the policy of the United States that no department or agency of the United States government shall issue documents recognising United States citizenship, or accept documents issued by State, local, or other governments or authorities purporting to recognise United States citizenship, to persons” of unlawfully present or temporarily present mother and a non-citizen father.
1 Executive Order: Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship: https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential actions/2025/01/protecting-the-meaning-and-value-of-american-citizenship/
2Fourteenth Amendment: https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-14/ 3FAQs About Trump Birthright Citizenship Order for H-1B, F-1, and L-1 Families:
Children born to Bahamian mothers carrying a tourist visa will no longer qualify for United States citizenship unless the father is a United States citizen or permanent resident.
Employment Visa
Children born to Bahamian parents who are on a temporary work visa, like the H-1B visa, would no longer qualify for United States citizenship, and the parent(s) will likely have to apply for a dependent visa for their children.
Student Visa
Children born to Bahamian students will likely face challenges obtaining United States citizenship if they are no longer entitled to citizenship at birth.
Petitioning
US-born children will lose the ability to petition on behalf of their parents once they turn 21 years old, as they too will no longer qualify for United States citizenship under the new policy. It should also be noted that Bahamian immigrants who have applied for a green card and are experiencing delays are likely to experience further delays. Additionally, active immigration cases may leave Bahamians vulnerable, as courts could become overwhelmed.
Legal Challenges
Immigration advocates have filed several lawsuits challenging the Executive Order, with some arguing that it violates the 14th Amendment.
Additionally, eighteen United States Attorneys General have filed a law suit against the Trump Administration, which claims that “The President has no authority to rewrite or nullify a constitutional amendment or duly enacted statute. Nor is he empowered by any other source of law to limit who receives United States citizenship at birth4.”
As of Thursday, January 23rd, 2025, a Seattle United States district judge, John Coughenour, blocked Trump’s Executive Order, citing that it is “blatantly unconstitutional”. Judge Coughenour temporarily prohibits Trump and any federal employees from enforcing the Executive Order for 14 days until a hearing on February 6th to consider a preliminary injunction. The judge expressed intent to review a long-term injunction in the coming weeks5.
4 United States District Court for The District of Massachusetts: Case No. 1:25-cv-10139: https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases25/2025-0121_Birthright-Citizenship-Complaint.pdf 5Judge temporarily blocks Trump’s executive order on birthright citizenship, calling it ‘blatantly unconstitutional: https://abcnews.go.com/US/judge-challenge-trumps-executive-order-ending-birthright citizenship/story?id=118005855
The failed developer of Bahamar, the Izmirlian group, has their principal spokesman Sarkis in the press in The Bahamas, running propaganda about the Bahamar project and their running dispute with the China Construction Company in New York. The group managed to get a bogus and badly written judgment by a New York court which has not been stayed by the appeals court in New York while the China Construction Company pursues its right to an appeal. This forced China Construction in the United States to seek bankruptcy protection. This caused the failed developer to come back in the press saying that China Construction was fraudulently managed. This is the same man who tried to pull a fast one on The Bahamas government by seeking bankruptcy protection in the United States after he failed to pay his bills to the China Export Import Bank. The Tribune and The Guardian are fully promoting this nonsense on their front pages. The fact is the dispute can have no effect on the Bahamar’s property at all. Secondly, with regard to the China Construction property within The Bahamas, nothing can be transferred unless the government of The Bahamas says it can be done. Our advice is the government should make it clear that Sarkis Izmirlian is not a fit and proper person to own any hotel asset in The Bahamas with his record of failure here. His continued interference in the internal affairs of The Bahamas makes it questionable whether or not it is in the public interest for him to remain in The Bahamas.
The New York state Court of Appeal in America has refused to stay the bogus judgment by a court in New York which gives the failed developer of Bahamar 1.6 billion dollars in damages for losses which the failed developer says are because of the China Constriction Company in The Bahamas.
Quite part from the judgment itself being bogus and an anti-Chinese decision, the fact is the Courts in New York have no jurisdiction over land in The Bahamas.
Why is that important?
The assets of China construction in the United States are apparently non-existent. The only hard assets the company has are two hotels in Nassau. Those hotels are said to be worth 335 million dollars. The judgement is 1.6 billion dollars. The company is required to put up assets that match the judgment in order to stop it while they prosecute an appeal.
We made the point in an earlier comment that we do not believe that those assets could have been pledged to a New York court because when it came to the enforcement of any judgement in New York, they simply could not if The Bahamas government refuses to allow the transfer to take place.
We repeat that opinion here and go further. We say that if it comes to liquidation of the asset in an attempt to enforce the ultimate judgement, the judgement should not be enforced in The Bahamas.
One other point, we say that the government of The Bahamas whether PLP or FNM should not allow any such transfer to take place where the Izmirlian group will end up owning hotel properties in The Bahamas.
The ownership of any hotel property by the Izmirlian group in The Bahamas would not be in the public interest of The Bahamas.
Number of hits for the week ending Saturday 21 December 2024 up to midnight: 510,594;
Number of hits for the month of December up to Saturday 21 December 2024 up to midnight: 1,765,699;
Number of hits for the year of December up to Saturday 21 December 2024 up to midnight: 19,015,846
Once again the United States, our friends and partners (so they say) have destabilized The Bahamas. In the past week, they released an indictment which showed that they had indicted two Bahamian officers, one a police officer and the other a Defence Force Officer for trafficking drugs and firearms through The Bahamas to the United States. In the narrative of the indictment, they made sweeping generalizations about Bahamian officials and a senior but unnamed politician. They use this kind of loose language all the time without any care about the consequences in this society. This is the same country that elected a convicted felon to the office of the Presidency. Donald Trump awaits sentencing even as he faces his inauguration on 20 January 2024. The United States is no position to do what they have done to this society. It is an act of dishonour and treachery. Yet this society itself has itself to blame because it is too trusting of the United States and too subject to American cultural practices. Everyone here seems to want to be and live in America and covets what America has, not accepting the freedoms and life that we have in this country. Anyway Elvis Cutis, Superintendent of the police force, who ran at the airport operations in Nassau and Darren Roker of the defence force are to be arraigned this week in New York, No doubt they will have their balls squeezed to spit out names, names that are probably in no way connected with what they are charged but in order to settle the U S and get them to ease up, they will say anything. You can’t blame them.
Just when the storm in a tea cup over the indictment of the defence force officer and policeman in the United States was settling down, the FNM and their trolls started passing around another bit of bad news. The Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) released a report that said 75 per cent of the businesses in The Bahamas revealed that they had to pay a bribe to get to do business. Here we go again. Our only comment is let’s see what else we can pile on. Just a thought though: he who pays the bribe is just as guilty of continuing the practice as he who demands. You think?
Mrs. Lesvie Archer reveals her study on the middle class at Fox Branch of the PLP. Monday 4 November 2024
We are enclosing a YouTube version of the Fox Hill Branch meeting where Lesvie Archer, of the Public Policy Institute of the University of The Bahamas, spoke to the branch on her study about the aspiration to be middle class in The Bahamas. There has been a lot of public discussion about the study with most the commentary about it shrouded in ignorance. The study is an important guide for public policy in the country and should be properly considered. Mrs. Archer is not saying that her study tells you what it costs to be middle class. The study says that if you want to live at certain level in The Bahamas, and to be at that certain level, then given her definitions, clearly defined, it would cost a certain level of expenditure. That got all twisted up in the fine print.
The Bahamas and Togo signed a communique 24 October 2024 to establish diplomatic relations. Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell with Togo’s Foreign Minister Robert Dussey signed the joint communique in the margins of the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting in Apia, Samoa.
Fred Mitchell with Ambassador Stan Smith and Permanent Secretary Melvin Seymour in New York City at the Future of Climate Summit hosted by Purpose Driven Innovation in partnership with Venionaire Capitol and Circle X Green Trillion Club with Enzo di Taranto Xzen at the table who presented an award to The Bahamas for its leadership on climate change issues. Marina Bird, ESG News and Alexandra Geithner, Planet Gold Media.
The Bahamas did not medal in the Olympics. It is a habit that we have come to expect every Olympics. It appears that Devynne Charlton was the closest that we came to it in the one hundred metre hurdles but that flamed out as well. But well done for effort. It’s tough to become an Olympic athlete period. The problem now is that the BAAA, the association that prepares athletes for the Olympics are not doing what they should to create the next generation of runners what with both the stand outs Stephen Gardiner and Shaunae Miller Uibo near the end of their running careers. Mr. Gardiner has been plagued by a series of injuries and Ms. Uibo pulled up in a critical heat. Neither was able to defend their gold medals from four years ago. And now an unholy nasty row has broken out between the two gold medalists Mr. Gardiner and Pauline Davis Thompson, two time gold medalist. She published on Facebook what looked like an accusation that Mr. Gardiner had fooled the Bahamian officials that he was well enough to run and thus when they found out, it was too late to arrange a substitute. Mr. Gardiner was livid and told Ms. Thompson that she should butt out and mind her business that she herself was not a good example to Bahamian athletes. This is what happens often when a team loses. People start blaming one another it descends into the unseemly. Neither comment should have made it into the public domain.
After being here for two years and promising to stay for the long haul, Virgin has abandoned The Bahamas again. They left if you remember because they said that we had no hotel rooms to put up their guests. When Bahamar was finished and opened they returned to The Bahamas. Turns out they were quarreling with the Ministry of Tourism about the extent of the subsidy that they will get from The Bahamas to keep people flying here. So now we are stuck with British Airways and the old planes that they use on this route with monopoly pricing. Small countries can’t win huh?
On Thursday 11 July 2024, a series of excerpts in the media of an interview with the relatives of a transgender woman from Chicago named Taylor Casey were published far and wide. Even the local broadcast stations published this prejudicial interview which ended up making false and defamatory accusations against the Royal Bahamas Police Force. Taylor Casey came to The Bahamas on holiday and to spend time at the Yoga Retreat. At some point, she wandered off on her own and was never seen again. She has a history of being bipolar. Her own family said that she was often depressed and there is a report that she wrote a suicide note in her diary. A search was done and nothing has been found, save her telephone in the deep waters off Paradise Island. She has disappeared. The evidence is that or suggests that a bi-polar individual simply wandered off and drowned by misadventure or deliberately ended her life. The mother and the sister in the face of this grief feel empowered to simply spout off any nonsense that comes to their heads about the investigation, accusing the Royal Bahamas Police Force of corruption simply because the head of the Criminal Detective Unit’s former head has been suspended but for something completely different than this investigation. He was in no way involved in it. The Bahamian police have always called upon outside expertise when it is needed and the FBI and the American government have been fully involved in the investigation. The person simply cannot be found. People and their families simply do not want to take responsibility for their own actions and those of their relatives which may sometimes lead to misadventure. It is always someone else’s fault. That is the evidence in this case, nothing more or less. The search will soon have to be abandoned because there is no further evidence and it has nothing to do with police corruption. We understand grief but that is not an excuse to talk nonsense.
Fred Mitchell was the patron for the independence celebrations in London marking 51 years of The Bahamas as a nation. Joined by Baroness Scotland SG of the Commonwealth, the Bel Canto Singers under the direction of Elridge McPhee, High Commissioner Paul Gomez, DCM Marchea Mackey, Second Secretary Justin Smith, Lord Ali, Sir Jerry Deveaux and scores of Bahamians the Brazilian Ambassador and the Dean of the Diplomatic Corps the Ambassador from Honduras 6 July 2024.
Jamaica’s right-wing Government has agreed to recognize Palestine as a state in the face of the slaughter of Palestinians by the state of Israel, as a sign of solidarity with the people of that country. Only Trinidad and Tobago and The Bahamas of the Caricom group are holding out on making that stand of solidarity. The Bahamas needs to act and recognize Palestine as a state.
With Prime Minister Philip Davis at a dinner hosted for Mark St Hill CEO of CIBC Caribbean Bahamas with artist Ambassador Jamaal Rolle, Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell, Businessman Adrian Fox, the Prime Minister, Mr St Hill and Ambassador Sebas Bastian. 10 April 2024
Prime Minister Philip Davis announced that the state of the country in fiscal terms was generally good in the House of Assembly as he delivered his mid-year budget statement on 21 February 2024. While the deficit target appears to be headed toward double what was anticipated, the revenues for the country continue to be strong. The Ministry of Finance is firm in the belief that the country’s revenue targets will be able to effectively manage the country’s expenditure. The Prime Minister also announced that the government is looking to execute its agreement to implement corporate income tax for companies with over the 750 million annual turnover. This will largely affect foreign companies in this country and will mean that the countries will pay here rather than in their home jurisdictions. The yield from the tax when implemented at the 15 per cent level is expected to be around 140 million dollars.
The IMF says that The Bahamas government will not be able to meet its deficit-reducing targets either this year or in the next years unless they raise taxes and introduce personal income tax. The PLP does not agree with the IMF on the deficit and neither do we. Financial Secretary Simon Wilson disputed the IMF’s assertion. As for personal income tax, we agree that there ought to be personal income tax on the top ten per cent of income earners in this country.
Fred Mitchell visits Mt Alvernia in Cat Island. A sacred space. 4 February 2024 at 206 ft above sea level, the highest point in The Bahamas which is owned by the Roman Catholic Church.
Fred Mitchell congratulated the principals of the Bahamas Striping Group of Companies following them being honoured as Businessmen of the Year by Jones Communication. Well done and a well-deserved recognition for contributing to the building of king and country. The photo was at a dinner at JW. 26 January 2024
The Bahamas enjoys a generally good reputation in the world, if you judge the number of “Ah Ha” comments that you find. This is largely the anecdotal stories of people who meet Bahamians and recall how they enjoyed their time when they came to The Bahamas. One of these was Joe Biden, the now President of the United States, who found his first wife in Nassau at the British Colonial. The other was the late Prime Minister of Japan Shinzo Abe who honeymooned in Nassau at what is now the Warick Hotel, then called Loews. But then you have the European Union and certain of the left in the United States and Canada who think of us as pirates and bandits stealing their tax money. The Prime Minister’s job today is to manage all of those competing images, to try and save a country that is wealthy but pretends to be poor, but has a GDP per capita which belies the story of poverty. One thing is the IDB said in 2020 that 47.6 per cent of the population lived under the poverty line. This does not portend a good political or economic result, unless the Governments are able to right this ship. The image is important as we try to find the money to save ourselves from the ill effects of climate change.
The Attorney General Ryan Pinder told a Central Bank conference on Money Laundering meeting in Nassau last week on 18 January 2024 that hard upon a UN report that the right to be free strangulation of national finances was a human right, The Bahamas was seeking to bring a case in the International Court of Justice at the Hague to change the attacks by the European Union on The Bahamas Financial Services Sector. The Bahamas is also working at the UN on a worldwide tax treaty, to stop the EU from abrogating unto itself the ability to regulate the tax policies of independent countries. These are all good moves but the EU continues its oppression without let or hindrance.
There is a list of public projects that need to get done if the PLP is to face a reasonable chance of a second term. The list is long and the demand for money is high. While her revenues are good, there are a plethora of complaints about the execution of projects. Increasingly, The Bahamas has to turn to the private public partnership model to get these projects done. The major one coming up is the power needs of the country through Bahamas Power and Light. Every time the light flickers in The Bahamas, we are reminded of how unreliable BPL is and how expensive the power is. So the major priority is to try to find a solution to the power problems of The Bahamas. Our suggestion is to go to renewables cold turkey. This has been rejected as unreasonable.
Attorney Mark Symonette Rolle held a press conference to announce that he was taking action against the owners of a club who excluded a transgender woman from the club and then the woman was set upon by a group of people because they discovered that she was transgender. The comments on social media were scathing about the woman and the homophobia came out in earnest. This is some sense a really sick society. The Prime Minister condemned the attack. The U S Embassy has called for a full investigation.
Neil Hartnell, the British muckraker, who runs the Business Edition of The Tribune went looking for dirt in the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) report on our country’s economic performance. He found it. The dirt was that the IMF said the Government was forecasting a .9 per cent of GDP deficit in its 2023/24 budget, but the IMF thought that a more realistic budget deficit was at 2.9 per cent. So old Neil Hartnell claimed that this blew a hole in the Government’s financial plans. Two plus two where he went to school equal five. The fact is the report praised the Government’s management of the economy and revised its growth figure from 1.8 per cent to 2.3 per cent. As Michael Halkitis, the economic affairs minister said “ this is huge”. Wel done Minister. Neil Hartnell: bah humbug.
The governor of the Florida Ron DeSantis is an idiot. This man has twice gone off in what is charitably called an unfortunate analogy. In his crazy rhetoric to defend the murderous campaign of Israel against the Palestinian people, he claimed that Israel has the right to defend itself. He said that if The Bahamas were firing rockets at Florida, the United States would flatten the place. The fact is The Bahamas has no rockets unless they are hidden on the U S base in Andros. There is no ill intent toward the US. The Bahamas spends over a billion dollars in Florida’s economy, yet this stupid man runs on with this analogy, not once but twice, He hasn’t got a prayer of getting elected President. He is just an idiot and Donald Trump will eat him for lunch in the Republican primary. He is just a stupid man. Rick Fox, the basketball player, posted a note to condemn the remarks. Other Bahamians need to speak up. The Prime Minister criticized the remarks but said he had no wish to get involved with a tit for tat in American domestic politics. The Opposition Spokesman and former Foreign Minister Darron Henfield called the remarks unfortunate. The Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell described them as cockamamie.
Foreign Minister Fred Mitchell at the Diwali Celebrations of the Indian Community in The Bahamas at St John’s College Auditorium in Nassau. Joined by Masakui Rungsung, High Commissioner to The Bahamas for India, Lowell Mortimer, High Commissioner for The Bahamas to India, Myles LaRoda, Minister for Social Services, Jerusa Ali, Director General of Foreign Affairs, Jeffrey Lloyd, former Education Minister. 25 November 2023. Photos by Calvin Brown Jr RBDF. Diwali is the festival of lights and India’s biggest festival.
Fred Mitchell with the Diplomatic Corps at the Garden of Remembrance in downtown Nassau for Remembrance Sunday. 12 November 2023. With the diplomatic corps and the RBDF Rangers.
Fred Mitchell, Foreign Minister, with the Saudi Ambassador to The Bahamas, and Tony Joudi, Ambassador for The Bahamas to Saudi Arabia and Director General Jerusa Ali. 26 October 2023. Calvin Brown Jr RBDF Diplomatic Week at Bahamar
Fred Mitchell, Foreign Minister, Havana Dip Corps dinner hosted by Qatar Ambassador to The Bahamas HE Jamal Al Bader with Czech Republic, Norway and Romania in attendance, with The Bahamas Ambassador to Qatar Tony Joudi. At Bahamar 26 October 2023
Protesting preachers at the University of The Bahamas. Tribune photo 3 October 2023
On Thursday 5 October 2023, on the 70th birthday of the most prominent voice for the rights of gay and lesbian people in the government, the preachers of The Bahamas were at it again. Having embarrassed the country in 2004 by their shocking and unseemly behaviour toward visitors on a ship coming into the Nassau port, they were back at it again.
This time they were are the University of The Bahamas, the forum of academic freedom, where the week of gay and lesbian pride was being discussed by Bahamians of repute about what it all means in The Bahamas. The preachers said that the forum should be cancelled and that this was not something that should happen in The Bahamas.
For the love of God, we don’t know why these preachers don’t go find Christ. The silliness of the arguments is incomprehensible.
So here’s the thing. If they look around at their congregations, young and old, in the choir, in the pulpit, in the congregation, one gay man or woman after the next. In fact, if they follow their dictums and purged their benches of every gay or lesbian in the congregation or choir, the church would be empty. They know it and yet they persist with this public rubbish which makes them look like a bunch of ignoramuses.’
Why do these people care about who is sleeping with whom, or who loves who? What is it to them? Many of them have multiple relationships with women and children all over the place.
They went farther and went on the University campus and disturbed the forum that was being held there. So sad.
We know that these things are watched carefully by the U S embassy and we know how dear human rights and LGBT issues are to them. We know that the pictures spread of the hate speech by these pastors may have reached into the embassy here and the question is whether these people are fit and proper persons to go to the United States. One withdrawal of U S visas and they would stop all the bullshit from them.
Number of hits for the week ending Saturday 7 October 2023 up to midnight: 307,178;
Number of hits for the month of October up to Saturday 7 October 2023 up to midnight: 307,178;
Number of hits or the year 2023 up to Saturday 7 October 2023 up to midnight: 16,968,234;
Free Mitchell, Foreign Minister, watching the Royal Bahamas Police Force Pop Band as they performed junkanoo and pop tunes on the promenade at Lake Geneva with Patricia Hermanns, Ambassador to the UN in Geneva. 28 September 2023
Minister the Hon. Frederick A. Mitchell, MP signed on to the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons at the United Nations Heads of State and Government meeting 19 September 2023. The Bahamas is committed to working with our international partners to ensure a safer and more secure world.
Fred Mitchell congratulates Australia’s Foreign Minister Penny Wong following her address to the 78th General Assembly Debate in New York at the United Nations. 22 September 2023
As much as we try to stay on the sidelines, we are in the middle of a cold war with China on the one hand and the United States on the other. The Chinese say they offer generous development terms. The latest is trying to fix the poor workmanship by their people at the National Stadium. They say they have no hegemonic designs but whenever they come calling, they want you to sign on to their Belt and Road initiative and their global security initiative. The Bahamas has so far resisted, given the stiff and often nonsensical objections from the United States. Perhaps irrational is the word. But the fact is given our geographical location, and our economic dependence on the United States, the reality is what they say it is. As the late Arthur Hanna once said: we are nestled next to a giant and we are only as independent as the giant allows.